Faith and World of Warcraft at Colorado University
Buckle your seatbelts on this one -- if you aren't concerned with the bigger picture behind a virtual world like Azeroth and would rather hear about dragons fighting each other or the latest class changes, best look elsewhere on the site. But a student at Colorado University has a theory about World of Warcraft that might sound a little out there: he believes the game is a new religion.Not necessarily in the sense that you should skip church to raid (though lots of people probably do that anyway). But in the sense that it meets a sociologist's definition of religion: it provides community, ethics, culture, and emotion. And it's hard to argue with that: we're living proof of the community around the game, there's definitely plenty of culture and emotion, and... ethics? CU student Theo Zijderveld is proposing that even if the game itself doesn't promote ethical behavior, the push is there -- we're rewarded for doing the right thing, and often punished for doing wrong. Work with others in a group, get better loot. Camp someone's corpse, and their guildie or alt shows up to camp you.
Intriguing idea, even if it does sound like something cooked up for a college student's thesis (which is in fact what it is). It's certainly not a religion in that there is no higher power involved (unless you believe that Ghostcrawler is in fact a god) -- obviously, we all believe that everything in Azeroth was made by men and women, or at least hard-working Gnomes. But as for what playing World of Warcraft creates in us and makes us feel, those results and ideas are very close in many ways to what organized religion does. Quite a theory.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Virtual selves, Odds and ends
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 4 of 5)
Tuhljin Jan 29th 2009 11:25PM
This student better get a very poor grade if his teacher has any self-respect (and the story is truly as it's presented to us here). Are any of you seriously arguing that it's a religion, or just arguing for the sake of arguing or because you personally dislike religion (and/or those that practice it) and/or Christianity? WoW doesn't involve a belief system. Subscribers don't share a moral code by which they are supposed to live their lives. There's no serious philosophy, shared devotion, doctrine, "bigger picture" stories of what came before and will come after life, or anything on that level at all. The very notion is just absurd.
Stretching definitions to make a joke about the "ritual" of distributing loot, game lore, etc., may be clever the first couple of times, but if you seriously believe it, there's something wrong with you.
babs Jan 30th 2009 1:43AM
WoW hasn't brought about the slaughter of millions (not in the real world at least), a vicious bigotry against non-believers, and the suppression of intellect and reason.
Can't be a real religion without those essentials, now, can it?
Zhiva Jan 30th 2009 5:37AM
^
Agree.
Tuhljin Jan 31st 2009 5:04AM
More like, it can't be a religion because you can have a discussion about it on the Internet without a flock of bigots rearing their ugly heads.
Science of Identity Jan 30th 2009 1:30AM
hmm...maybe I'll list WOW next time I'm filling out a form...
Dracudian Jan 30th 2009 1:51AM
Buddhism is a religion where no god is central, a divine or omnipotent being is not a criteria of a religion... Hence the last part of the article is kinda inaccurate and the guy is theoretically right ;)
Lemons Jan 30th 2009 6:35PM
but secretly you all worship that fat statue correct?
I mean I just assume with all the belly rubbing..
StoNe Jan 30th 2009 1:59AM
Hey,
Makes sense to become a religion, if Christian's can get away with pushing a bible...at least WoW as gfx which alone makes it 'more real'
PS: religion LOL
Bossy Jan 30th 2009 2:47AM
Of course Wow is a '"religion" to some people. Just like any social group with a mutual cultural and ethical code.
If ANYTHING this thread is about how trivial ANY religion is !!!!
---->Religion is needed for most of us to counter the fear of death and the meaningless of life.
The insignificance of mere existence in a world with millions of billions of stars and galaxies.
Wow serves the same insignificance as any other "religion".
The only difference is that Wow players are not taking by the BALLS when a family member dies by a stuctured church or voodoo man or Allah terrorist (depending of the civilization you are living in).
Bossy Jan 30th 2009 2:52AM
Add to the above:
Football is a religion to some, as is any sports/mutual hobby that counters....
the insignificance of being in and endless rather meaningless world of millions of billions of galaxies.
