Spiritual Guidance: Holy talents - Did we get the shaft in Wrath?

Every Sunday (usually), Spiritual Guidance will offer practical insight for priests of the holy profession. Your host is now Matt Low, the grand poobah of World of Matticus and a founder of PlusHeal, a new healing community for all restorative classes. Matt scored a beta key and busied himself speccing and respeccing his Priest multiple times. This week, he takes time off to answer an important question about the Holy tree: Is it worth getting excited over?
Generally, the new Holy Priests' talents in WotLK beta seem pretty underwhelming. Compare the flashy things some classes are getting, and take a look at Holy Priests... did we really need a THIRD talent to increase healing of some spells by 10%? Especially since the second one (Empowered Healing) was nerfed to always be weaker then the first one (Spiritual Healing). Yet another +healing talent for a different set of spells just smells like "we needed a talent to fill this spot and had absolutely no ideas."
The way it looks right now, I expect that I'll be healing pretty much exactly the same way at 80 as I am right now - except without down ranking.
So, how about it, WI? Has anything really changed for Holy Priest healing?
The short answer would be no.
The same bread and butter spells we use now to heal at end game will remain the same when we reach level 80. I've already done several instance runs of Utgarde Keep, the Nexus, and Azjol-Nerub (which, by the way, is the shortest instance I have ever played.) I have tried multiple variations of different specs, as varied as possible as a level 72 Priest. No matter what, my options and my tools change only slightly, and not at all from my current options on live servers.
One question is this: Do Priests need more types of spells?
Let's look at our end-game arsenal (this means no Lesser Heal or Heal.) I'm linking the max-level versions of the spells.
Direct Heals
Flash Heal
Greater Heal
Binding Heal
AoE Heals
Prayer of Healing
Circle of Healing
Holy Nova
Utility Heals
Upon first glance, we have enough spells to answer just about any threat in the game. We truly don't need any more ways to heal players.
Thoughts
One way Blizzard has diversified our tree is by including more proc-based effects. I've experimented with Improved Holy Concentration. At first, it seems like one of those talents that most people would pass over. But read in-depth, and you'll see that you're getting an almost 1 in 6 chance of getting a free heal and an increase in spellhaste.
The next proc-effect we get is from Serendipity. This is what I would consider a win-win talent. If your heal lands and you don't over heal, great! You've just gotten your mana's worth from a spell in full. However, if your heal lands and the player didn't make use of 50% of the punch, you get a portion of your mana back. Especially with the loss of down-ranking as a mana-efficiency tool, this talent will become valuable as a refund of mana lost to forced over-heals.
Test of Faith acts as an extra safety net, increasing the effectiveness of your heals on targets with lower health. If your target takes a large hit, you can rest easy knowing that the next heal you land on them has a higher chance of putting them back up into the green. Even if it does't crit, the amount healed still goes up noticeably at low output.
Divine Providence will buff your specialist heals. It's not like Greater Heal and Flash Heal need any more of an increase anyway. The strength of this talent is going to depend on the encounters at the end of the game. Will the fights we experience allow us to utilize this effectively? That's not a question I can answer at this time. If I were a betting man (and I am), I would go over the top and push all in banking on Blizzard to really put this talent to use. On the other hand, Blizzard has clearly stated that no fights will require certain classes to complete – will a talent buffing only those heals that are unique to our class make a huge difference in end-game fights?
The only real new trick that we have to learn is Guardian Spirit. It's the Ace up the sleeves of our long (and brilliant-looking) Priest robes. What we have to learn is how and when to put it into play. I confess I haven't quite mastered the skill of this quite yet. I've actually intentionally not healed certain players (with advance warning of course) just so I could try and get a better feel for the mechanic. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that Guardian Spirit is going to depend on the twitchness and reaction time of players later on in the game.
As interesting as these new procs are, Blizzard did not give us anything that will dramatically alter the face of Priest healing in the Holy tree. We will be healing the same way at level 80 as we are now at level 70 – with a few more random surprises along the way.
Is that really a bad thing?
Looking around at the other restorative classes, Druids get another direct healing spell (aptly known as Nourish.) Paladins get an AoE heal (Beacon of Light.) Shamans get a talentable Cleanse and Decurse in the form of Cleanse Spirit as well as an interesting binding spell called Spirit Link.
Compared to the other 3 classes, we start out with a leg up on our competition. Whether Priests will stay as the premiere healing class in WotLK remains to be seen. At this point, we've exhausted our knowledge and testing of the way Priest healing will work in Northrend. Blizzard simply made it so that the spells we use now will have additional effects and benefits. Think of it as a way of saving us the time and effort of having to manually activate these abilities.
