Gamers on the Street: How heroic do you gotta be to do a heroic?

When I popped onto the Thrall realm recently to visit with players for Gamers on the Street, I had intended to talk to players about how the Wrath of the Lich King will offer the same instances in both 10-man and 25-man sizes. But as message after message from players seeking heroic groups or group members scrolled through my chat window – none of them stating "no blues" up front, which players list right up in your face on the realms where I play – I knew I needed to follow up. Do players on Thrall simply assume heroic players possess a certain level of gear? Do they plan to carry weaker players? Does the heroic community only group with others they know? I flipped back to WoW Insider for recent insights and found tips for beginners to heroics and pointers toward the easiest heroics, but nothing that offers players ideas on how to actually get into a heroic group.
So Gamers on the Street hit the street to investigate.
Wake, Human Warrior <Torrent> We first spied Wake in chat, offering to tank for any heroic. A quick look at his gear was enough to show that he wasn't in danger of suffering from undergear-itis, so we wondered how tough he usually found getting into a PuG for heroics.
Gamers on the Street: Hi Wake, this is WoW Insider. We're trying to find out how players on this server handle heroic PuGs. Do most PuGs here require excellent gear? Do groups take players with blues?
Wake: Well, everyone's got to start somewhere -- and if it be blues and greens, then yah, sure, why not? Usually if you know how to play your class, you will work up the epics sooner or later.
What about you -- have you done a lot of heroics yourself?
Wake: Heh ... yah.
But you're open to taking players with less advanced gear?
Wake: Sure. As long as they know what they are doing, gear isn't a factor.
Many players seem to feel you need to be in purples already before tackling a heroic.
Wake: Haha. Well, those are the ones who are lazy and don't like to play their class as well as it should be played.
Do most heroic PuGs here share the same outlook, do you think? Or do other players tend to be a little pickier about gear?
Wake: Lots of people on this server seem to be lazy and want things done for them, and lots don't understand that it doesn't just get handed to you.
Do you think that's because Thrall is an older server?
Wake: Never really thought about it, but that seems pretty logical.
Fair enough. Thanks for your thoughts, and good luck with your heroic!
Smokedogg, Human Paladin <Blood Sweat and Tears> Smokedogg, the GM of <Blood Sweat and Tears>, answered our call for more feedback. With a number of 70s who've run heroics and with experience making sure the players in his guild are well geared and on the right track, he was able to offer some astute observations about Thrall's heroic scene.
Do players here generally screen pretty hard? On some servers, heroics are considered speed badge runs and players in blues who need the gear never get a chance.
Smokedogg: I won't take anyone who ain't in at least all 70 blues. No blues are fine but not for all heroics. I think SH, SV, Slabs and Arc, you want a group with a good portion of their gear being epics, whereas Ramps is easy and blues are ok.
Do you think this server is especially hard to get a heroic pug on, or fairly reasonable?
Smokedogg: Heroics are easy to PuG here 'cause of the high population of the server.
Some servers in the same situation are snobs about it, though, and want to do speed runs with epic-geared players only.
Smokedogg: Yeah. As a GM, I find that doesn't teach the players good gaming.
Smart tactic. Any tips for players trying to break into heroics?
Smokedogg: Get all your level 70 blues from higher regular dungeons such as Arc, SLabs, SV and SH. I take players into Kara with blues.
Whoa, wait a minute. There are groups now that want something more than blues for Kara?
Smokedogg: As long as they have all level 70 items (blue) enchanted properly, there is no reason they can't succeed in Kara. And gems, too -- they should (have) blue gems in blue gear; nothin' lower.
So are there a lot of players on Thrall doing Kara who are just after badges or to backfill one or two pieces?
Smokedogg: Some are there for badges. Some need one or two pieces as slight upgrades.
So not many players actually at that progression level, then?
Smokedogg: There is a large amount of 'toons on this server in SSC or beyond.
Interesting stuff. What's your guild working on now, progression-wise?
Smokedogg: TK ATM; started last week. Haven't gotten Void yet, although we got him (to) 8%. LOL
Well here's to better luck this week. Oh, and good luck with your heroics!
Filed under: Features, Interviews, Gamers on the Street






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Aztec May 19th 2008 4:24PM
I think it matters more for tanks and healers to have all epic gear for heroics. DPS could probably get away with having weaker gear like all blues. The boss fights might take longer and it would be harder on the healer, but easy heroics like Ramps are very doable.
I know alot of players who are scared to do heroics because of their lack of gear. How else are players suppossed to get gear though? Grinding out points for pvp gear can get old.
Manatank May 19th 2008 5:03PM
I had no problem tanking heroics in blues when I was gearing up my paladin. I only tanked regular SV, SL, SH when I was leveling (couldn't do tempest keep because of the stupid flying mount limitation at the time). That way I already had all the level 70 blues when I dinged, and was able to tank heroics and Kara right away.
