Raid Rx: Analyzing your healers Part 4
Raid Rx is designed to encapsulate and cure the shock and horror that is 25-man raid healing. Ok, so it's mostly horror... Anyways, if you're a big fan of X-TREME Whack-A-Mole (or are being forced into it against your will) this is the column for you. That above is the fun product of Wordle. I creatively call it "WoW WWS Healing". Click on it to give it a spin of your own.
So, if you've just randomly stumbled upon this multi-part saga on WWS meets healing, here's a lovely link to get you caught up. For the rest of you operating with mere short term memory lapses, this link right here will transport you to the example WWS we've been mulling about. But more on that after the jump.
Today brings you the latest installment of data analysis, healorz style. Having covered total healing and class comparison tactics last time, I'd now like to turn your attention to fight analysis. This is the meat and potatoes of using WWS, the place you'll spend countless hours staring at the screen in disbelief while simultaneously pulling the last of your hair out. Also, don't forget all of the pictures in this post are links to full versions.
So class, please open your WWS to Gurtogg Bloodboil (here's the WWS link, mouse over the drop down selection next to Split) and turn to the Heals tab. On this fight we went with 8 healers. Poly, Sag, and Rain were on the 3 tanks, Ithnan, Ashra, and Cirrus. Everyone but Harma, Hwesta, and Taurus were on Fel Rage targets. Rain and Aquarius are new to the fight and are working on gear.
Before embarking on this whirlwind of data, it's important to keep in mind what you're looking for. I do this in the form of questions, to both keep me on task and to be sure I don't skip something. Here's my list:
1. Did they die? What was the cause?
2. Were they using the right heals for the assignment?
3. Did they cast enough heals in the right spell balance?
4. Did they decurse enough?
5. Were they healing the right people?
If you click on the Columns button with the gears on it, you'll see some check box options for what the Heals tab shows (pict). I normally snag Death right off the top, and DPS time if I see some suspicious looking Damage Out percentages in the % Out column. Raw Heal will give you a feel for how much they tried to heal versus how much landed.
Scanning the list, a couple of things jump out. For one, the paladins seem to be spread out. Aquarius was only present (i.e. casting) 79% of the time, mostl likely since he died. To find out why Aqu croaked, click on his name. Right above the Abilities tab you'll see "1 Death 20:29". Click on the time to see a combat log of what led up to his death. It looks like a combination of Bloodboils and a Fel Geyser finished him off. The geyser damage is the result of standing too close to the person that's targeted with Fel Rage. That being said, he took about 4.7k BB dmg with no heals. More self-healing and better positioning would have saved him, but he was new to the fight, so these things happen.
Back to the over-all fight table. Sag and Taurus are 3% apart on total effective healing, which is less than my 5% rule of thumb, so it's not a big deal. The difference really is good example of how an assignment will affect your numbers, though. Sag was on tank healing, and due to the way we do Gertie, she was standing in one place for most of the fight. Taurus, on the other hand, is on raid healing and fills in for any Blood Boil soakers, should they die. I can say from experience that Taurus spend about half the fight running in and out of BB's.
Let's look closer at one of the healers. Mist, you're it. Click on his name to bring up his data for the fight. Mysteriously at this point, Mist has become Fog. WWS is all about complete randomization, to the point they change things mid-stream. Ok, whatever. I'm calling him Mist.
Right now there is a ton of information in front of you. Let's start from the top and work down. Active Presence is basically the time from Mist's first cast after the fight started, to his last before the fight ended. We've already seen this from the other table, so keep on going.
Heals to Friends and HPS (healing per second) are in light purple. Be aware that this is the effective healing, or the healing amount that actually landed on people. This does not include overhealing. HPS is the healing per second for the time that you were healing (remember active presence from above?). It is not the HPS over the entire fight. So you could have a very high HPS by healing a ton at the beginning of a fight and then not casting a single heal once you go OOM. In the realm of importance, I only use HPS for my own improvement and generally do not pay too much attention to it for others. HPS is good to watch if you've just done some major regemming or are building a haste set.
The default when you click someone's name is the Abilities tab. Under Heals you get a list of all the heal spells that count as healing for Mist. In this example all of the spells listed were cast by Mist himself. In many cases you'll also see PoM, Healthstones, and the like listed here. The Total is the total effective healing for those spells for the Gertie fight. The percentage reflects the balance of healing between the different spells.
Looking farther to the right you have Hits and Ticks, plus their averages. For direct heals you're going to have hits, or the number of times a spell was cast. For HoTs, you're going to have the number of ticks that spell ticked for. This creates a bit of a grey area, meaning you can't really tell how many times the HoT was cast from this data alone. Thus it's a bit difficult to determine if they're using the spell enough or if ticks are getting overwritten by other heals. Things like Fel Reaver's Piston can also fall under this situation.
Mist was on raid healing, not tanks, which includes trying to keep Fel Rage people alive. Because of this, I'd expect to see more direct heals than HoT's, and we see this here. I am a bit surprised by the low-ish Lifeblooms compared to the other amount of healing. To see where the LB's are going, click on Lifebloom and then at the top select Gurtogg Bloodboil. You'll get this information. You can see Mist has about half of the ticks that Rain was rolling.
On the table at the bottom, you'll see that the tanks have the majority of the LB buff gains but there's a decent spread across some raiders. Looking into the raiders that got LB (click on Quesse and then click the Gains, Buffs, and Debuffs tab), you'll see that Mist was LB'ing people that were Fel Raged. This makes sense since you need 3 stacks of LB to be viable for healing. This is difficult to do on raid healing when the damage jumps around. So sticking it only on the Fel Rages is the best use.
Tune in next time for more analysis. We still need to chat about decursing, combat log events, and the like. See you soon!
