Guildwatch: Caught redhanded, but too late

Who could that be? A former officer of Death Squad-- they had some jerk get promoted to officer in their guild, and then grab their stuff and ditch them, leaving them nothing but this log full of stolen items. Not cool. Be careful out there.
Meanwhile, there's lots of other guild news going around the realms, and this column is where we condense it into a smooth, witty form for you every week, and lay it out flat just for you. Click the link below to read this week's GW. And don't forget to send us your tips-- hit up wowguildwatch@gmail.com with drama, downed and recruiting news.
Meanwhile, there's lots of other guild news going around the realms, and this column is where we condense it into a smooth, witty form for you every week, and lay it out flat just for you. Click the link below to read this week's GW. And don't forget to send us your tips-- hit up wowguildwatch@gmail.com with drama, downed and recruiting news.
DRAMA
- We reported on Team sYn of Malfurion a while back-- their GL passed off duties to a friend, who then passed them back and caused the guild to disintegrate. All we've got this week is a little more detail on what he did when he came back-- apparently there was a pair in the guild that got promoted to officer status, and that spun a lot of people the wrong way. So lesson (if there even is one, other than don't reinvite an old GL who's already left the guild): be careful who you promote to officer.
- Kudzu on Underbog kicked out not one but two members recently, supposedly for being "attention whores" (our tipster's words, not mine). Apparently the two members were transgendered and one had recently transferred from another server, and apparently guild members had problems with them making waves in guild chat. Our tipster says the officers were egging them on all the time, but then later determined that the way to "fix" things was by just kicking them out.
- Can't Quit You on Baelgun-A is supposed to be "a drama-free guild," (aren't they all) but then there's this. Apparently one of their members had an alt named "Buttzlol," that one of the guildies felt was a little too immature to belong in the guild, and asked the alt to /gquit. The forum post then blows up into a condemnation of the guild at large and, despite his best efforts to avoid the "we're getting too hardcore" argument, says they're getting too hardcore. I have to say-- I do admire the guild's efforts to lock the thread up and shut down the drama before it even starts, but guys-- this is WoW. It's serious business. Let that drama fly free! Update: Aww, CQY didn't want to play our game, and deleted the thread. Here's their reaction to our post, though. I laughed at "LEAVE CQY ALONE!"
- Shadow Covenant on Shattered Hand has been experiencing a migration of its raiders out of the guild and into Versus. It's mostly on good terms, though, we're told-- lots of the raiders just felt SC wasn't progressing the way they wanted it to.
- This very column was used last week to give an "ultimatum" to Bratach Gheal on Bloodhoof-A-- one of their members emailed us to say that progress wasn't happening, and that the guilds' leaders should kick it up a notch. This week, someone who is presumably one of the guild's leaders emailed and said to "take your ultimatum and shove it, kthxbai." They say that BG has always been a casual friends and family guild, and that they're just fine with taking their sweet time progressing the way they want to. Which is all fine and good by us. Our original tipster is recommended to find greener pastures if he's looking for more progression.
- Small shakeup in Modus Operandi of Daggerspine, a familiar face in GW's downed section-- Methar has left the guild for Infinity. A few other raiders have left MO lately, but apparently it's all congenial-- they just want a little faster progression, and still want to do a Kara run occasionally to play together. Methar sez: "Thanks guys I'll always be MO in my WoWHeart." That's cute, but needs moar drama!
- Tiny bit of drama directed at Athanatoi on EU Shatar about the AQ gate opening. The thread doesn't get really good until about page 3, at which point someone accuses the guild of giving titles away, and then it's all downhill from there.
- Death Squad on Ner'zhul had their guild bank raided by an officer who'd been with them for quite a while. He nabbed it all (see pic above), and then split with his girlfriend. Sadly, a GM told them that there was no way they could get their stuff back. Sorry to hear it, guys, but you seem like a tight guild-- you'll survive it.
- Interesting story from Glory of War on Lightning's Blade. One of their members (not an officer) offered the guild a 1000g bounty, to go to a random member of the raid that finally downed Gruul, a fight they've been beating their heads up against for a while. The next raid, they had huge attendance (had to turn a few people away), and lo and behold, downed Gruul. And yes, someone walked away with 1,000g. Now, our tipster says that as a guild officer, he doesn't necessarily condone the bounty idea (he wants to assume that they'd have downed Gruul with or without the gold), but he says never to count out greed as a motivator. What do you all think of giving a bounty for a big down?
- Shinsei on Kilrogg-A dropped Zul'jin on January 1st to start the new year off right! Grats-- now, when trolls say, "Vengeance for Zul'jin," they'll be asking you to attack Shinsei.
- Scions of Vindication on Garithos-A, and they had an interesting helper to do it: their MT had been DC'ing all night due to what seemed to be an overheating router, so on their last attempt, he put an ice pack right on it. Did the trick-- they finished Curator and picked up the Chess Event loot. Sweet.
