Analysis: Is the WoW laptop worth it?

Still, it does come with a lot of stuff-- not just a sweet 17" laptop, but also lots of Blizzard swag, and even that FigurePrints coupon. But the burning question is: when you add it all up, is the WoW laptop really worth it? I could probably think of better ways to spend $4500, and I'm sure you could, too. But if we really did want all of this stuff, and had the money to buy it with, would the Dell deal really be a bargain?
That's what I'm planning to find out. After the jump, we'll break down what you get with the set, what it costs, and whether or not this Dell deal really is the WoW fan's biggest dream, or whether or not you could save some cash just by buying it all separately.
So straight from Dell, here's what's in the set (this is the one that we're giving away later on, so keep in mind that you could win all of this stuff for free), and here are the prices I found for everything in it.
XPS M1730
This is the main computer. Dell lets you customize every piece of any computer you buy, so depending on the options that you get, the price will go up or down. But using the specs from the laptop we're giving away (2gb RAM, T7500 7700 Core 2 Duo processor, 200GB HDD, Dual SLI Nvidia cards, Logiitech Gamepanel LCD, backlit keyboard), the closest match seems to be the "Better" version of the laptop. Actually, as commenter Kadaan points out, the WoW laptop has a SATA drive, not a RAID drive. And somehow I missed that the processor on the WoW laptop was 7500, not 7700. So the WoW laptop is actually closer to the "Good" version, which retails at... $3528 $2699. Throw in an extra $50 for the extra 40 GB on the HDD, and you're up to $2749. Obviously, that changes the analysis below, too.
Blu-ray disc drive
This is the only thing I can see that's on the Dell laptop but doesn't come installed on the normal "Better" M1730. And it'll run you an extra... $200.
WoW Customization
Each laptop is custom designed for Horde or Alliance. But Dell obviously isn't the only company that customizes laptops-- an average laptop customization job costs anywhere from $99 to $199. Let's assume that you want it done really nicely, but on the other hand, your cousin knows a guy, so... $150.
WoW desktop backgrounds and screensavers
Who are they kidding? Sure it'll take a little while to find the images and load them on there, but as cool as it is to have this stuff pre-loaded, odds are you'll get sick of it and change it anyway... FREE.
WoW Backpack
I'm not sure where Dell is getting these backpacks, but buy a nice 17" laptop bag from Amazon, customize it with two or three Jinx WoW patches, and voila: a WoW backpack... $29 for the bag + $12 for the patches = $41.
And inside the backpack, you'll find:
Retail copies of WoW and the Burning Crusade expansion (with a certificate to upgrade to collector's editions, a behind-the-scenes DVD, and a WoW soundtrack)
I thought this would be super easy (there is a Battlechest out now, after all), but the collector's edition makes it tougher-- you can still buy the BC collector's edition, but the vanilla WoW CE is only available on places like eBay. And even if we just bought the CE for each, we'd get the pets, but we'd get a lot of extra stuff that Dell isn't giving, either-- the maps and mousepads and so on that came with the original items. So let's say you buy the BC collector's edition, and your good friend sells you his original WoW CE box for retail price and a six-pack of beer. And that gets us the pets, the soundtrack, and the DVD, too, since all of that stuff is in the BC CE. All total... $140.
...With all the patches downloaded and installed
I thought about calculating how much time it would take you to download and install all the WoW patches since the beginning of the game, and then multiply that by the average US wage to get an exact amount of how much time is money in this situation, but come on. As cool as it is to get a laptop in the mail that's updated to the latest version of WoW, is it really worth paying for? FREE.
(Save your "Price is Right arguments" until the end, please.)
Warcraft III Battlechest
Includes Warcraft III and Frozen Throne, and strategy guides for each... $40.
Strategy guides
For both Burning Crusade and the vanilla WoW... $35.
WoW TCG starter decks
For Heroes of Azeroth and Through the Dark Portal sets... $16.
WoW and Burning Crusade paperback novels
Tides of Darkness and the Rise of the Horde novels... $16.
Beta club key card with keys to future Blizzard betas
Can you really put a price on these? Well, probably-- all of the beta keys we know of from Blizzard have come from BlizzCon, and so the only way to get the keys was to plunk down $100 for a BlizzCon entrance fee. Of course, a lot more came with it (including, you know, the experience of BlizzCon), so let's say that getting the beta key was 20% of why you went to BlizzCon... $20.
