Why the PvP game exists in WoW, and why it's a good thing
Last night I posted why I feel that the PvE game has been, is, and always will be the real game in WoW. One of the interesting inferences that people made was that I don't like PvP, and that I don't do it. Nothing is further from the truth. It was interesting to read the number of comments on that article, and I think it might surprise some folks that save for this introduction paragraph and a few edits I made, this article was written before I wrote my PvE piece.So, why do I PvP? What attracts me to the PvP game, and why is it a worthwhile thing to do in WoW? There are three primary reasons that PvP is a game worth playing. First, it provides a critical and necessary change of pace from the PvE game. Secondly, it gives those with limited play time an opportunity to enjoy the game and succeed at what they do. Finally, PvP is beginning to turn into a legitimate eSport, and provides some good entertainment there in. Let's look at each of these reasons individually.
A Change of Pace
Raiding and playing the same five man instances can get quite boring over time. While several encounters are scripted to have random elements in them, they essentially come down to repeating the same thing over and over. PvP provides a different thing to do – even though some fights essentially come down to the same action again and again.
In order to keep the game interesting a change of pace is needed. PvP provides this. Without it, the game would become stale and bland, with only the PvE side of things to do. This would no doubt draw away a portion of the player base, something that any game wants to avoid.
A Casual Approach
You might only have a few hours a week to play WoW, and that's just fine. PvP provides a great way for those with limited play time to get some nice gear and have fun while doing it. Casual PvP makes for a great way to retain the player base, and thus keep the PvE updates to the game coming. Of course, there is also casual raiding and instance playing too, and that's another fine aspect of the game.
However one thing that PvE casual play can't approach PvP casual play is in the rewards that it earns. It simply is easier and quicker to get good PvP gear casually than it is to get good PvE gear casually. It might take a casual guild four or five months to clear Kara, but only take a month or two to get a full PvP epic set.
This is not to say however that, just like raiders, there are not hard core PvP players. The arenas, especially the higher end competitive arm of it (like the arena tournament), caters to those who want to take a hard core approach to PvP. And that's a great way to spend your time if you're into that. While I personally am more of a hard core raider than a PvPer, I still do enjoy my weekly arena matches.
A Competitive eSport
PvP in WoW is quickly becoming a legitimate eSport. For evidence of this you need to look no further than the arena tournament that is begin sponsored by Blizzard. The winners of the tournament are going to walk away with a hefty sum of money, enough that if they spend it right they'll be able to live on for a year. This is only a positive step for the game, and one that will eventually lead to bigger and better things for both WoW and the larger MMORPG community in general.
For all of the reasons above, I find myself compelled to PvP. I enjoy the game, even if it's not the real game in WoW. It provides me with a change of pace, some easy casual play on my alts, and is the beginning of a competitive eSport. These aspects are, in my opinion, the corner stone to the additional game Blizzard has built on top of WoW, and this is only a good thing.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, PvP
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 4)
thethirdmoose Apr 20th 2008 6:35PM
you can record gameplay, at least in the mac version...
Adam Flanczewski Apr 20th 2008 7:15PM
Yes, I'm aware that I can record videos with the MacOS X version on my PowerBook, but I mainly play on my E6600/8800GT workstation with a glorious and large screen.
I understand that it was easier to implement QuickTime recording of in-game footage in the MacOS X version, but they have not added any similar functionality to the win32 version. A better solution would be to simply log all matches as simple replay files similar to StarCraft/WarCraft. No performance hit, easy to share. Downside? No view of clicks (if any...) or UI elements.
schwonga Apr 20th 2008 4:25PM
I like your article for the first two points you made, however I have to disagree with your third: I couldn't care less about eSports. It adds a lvl of annoying fan boy obsession that this game has enough of already and that really serves as a distraction from the core game.
One thing I think you missed out on is the added social aspect. Yeah, raiding invovles a lot more cooperation and organization, but in PvP you are fighting against actual people, who think and change tactics and, yes, scream at the computer when you lock em down and burn up em. I love the fact that I'm fighting against real people and not just some ones and zeros.
Comely Apr 20th 2008 4:39PM
I get the feeling you aren't very high rated in arenas and have no idea what you are talking about.
Heenmor Apr 20th 2008 4:46PM
Oh, now i see. 1) When you get bored in PvE (The only REAL World of Warcraft) then you might dabble in PvP (Not true WoW)
2) Lets the "casual" (you define that word) players catch up to PvE 1337ness
3) It attracts more people to WoW who can then become PvE zealots and make you look good.
Is this the drift? It has not redeemed the prior article, which made me most disappointed to the point of possibly not checking this site twice daily in the future. Might as well browse the general forum slop.
Svenn Apr 20th 2008 4:49PM
"easy casual play on my alts"
Ofcourse it's easy, you play in 1300-1400 rated games.
shakezoola Apr 20th 2008 5:11PM
Man this just seems like a copout now. "Oh crap I posted a very one sided, poorly thought out article that offended a lot of people and now the site is mad at me. Time to flip the coin over now and make it all better."
