Bartle, gender, and the demographics of WoW's classes
A little while back the gamerDNA blog did a nice breakdown of how WAR classes correlate with how gamers do on the Bartle Test of Gamer Psychology, a widely used test that can break down exactly what type of player you are (Achiever, Explorer, Socializer, or Killer). It was such an interesting writeup that I hoped they'd do it with WoW classes, and apparently I wasn't the only one -- they've got a new post up now examining which classes in Azeroth align with which types of players.They throw gender into the mix as well -- turns out that while the classes have generally the same percentage of players (not surprising, given that gameplay dictates the classes should be fairly balanced), things start to break up when you add gender to the mix. Priests and Warriors seem to have the biggest separation: according to their data (obtained via the profiles on their site), most Priests are played by females, and most Warriors are played by men. Paladins as well tend to be male, though not as much as Warriors, and Druids tend to be female, though not as much as Priests. Women also tend to prefer the elven races (Blood and Night), while guys apparently prefer Orcs and Dwarves (which helps my -- sexist, I admit -- theory from way back on the WoW Insider Show that the Dwarven starting area appeals to guys more than women).
The Bartle breakdown is interesting, too -- Killers prefer Rogues (duh), Warriors tend to be Achievers, and Hunters have the slight Explorer edge, but in general, the classes have a fairly even distribution across the board. All of the different roles can be filled by all the classes, which speaks to the way Blizzard has built the classes -- you can really solo, PvP, or group up with any of them. WAR's differences were distinct, but in WoW, Blizzard has done their best to make it so that whatever Bartle type you are, you can log in with any class and do what you want. gamerDNA promises more research here (including a Horde and Alliance breakdown), and we can't wait to see it.
Filed under: Night Elves, Blood Elves, Odds and ends, Virtual selves, Analysis / Opinion, Warrior, Priest, Paladin, Hunter, Orcs, Dwarves, Classes






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
dan Oct 20th 2008 2:10PM
I adore Richard Bartle but I've said it before and I'll say it again the psych test just isn't as nuanced as it should be. Esp. given how games like WoW have opened the floodgates on a wider audience.
Nick S Oct 20th 2008 4:06PM
Yeah I looked through it; it needs some significant tuning up. I got extremely high scores in "Killer" and "Achiever" and very low scores in "Social" when in fact I play the game to socialize and hate PvP... so clearly there's some work to be done.
timmy! Oct 20th 2008 2:10PM
So now I can tell all the woman I have a feminine side since I play a druid and a priest =P
*Paladin is my third toon
Malsorian Oct 20th 2008 2:19PM
His charts assume that women play female characters and men play male characters. That's a very large presumption to make considering that about half of the female characters in my guild alone are played by men. In fact, this nullifies about half of the article since he actually can't make that assumption. You can say that when people choose to play Night Elves, a large portion of them choose to play female NE's but you can't say that those are women choosing to play females.
Matt Oct 20th 2008 2:26PM
I have half and half.
I play two female characters (warrior, priest), and two male characters (paladin, shaman).
It is more aesthetics than anything. The male character models look awkward.
Mike Schramm Oct 20th 2008 2:29PM
I thought it was people who identified as female and male on the gamerDNA site, not the ingame characters. But maybe I'm wrong about that. I agree -- if it's the gender of ingame characters, these charts are more or less useless.
Sam QforQ Houston Oct 20th 2008 2:50PM
Mike is right, it is people who identified as people being female or male in real life, not in game. It is *NOT* the gender of their characters ingame.
oldwisemonk Oct 20th 2008 3:46PM
Depends on how the data was gathered. The Bartle test is a questionnaire. So the question phrasing and number of people that took the test would matter most.
Mandydeth Oct 20th 2008 2:33PM
Indeed, I roll toons based on how the gear looks on them and how they look.
Personally I don't like running around as a man in a skirt (Priests, Mages, Locks, and sometimes Shamans/Druids)
So I'd rather roll females for those classes.
Warriors, Hunters, Pallys, and Rogues generally look better as males.
This is coming from an aesthetically viewpoint, not a sexist one.
Andy Oct 20th 2008 2:41PM
Are these statistics based on the characters sex or the sex of the player? Also in WoW a lot of the itemization kind of implies that Priests should be female or cross dressers. Kamaei's Cerulean Skirt, Virtuous Skirt, Devout Skirt, Gown of Spiritual Wonder & Masquerade Gown.
It is also kind of funny to see that more Females tend to be Druids. In pre-WoW only males were Druids and most Warrior types were female.
Interesting article to say the least..
Andy Oct 20th 2008 2:43PM
"It is also kind of funny to see that more Females tend to be Druids. In pre-WoW only males were Druids and most Warrior types were female."
When it came to Night Elves that is...
Sam QforQ Houston Oct 20th 2008 2:52PM
These statistics are based on the sex of the player, based on information people input when they sign up for gamerDNA.com.
-Sam Houston
Community Manager for GamerDNA.com
oldwisemonk Oct 20th 2008 3:54PM
This is where I agree with the test poster that it will be interesting to gather more data on the Horde vs. Alliance aspect of it. I'm sure the fact that Druids can only be Tauren and Night Elf has a huge impact on the percents, given that women are drawn to Night Elves. Same goes for the Shaman and Paladin data. Very curious to find out more. I still want to know what the poll numbers were, along with their play-style (casual vs hard-core) and location/region (is this primarily U.S. or is it global?).
Marty Oct 20th 2008 2:52PM
I'm going to assume that this chart draws it's numbers from percentages, and not actual numbers, because as cool as it is that lots of girls play this game, I really don't think they outnumber males on any class. We all know WoW is mostly a sausage fest, after all.
Sam QforQ Houston Oct 20th 2008 2:55PM
Yes, you are correct. These numbers are percentage based.
-Sam Houston
gamerDNA Community Manager
Manatank Oct 20th 2008 2:59PM
I seem to run into quite a few women playing WoW. Maybe they don't like talking with you?
Manatank Oct 20th 2008 2:59PM
I hit the reply button to rochmoninoff, not Marty. How did I end up in here?
rochmoninoff Oct 20th 2008 2:54PM
Nick Yee at the Deadalous Project
http://www.nickyee.com/daedalus/archives/001641.php
Has done exhaustive studies of this.
He's found that the Bartle classification isn't very accurate.
He's also found much more definitive data regarding gender and character selection.
http://www.nickyee.com/daedalus/archives/001634.php
I think that you should have done some more research before posting!
here is a thought Oct 20th 2008 3:07PM
#001369 "WoW Gender-Bending"
http://www.nickyee.com/daedalus/archives/001369.php
made me laugh
old men like to be women, who would have guessed?
Mike Schramm Oct 20th 2008 4:31PM
We already posted about the excellent work of Mr. Yee not a week ago:
http://www.wowinsider.com/2008/10/10/daedalus-project-updated/