Copyright Controversy Continues
The recent decision by the WoW guild
The Syndicate to copyright its name has, as expected, ruffled more than its share of feathers. As with any untested
waters such as this, there appear to be bigger issues than simply not allowing someone else to use the name. According
to Ralph's Website, the very issue of trust and the integrity of the playerbase as a whole may just be at stake...or at
least, that's what Ralph thinks.Okay, that may be a bit of hyperbole, but he does raise some very interesting points in his article. There is a sort of first-come, first served etiquette that MMORPG players have come to accept, and the actions of The Syndicate certainly do call that issue into question. Read more about it & make up your own minds...
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, WoW Social Conventions, Guilds, Odds and ends, News items






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Tony Walsh Feb 9th 2006 11:11PM
The guild didn't copyright its name. They registered a trademark for the name. And we don't know how recently they did it. Raph says "I actually heard about this a while ago..." in his post here: http://www.raphkoster.com/?p=302
Zequel Feb 10th 2006 10:23AM
This is what happens when anal lawyers and people who watch too much court TV try to play a game. I remember when the Internet used to be fun before all the big corporations came along with all their patents (one-click shopping anyone?). I'll laugh when their precious trademarked guild disbands.
Diesel Fire Feb 10th 2006 6:20PM
What's funny, is that they may have a trademark on "The Syndicate", but Blizzard owns everything inside WoW. So if Blizzard wants to create a faction called "The Syndicate" and wishes to take away their guild name for what ever reason such as to remove confusion, there's nothing their precious trademark can do about it.
Besides... doesn't Bullfrog have a copywrite and trademark on the name "Syndicate" concerning a video game they made? I remember hearing that these WoW guild guys also trademarked the singular word "Syndicate". I would be interested in seeing how Electronic Arts decides to deal with intellectual property infringement.
Brudus Feb 10th 2006 9:27PM
I belive Blizzard will let the kids argue untill it gets out of hand and then finally step in and enforce what it clearly states in the EULA.
Eric Feb 11th 2006 12:22AM
Yes, Bullfrog published a game called Syndicate Agent. I really miss it and wish I could find my copy of it from 1994 :->