You do realise guilds on there are also ranked by the drops they get - so if Nihilum haven't been farming BT 24/7 for the last 10 months, (which nobody in their right mind would do) then other guilds will gain more points and be listed higher than them; and it also depends on drops.

If a guild gets lots of Warglaives drop, then guess what - they will earn more points on the WoW Jutsu site.

You know, the FAQ's are there for a reason.

Yes. And if you read the faq for it you'll realize wowjutsu awards marginal points for repeated kills.

Besides, Nihilum was top of the list before 2.4. Which means they got credit for farming BT etc as much, moreso, than anyone. All this means is other guilds have pulled ahead of them post 2.4. Perhaps momentarily.

Not in top 40!? Then this video on how to beat Brutallus is totally worthless!

"And if you read the faq for it you'll realize wowjutsu awards marginal points for repeated kills."

Yes - but if guilds repeatedly get the top drops then they will earn more points.

You will also recall how then the Illidan race was on that when other guilds killed him, they were only fractions of points away from Nihilum anyway.

So your new point is...?

Not a new point. The same point.

The quality of drops have nothing to do with the points you're awarded. Only evidence of the first time boss kills. And then infinitesimal incremental points per kill after that.

All of that is made pretty clear in that faq you mentioned.

Let's go back to your original point because you clearly have some issues with this topic...

"Last I checked Nihilum wasn't even in the top 40 worldwide guilds on wowjutsu...."

And?

Pretty sure that's covered off in my post from 4-06-2008 @ 9:35PM.

but if you want more clarity here goes:

Nihilum is not the "flagship" guild at this point in time as the author suggests. Say what you will about wowjutsu but it is objective, unbiased, and the closest thing to a popularly accepted leaderboard for pve content in WoW. It's certainly historically accurate to give that crown to Nihilum for all their consistent and persistent excellent effort and will likely be so again but right now that honor goes to another guild(s). That's all.