World of Warcraft as a teaching tool
Most of us were kids at one point. A portion of us probably played computer or video games even as kids. Thus, I'm sure that at least a good handful of us, when told by our parents to turn off the computer and go do homework, eat dinner, or get some fresh air, tried to counter with something like this: "But Mom, games are educational! They give you hand-eye coordination and map reading skills!" Now, all these years later, it seems we may finally be getting some backup from teachers and educators. Livescience.com recently highlighted some educators who are using World of Warcraft or lauding it for its educational values.Educator Constance Steinkuehler of the University of Wisconsin-Madison started an after school WoW playing group for young boys. She's found that these 8th and 9th graders, who had no interesting in reading or writing, now get into detailed and lengthy discussions on raid strategy and gearing up and the like on their message boards.
They also meet one Saturday a month for more involved projects such as maintaining the guild website or putting together graphic novels based on their Warcraft adventures, which provides more opportunity for learning. She and her colleague, Sean Duncan, have also studied posts on WoW message boards, and found that many them have a good level of scientific literacy.
Of course, not every player participates in these "higher level" discussions, but it's nice to know that when we discuss a little bit of theorycrafting, we're actually flexing our intellectual muscles. It makes me feel better about sometimes getting a little flustered over all this theorycrafting math -- math was never my strong subject in school. But regardless, now I can count my time spent browsing the elitist jerks boards as intellectual enrichment, which is pretty sweet.
Livescience points out, though, that looking for educational value in World of Warcraft isn't completely new. They cite our own little blog here, WoW Insider, and an interview you may remember with the Horde of Unschoolers, a guild made up of a homeschooling mom and her kids. Takulah uses the game as an opportunity to teach her children, or to let them ask their own questions, on a daily basis.
Of course, when it comes to more traditional schooling, I'm not sure we'll see World of Warcraft for High School credit any time soon. Of course, it is available for college credit, so who knows? Regardless, it is sort of nice to see my younger self vindicated about all that gaming.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Virtual selves, News items






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Dr00d Oct 4th 2008 8:36PM
well.... wow can teach u stuff. Learned hell lot english by chatting with people though, and now im best in class hehe. Also learned to use almost all fingers at one time to write with without noticing hehe.
daniel.roy Oct 4th 2008 8:49PM
It's a game. No more, no less.
For me, those seeking to depict it as a place of learning and education are as misguided as those who would depict it as the Devil's breedng ground.
Swift Oct 4th 2008 10:48PM
Just because it is a game does not mean it cannot be leveraged for educational purposes. You would be surprised at how many different skills are involved in successfully playing a game such as this.
Robert M Oct 4th 2008 11:16PM
WoW is what you make of it. Yes, it can be the devils breeding ground if you treat it as warcrack, and it can in fact be a teaching tool.
Those who would write-off the benefits that would come from a program like this are the same people who refuse to believe that it does "take a village" to raise a child.
In a world where "no child left behind" was/is a horrible bipartisan failure because the government failed to recognize that leaving no child behind isn't done with standardized tests and textbooks. It's done by educators that use every possible resource to teach.
Instead of dismissing the program, appluad it and its developers for honing in on the lost boys of the American education system. Too many times we shove ritalin down the throats of our youth because teachers would rather drug them instead of recognizing that not all people learn in the traditional manner and then adjust their teaching accordingly.
Faerun hit it right in the head when he said, "I don't think they really mean that WoW will teach you a lot, but that preparing for raids and learning how to play your character well will make you want to learn things (theorycrafting - math, blogs - writing, guild web sites - computer science) that you wouldn't have bothered to learn otherwise."
Balius Oct 4th 2008 11:21PM
Children are not stupid. They are incredibly good at absorbing information, in memorizing and in developing skills. They only use that ability, however, when they are interested and engaged.
If I were a teacher and had a classroom full of WoW addicts, you'd better believe I'd use examples from WoW to demonstrate purely academic concepts. If they were into pokemon, I'd use examples from Pokemon. If they were into cowboy princesses from Mars who get their magical powers from Starburst brand candies, I'd find a way to use that too.
Dry lectures don't work nearly as well as when children want to learn something.
Tuhljin Oct 5th 2008 12:11AM
This comment scares me.
Tuhljin Oct 5th 2008 12:46AM
Bah, that was supposed to be in reply to the first comment of the thread. I swear this blog's comment engine is seriously buggy.
Tuhljin Oct 5th 2008 12:48AM
Also, I'd delete it if I could. I misread the post I was replying to.
Jane Gray Oct 5th 2008 5:04AM
Isn't the cliche you are looking for "devil's playground"?
