Raid Rx: Help! How do I start organizing my healers?

Raid Rx has returned from retirement! Every Thursday (usually), Raid Rx will help you quarterback your healers to victory! Your host is Matt Low, the grand poobah of World of Matticus and a founder of PlusHeal, a new healing community for all restorative classes. This week I explore a few questions that new healing leaders have.
This is a question that caught my attention on the Plusheal forums. Julanna just became their guild's de facto healing lead and had some important questions to ask.
So, I have become our de facto healing lead. We have very little structure. We need some. I am not sure how to get some coordination going between our healers.
How do you communicate with your healers? How much do they expect from you in terms of instructions or advice? Is it before the raid? During? How can you get the raid leader to understand that healing assignments other than "don't let people die" are important and make things go better (especially if it is a tank with a healer alt)?
I am not positive about assigning other classes of heals, and I am the only holy priest.
Any resources out there I should look at? That may inform me of other classes basic skills, spells, etc?
Or any advice you may have from a newb officer, newb healing lead, newb progression raider from a new guild?
I'll break up these questions individually and answer them based on my own experience.
How do you communicate with your healers?
At the basic level, establish a private channel just for you and your healers. Ban all DPS if you must. The last thing you need is DPS in the channel requesting their own healers just for them. We'll get to that later in a moment. For now, your directions and questions will be done in here in private.
Most guilds use Ventrilo to communicate via voice. It's a huge asset especially if you happen to lose a few healers and you need to refocus and redirect the rest of your healers accordingly. It helps to have a loud and booming voice to ensure that your instructions cut through anything else. I've heard being the only woman also helps since everyone quiets down rather quickly. But do what you can.
Figure out your needs
Before you start thinking about what you want your healers to be doing, figure out what needs to be done! As the healing lead, you are the central liaison between your tanks and your healers. Tanks pass their requests to you and you pass your instructions to your healers.
For most encounters, I default to having two healers on the MT and everyone else on the raid. Feel free to adjust this as you see fit.
Naturally fights like Four Horsemen and Patchwerk will have completely different assignments. Four Horsemen involves 4 tanks being used and you'll have to split up your healers in such a way to maintain the health of all four tanks along with your raid.
Exercise time
Let's use the Four Horsemen example. Two Feral druids are tanking Lady Blameaux and Sir Zelik. A Death Knight and a Warrior are tackling Thane Kor'thazz and Baron Rivendare up front respectively.
You have at your disposal:
- 1 Discipline Priest
- 1 Holy Priest (undergeared, low mana regen)
- 2 Resto Druids
- 1 Holy Paladin
- 1 Resto Shaman
Assuming your raid is going for the traditional nuking strat of Thane first, how do you setup your healers? (I'll give my answer at the bottom of the post).
How much do they expect from you in terms of instructions or advice?
The art of healing is like mathematics: It's largely trial and error.
Expect to be wrong. Expect to cause wipes because your assignments are slightly off. Expect to tinker and retool your assignments. Expect to shuffle a lot until you manage to get to the "Ah ha!" moment. You'll know it when the raid manages to last a significant amount of time into the encounter before collapsing.
I've been on both the issuing and receiving end of things. Last week, I mentioned the outcome oriented approach. In a nutshell, it means you as the healing lead expect a certain ideal result using whatever means necessary. I don't like to tell my healers to use X spell or Y ability. I expect them to rely on their gut and experience to get the job done. Even if it's Flash Heal spamming, or a combination thereof, as an entry level healing leader you'll want to aim for the plan A result of overall success. Everything else is secondary. If you're not able to reach that goal, that's when you want to step in which I will explain in a second.
Don't crush your healers because they used the wrong spell rotations. They managed to successfully heal through a boss. Let them savor that moment.
For now.
Once healing becomes a problem, start taking a closer look. It becomes obvious when certain things aren't working or a healer isn't doing something right (especially after 24 wipes).
Here's a real example I used several weeks ago when I was still progressing through Naxxramas. Apollo's one of my Resto Shamans and Archimedes is the main tank on Patchwerk.
"Look Apollo. I know you've been doing nothing but Chain Healing on Patchwerk. But we're not getting the results we need. I'd like you try doing nothing but Lesser Healing Wave instead on Archimedes instead. Let's see if there's a noticeable difference, okay?"
Your healers will be different from each other. Try to determine how they best respond to you. Some prefer it when you talk to them out in the open and respond better. Some prefer you speak to them in whispers. Some will come to you. Others will want your help but won't come to you because they're shy or something. As such, you may have to go to them and "check in".
How can you get the raid leader to understand that healing assignments other than "don't let people die" are important and make things go better (especially if it is a tank with a healer alt)?
This is going to sound absolutely hypocritical about what I said above regarding the Plan A road to success. Not letting people die is the overarching objective that you and your team want to accomplish.
The best way to get your raid leader to understand healing assignments is for you to take charge of it yourself. By knowing what classes and specs are better for certain jobs, you can play to their strengths.
Remember that some classes are better at certain situations than others. Use that to your advantage. Show initiative, take over the job yourself and if things go well your raid should notice a marked increase in survivability.
