Gold farmers try to take their game onto guild web sites
Last week I wrote about my harrowing experience of finding a gold farmer in one of my instant messaging windows. Apparently somebody "in one of those countries" (I'm slapped on the wrist every time I single-out China) must have swallowed a creativity pill. Just when I thought there was nothing new on the horizon, Aleeyah from Livejournal posted an article -- complete with screenshot -- of an odd in-game e-mail that was received from someone we can fairly safely assume is in the professional gold farming business.The written English in the in-game message is nearly bad enough to send one of my editors into a seizure. It's almost bad enough you can't understand it at all. The bare essentials that I can (barely) glean from the message is that the farmers are now offering gold to guilds in exchange for advertising.
Why would they do this? As I said in my last article on this subject, I think they're losing on the home front. I think their current marketing techniques are not bringing the level of revenue that they want. I think more and more people are discovering just how easy it is to right-click a spammer when they're checking their mail, silence the spam, and have the feel-good feeling of knowing they've done something right for their community. I know I do it all the time. I won't go as far as to call Blizzard's anti-spam tactics a flourishing success, but as the old saying goes "If you can't beat 'em, wear 'em down," and I think that's exactly what is starting to happen.
So if real-money transactions are frowned upon by Blizzard and prosecuted by Blizzard, why wouldn't they just try and move their advertising medium to neutral ground? Sure, there are lots of guilds that will have nothing to do with selling their corporate souls to the devil in this manner. You can rest assured however that there are also lots that would jump at an opportunity like this that could pay for all their bank tabs for nothing more than a measly advertisement on their guild web site. It does bring up the interesting question however, of whether a guild that supported a gold farming business financially could potentially face retribution from Blizzard. While I can't see a guild getting banned en masse for this, it would sure be a wakeup call if such a guild logged in to find their tag gone along with all their guild bank slots and contents.
Does this mean that the spamming around the Ironforge and Orgrimmar mailboxes is going to let up? Not likely, or at least not very much. It just means "these people" have found yet another way to devastate our server economies for their own profit.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Virtual selves, Odds and ends, Economy






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Aleeyah Jan 23rd 2008 10:35AM
Wow, I'm famous! Nice to see my posts on LJ have some worth. Haha.
Well, I don't think that I could seriously take this offer on board considering how I feel about the gold farming sweat shops after having seen footage of the conditions they are forced to work in, it's slave labour.
Yeah, you could profit in your virtual life in your virtual world, but at the cost of what?
I'm really not up for supporting that...
Ecoticus Jan 23rd 2008 10:53AM
The proliferation of gold has indeed affected (though maybe not devastated) the in-game economy of wow. What's interesting to me, though, is not that there has been inflation, but that prices have inflated differently for different goods, which in turn changes the game experience for different types of players.
While the price of primals and other crafting mats has definitely gone up, the cost of repairing, flying, purchasing mounts, has not gone up (gone down in terms of real wages). What's the effect on the gamer? For a casual like me, not a huge effect, and might even benefit me, even though I have never bought gold. My primals are selling great from the influx of gold, which means I have plenty of funds to cover the non-inflated cost of my kara wipes.
Who does it hurt? The hardcore gamers. They are the ones who buy the most consumables, enchants, gems and other such items which are highly susceptible to inflation. If they plan to buy such consumables, gold buying in the economy simply increases the hours of farming necessary for each hour of raiding. Unless, of course, it is the hardcores who are buying the gold.
BarliTruebeard Jan 23rd 2008 12:16PM
I've recently found a way to discourage gold-spammers around the mailboxes that have gotten them to log off within just a few minutes. I've created a macro that fires off 5-6 emotes in a row. I target the spammer or simply anyone else in the area and fire off my AntiSpam macro and it quickly removes the spammer text with emotes from my toon. The gold spammers message is quickly removed from most players text windows and can be fired off immediately as soon as they send it off again. I've not gotten any complaints from other players (so far) but it seems to discourage the goldspam. After about 4 to 5 attempts to spam and being quickly overwritten by emotes, they log off. Seems to work. I use it when I log onto my bank alt around the mailbox. If they are spamming gold ads then I spam my emotes to cover up their message. Is this simply adding to the problem or is it more of a public service to get their spam scrolled off the chat window?
/point
/laugh
/burp
/cheer
/openfire
/dance
Evander Jan 23rd 2008 12:47PM
You're probably preventing some people to actually read their spam but that's about it.
Those are spambots. They are made to go from point A to point B, say their stuff and log. Nothing you'll do will change this. You can yell at them, spam them, they will do what they are programmed to do.
thebvp Jan 23rd 2008 1:23PM
I'mI’m going to play devil’s advocate here.
1) Societal laws =/= moral laws. It’s not morally wrong to speed in your car. God will not come down and smite you if you rip the tag off your pillow. Similarly, you are not going to hell for buying gold.
2) When people buy gold, they are making a real time/value judgment. This is no different than buying a car, dvd, or cell phone. You weight the benefits against the costs and make a decision. As has been mentioned in this thread, gold is plentiful and easy to come by. Then why do people still buy it? Time. Like it or not, the game is still a huge time sink and not all of us are able to spend a few hours a day picking flowers in Zangarmarsh. If you still want to raid, pvp (talk about a huge time sink), or whatever, but have real life commitments that prevent you from picking said flowers or grinding out rep for a faction that awards you with a mount that you will never use (epic flyer), spending $40 so you don’t have to worry about having guildmates harass you about having unenchanted gear or “ghetto gems” might very well be worth it to you.