Almost no breeding of any sort goes on among wow players near as I can tell.
As a female gamer I do everything I can to keep it that way.
Kya Oct 4th 2008 8:59PM
Remember kids, nerfs are part of life too! Enjoy! :)
Voodoo Oct 4th 2008 9:01PM
Actually, the college or college credit class you link does NOT in fact have you play World of Warcraft, as the title of the class suggests. It in fact, reading in the description further, has you download and subscribe to Lord of the Rings Online.. /suckage.
-V
Faerun Oct 4th 2008 9:06PM
I don't think they really mean that WoW will teach you a lot, but that preparing for raids and learning how to play your character well will make you want to learn things (theorycrafting - math, blogs - writing, guild web sites - computer science) that you wouldn't have bothered to learn otherwise.
Tricia Oct 4th 2008 9:34PM
I let my 8 yr old son play WoW for regulated periods of time after homework and chores have been finished and provided his behavior's been good. It makes for an excellent 'carrot' in that respect. Likewise, it encourages his reading and problem solving skills quite a bit, since we urge him to read all his quests and do much of the solving of such quests on his own. The limited math skills he needs to use are also an added bonus. No, I don';t consider WoW to be some sort of computerized tutor, but I do see it as a fun reward that also has added benefits towards education.
Summer Oct 4th 2008 10:52PM
We let our 8 year old (now 9) play over the summer for the same reasons. Reading the quests and following instructions to figure out what to do and what direction to go reinforced skills she needed to practice while letting her have fun. I spent a lot of time saying "Did you read the quest?" but it was worth it.
Older kids though, not much they can learn from it!
Eisengel Oct 5th 2008 12:51AM
Thank you.
As a PhD student, teaching assistant, and eventual professor... very often I find myself helping students by simply going to an assignment's description and just dragging them through the exercise of actually critically reading it and establishing carefully and precisely the assignment's specifics, restrictions and requirements. Often once they fully understand where they have to begin and where they have to end, they can form a plan, determine steps and start getting useful work done.
Anything... anything parents can do to enhance their child(ren)'s ability to read critically and to absorb and apply information is a great boon to them. Today you can find out nearly anything in a few seconds online... but if you don't possess the capability to actually extract and apply what you read, you're effectively lost.
@Tuhljin
Scary or not, it's how it works. While I'm not trying to connect with students based on Pokemon or Starburst-powered Martian Princesses, I definitely approach an explanation of a topic differently based on what my audiences' experiences are. I can explain the same thing to a mathematician, a statistician, a theoretical computer scientist or an electrical engineer in a way that they would understand, but none of the others would. The important thing is to discover what your audience knows already, what memes and processes they already understand, and to basically create metaphors between what you want to teach and what they know. Once you give them a foothold in the new stuff, you can expand from there, working from the base of understanding a metaphor related to something they already know.
Taytayflan Oct 4th 2008 10:13PM
I learned to type by playing WoW. You get motivated to be better when an ogre is trying to bash you face in and you need a heal. I've bonded with my friends better and am reading a lot more than I used to. I also figured out I have storytelling skills.
Saiforune Oct 4th 2008 11:00PM
I agree, but after a certain point by teaching a child to play WoW at an early age it will lead to a heavy addiction in their later years where studying is more important than those basic reading and math or even "map reading" skills.
It's hard to players to quit "cold turkey" and focus on schoolwork and actually be successful.
But btw, Cause I commented here, I just made this post awesome. =P
Love,
Saiforune
Robert M Oct 4th 2008 11:24PM
There is enough evidence to show that addictive personalties are the result of the genetic tendencies.
Those who would show detrimental addicitive personality traits will show them whether they play WoW, gamble, drink, etc.
Let's not act like letting a child play WoW creates the addictive personality, that's misleading and encourages others to refuse to recognize addiction as a disease.
Balius Oct 4th 2008 11:31PM
The only kind of "addiciton" WoW can create is what's termed by some, "psychological dependence". It makes people feel good, so people want to do it more.
Cutting children off from WoW on that basis is ridiculous; the same dependency can be formed for religion, or reading, or hopscotch. Enjoyment based addiction is more easily broken than even an addiction to good food, which is just as well because you cannot CANNOT expect a child to only do things that aren't in any way enjoyable in order that they be able to study without distraction.
What you CAN do is enforce time management skills (using WoW or not), teaching a child to prioritize both things he wants to do and things he needs to do.
CrazyAl Oct 4th 2008 11:22PM
"But Mom, games are educational! They give you hand-eye coordination and map reading skills!"
When I was a kid it was ... "Mom, there is no 'pause' button in this game!!" which was usually a lie of course, but she would buy it for a while so I could postpone the chores