While I admit I'm not exactly jumping out of my chair and screaming "YEEEEEAH" on most of the Holy talents, I'm relieved to know that I don't have to completely abandon the old ways.
Food for thought
- I haven't even gotten a chance to play with Inscription yet. I glanced over them briefly when they were announced and gave it a passing grade. Inscription does allow us to customize our Priests even further even though it is in a subtle fashion.
- I can't shake the feeling that set bonuses will come into play. They made a fair impact in TBC. I wonder if that concept will be explored even more when we have additional gear choices to choose from. In TBC, certain set pieces were enough to make me rethink my style of play - when I got the T6 set bonus which reduced the mana cost of Prayer of Healing, I made a conscious effort to use that more often when Circle of Healing wasn't needed.
Want to find more great tips for carrying out your Priestly duties? Spiritual Guidance has you covered with all there is to know!And don't forget to check the WoW Insider Directory for more priestly info!
Filed under: Priest, Analysis / Opinion, Talents, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance, Inscription






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Simon Aug 25th 2008 5:01AM
Even as you point out, holy priests do already have a full complement of healing abilities already, unlike other classes the gameplay that we'll experience in Wrath seems to be more or less the same.
So that's years of playing a class without much of a refresh, as holy didn't change that much in TBC either...
Compare and contrast with how much feral druids changed with TBC or how palas are going to change with Wrath.
Of course it means that holy priests are mostly where Blizzard wants them to be, but still...
SCH Aug 25th 2008 5:40AM
Just a minor bug: this article is tagged under (Rogue) Encrypted Text. I guess its not intentional.
ArtV Aug 25th 2008 9:00AM
Man, park your waaaambulance and sit tight.
The Dev's have clearly stated that Priests aren't finished yet.
Gabby Aug 25th 2008 9:42AM
Personally, I hope they don't change holy too much, the changes already have convinced me to spec back to a full tiered Holy. The changes are nice, and I can't really see what we need (besides a holy form of course! ARE YOU LISTENING DEVS? I WANT ANGEL WINGS.)
But yeah, Holy didn't need much changed, they made Lightwell useful and turned Circle of Healing into a really powerful spell, so I really can't complain.
Doopydoo22 Aug 31st 2008 7:07PM
/signed
Maybe they could add in some HDR business so we can use it as a weapon.
hpavc Aug 25th 2008 9:54AM
Whats this downranking you speak of?
PsychoChris Aug 25th 2008 10:02AM
Simon,
Don't you think its a bit unfair to claim priests have not changed from old world to TBC?
Did you not get binding heals and prayer of mending? Those were big changes. PoM is one of the stand out abilities priests have that differentiate us from other healers. I also think "Gaurdian Spirit" will play a large roll in end game raiding.
Although other classes may have gotten more love, its not like priest are left out in the cold.
shadowwolf007 Aug 25th 2008 10:38AM
"Compare the flashy things some classes are getting, and take a look at Holy Priests... "
I really, really hate this statement. I stopped reading your blog entry here.
Juliah Aug 25th 2008 1:05PM
I agree, Matt. It's a meh list so far.
One thing I'd like is to be able to spec for a flash heal that's really actually instant.
Illuminus Sep 2nd 2008 1:47PM
How i see it is that down ranking was a crutch for players with poor mana management skills and the lack of a "true healer mind set". This being that there is only one point of health that matters and thats the last one, everything else is a buffer for that one point. You dont need to be casting 24/7 to be a good healer heck most bosses i have done have not required drinking a pot at all well timed Shadowfieds work well. So im not worried about the loss of downranking or the one and done affects on pots in fights, as like i said with proper mana management and communication among healers you dont need to be spaming skills to keep the raid alive.
pissedpriest Sep 14th 2008 6:42AM
Correct me if i'm wrong but wasn't it stated that holy tree spec'd priest will be more of a group healing class with reasonable single target healing capabilities? if so then why the fuck did they put a 6 second CD on CoH?
I may be wrong about this havent had much time to keep up to date on beta news lately is there something i missed or did we just get shafted again?
xiao284 Mar 24th 2011 9:16PM
Shop on sale Keen shoes now to enjoy a very large discount. Keep your cool under pressure with these cheap Keen sandals. Buy
Keen footwear now in our Keen online shop now to enjoy free shipping worldwide!