- An Army of Juan (winner of this week's Best Guild Name award) on Cenarion Circle went for the first time into Karazhan (on their first raid as a guild), and downed both Attumen and Moroes. Maiden is on notice. Grats-- welcome to the wonderful world of the endgame!
- Saints of Elune on Eonar-A downed three bosses in 3 hours in Kara the other night (the third was Maiden), and they did it all with only 9 players. Cool.
- Bloodlüst of Skywall-H dropped both HKM and Gruul on their first time into the lair after making it through ZA without 25 man gear. Grats!
- Armageddon Korps downed Gruul for the first time. They're also recruiting DPS and prot warriors, a shadow priest, and two hunters who aren't noobs.
- Modus Operandi on Sentinels-A (I guess not the MO in the drama section) has gotten the coveted 5/6 and 3/4. Vashj is on notice!
- Imminent Rueage on Thorium Brotherhood downed both HKM and Nalorakk, who, I assume, rued the day they ever stepped foot in an instance.
- Despised on Duskwood cleared out Gruul's on their first attempt ever. Noice!
- Order of the Raven on Aggramar has downed Illidan for a server first. They also say they've "beaten the game," but only if you've beaten Hyjal, guys. And Sunwell is just around the corner-- don't hold on too tight to those crowns, but do enjoy 'em while you've gotten them.
- Redeemed on Burning Blade-A formed four weeks ago and has downed lots of bosses since then: HAS, Alar, Lurker, Hydross, and Leotheras. Also, they're seeking a enhance shammy and a prot paladin. Don't you love raiding jargon?
- Vox Noctis on Hyjal-A is recruiting all classes but hunters. They're working on bringing up their raiding nights from 3 to 5 nights a week. If you're interested in raiding with them in SSC and TK, look them up.
- Eternal Guardians on Frostmane is a casual guild that just put Kara on farm, and is recruiting all classes for 25-man raiding, specifically prot warriors, resto druids, and any type of rogues, shammies, priests, and locks.
- Outcasts on Lightbringer-A is seeking raiders (and they do mean raiders, not just folks wanting to hang out) to help progression past Kara and into ZA and the 25 mans.
- Not necessarily a recruiting notice, but a tipster wanted to send a shout out to Horde Enforcement on Norgannon-- he says they're a very welcoming, inclusive guild, and that the officers and members are always ready to help out both newbies and leveling alts. Shout out, he says, to Spankit, Zanina, Unhollypally, Nonphixional and all of the rest of the guild from Heipher the Cow.
- Spectacular Death on Silvermoon, we're told, was named after the GL's tendency to find those all over the place in Azeroth and Outland. It's a casual retro raiding guild-- they're starting with Onyxia at the end of the month, and raiding all the old content up to Kara and the current endgame. They're currently recruiting level 53 and up to come with them.
- The League of Assassins on Silver Hand is looking for recuits at all levels and classes who are interested in leveling and improving the skills in fun and relaxed guild.
- Gone to Plaid on Kel'thuzad-H is farming Kara and is experienced in ZA and Gruul's-- they're looking for a few good raiders to fill out ranks for 25mans.
- Templar Knights of Shandris finished off Illhoof and Prince in Karazhan, and are now looking for healers and good DPS to fill out a second Karazhan group.
- Team Punishment on Dentarg is recruiting, and about to hit their one year anniversary. They have everything you'd want in a guild-- a weekly lottery, a guild bank, and a website.
- Dysthymia on EU Aggramar is a group of players that just transferred from the Darkspear server. They've had Kara on farm, and are now looking for new members around Gruul's and starting SSC/TK. They're seeking every class, but please be geared up to the level and ready to go.
Filed under: Guilds, Instances, Raiding, Guildwatch






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
ketchie Jan 26th 2008 11:25PM
our guild bank got looted a number of times, due to merging with another guild who then desided to leave taking half the stuff and the gold, this made most the original members leave and so did our gm, i am now the new gm and am having to rebuild the shattered guild, what i think is there needs to be a password system on the tabs that can be set to insure that only the people who can be trusted can take items
ketchie Jan 26th 2008 11:27PM
if you do this why are you still readin wow news?
Jeccius Jan 9th 2008 3:03AM
With our guild we decided early on to have a Public Guild Tab with a grab limit of 5 per day and 2 other tabs with half-decent stuff stuck in it which were viewable only. If anyone needs an item from any other tab they have to email us with the character and reason for needing the item, then we'd send it to them if justified. Seems to be working well and it seems to have avoided the obvious ninja'ing attempts. Also gives us heads up if someone decides to start emptying the main tab.
Necrous Jan 9th 2008 3:10AM
Not knocking your article, but the only thing really surprising about this story is we didn't hear about several cases of the same thing happening within weeks of guild banks release.
