Australian TV covers World of Warcraft
Fortunately, this "mY Generation" show from Australian TV is a little more fair with WoW than the last bit we saw. Though the stereotyping of an entire generation and the video effects grate after a while, it's a generally better look at what it's like to be a World of Warcraft player. It would be nice to see, for example, these kids going out to a movie occasionally or interacting with other people (since most of WoW's population actually does that), and it would have been good to hear from more than just that scientific woman talking about the average playtime -- why all the focus on how many hours /played these people have and not what it feels like to play during those hours? But as far as mainstream reporting goes, it starts out as a pretty good description of what it's like to be a WoW player.
Part 2 and part 3 start to fall down, though, and by the time an intervention rolls around, the show gets a little more biased. I have to say, it would be fun to see a documentary done in this way for someone who watches TV 20 hours a week -- "We wanted to hang out with her, but she said the season finale of Top Model was on. She's a completely different person now!" Somehow, staring at a screen and doing nothing is still socially acceptable, but according to television itself, staring at a screen and interacting with other human beings isn't.
Thanks, Luke S.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Virtual selves, Blizzard, News items






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Tristina Aug 11th 2008 4:19PM
Interesting. It would seem like gamers are always grouped into the "no life" category while, as you said, people who sit dumbly in front of the television are completely overlooked. I'm a gamer and I run a successful business and have a close group of friends both in-game and "in real life" and it's rather disheartening when gamers are stereotyped as anti-social, lazy people. There are deviants in every crowd, in every area of life. Why single out gamers?
DirtyPriest Aug 14th 2008 5:56AM
Because its a weird scary thing for old people who do watch TV and possibly when they were young THEIR old people were scared that tons of americas youth is wastin their time staring at a box.
But even when I was young and all we had was atari or NES. Old people were still raging on TVs for corrupting youth and making them lazy and fat. Just now the focus is more on gaming.
Old people are... old.
Aurdon Aug 11th 2008 4:19PM
anyone else cringe when people use sappy forced titles like "generation Y"....who appreciates being called that?
Nick S Aug 11th 2008 4:31PM
Not I.
Have you seen Generation Kill on HBO? They've gone and applied a label to me and my contemporaries based on America's participation in the war in Iraq.
Negative feelings about the war completely aside, is it fair or even remotely logical to call us "Generation Kill?" Really?
On the plus side, it's better than Generation Y... at least we sound bad-ass.
Generations Aug 11th 2008 7:46PM
The commonly used term, "Generation Y", alludes to a succession from Generation X, which was popularized by the Canadian fiction writer Douglas Coupland in his book "Generation X: Tales for an Accelerated Culture". Both terms are common usage in the social sciences.
Hilus Aug 11th 2008 4:25PM
"...Somehow, staring at a screen and doing nothing is still socially acceptable, but according to television itself, staring at a screen and interacting with other human beings isn't..."
Owned, tv.
Verodio Aug 11th 2008 4:29PM
People will always stereotype anything that they don't understand. The facts are that most men under the age of 40 years old play video games and a significant part of the population outside of the demographic does too. It's possible to look at any small sample of people from within anything at all, of the extremists and carry it too far and use that sample to create a sweeping generalization.
I could find a group of workaholics that have destroyed the families and lives by dedicating too much of themeselves to their jobs and then declaring work as unhealthy. Biased reporting like this belongs on Fox.
Nick S Aug 11th 2008 4:28PM
"Somehow, staring at a screen and doing nothing is still socially acceptable, but according to television itself, staring at a screen and interacting with other human beings isn't."
This.
It's the pot vs booze argument, just applied to video games vs television.
People decide they don't like something, *then* come up with reasons why not. The need to convince themselves that they've made the right decision is frighteningly desperate.
Brian Aug 11th 2008 4:47PM
"Somehow, staring at a screen and doing nothing is still socially acceptable, but according to television itself, staring at a screen and interacting with other human beings isn't."
For a more accurate version, replace 'socially acceptable' with 'generates add revenue for TV'
Frank Aug 11th 2008 4:51PM
that wasn't TOO bad. it did tend to demonize WoW, though..."ohh, it's a scary game, and you could get ADDICTED!!! be afraiddddddd" dun dun dunnnnn....
but the people were very typical players, and that was nice to see. they certainly were just like me and players i know, that's for sure. we're all trying to find a balance, and it's easy to get too deep sometimes.
one thing i wished they could have hammered home a bit more was how you're not just playing a game, passively, you're playing and interacting with other players around the world and that sometimes it really IS hard work with responsibilities of its own that are pretty serious. it's easy for someone to tell me to brush off a raid with my guild to go to a movie, but they don't KNOW my guildies, and they don't know what sort of planning it takes to set up a good raid, and how hard it is to keep a guild healthy and functioning.
Smurk Aug 11th 2008 5:06PM
Saying "it's not as bad (or it's equally bad) as TV" is missing the point. If there's anything to be irritated by, it's the tone of the piece towards, not 'gamers,' but an entire generation: "LIKE MOST SPOILED PIECES OF SHIT, THESE YOUNG PEOPLE LIVE AT HOME AND QUIT JOBS AT WILL."
Fairly entertaining though. The one guy saying something about getting slain by an elf - a Simpsons reference, surely? Dad talking about "some sort of Internet" = laffs.
Skyer Aug 11th 2008 9:01PM
I know it might look like "SPOILED BRATS NEVER LEAVING HOME" but if you live in australia, the situation described isn't all that uncommon and most australians would probably understand.
The "great australian dream" has always been to own a house, but increasing interest rates, coupled with fuel costs has pretty much shattered that dream. House prices in western australia had started to equal that in sydney during the real estate boom. There were some people living in sea containers if I remember right.
Naix Aug 11th 2008 5:20PM
I play 2 hours or less a day. I enjoy working out much more, but I get to connect with friends. It beats watching TV like a zombie.
Naix Aug 11th 2008 5:42PM
I play 2 hours or less a day. I enjoy working out much more, but I get to connect with friends. It beats watching TV like a zombie.
Thander Aug 11th 2008 6:53PM
I don't think it was too bad. I do believe WoW is more addicting than other hobbies just because it's so easy to get into. I thought it was okay to show how these people balance it with their real lives.
Most people who play wish they had more time to do everything they want to do in WoW. We constantly remind ourselves of the important things in life to keep our playing in check.
The only people I know that aren't like this are the ones that only play with people they know in real life. They get used to only playing when their real life friends are on. If they log in on their own time, it can be very boring by themselves.
Zamn Aug 11th 2008 8:08PM
Some bits of it were deliberately misleading, like where the guy is explaining you can't just get up and walk away because other people are relying on you, but it's edited to make it look like he's saying you can't just get up and walk about because that's just how bloody addicted you are.
BookhouseBoy Aug 11th 2008 8:40PM
Yeah, I think one has to really look at how this is apparently one episode in a TV series about "Y Generation" that may have "mY" in the title, but to my eyes, the target audience is NOT anyone under the age of 30.
That soccer/rugby guy, what a jerk. "He's having an emotional relationship with a GIRL online, instead of running around in the park with a bunch of sweaty dudes !"
Sounds like a broken heart, LOL.
BookhouseBoy Aug 11th 2008 8:54PM
Oh, and here's links to the REST of that piece... WoWInsider only gave you part 1 of 3...
part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0csvZJHu8E
part 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouRiBlJMfeg
Seith Aug 11th 2008 8:53PM
I have the recipe to Luke's Nachos if anyone wants it ;)
Matt Aug 12th 2008 12:05AM
Ha i know Luke from that video, use to work with the guy. He played on the Aman'Thul server, guild called Endless.