An overdose of headless chickens
A frustrating phenomenon which has plagued battleground groups for as long as I've been PvPing is the headless chicken syndrome. However, it seems a lot worse of late -- or maybe I've been playing more.The first indication of a headless-chicken battleground is when ten or fifteen players stand around at the start of a match yelling "inv", none of whom seem to want to do the work of inviting themselves. Fortunately this will stop in 1.12, though the sentiment won't. If one player is brave enough to step up as leader, chaos usually ensues despite his or her best efforts.
The worst experiences in battlegrounds I've had occur when one player takes leadership but several others somehow think they are leader too, spamming raid warnings and contradicting the leader's orders. Disorganisation ensues, people spread all over the battlefield and a quick loss is on the cards.
In some battleground matches, however, one player taking leadership early works wonders -- everyone listens, does what they're asked and a coherent team emerges. It's highly dependent on the individual players, and the leader in question, as to whether this happens or not; nine out of ten times, it doesn't. Have you noticed the headless chicken syndrome, or does your server manage the impossible and create organised battleground PuGs?






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Will Aug 2nd 2006 5:07PM
Bladefist, EU, horde.
Never seems to happen too badly. Usually the highest level person just uses an auto-invite addon. You "/w invite" to them and you're in, easy. We have it organised, and I'm talking about pugs here.
The only thing that changes is how communicative the leader is. Sometimes you get really good ones who use raid warnings properly, and sometimes it takes us more than 10 mins to beat the Alliance.
Pulse Aug 2nd 2006 5:08PM
I'm sure everyone has noticed this. What can be annoying is when several veteran players are in the group but do not step up and take leadership. Often there are people who are willing to be lead, but do not have the experience to be a leader. If you know what you're doing, take control, other's will follow you if you show your knowledge!
Nathan Aug 2nd 2006 5:10PM
I've noticed it myself and it is worse these past two weeks than any other time that I've see. The other problem I've notice showing up is the fact that people will go in with a small group of people they know or are in the same guild as and will make a small group of 5 or 6 and not pay any attention to anyone else that joins the BG.
Ryan Aug 2nd 2006 5:39PM
I usually don't PvP unless I'm in a guild group that queues together (especially for Arathi Basin - we can do better than most PuGs there). We're coherent enough to win a good deal of WSG matches on a server where horde usually trounces PuGs.
We're a raiding guild, so vent/raid chat are used at all times. The PvP-geared horde groups get their money's worth from us, even if they win.
Duwanis Aug 2nd 2006 5:45PM
Taking charge early (or at all) hasn't worked in a lot of the PUGs I've been in. What seems to happen most of the time is somebody takes charge, and people either argue with them or don't listen. It's not that the strategy's not sound (OK, we've got three points in AB, so hold them), it's that people are either a) stupid or b) want to go do their own thing (STFU WE NEEDZ TEH FARM/STABLE!!!!!) ... If you've got people that listen, though, more power to you :p
Badge Aug 2nd 2006 6:05PM
I have an awful time in most BG PuGs. Either there's no leader, or everyone's a leader. Both end the same way: in an Alliance loss. The fact that the Horde on Destromath have really good, organised PvP groups and guilds and the Alliance has mostly PuGs doesn't help much either.
B.S. Aug 3rd 2006 12:58AM
I have seen all this before even in guilded groups. The reason people flock off is because they want to farm honor kills. The more people they kill by themselves gives them more honor than grouped up. So there mystery solved.
Dan Aug 3rd 2006 12:37PM
Playing horde, I haven't really ran too much across this. On occasion, yes and we would get wiped out extremely fast, but the alliance on my server has problems with this all the time.
How do I know that?
Simple, we kick their butt extremely fast!
Teamwork Pwnz!