Hello! Are you a farmbot?

I've run in to more than a few farmbots in my day -- often in Winterspring, while farming Timbermaw reputation. The furbolg you had to kill to gain favor with the Timbermaw also happened to drop good coin and runecloth, making them lucrative targets for farmers. The bots (characters controlled by a computer program of some sort rather than a human being) were always easy to spot. They'd follow a set circuit around the area, taking down targets one at a time. When the area was empty, they would return to a spot near its center and spin around in circles until they managed to target a fresh spawn -- and then they'd begin running an identical circuit. Depending on the particular farmbot, sometimes I could game their system and let them farm reputation for me. See they've targeted something? Assist them and use an instant attack to tap it before they can -- back when I was doing my reputation farming, the farmbots didn't have seem the intelligence to notice if something had been tapped after they've targeted it and sent in their pet to attack. (They were, of course, always hunters.) A real person would certainly be annoyed by this behavior, but the farmbots would simply continue their cycle.
However, a post up on Kinless' Chronicles makes me wonder if the farmbots have managed to get smarter. Kinless noticed an orc hunter constantly (from 4AM to 4PM, server time) mining thorium in the Eastern Plaguelands. That information alone simply screams farmbot to me, but there's more to the story that makes me wonder. On one encounter with this suspicious hunter, Kinless decided to follow him along his farming route. The hunter dismounted in Hearthglen and started to fight the elite guards there. Figuring that anything worth this much effort to an obvious bot must be wealth indeed, Kinless ventured inside to see what was there. And inside? He found not a single thorium vein and he barely made it out alive. But in his chat box, our friendly farmer was kind enough to wave him farewell before mounting up and leaving. Kinless explains the quandary:
This is a live player, with brains, who does nothing but farm mineral nodes across Azeroth. (I later noted him in the Barrens, Winterspring, Burning Steppes.) He does nothing but farm, and plays round the clock, and does not own the expansion. He's certainly not funding a main, or a twink, since he's got no time. And it's a live player since he played that little trick on me.
This isn't possibly an entertaining way to play the game, so what's happening here? Is it an improved intelligence bot? (Now with new player-baiting technology!) Or are we seeing live players out farming for real world profits? Unless we can get them to start answering whispers, we may never find out.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Cheats






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Natali Apr 25th 2007 5:52PM
But... but... I do that when farming Timbermaw rep, and I'm at my keyboard for the whole time. :( I'm no bot. I just like to spin in circles.
Vykromond Apr 25th 2007 5:57PM
Er... it's just a human farmer, possibly (but not necessarily) in East or Southeast Asia, paid a low wage to farm gold. This is an old, old phenomenon.
Taudok Apr 25th 2007 6:13PM
well i've come to find out that there are web sites out there that will use actual people to level up a profession for you. a friend of mine used one at one point to level his mining up from 0-300 in like a day or two. so i guess this one would fall into this category. they even go as far as to ask you how you would like them to react/interact with other players/GMs. so yeah i guess the "Chineese Farmers" have gotten a little "Intelligence Buff"! lol
Juo Apr 25th 2007 6:19PM
or it could be someone *gasp* farming just for the sake of farming?
I know PLENTY of people that farm insane amounts of ore/herb/fish, ect...because they enjoy it. And in the long run it funds them, their alts, and some of their friends.
At one point myself I had over 1000 herbs spanning multiple characters, and a friend of mine has 2k+ adamantite ore hanging out in his banks...
some people...just do it for the sake of farming...just because you see someone mining all day, or picking flowers all day, doesn't mean they are some underpaid chinese sweatshop worker...it could very well be someone with a designated "farming weekend" (or week ^_^) ect.
Kirby1612 Apr 25th 2007 6:31PM
I'm gonna agree with #4, i have lots of Primal Earth, Ore, and a few jewels sitting in my bank. When I'm running circles in Shattrath, why not be productive and farm? Waiting on people to get reagents before Arcatraz? Give Netherstorm a quick spin.
Alternately, he could actually be working for hours on end. Maybe filling in orders for mats? Or just selling what he gets to sell for real world $$. Work from home and make some semi decent cash?
Pingmeister Apr 25th 2007 6:33PM
I am always amazed that some folks just can't comprehend that someone might have fun doing something that is drudgery to another.
I PvE solo.
That's it. I don't group. I don't raid. I don't PvP at all (not a single time).
I like to PvE. I enjoy wandering into an area and killing monsters. Day in. Day out.
I am actually at work right now thinking about where I'm going to go tonight.
Sure, I may be insane and my wife does succeed in dragging me away from my PC fairly easily, but I absolutely love playing WoW the way I do.
Three more hours at work. Then I get to go PvE!!!!
Mats Apr 25th 2007 6:38PM
it sounds more like a china farmer then a programmed farmer to me.