Keiji Jan 9th 2008 6:28AM
This happened a bit after 2.3 was out. I got invited to a guild. They were fine, great players but never had to see the GM online. People said that he was sick and would return in some days. Fine, health problems. Then one day he logs on wipes on the gbank and gets in vent saying that he's been hacked. Then he passes GM to another and gquits. Few minutes later, we discovered that he was just faking get hacked. He and some officers transfered and he changed his name. Thou he changed his name, was nothing so different. Easy to track him down. Too bad.. they looked decent people at first. :T
Razhlok Jan 9th 2008 8:11AM
We have three tabs on our guild bank. One for officers (with Hydross resist gear, rare crafting materials, repair bots, etc), one for top tier raiders with raid consumables (food, potions, elixir's, etc) and then a "free-for-all" open trade tab. One of our members got hacked and our free-for-all tab got cleaned out. Not the end of the world because its mostly junk in there. But, if a top tier raider or officer got hacked we would have been in deep doo-doo. So now we have a withdraw limit of 5 or 10 stacks for all tabs.
LFD Jan 9th 2008 8:23AM
The 'Can't Quit You' guild name made me lol.
nav Jan 9th 2008 8:54AM
Re: Glory of War - aren't in-game lotteries against the rules? ;-)
Atie Jan 9th 2008 9:00AM
The Shadow Reg on Cho'Gall had this happen the other day. An officer logged on, added two people to the guild (lvl 1 toons), promoted them to officers, who then CLEANED out our bank. They then /Gquit and deleted the characters. The officer in question was in Class at the time and did not log on. In this case I do believe he was hacked.
Mayo Jan 9th 2008 9:48AM
on Aggramar *has* cleared Hyjal, as well as Black Temple. Archimonde first killed on 12/28/07 & Illidan on 01/07/08.
Mayo Jan 9th 2008 9:48AM
^ Order of the Raven on Aggramar. Darn thing swallowed my tags. ;)
Sorosst Jan 10th 2008 9:31AM
Regarding the bounty for Gruul: Greed will ALWAYS be a motivating factor in human affairs. It's one of the only motivators more powerful than abject poverty, in fact. Might as well harness that power than beat your head against it, I say. Yay capitalism!
Spiritofire Jan 9th 2008 10:04AM
The Highland Army on Dunemaul(A) has downed Gruul for the first time 1/7/08. Lurker below on the horizon.
We are always looking for people to run, recently wanting some more healers.
About 4 days ago our main Officer incharge of our guild bank got hacked cleaned out everything worth while such as DMF cards, patterns, crafting mats, and some expensive pots. Then they transfered their character off our server and attempted to sell the character. Luckily the GM found enough proof and they guild banks contents will be safely returned as well as our guildies character.
gagazet Jan 9th 2008 2:24PM
That whole cant quit you drama, wasn't drama. Just a waste of time and the tipster has to get a life. While this guild try's to remain drama free, life is never that easy. The drama is rare and usually simple misunderstandings by those who get out of control. i.e. the person who starts the drama
aerosaucer Jan 9th 2008 10:49AM
Can't Quit You is the guild of the gaming website 1up.com (EGM and GFW magazines' website). They talk about it all the time on their WoW and MMO podcast, Legendary Thread. It was started as an uber-casual guild of lowbies, and got so big it split into two. I was under the impression that one part of the split was hardcore raiders, while the original CQY was full of people who liked to chat and mailspam each other pies and never got past level 50, but apparently that's not the case anymore.
I'm an avid listener, but lately their podcast has gotten pretty boring. The older episodes with Luke Smith are hilarious though (SCARAB LORD).
I highly recommend their GFW Radio podcast instead.
Garu Jan 9th 2008 2:42PM
At one point, we had split into two guilds. Something to do with "Overcrowding" or something like that. It seemed like a good idea at the time, but we have since regrouped back into the main CQY group because we realized it was kind of a silly idea. Also, while we are by no means hardcore, we are also not casual. We prefer to just be what we are, CQY. We do what we feel like at the time, really.
Solex Jan 9th 2008 3:04PM
When Luke was on Legendary Thread it rocked and was a big reason I started playing wow, now Jeff and Karen don't bother to log on which is amazing because they now do the show every 2 weeks, Demian and Sean are the only ones who raid end game as a hunter and priest so there's nothing really exciting about either and Ryan is either playing a different mmo or he's lvling a hunter in stv. So they talk about all the events about a week after they happen. You can sort of tell none of them really want to do this podcast anymore. As for Can't Quit You, I'm sure it's an awesome guild but I think casaul is synonymous with "I'm to terrible to ever get into a raid" or "I have crappy gear and no one will ever take me." Last I'd heard though they made a raid guild then it was becomming too hard to manage so they remerged back together.
Felix Jan 9th 2008 11:24AM
Re: Kudzu
Find out the facts before you post this kind of inflammatory trash.
onetrueping Jan 9th 2008 12:10PM
So your idea of enlightening people on what happened is to call the original bit of news "inflammatory trash?" Way to help your case there.
ThorinII Jan 9th 2008 12:47PM
So, what part is "inflammatory trash?" And what is the real story if there's something wrong with what Kudzu said?