Now that I have all of the nice badge gear, and some 25-man epics, I find that heroics are so easy to tank I have to switch out my high end tanking gear for something with less mitigation so I can actually take damage. Tanks who don't take damage can't keep up with agro. Warriors and druids need it for rage, and paladins need it to regen their mana pool through spiritual attunement. Luckily as a paladin, I can just swap tanking rings and trinkets for spell damage ones and it not only solves my incoming damage issue, but also amps up my threat to untouchable levels.
My point being that having epics doesn't make a huge difference in tanking heroics, because tanking epics will make a tank out gear heroics. For me, epics just amp my threat and allow my healers a bit more breathing room.
Kyle May 19th 2008 4:27PM
Why not heroic's in Blues? It is about progression. Greens and some blues drop in the world as quest rewards, blues are in Normal mode dungeons. It makes sense to have blues to go to heroic mode which is 5 man raids for the people who can't do 10/25 mans.
I guess the reason for this is column is because of the welfare PVP epic situation.
George May 19th 2008 5:45PM
Hey buddy, heroics drop purples and badges (which can be used to buy purples). Most crafting professions have epic gear that can be crafted at 375.
So yeah... you don't really need to do Kara in blues and greens.
Way to tie in the whole welfare epic thing unnecessarily.
Justin May 19th 2008 4:37PM
I did my first heroic literally immediately after dinging 70, with a pug. In blues and greens. We wiped once on the first boss (it was Steamvault) but after that it was fine. I wasn't lighting up the DPS chart but I never pulled aggro thanks to Omen, I made sure our healer was Soulstoned, I gave out Healthstones, and I re-banished elementals halfway through fights.
Since then I've had a couple other successful heroic runs, and a couple unsuccessful ones.
It seems that when EVERYONE is in the gear I'm in (late 60s blues and greens), Heroics are too much for the group, no matter how well we play. But when I'm the one in the lowest gear, we breeze through. And the group is happy to have me despite my gear, because I know my class & know my role.
Xonate May 19th 2008 4:39PM
As a ZA geared tank, getting heroic groups is easy, and I very often find people just whispering me after seeing me in IF trying to get me to tank for various heroic runs. However, even when I was still in just 70 blues, wearing various pieces of the bold/felsteel set, I had people wanting me to tank for heroics as well. Maybe it's just because I'm a tank and people are almost always looking for them, but on my server (Silver Hand) there seem to be quite a few people going to heroics in blues or maybe even a couple greens. The only real exception is heroic MgT, where having almost all epics is almost a requirement for anyone trying to pug it.
Memzer May 19th 2008 5:07PM
Completely agree with the point Xonate made. Getting into a Heroic PUG is completely dependant upon your ability to Tank, Heal, or .
I've leveled every character to 70 now and I never, EVER, have trouble getting into a daily Heroic group on my Tank or Healers; people are just so desperate to get those classes. As Xonate said - if you're playing a class that can Tank or Heal you can expect 5000 whispers a day (ok, maybe not that many) from poor souls who've been waiting for two hours to find one.
On the DPS side things aren't so good. Generally I've found that people on Frostmourne tend to armory you and favour non-newbie runs. Regardless selection for Heroics is generally based on | Gear > Class with it being extremely difficult to get a spot as DPS without any CC. Especially for something like H:MgT - I've never gotten my enhancement shaman (t4/5 geared these days) to go to a non-guild H:MgT.
My suggestion to anybody playing a non-CC DPS class is to befriend yourself a Paladin Tank. These days a Karazhan geared Paladin and a decent healer are able to complete most heroics without any crowd control at all and thus are usually more willing than say a druid or warrior to give your Boomkin, Retadin or Kitty a run through that instance :)
The other option if you're just running heroics for badges is to start working for an off set for your non-cc alts. My druid is balance but I'm happy to do his dailies and respec resto to heal a Kara raid for 20 odd badges :)
But yeah, getting off topic. If you're on Frostmourne and you want to do heroics:
Tank > Healer > Mage | Hunter > Rogue | Warlock* > Everything Else
*: Warlocks won't ever struggle to get into H:SH or H:Mech runs.
Manatank May 19th 2008 5:08PM
Heroic MrT really is a skill check more than anything. More so than any other 5-man, it requires DPSers that aren't retarded. Usually a good healer and tank can make any 5-man a breeze. MrT requires teamwork on the level of raiding. Poor players should not apply.
Andrew May 19th 2008 9:12PM
I disagree a little on H. MrT, only because the difference between geared DPS able to down the majority of a six-pull within the duration of a Sap and DPS that has to deal with CC breaking mid-mobs in really noticeable in an instance filled with casters, healers and ranged mobs.
If you have undergeared DPS, it's mostly a skill check for your tanks and healers. If you have undergeared healers or a tank, it's skill check for your CC. Nice tension, I think.
Vashu May 19th 2008 4:49PM
on Al'akir Eu, my old server, there was steady amounts of PUG Gruul, Magtheridon and karazhan going on every week. There was even a full alt guild that cleared SSC, TK and most of Hyjal as well.