Deathlike Apr 20th 2008 5:17PM
I think these articles could've been better if they were co-written with another author who disagreed with your opinion.
In fact, I'm going to suggest that as a column - I think I'd enjoy seeing these sort of "debate" topics as long as both sides are argued. If you had, say, the author of the "Art of War(craft)" column (I forget his name, my apologies) argue the other side of the coin subsequent to the first article.. it would've been much better accepted.
Eternalpayn Apr 20th 2008 5:23PM
You should have just quit when you were slightly-less far behind than you are now. This was just a half-assed excuse to try to make your flaming PvE elitist post seem justified.
Druid dude Apr 20th 2008 5:42PM
Grats on edging out Shramm for the Jackassery Award.
Aldrel Apr 20th 2008 6:39PM
I didn't think it was possible, but apparently it is. Too bad some of the news on this site is good because most of the stuff is worse than worthless.
Grog140 Apr 20th 2008 5:46PM
Grow up people, it's just an opinion piece.
For those of you who aren't intelligent enough to grasp that concept; it's where another person relays their opinion through some written medium and provides reasons as to why they think that way.
Just because you don't agree doesn't mean it's right, wrong, or that he's gay. It just means you don't agree.
Again, everyone just grow up.
Druid dude Apr 20th 2008 7:16PM
For those not intelligent enough to understand what people are so unhappy about, here's a hint: It has nothing to do with being for or against PVE or PVP, and has nothing to do with opinions.
Pzychotix Apr 20th 2008 7:45PM
And we're just a bunch of people voicing our own opinions about the writer's opinions.
No one's saying he's right or he's wrong.
We're just saying it's all a bunch of flamebait. Which it is.
anon Apr 20th 2008 5:48PM
wow, way to jump on a writer for expressing any opinion at all. bash him for saying that the main focus of WOW is pve, bash him for saying he likes pvp...i guess you are right, you can't like both pve and pvp. pick a side and stick to it! /sarcasm off
i think if you look at both articles together they make perfect sense. in this game, as opposed to say HALO, you need to progress in the pve content to at least some degree before you can begin to play pvp. if for no other reason that shows that pve is the focus of the game. that being said, i think the case is argued that pvp while not the main focus of the game is a very crucial part of the game and that one can enjoy doing pve/pvp or (gasp) both.
esumiwa Apr 20th 2008 5:50PM
Blogists are NOT journalists.
Let me repeat that.
Blog writers are NOT journalists.
Blogists are at best op-ed, opinion edition, writers attheir best, but for the most part, they're just regular folks that have been given the opportunity to write by the internet and given the semblance of journalistic writers. Just because a person can write a structured piece, does not make them a journalist.
Or even a good writer.
So to the folks decrying a journalistic standard on an opinion site, you are mistaken.
Would you compare Perez Hilton as a journalist to say, Anderson Cooper, Pearl, Cronkite?
Well, some of you probably would because you have been duped, fooled, convinced that blog writers = journalistic integrity.
No blogger is a journalist nor should be given the same respect or power of being an authority of a journalist.
they are simply writing their bets opinion.
Mark Crump Apr 21st 2008 1:39PM
Generally, I don't think it's fair to exclude bloggers from the journalism table. According to the wiki, a journalist is "a person who practices journalism, the gathering and dissemination of information about current events, trends, issues and people." Bloggers can do that. A good example is the Interdictor (the guy that livejournaled on the scene coverage during Katrina). His coverage was the most accurate, and far better, than what we were getting from mainstream journalism. In fact, you can make a strong argument that what mainstream "journalism" is doing now is simply acting as mouthpieces.
Anyone writing about events (even in games writing) should adhere to the Standards of Professional Journalism (http://www.spj.org/).
Good bloggers can be good journalists.
Bad bloggers can be bad journalists
Bad journalists can be bad journalists.
While Adam wrote about his opinion, it's really what would be called an Editorial in a magazine or newspaper. And those can be as off-base as people think Adam is.
Massadonious Apr 20th 2008 6:26PM
Opinion piece or not, I still think it's a little disengenious of him to put this piece out right after he praised PvE as the greatest thing since sliced bread. If anything, he should of passed this off to a different writer, (excuse me, opinion writer) and have him write an intro contradictory to Adam's PvE piece. As it stands now, opinion or not, he just looks like a hypocrite.
anonymoose Apr 20th 2008 6:58PM
I didn't like the preceding anti PvP flame bate article, and I don't like this one.
Congratz on completely destroying any potential for credibility as a contributor to WoWInsider.
WoWInsider, can you sack him or provide us with a method to /ignore specific authors? Usually I feel compelled to provide some sort of intelligent response as opposed to the sheer flaming I am doing now--but the baiting of the oringal article and the half hearted approach to this one is pretty sad.
btdown Apr 20th 2008 7:09PM
Pvp is not crucial or in any way necessary. if it disappeared tomorrow (which i hope it does) it would not affect anything.