Comments wiped on Thottbot
Sometime today, it seems as though the comments on Thottbot.com were wiped. Maybe. Some Thottbot entries, like this one for Atiesh, have plenty of old comments still on them. But others which definitely used to have comments, like the Bad Mojo Mask, seem to be wiped clean.Which is definitely trouble, because while there are a lot of WoW resources out there, Thottbot was well known not only for its completeness (they even had spells in there that were only used by NPCs or objects), but for the player comments on each quest. Not only could you find out where a mob spawned, but you could see players telling you how hard it was, how they had beaten it with their 49 lock by chain fearing, and whether the rewards were good or bad. Without the comments, Thott's just not Thott.
There's a few rumors floating around as to why this happened-- it could just be a server mistake, or it could be an attempt by Thott to clean out the gold sellers that were advertising in the comments. Some of the comments may have disappeared and come back, so it could be just a temporary thing (unfortunately the site news doesn't provide any clues because... it was wiped, too). I've dropped a note to Thott himself to see if he can give us any feedback on the subject-- I'll let you know if we hear any more
So if you've ever used Thottbot in the past, now's the perfect time to give back-- leave a comment on a few quests or items you know well to help rebuild the database. I'm sure a site like WoWHead would love to take advantage of Thott while they're down, but Thott's the first and original. I would hate to see them go down like this, especially if it's a tech mistake of some kind.
Update: Comments are now back on the Bad Mojo Mask entry, as well as on the site news. Whatever the problem was, it looks like it might have been only temporary.
Filed under: Tips, Tricks, How-tos, Fan stuff, News items






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
snivlem Sep 29th 2006 12:34AM
So we should donate to them even though the company that runs the site sells gold?
Or am I high?
Mike Schramm Sep 29th 2006 1:16AM
Donate your time, sheesh. Fixed. And yes, you are high.
Medros Sep 29th 2006 10:51AM
I would be shocked if they were cleaning spam to get rid of gold sellers, unless their parent company was tired of spammers advertising their competitors.
Sylythn Sep 29th 2006 3:23AM
Man, some of those comments were critical - every so often I'd come across incorrect or out of date info on Thottbot, and it'd only be the comments that made me aware of it.
One good example was, I was hunting for some mob to get a cool wand...and in the comments in Thottbot, I found out it was a Scourge Invasion mob, so until that event happened again, I'd be looking for a non-existant person.
Tigraine Sep 29th 2006 5:45AM
To be honest..
I stopped using thottbot somewhen after 2 weeks of release when allakhazam was already offering a mutch better Database for me.
I mean, Thott is great if you want to search something particular (like. . all blue items with stats above xxx on that slot) .. but for the average things like typing in "Executioner's CLeaver" to find out where it drops Allakhazam just did a better job.
Almost no wrong information, clear interface, maps are good.. comments are ok ..
why bother with thott..
But.. ok.. you've got a point.. he was the first ..
foip Sep 29th 2006 10:28AM
soooo, bad mojo mask. Just looked there and it had comments from 1.6 years ago.
Jacob Sep 29th 2006 9:29AM
Comments seem to be back up as of this morning. Didn't do an exhaustive search, but there are definiately comments working again.
Branislav Sep 29th 2006 10:12AM
I am not sure you guys from the other side of the Atlantic know about Cartographe project.
It is french and available in english as well.
You should definitely give it a try since it is much more convenient than any of the tools mentionned above.
http://tixu.scribe.free.fr/indexen.php