Marcie Knox hates it when she has to heal outside her comfort zone. Burn healing on Brutallus pretty much makes or breaks you. Give me back the tank loving... And as always, send your healing-in-action screenies to marcie[dot]knox[at]weblogsinc[dot]com!
Filed under: Druid, Paladin, Priest, Shaman, Analysis / Opinion, Tips, How-tos, Raiding, Raid Rx (Raid Healing)







Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Tychon Jun 30th 2008 1:21PM
Great article as always.
Teresa Jun 30th 2008 2:26PM
What you're neglecting to think about, is that Rain was only healing 6 ppl (with himself occasionally) while Mist was raid healing. Its harder to keep full rolling Lifeblooms on an entire raid compared to just 6 people. Remember that only the first ticks of Lifebloom is attributed to the druid, but the BLOOM portion of the heal is attributed to the person it heals. So its normal & expected that Mist will have less Lifebloom heals, as its doubtful that he can keep 2-3 stacks on the entire raid.
Especially when you don't kinow healing mechanics, and don't know what you're talking about.
As I said last week: Unless ppl are dying from lack of heals (and not from stupidity from dps/tanks) then you really shouldn't be second guessing your healers.
If you are having healing problems:
Check to make sure that each healer is using the correct spells - priests shouldn't be using flash heal a lot unless theres spiking dmg on dps or its trash, shamans should be chain healing, pallies should be using flash of light, druids should be using anything but healing touch - and thats it.
BTW: The priest should have been tossing ProM way more than they did. It had a total of 25 jumps, and considering each cast on Bloodboil WILL jump all 5 times, the priest casted it only 5 times. Which is pathetic really. On this fight they should be hitting it on every cooldown.
Gysh Jun 30th 2008 3:06PM
Teresa, your spot on.
As for the OP...I looked at your numbers from WWS and the spell usage from your healers. Keeping in mind that Bloodboil is heavy raid healing fight, i am shocked you didnt run a CoH priest. Even more surprising is your shaman healing is weak at best (CH4 spam should rock epeen meters along with CoH)
What this comes down to is simple...Analyzing WWS healing meters is a quatum level failure! Healers are not measered by time-on-mob and DPS like DPS'ers.
Harmun Jul 1st 2008 11:02AM
Teresa, you are way off. Measurement of a healer's performance are vital to that player's improvement. It's not "second guessing" to analyze what they did. Also, the spells you just defined as "right" aren't always right. Every situation and build has its own "right" spell mix.
Lastly, I'm fairly certain that if Marcie didn't "kinow" healing mechanics, she wouldn't be as far progressed as she is in the end game, let alone be writing for wowinsider.
Marcie Knox Jun 30th 2008 4:38PM
@Teresa: I think perhaps you missed the point that I'm trying to take people through a thought process. In this case it was, "The LB numbers seem low" and then when we went through the data and when we really saw what was going on, it all made sense. You're going to start out with preconceptions and you need the tools to figure out whether they're correct or not.
As far as the priest goes, I'm pretty sure something strange was going on with them. Exactly what that is will be talked about in another post.
@Gysh: You can't use what you don't have online at the time.
As far as comparing shaman to druids, I've talked the pitfalls of class comparison a few times. Realize you're comparing druids who stand still the entire time to shaman that are running in/out of bloodboils.
Shinwei Jun 30th 2008 5:35PM
That's kind of strange why you would ask your druids to stand still while having your shamans move. Druids can cast while moving and Shamans can't.
Teresa Jun 30th 2008 6:56PM
Shinwei is completely correct.
But I'd like to add to his comment..
Running in & out of bloodboil takes less than 5 seconds. Run into bloodboil position, stay til you get bloodboil, run out of bloodboil & plant yourself til you need to take another stack. Its not as if you need to keep moving around the entire time. Your shammies *should* have been #1 & #2 on that list.
As to the Priest.. Theres no excuse for not spamming ProM on a fight like this. Its not that hard even when tank healing.
Nirea Jul 1st 2008 10:48AM
2 comments on Theresa,
Do you realize that you are exactly doing what you dismissed in the first place, i.e. analyzing and criticizing a fight that went well?
As far as i see Marcie didn't say a word about neither the shaman nor the priest, so you should wait with that kind of critic when she analyze them...
Trying to diminish the achievement of some of her guilds healer doesn't prove her argument wrong anyway
As for having your Paly's only use flash of light... that won't bring you very far when talking about high end raiding... (Say Brutallus or MT heal on Kalecgos, or Illidan phase 2 etc)
Anyway keep up the good work Marcie! I didn't toy that much with wws before but reading your entries it became much more interesting to toy with it! Looking forward to your next post
Nettles Jul 1st 2008 12:03PM
Love the column, but I'm SOOOO confused. I play a holy CoH priest and look forward to the Gurtogg fight with a vengence. This spell excells. I can heal my own group with a mix of Prayer of Healing and CoH, or assign me to another group to CoH/PoM. I usually try to keep PoM up on one of the tanks to help with threat a wee bit.
So-- here's what I'm confounded by: the holy priest in the sample WWS report is assigned to tank healing? Though I see she's healing a wide variety of the raid too. She's casting mostly g-heals and flash heals, with only 11?! hits of Prayer of Healing. Last Bloodboil fight I had 86 hits of Prayer of Healing, and would have had more if I wasn't CoH'ing so much. Even is she's the imp DS priest, personally I'd switch the druid back to tank heals and the priest to Bloodboil heals. But obviously the fight was a one shot, so it worked. = )
It's super easy to be outhealing everyone else on this fight as a priest. NOT that that is the goal of being a healer, just the way the fights works out. Same with RoS.
Looking forward to more of these analytical posts.