Theserene Jan 23rd 2008 3:39PM
I bet these gold companies will never cough up the money. They get free advertising from a guillible guild and lets face it, who are they going to complain to when they don't get the cash? Blizz?
JamesofBerkeley Jan 23rd 2008 4:59PM
It seems an awful lot of talk about cheating and morals and yadda yadda yadda. It is so much simplier than all of this.
Buying Gold means you are no longer playing the game.
Simple. You are done performing the "exercise" required to get your bit of cheese and now you want someone else to do the labor for you. You lose in the process. If getting gold by playing the game is no longer fun, then I believe you need to call Blizzard up and cancel your account until such time that running a digital avatar around a mystical impossible world to collect virtual money to buy virtual toys to kill virtual monsters and feel good about virtual accomplishments sounds fun again.
Sorry for the run on. I love playing WoW and all the random crap I can do, but for one last time, its a game that is about the experience. Not fun? Quit.
thebvp Jan 23rd 2008 7:48PM
I’ll agree that buying gold is analogous to outsourcing. The reasons that both occur are very similar. I don’t like outsourcing, you may not like outsourcing- I’m pretty sure most people don’t, yet it happens because people would rather spend less than employ American factory workers.
The point is- if you support Nike making shoes in China instead of the States so your Jordans won’t cost $500, you’re like a gold buyer. If you merely tolerate outsourcing as a necessary evil, but understand the reasons why Nike does what they do, those reasons are very similar to why someone would buy gold. If you’d rather pay $500 for a pair of Nikes (I don’t think most people are like this), you are not a gold buyer.
Outsourcing, like gold buying, will never go away until we address the reasons why it occurs. Doing so in WoW (must like in RL) would drastically change the game as we know it.
Paul Jan 23rd 2008 9:48PM
Hmmm my biggest issue with gold farmers is how the hack peoples accounts steal everything and devastate the people who were actually playing the game for fun all in the name of giving the lazy asses of the world a way to cheat in WoW. I don't give a flying hoot if you want to ruin the game for yourself. I don't think the gold farmers destroy the in game economy either.
But they aren;t happy with that. They start screwing with people's accounts and ruining the game for others in a really bad way and people defend this practice? I hope everyone who has ever bought gold from gold sellers end up with their accounts totally F'ed and Blizzard says "You bought gold so oh well!"
Tarbh Jan 24th 2008 1:01AM
In my opinion, put one mob directly in the patch of the starting zone and the capital city, 1 son of hogger, which can be killed by anyone high enough to get there, but make it trouble for level 1/2 etc, and make the nature of it's attacks/debuffs so random that it would ruin anyone's attempts at making a macro to get around it.
LostOne Jan 24th 2008 10:15AM
Goldfarmers are losing all over:
* Easily reported for spamming in game.
* Paranoid people avoid their websites fearing that they'll let keylogging malware on their system.
* It's easy to farm gold doing dailies and continuing to quest after hitting 70. I honestly think daily quests are part of Blizzard's war against gold farmers. By making it easy to farm ~100g per hour doing dailies each day, less people are likely to buy gold from goldfarmers. And with daily quest limits going up in 2.4, it'll only get harder for the goldfarmers.
springz Jan 30th 2008 11:09AM
@22
Actually I was talking about the goldfarming bots you see running around killing/skinning stuff in winterspring/nagrand.
Those are not trial accounts :-)
Westley Jan 22nd 2008 6:13PM
1. Accept the agreement with the gold farmers.
2. Post the ad.
3. Buy the bank tabs, get the gold, etc.
4. Quickly remove the ad.
5. PROFIT. By keeping the gold, that is, and telling farmers thanks for the gold and to piss off.
Scoottie Jan 22nd 2008 6:26PM
Westley's idea is funny, but would probably get your whole guild banned by Blizzard.
I just delete all new users to my forums that dont seem legit. Yes its a pain but it gets easier the more you dont cuz you start to see a pattern.
Cap Jan 22nd 2008 8:03PM
To Scoottie:
If you're using PHPBb, install a mod called "Textual Confirmation". It's worth WAY more than gold to me. It cut down the spam on my forums to nearly zero literally overnight. Go to the PHPBb website and search their forums for Textual Confirmation.
infection Jan 22nd 2008 6:21PM
I'm partly satisfied.
They have to create a character, run allll the way to org, spam, log off real quick, create a character.....
They are having to put in a lot more work since you can just click report them.
And in the end.. they are spamming /s not /1 or /2
Their total audience is barely any players at all for the work they have to do to get that new character to the mailbox.
PeeWee Jan 23rd 2008 4:03AM
This can be done with hardware macros. Actually, I can make a macro for my N52 right here, right now, that'll start WOW, create a new char (lvl 1 warrior) run him to Orgrimmar, spam away and then log off.
mark Jan 22nd 2008 6:26PM
As we saw from the somepage.com incident, gold spammers are inserting virus programs into their advertising. So, just place an ad in a guild's website, wait a little while for the keylogger to get all the guild members passwords, then drain the gold from the entire guild.
Sal Jan 22nd 2008 6:34PM
So yeah, my account was justed hacked by farmers :P. Sold everything on two of my alts and used my rogue to farm. Specced a dagger rogue for sinister strike use, and didn't even have backstab on the bar *gg farmers*. Blizz helped me get my account back and an hour later, suspended me for what the farmers did with my account. Yeah, it's nice to play WoW, right? :P
Theserene Jan 23rd 2008 3:42PM
How did they get your account? Did you download some dodgy software?