Setting up your audio just right
Kestrel's has an interesting post up about how he deals with audio while playing -- he listens to game audio (or music, apparently) through his computer's speakers, and pipes Vent audio in through his headset. The headset is hooked up via USB (so the sound signal can be different from the speaker signal), and of course the speakers are hooked up to the regular sound card. I'd have thought the way most of us do it (though we do know that some players don't listen to game audio at all, instead choosing music or even a movie over any of the sounds from the game), but apparently Kestrel had some people ask him about it, so maybe it's not that widespread.Personally, I play with a laptop next to me, so I run Vent on that, and let the WoW sounds play on my desktop computer. But there are probably lots of people out there who use just one computer, so must alt-tab out to run Vent, and thus have their game sound and Vent sound coming through the same speakers. And there may even be a better way to do it -- maybe it would help things to have Vent coming out of a different speaker instead of through the headset, like from the surround sound speakers behind you.
In fact, it's too bad the in-game voice chat (remember that?) isn't a little more imaginative in how it plays the sound out -- it would be interesting to have players' voices positioned in 3D space around you, much like the game sounds already are. Vent is more or less necessary for raiding in big groups, but it's too bad that extra audio can sometimes break the illusion of the game.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Odds and ends, Hardware






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Tatharnio Feb 2nd 2009 6:08PM
I actually do it similar to this. I run WoW on a laptop which is bluetooth enabled, and i use my bluetooth headset from my cell. I can then run my game sounds and vent independant of one another, keeping vent in my ear while not blasting the game sounds over people's voices, and making sure that i don't have to lean forward to yell into the teeny mic hole on my keyboard. I find this to be a very lightweight and convenient way to do it, and being wireless means i don't have to remove my headset and miss any conversation if i go afk.
DrThePunisher Feb 3rd 2009 11:33AM
I don't play with the game sounds. I might, but for some reason shaman clearcasting overrides every setting in the game and plays at 100% volume no matter what. So I'll be listening to the quite music but every time (or mostly everything) I'll be blown away by the crack of clearcasting. It's ended my listening to the game sounds... which is really sad. Music / vent all the way for me.
Pike Feb 2nd 2009 6:11PM
Kestrel is a he ;P
Pike Feb 2nd 2009 6:14PM
Heh, see you fixed it already. Move along, any other commenters!
Lich Minion Feb 2nd 2009 6:19PM
I actually run a computer with 3 gigs of ram, 2 video cards, and two monitors, so I can run vent on one monitor and run wow on the other, larger monitor. I also have 5.1 surround sound headphones, so I can listen to everything as if it's happening around me, it's a great set up.
Gnosh Feb 3rd 2009 9:07AM
Since the article is about "audio", not "how expensive is the poster's computer", let me fix your post.
"It's really convenient to run Vent with multiple screens; you don't have to alt-tab to see who's speaking!"
See? See how much less douchey that sounds?
MarkA Feb 2nd 2009 6:23PM
Is anybody else driven nuts when people have their game audio coming over their speakers so that every time they talk in vent you hear *speech* plus *EAR SPLITTING COMBAT/TECHNO/WHATEVER*? Or the guy who chats while you chat so that everything anybody says is echoed back over whatever the person is saying.
The one thing that the in-game audio comm has going for it is the option to mute the game when someone is talking. If they could make that work with vent, my life would be so much better.
Kestrel Feb 2nd 2009 6:28PM
In fact, Mark, I make VERY sure that game sounds are either inaudible, or barely audible, over Vent. Primarily, I use game sounds to alert me to events I need to respond to: Boss alerts, buff/debuff/aura changes, etc. (I play a healer).
But yes, your point is well taken: For example, the people who refuse to use headsets with noise-canceling mics, so their speakers (or environment--think screaming kids and a blaring TV) are feeding right back into their microphones.
Annoying is a nice characterization. ;)
Distayned Feb 2nd 2009 6:25PM
Onboard 7.1 soundcard for my itunes, running through a stereo receiver. 5.1 soundcard for the in game sounds, running through speakers built into my monitor, and vent running through a USB headset. Lets me easily set volume independently for everything depending on what I'm doing.
Schnoggo Feb 2nd 2009 6:36PM
Actually, the Mac client allows you specify independent channels for in-game voice.
But like a lot of people, I run vent on the USB port and the game on the main speakers.
Geniusjones Feb 2nd 2009 6:36PM
That is, UNLESS you have a Mac and a USB headset, in which case you can set your audio to go through any combination of the headset and either internal or external speakers using a combination of the WoW settings, the Sounds System Control Panel (In System Preferences, under the Apple Menu), or by picking the sound source and output in Ventrilo proper. I'm sorry Windows users, the sound controls in Windows really really sucks.
Minidrake Feb 2nd 2009 9:38PM
Troll Comment is a Troll.
I'd be hard pressed to pick a desktop OS since 2001 that couldn't do exactly what you just described.
Arashikou Feb 2nd 2009 6:37PM
I haven't been a raider since the days before there WAS an in-game voice chat. I'm always curious when people say that an outside voice chat program is still pretty much required if you seriously want to voice chat. What is it that makes external voice chat so great? Or, conversely, what does the in-game voice chat lack?
vexis58 Feb 2nd 2009 6:46PM
The couple of times I've ever used it (soon after it came out), it's been really bad quality, and often very hard to understand what people are saying, forcing them to repeat themselves several times, which doesn't make it any better than typing. Most of the groups I run with nowadays act like the built-in voice chat feature doesn't even exist.
In a given 10 or 25-man PuG, someone's bound to have access to a vent server, so we just use theirs.
DavidC Feb 3rd 2009 1:53PM
Raiding without Vent Chat is like Melted Ice-Cream with no toppings.
WoW is not about pushing a bunch of buttons, it's about laughing at the guy that pushed the wrong buttons :-)
Can you raid without voice? Well, can you get to work by walking? Sure. But raiding without voice is boring, takes longer, and produces more wipes ... period.
Can any of you imagine learning 25 man 3 Drakes without Vent? You would have to be into S&M to enjoy that experience.
Robert Feb 2nd 2009 6:39PM
All the 40, 25, and 10-man raid I have been in are fine with the in-game chat feature. Hm.
zappo Feb 2nd 2009 6:40PM
I just pipe everything through my headphones then mute or down the volume on whatever I don't want to listen to. Often that's the people in vent.
McRaider Feb 2nd 2009 6:45PM
So I use skype, as I usually group only with my friends I know IRL. I just have 2 problems:
1. I have a laptop, whitch has gotten bored to alt+tab out of wow. It tends to freeze for a while when going to the desktop >.<
2. Everybody can hear the sounds from wow through skype! We have looked around, but haven't found an answer for that. Does anyone know about this problem?
vexis58 Feb 2nd 2009 6:48PM
Have you tried Gmail's voice chat feature? I use it regularly to chat with my iRL friends while playing. It doesn't have push to talk, but I like it better than Skype for small-group chat.
Skype was always telling us the other person was offline when we were both on, always forcing us to quit and reload the program just so we could start talking to each other.
McRaider Feb 2nd 2009 6:55PM
They hate gmail's voice chat for some reason :/