"Golden Ticket" which entitles customers to a free FigurePrints character made
The site doesn't actually open until next week, but we're hearing it'll be $100 plus $15 shipping to do this without the actual laptop. So... $115.
Knowing you have the cash to pay through the nose for an uber laptop outfitted with everything a WoW fan could ever want, and yet still being a complete nerd...
PRICELESS. I'm only kidding! Let's add it all up and see if the Dell deal is cheaper or not:
Computer: $3528 $2749
Blu-ray: $200
Customization: $150
Desktops and screensavers: Free
Backpack: $41
Copies of the game...: $140 (depending on how you get the CE pets)
... with patches installed: Free
Warcraft III battlechest: $40
Strategy guides: $35
TCG stuff: $16
Novels: $16
Beta key club card: $20 (depending on how much you like BlizzCon)
Figureprints character: $115
Total: $4,301 $3522
Dell price: $4,499
Amount you'd save by buying all of this stuff by yourself: $198 $977
So technically, if you'd rather just buy everything yourself, you could still save about $200. However, in Dell's defense, I didn't charge at all for installing all the patches or choosing the wallpaper, or for the trouble of going out and finding all of this stuff on your own. The cost of that in time, plus the status of owning an official "World of Warcraft Edition" laptop, is most likely worth $200 to anyone who's got the money to spend.
Update: Given that the laptop without the WoW stuff is so much cheaper than I originally thought, you're actually looking at paying almost $1000 for the privilege of owning an official WoW laptop. It's a premium computer at an even-more-premium than premium price. I'm not sure that Dell can justify charging this much just for all this stuff-- sure it'd be a pain to go out and find all of these things yourself, but even if you just want a super customized laptop, for $1000 you can probably have it plated in silver and gold and still have change left over.
Some of the prices are also debatable, I'll admit-- the beta key actually holds a bunch of different keys (though we're not sure if they're for separate Blizzard games or keys to hand out to your friends for one game), so who knows what the value of that one is. And the backpack might be really nice, or it might not-- we just don't know yet. And of course, this analysis is about value to the customer, not profit for Dell-- they're already making a profit on the laptop, as is everyone else you buy this stuff from, and odds are they got all the official Blizzard stuff for free straight from the source.
On the other hand, anyone who's buying this laptop probably isn't buying it to save money anyway-- can you really be a WoW fan and not own retail copies of the game yet? No matter how much you spend, you're going to be getting some things you don't need in this deal. As usual, it's really up to the buyer whether it's worth it or not, no matter what the prices are.
And hey, if, like me, you aren't planning on spending $4500 on a laptop no matter what you get with it, don't forget that you can still win it for free! Stay tuned to WoW Insider for more about the WoW laptop, and your chance to take all this stuff home for $4500 less than the retail price.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Blizzard, News items, Economy, Features, Guides






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Bukinara Dec 6th 2007 2:12PM
seems like a pretty well reasoned analysis to me. probably would've been better to just let dell pay you off though.
Xeren Dec 6th 2007 2:12PM
nope.
Skylark Dec 6th 2007 2:19PM
Not in your life would I buy a laptop for WoW. My PC is good enough to play with no lag and all video settings on full.
Lenny Dec 6th 2007 2:15PM
The paramount of geekdom is not just wanting things like this, but diving into the math to make the price justification of purchasing it :D
Scoottie Dec 6th 2007 2:16PM
Is it worth it? Hell No
nativebrown Dec 6th 2007 2:16PM
i could sell you a box of monkey sh1t at a low cost.
doesn't mean its a good value if you don't need it to begin with.
Kadaan Dec 6th 2007 2:18PM
The only difference in system specs between the WoW model and the entry-level M1730 is the WoW model has Vista Ultimate (+$150.) So $2699+$150 = $2849. Performance-wise they're identical.
You're paying for the custom casing. The Gamepanel, backlit LCD (both not on the "better" M1730,) lighted speaker grills, etc.
The only question is whether the Blizzard swag is worth $1650. Personally, it's not. For that much you can buy a 30" LCD and a top-of-the-line desktop that would play WoW 50x better. If you need the mobility, I'd spend the extra $1650 actually upgrading the performance instead of the looks.
