Faith and World of Warcraft at Colorado University
Buckle your seatbelts on this one -- if you aren't concerned with the bigger picture behind a virtual world like Azeroth and would rather hear about dragons fighting each other or the latest class changes, best look elsewhere on the site. But a student at Colorado University has a theory about World of Warcraft that might sound a little out there: he believes the game is a new religion.Not necessarily in the sense that you should skip church to raid (though lots of people probably do that anyway). But in the sense that it meets a sociologist's definition of religion: it provides community, ethics, culture, and emotion. And it's hard to argue with that: we're living proof of the community around the game, there's definitely plenty of culture and emotion, and... ethics? CU student Theo Zijderveld is proposing that even if the game itself doesn't promote ethical behavior, the push is there -- we're rewarded for doing the right thing, and often punished for doing wrong. Work with others in a group, get better loot. Camp someone's corpse, and their guildie or alt shows up to camp you.
Intriguing idea, even if it does sound like something cooked up for a college student's thesis (which is in fact what it is). It's certainly not a religion in that there is no higher power involved (unless you believe that Ghostcrawler is in fact a god) -- obviously, we all believe that everything in Azeroth was made by men and women, or at least hard-working Gnomes. But as for what playing World of Warcraft creates in us and makes us feel, those results and ideas are very close in many ways to what organized religion does. Quite a theory.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Virtual selves, Odds and ends
Transmog yourself into an Avenger!
6 blue posts to read before Diablo 3's launch
Cross-realm zones coming soon
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news







Reader Comments (Page 5 of 5)
Antonia Jan 30th 2009 4:59PM
The only way i can see this making sense is if they were to say that the lore is like the Bible and the game itself is like some sort of living, virtual, Bible that you can be a part of yourself..
i get the sense of community is there and all but we don't call a city or town a religion.. otherwise we'd all be getting tax exemptions.. and yes that analogy works based on the situation being described here, communities often think the same and have the same set of rules, just like cities and their people/laws.. its NOT religion and neither is WoW, WoW is more like a city MAYBE and even that's stretching it
I get the whole being rewarded for doing good but getting a gold star on a test as a kid didn't mean the big G had blessed me. just means i did a good job.. and really where does that leave the forsaken? most of their early quests have them tracing around helping to make a new plague TO KILL PEOPLE.. where are the good in that? where is the ethics in that!?! i hope this guy isn't going to medical school cause I'd be even more fearful of our health care system... and what about the rest of us non-forsaken? we're supposed to buy the this new religion wants us to slay animals and countless respawning peoples? i get the crusades were holy wars where people died but those people felt they had a purpose even if most of us now agree it was a little misguided.. "leveling" wasn't that purpose.. maybe phat lootz was but that's another issue.. the game, if this is to be held evident, is a training ground for killers.. which doesn't AT ALL help the fight for players rights with every government in the world that's trying to blame violence on video games... so seriously THANK YOU for helping them...
and seriously how are we punished for doing wrong in the game? we die because we pulled bad? so bad pulls are a sin now? are you kidding me?.. how is that any way like punishing a sadistic real life killer? like i stated above we kill all the time so we should, in effect die every time we log in.. and what? all people killed, bad or not, should get to run back to their bodies?... THE BUDDHA WILL NOT BE HAPPY WITH THIS AND THAT DUDES ALWAYS HAPPY..
there really is no "wrong" in WoW the game doesn't allow "wrong".. there are no branching pathways of choice in our actions, there isn't a "evil" path to take even as a roleplayer.. you either do the quests, or raid the raid, or you don't.. there are no consequences, which is the same argument made for the way people act any where else online, there's nearly no rules even when there is rules so people, in most cases, feel free to act out.. THAT'S THE OPPOSITE OF RELIGION.. there's no being excommunicated, even in a game where GM's can ban you, cause most of the time THAT WONT EVEN HAPPEN EVEN TO THE WORST OF PLAYERS..
"Camp someone's corpse, and their guildie or alt shows up to camp you." I don't believe that this is in any religion, i believe this is just "the golden rule" and a lot of people mistake that as being part of many religions.. Jesus' idea of turning the other cheek would not permit this action AT ALL.. actually so does "thou shalt not kill" in the big 10.. but whatever..
Honestly i hope this kid failed his thesis because the whole thing has MAJOR holes in it.. if the professor had any sense he would have failed him just for the cover page.. if the professor sat on any of the numerous WoW forums to research a little of what the kid was saying, to gain knowledge enough to grade the paper, he'd see that half the stuff mentioned doesn't exist in the game.. its a ruse cooked up by a kid who would probably rather play a game then even DO his thesis.. WoW is a GAME made by men and while some people (myself included) may feel that religion was also its NOT AT ALL COOL to go about saying a game is a religion and defile what millions of people in real faiths believe in.. please just leave that to L. Ron Hubbard.
Necronx Jan 30th 2009 5:29PM
I do not care who you are, what you believe in, or why you're so arrogant to be racist to anybody. If something interests you, go with it 'til you get bored or do "it" your whole life, whatever "it" is. I can't understand how you people get sooo offended by somebody doing or saying one simple, stupid, little thing. If somebody says FU, say it back then continue with your miserable life. I'm roman-catholic. Big deal. I'm certainly not a religious person nor do I preach to anybody about Jesus or any of that crap. If you're Atheist or any other religion. Whoop-de-f***ing-do. You have different views on life, as does anybody else in this world. Get over yourself. Don't preach about how or why you THINK that you are better than everyone else. Instead you're just as ignorant and pathetic if you do.
Just quit giving a damn and maybe you might see things funnier. Or at least, less offensive. I personally find it funny to see you people bickering over a kid that decided to write a thesis on how WoW could be viewed as a religion.
Lemons Jan 30th 2009 6:41PM
"But in the sense that it meets a sociologist's definition of religion: it provides community, ethics, culture, and emotion."
That is a terrible definition of religion. Any decent god fearing religion has a god to fear. A tenth grade chess club could provide community, ethics, culture, and emotion, but that doesn't make it tax exempt.
Ronald Jan 31st 2009 9:17AM
I have a theory on who is a higher power in the game. GMs , We can't see them but we know they are there. If we open a ticket (prayer) they will answer our call even if it is a few days later. They also punish those who do bad.
David Feb 4th 2009 2:13AM
Oh wow! I was actually interviewed for this guy's thesis a couple of months back. Seeing a post about him here makes me squee like crazy! :P