Rich Apr 25th 2007 6:42PM
Could have been a monitored bot - maybe someone was watching over several bots running, and when he noticed you he took over the one you were following.
Mark D. Apr 26th 2007 5:03AM
Rich:
Exactly what I thought. That'd be a good way to prevent overly bot-like behaviors if messaged or tracked and would ensure that nothing went amiss or the bot was being gamed for another person's benefit.
I know the inclination is to assume, as several have, that this is some poor wage slave, but it could just be someone with a second system humming along beside their normal work box or home computer. If it weren't for my objection to botting, I could easily have one system cart a character around while I do something on my laptop right next to it, intervening when needed.
Hybrys Apr 25th 2007 7:53PM
Errr... There are, up to, three Thorium Veins in the back of Hearthglen.
MG Midget Apr 25th 2007 8:01PM
If you do bump into a bot farmer, add it to your friends list. It can be interesting to track them down and follow their progress and at times take advantage of them.
Skinners can really take advantage of these bots if they are killing skinnable stuff. Just follow them around and skin the bodies. I did this once in Winterspring and walked off with about 150 rugged leather, eventually quitting out of boredom.
mike_a Apr 25th 2007 8:08PM
I'm a human controlled farm bot. I used to run in a pattern farming EPL. Now I run around the same path for hours killing the same mobs for motes.
I've had people yelling at me for being a damn bot - ruining it for legit players, but I'm just a blacksmith.
If you want to do blacksmithing it's kind of necessary.
Yippster Apr 25th 2007 8:07PM
Perhaps he could have programmed the bot to /wave whenever another player got within a certain distance of him.
1Adam12 Apr 25th 2007 8:24PM
I actually like 'farming'. I happen to play during the middle of the night (My time zone = server time) so it is much easier to farm/grind.
If I do see a bot farming, I really enjoy messing with him. But I have seen one 'smart' bot in Winterspring. He was killing Moonkin, following a pattern and mining Thorium. He would totally ignore my whispers and my antics. He would 'kill' for me if I tagged the mob first. However, I'm on a PvE server so I turned on my PvP flag. After a few minutes of me running circles around him and such, he suddenly targeted me and attacked. I just stood there and waved at him... After I got back to my corpse he was gone... About an hour later he was back running the same routine.
Bronori Apr 25th 2007 8:24PM
Ive seen some farming scripts before and there is one that checks for followers and if it detects the pressence of a player for more than X amount of time it does some weird patterns... seems like it could be one of those...
Theres other bots that alert people to things... I know of one that plays a loud noise if you get a GM whisper (im talking painful, wake-the-dead loudness here) so my guess is its only a step away to have it check for targets around you (I think its actually possible with LUA)
Overall Id say its a minimum wage farmer that just plays on several machines at once only adjusting for small changes in botting programs who just happened to notice
G Apr 25th 2007 8:26PM
mike_a makes a good point. I've done engineering and jewelcrafting on alts. But my latest is a blacksmith, and I've never needed so much ore. I often use my level 70 jewelcrafter to collect it, since he can also mine, but can get around much faster and not worry about mobs. I'm sure I look like a bot when I zone out and race around Un'Goro. No bot, just bored, with no reason to do anything else but make a straight line to the next node.
MajorBill Apr 25th 2007 8:28PM
I've seen farm-bots getting smarter, but usually, they don't attack you if you don't attack them. I've only had one instance of a bot attacking me on sight, and following me all the way to Refuge Point >=)
One great note btw for spotting a farmer, look for a Hunter with a pets name such as "Boar", "Cat", or "Bear"
NewAlt Apr 25th 2007 9:49PM
I just created a new human alt the other day. I get a group invite without any chat from this character running around killing stuff randomly. Naturally I decline, but a little later I get into some trouble with a few extra mobs that I couldn't deal with. This character heals me then invites me to group again (but again, no chat). I figure I owe him one, so I join up. I try to chat a few times, he never responds. Instead he just continues running around and killing stuff, he's not even looting anything. Then he suddenly stops and starts spinning in place, that's when it dawns on me, this must be a bot!
So how's that for a clever strategy? Who's going to report a bot that groups with you and does the dirty work? I'm a programmer, and though I haven't actually done anything with WOW scripting, I have looked into the API. This kind of intelligence would be really easy to put into a script. Pick a target randomly, if target is ally and is low on life then heal and invite. If target is mob then attack.
Talitha Apr 25th 2007 9:59PM
@14--- YOU GOT KILLED BY A FARMBOT.....LOL :-)
tragedy Apr 25th 2007 10:24PM
I farm like this regularly... friends say I have a bit of a "profession obsession"-no, it's not entertaining, but if that's how you wanna spend your time, why not? I usually farm things like this on a reg basis for myself, for alt's profs so that I don't have to get the mats myself while levelling to skill up the profession, for other people, etc., and I have "routes" that I take through places to do it for just about anything I decide to farm up at any given moment :P