Concerning Heroics, You do need a certain amount of gear as a tank atleast. You can get off a bit easier if you're not the tank though. Since as a tank you have to reach minimum requirements for mitigation. It makes sense to look at peoples gear and enchants / blue 70 items makes everything easier for everyone. Though epics is a bit overrated
Edboy May 19th 2008 6:52PM
This argument confuses me. That's why I stopped trying to gear up my warrior. People say that you need blues and epics to get into heroics or Kara. The problem is you need to get into heroics and Kara to get the gear.
pvp gear is even worse because now people are complaining that too much pvp gear is bad and yet they still want you to carry it around.
Caitlen May 19th 2008 7:45PM
@ 17:
It isn't that PVP gear is bad, far from it. The problem is that PVP gear generally spends a large chunk of its item budget on stats such as stamina and resilience which, depending on class and situation, might not be as beneficial in a PVE encounter as other stats such as defense, block, hit, etc. In some cases therefore, blue-level gear can be better for heroics/raiding than purple. In some cases it isn't. Purple is not always better than blue.
It's up to the individual player to know what gear stats are most beneficial for their role in any given situation, and carry (or have available) alternate sets accordingly. If you aren't familiar with what stats to look for, and in what quantities, finding heroic PuGs will probably be harder, as will the runs themselves. There are many good websites available to help players learn the necessary information to improve their efficiency.
blackcrows May 19th 2008 8:06PM
I agree. My guild has been bashing our heads against Moroes for over a month with little success. Half the guild says we can't do it cause we don't have enough epics. But where are we supposed to get these epics?
It seems like people just want to be carried though KZ by a SSC/TK guild, and don't want to put in the work to learn how to down Moroes with 10 people in all blues.
Justin Jones May 19th 2008 10:45PM
PvP gear is almost completely useless for some classes. Take a Priest for example, none of the PvP gear has spirit. If you take more then 1 or 2 pieces you are seriously going to gimp your mana regen (and +heals somewhat too).
I had no problems gearing my priest. I crafted PMC, grabbed a couple of BoE's, grinded some rep for some other blues, did some heroics and was doing Kara within my first week of hitting 70 with 1200 +heals.
I didn't have a main, but I did have a friend helping me out a little. Most importantly, we had a core group of (3 - tank, heals, 1 dps) people to run heroics and help each other out with quests. And no, they weren't over geared, we all levelled together from 60-70 pretty much.
It would have taken me longer to get a set of PvP gear, which would have been *worse*. I really don't understand why people bother.
Milktub May 19th 2008 4:58PM
I had pretty standard tanking progression. By the time I respecced Prot after a couple weeks at 70 (wanted my epic flyer) I had all lv70 blues. Most were instance drops, but I also had the Felsteel set and two quest rewards.
Specced prot and started doing heroics.
Months later the only blues I have left are my boots, one ring and one trinket. It does make heroics easier. I now get less scared when I see mid-60s greens on my groupmates.
Memzer May 19th 2008 5:15PM
Yeah tanks can get away with mostly blues for the entry level heroics as long as their DPS don't fall into the
"OMG I aggro'd."
"Dude, you just pyro, pom, pyro'd before I even got near it!"
crowd. That being said though, especially for a warrior, getting your hands on a decent tanking weapon makes a huge difference. Your threat generation does gain a significant boost when you go from that Crystalline Kopesh or Grom'tor's Charge to your Sun Eater ;)
Kaname May 19th 2008 5:08PM
I always find it absurd the gear requirements some people have for heroics/kara. When you look at the gear dropped as an indicator of progression, Blizzard didn't design heroics to require even full level 70 blues, as evidenced by most of the lv 70 blue resto shaman pieces dropping in what many consider the harder heroics. And ignoring crafted pieces (which usually require primal nethers anyways) and BoE epics, heroics and kara were the only sources of PvE epics for a fresh level 70 back in the day, so requiring epics to start them is just a stupid catch-22.
The gear requirements some people place on healers and tanks is kinda stupid too. I started healing heroics on my shaman very successfully right at level 70 with only 800 +healing and only a handful of late 60s blues. And my first run of heroic arc was with a tank that had only a single epic, and the only wipe was when he pulled 2 of the void guys at once, and that was only due to the all of the dps dying.
Bylak May 19th 2008 5:27PM
I'm a Prot Pally on Eonar, about half epic'd out. I know there are some heroics I can and can't tank with the gear I have, but people seem to have a lot of unrealistic expectations. Kind of a "oh you're a prot pally let's AoE tank this entire thing ezmode!!11" mentality. OR they'll outright refuse me because I'm still sporting some blues.
In my experience people get to be really lazy when it comes to heroics. If you have to work and actually play your class, do some cc people get turned off real fast. More so if there's even as little as one or two wipes in a run.
Joe May 19th 2008 5:25PM
I farm in blues rather than my epics ... and I have been told that I am not good enough to do a heroic because I happened to have logged in my blue gear the day before. Truth be told, I am an SSC/TK T5 hunter. You never know what you are going to get, and honestly, heroic anything in full epics offers no challenge, and therefore to me is boring and pointless.
bluesky_v2.01 May 19th 2008 6:02PM
I don't have much to say except for: "Thrall FTW"
Having a "fully-epic" requirement for the Heroics is ridiculous same as that for Kara because isnt that why we do heroics - to get epics?