Religion is just another invention of men, just like all above activities.
KT Jan 30th 2009 3:38AM
I think actually the ethical part of it is very tenuous. A religion generally imparts ethics and rules that are applicable to life in general.
The ethical system of WoW (don't ninja loot, etc) is only applicable within the context of WoW and doesn't translate to life. In life you will never find yourself raiding, questing, or looting mobs, nor do you group up with people in the same way to accomplish tasks or communicate in the same way. So you will never use the ethical system of WoW outside of that context.
In that sense, the ethics system of WoW is less like the Bible and is more like the rules for using the community swimming pool. It's a set of situational rules and not a system of general ethic that are applicable in a wider context.
Andy Jan 30th 2009 5:13AM
I believe that what separates "real religions" from "could be religions" is the hope it provides its followers.
How many get genuine hope from playing wow? and im not talking about "i hope i get phat lewtz!11!one!"
Prayer in any form usually provides genuine hope in some way.
Kanwi Jan 30th 2009 5:16AM
This is so funny reading everyones little bitchy comments. I personally dont have what you might call a mainstream belief and I certainly dont concider WoW a religion by any means. I also think anyone who is basing their life morals on a game needs to get outside and see the real world and learn about that. Also, religion isnt just Christianity or Hinduism or even Jedi. Religion can be a personal thing. I have a strong set of morals and beliefs. These morals and beliefs I got myself. I've seen alot of things. Some good some horrible. You learn from these experiences and can use them to help reflect who you want to be. I'm now a strong person. I feel I can tell good from bad and that isnt just basing it on what you see or hear on T.V and games. Get outside and learn things for yourself. And ask yourself this every once in a while.
What is the point in it all?
I found my answer. Whats yours?
Adam R Jan 30th 2009 7:58AM
/thread
StoNe Jan 30th 2009 10:32AM
@Kanwi
I think your ideas on religion are inaccurate. I think you're talking about faith...not religion.
Religion is a more set of beliefs with structure, almost like organised religion and " is my creator according to " and "we should all live by rules laid out in "
Having an ideology is more like a faith.
I for example am not religious, but I have faith...faith in mankind, faith in good music, and faith in my friends and a frosty pint after work.
But to take this thread seriously, I'd argue that WoW could be a cult following, not a structured religion.
Wark Jan 30th 2009 8:27AM
Here in the UK we have a census coming up in a couple of years. If enough ppl put down 'Warcraft' or 'WoW' as their religion, by law it will be recognised and made a religion.
They did it in New Zealand with 'Jedi' at their last one.
Question is, who do we worship? Prehaps we too can fragment into a bunch of fundamentalists...
FireStar Jan 30th 2009 9:44AM
Someone's gonna get a masters degree for that?
jrizutko Jan 30th 2009 10:56AM
Wow is a religion the exact same way that golf is a religion. Its a hobby that shapes people's lives. Some people take it more seriously than others, but everyone who partakes shares a certain kinship. Comparing and contrasting WoW to an organized theology is just a semantic game; It has little applied value, but it makes for fun conversation.
Vandell Jan 30th 2009 12:34PM
I would call that "society", not "religion". Religion takes common sense and shakes it all up a bunch.
Dennis Jan 30th 2009 3:31PM
Fascinating angle, but I doubt Blizzard will file for non-profit status any time soon. With 12 million subscribers, there's potential for as many adherents as well known religions. (http://www.adherents.com/Religions_By_Adherents.html)
However, this does remind me of the discussions around Second Life and religion a few years ago. Were they real churches and congregations if they met in SL? Is it about 'how' they come together or 'what' they do when together? Do you need a real world organization to be recognized virtually?
I've seen my children learn very real world ethical lessons in WoW. I've seen them donate money they earned to a common cause, help out strangers (even cross Faction-gasp!) on the same quest, and gain insight into human behavior from watching others behave well and badly. They mostly likely learned those lessons in real world situations and organizations, but I'm certain not all of them.
By the Light of Elune!
Fortunately, sociologists don't get the final word on what is and isn't a religion for an individual. Faith and spirituality are most personal experiences.