You can also spend a couple hundred bucks at colorwarepc.com to get a custom paint job on your own notebook if you care about the look.
Kadaan Dec 6th 2007 2:25PM
"Blu-ray disc drive
This is the only thing I can see that's on the Dell laptop but doesn't come installed on the normal "Better" M1730. And it'll run you an extra... $200."
Not sure where you're getting that from, but when I view the WoW notebook it says "CD / DVD Burner (DVD+/-RW Drive)" and not a Blu-ray.
So really it's:
Your Total: $4,301
- 679 because it's the base model, and not "Better" (no RAID, C2D 7500 and not 7700 the "Better" has)
- 200 (no blu-ray)
Real Total: $3422
Amount you'd save by buying all of this stuff by yourself: $1,077
Mike Schramm Dec 6th 2007 3:13PM
Dell told us the WoW laptop we were giving away would have a Blu Ray drive on it.
But you're right about the other specs, including the RAID and the CPU. I've updated the post to show just how much cheaper the non-WoW laptop is.
shiangchen Feb 22nd 2008 7:53AM
well put, true fans go for performance not "bling".
-Though I'm sure the price will go down ....lets say a bit more dramaticly than the other versions of M1730.
It's not really like ps3 was worth $6000+, but it really was worth I'd say 3k on the first day/week(if including shiping) it came out.
...same story here only a bit more high-end.
Bet you if in 5 years they came out with 5 better wow laptop versions you'll be lucky it's worth 2k.
Starie Dec 6th 2007 2:33PM
Wow, just wow. You analyzed everything but how WoW performs on the laptop.
How is the framerate?
Does the audio subsystem suck?
If a heatseeking missile were to fly past your house, does the laptop have a good chance of decoying it away from its intended target?
Good going.
Mike Schramm Dec 6th 2007 2:42PM
This is just a price analysis. The review of the laptop is coming soon-- Dan is planning to try the Crysis demo on it, I believe.
Matt Warner Dec 6th 2007 2:55PM
Another WoW Insider writer is brutalizing the laptop through a battery-of-tests to eventually bring you that very information. It'll probably be awhile since they are going to go ahead and review how several MMOs perform and not just WoW.
Corr Dec 6th 2007 3:05PM
zomg...lol
Jonathon Pop Dec 6th 2007 2:32PM
Are you taking free-base heroin?
Trema Dec 6th 2007 2:43PM
There's no real way to justify the price... its about the HAVING, not about what you are GETTING. I saw the prototype at Blizzcon, yearned for many months, and I jumped on the offer to buy one on the 4th. Having an exclusive, beautifully designed Horde-themed kick-butt XPS laptop is the attraction, not just the tech inside the laptop.
MadCow Dec 6th 2007 3:07PM
After the hell I went through trying to get Vista to run WoW effectively on a supposedly "Vista Optimized" laptop (stripping out memory hogging "improvements" & multiple driver downloads, plus the constant cheer of "Are you sure you want to run this program" crap), hell NO this isn't worth it. Even after all my tweaks, I'm lucky if my fps>10. Vista is an enormous pain in the ass when it comes to WoW - if I had a spare copy of XP I could go back to, I'd do it in a heartbeat. If you wanna spend $4k to screw up your gaming experience, go for it.
Richard Dec 6th 2007 3:48PM
UFAIL.
My Dell desktop runs WoW with Vista Premium at anywhere between 25-60 fps, depending where I am in-game.
Vista has nothing to do with it. I couldn't be happier with my Vista desktop.
MadCow Dec 6th 2007 6:03PM
@20:
If you didn't have a problem, count yourself lucky. Observe:
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=vista+problems+with+world+of+warcraft&btnG=Search
Or as Google says: "Personalized Results 1 - 10 of about 3,300,000 for vista problems with world of warcraft."
Gee, I guess that over 3 million web entries on the problem is my fault, not Vista's... might be wise in the future if you actually understood what you were talking about before commenting on it.
Richard Dec 6th 2007 9:45PM
@21:
Um, you really should learn how google gives search results before you make silly claims like there's 3.3M pages claiming problems with Vista/WoW.
UFAIL. Yet again.