Unless your raid leader is a healer, I suspect they'll be eternally grateful to hand the reins to you so they can focus on other roles.
This last piece of advice comes from Anna.
Trust your people. (And, alternately, don't bring people you can't trust). Healing requires everyone on the team to do his or her own job - and to trust other people to do their jobs as well. Allstars and Meter Monkeys don't make good members of any team.
Incidentally, her blog has just passed the 1 year mark! Send her a big grats! Anna has some great tips on building your healing team from scratch.
Matt's answers
Okay, back to the earlier question I posed:
1 Holy Priest and a Shaman healing Thane's tank and group
1 Holy Paladin healing Rivendare's tank and any DPS or 2 in the area
1 Discipline Priest and 2 Resto Druids on the central platform healing the 2 Druid tanks accordingly
Since the Holy Priest is slightly undergeared, my logic is to stress him as least as possible. Heal the tank that's going to be finished first: Namely, the one on Kor'thazz. This way, the Priest can break off and regen for a while before jumping back into the fray.
Note that there's no right or wrong answer. The goal of this exercise was to get you to think and allocate your resources accordingly.
Any healing related questions? Feel free to contact us or send a reply or direct message to @WoWInsider on Twitter.
Want some more advice for working with the healers in your guild? Raid Rx has you covered with all there is to know! Looking for less healer-centric raiding advice? Take a look at our raiding column Ready Check.Filed under: Druid, Paladin, Priest, Shaman, Tips, Raiding, Guides, Raid Rx (Raid Healing)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
bigepeen Feb 5th 2009 9:21PM
Firstly, I am pleased to have gotten first post, and secondly I have a speech to make.
I say to you today, my friends, so even though we face the difficulties of today and tomorrow, I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream.
I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal."
I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.
I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a state sweltering with the heat of injustice, sweltering with the heat of oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice.
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.
I have a dream today.
Forty-four Americans have now taken the presidential oath. The words have been spoken during rising tides of prosperity and the still waters of peace. Yet, every so often the oath is taken amidst gathering clouds and raging storms. At these moments, America has carried on not simply because of the skill or vision of those in high office, but because we the people have remained faithful to the ideals of our forebears, and true to our founding documents.
And I always wonder that 400-500 years ago when St. Francis of Assisi composed this prayer, they had the same difficulties that we have today as we compose this prayer that fits very nicely for us also. I think some of you already have got it - so we pray together: Let us thank God for the opportunity that we all have together today, for this gift of peace that reminds us that we have been created to live that peace, and that Jesus became man to bring that good news to the poor.
Thank you for listening, and Blizzard bless
Decrusher Feb 6th 2009 12:16AM
You win the longest-post-i-have-ever-taken-the-time-to-read award! congratulations!
thejaysee Mar 6th 2009 11:00PM
I think you will find it was only 43 that have made that oath.
One american president was realected and so said it a second time making the 44 times said
BTW-im my guilds raid heals officer and you are spot on
nice post
Usdom Feb 5th 2009 9:27PM
Blizzard is nerfing spirit to hell so we won't have mana regen, blizzard nerfed tailoring, blizzard nerfed CoH, Blizzard has made priests almost unplayable as holy since day one.
Stop healing until blizzard gets it's game in order. Go shadow. Have actual fun in the game YOU ARE PAYING FOR. When no one can find any healers and blizzard get the CLUE that no one WANTS to be holy, we do it because it is NEEDED and there for they should not try and SCREW US AT EVERY IMPORTUNITY, then Bliz will fix the game so healing isn't a pain in the ass and people will start to heal again.
Healers, WE control the world of Warcraft. Without healers NOTHING happens. Go on strike, go shadow, enjoy yourself until blizzard gets on the ball.
Ace Feb 6th 2009 6:51AM
But how will you enjoy yourself without a healer?
Nurowyn Feb 5th 2009 9:50PM
If you're not having fun, by all means respec. But don't try to invalidate an entire role because you don't enjoy it. There are plenty of holy priests out there that are good at what they do. If you're having trouble with class changes, you could ask them for some tips.
Aggregate Feb 5th 2009 10:02PM
Hah, IMPORTUNITY
Is that like connectitude? or linkitivity?
TehAlx Feb 7th 2009 10:18AM
Get over yourself. Healers don't control the game. Tanks don't control the game. DPS don't control the game.
Every part of the machine in the team dynamic has its purpose. Without the tank, DPS and heals will take too much damage and die. Without DPS, the mobs will outlast the team, and they will eventually die. Without heals, obviously, no damage will be undone and everyone will (you guessed it!) die.
Past this, seconding the fact that just because you dislike a spec doesn't mean the rest of the world doesn't and it's invalid.
Morruco Feb 9th 2009 3:35PM
Why all the hate on holy priests? Truly I'm confused. Our GM is a holy priest as am I. We are without question the two strongest healers in the guild. For example, last night we cleared the Heroic Construct quarter in Naxx. It wasn't a perfect run but we cleared it with only a handful of wipes. Most of the wipes were due to a few new members who hadn't seen the content. In other words, we had good talent. At the end of the night my GM and I were top 2 in HPS and total healing. Number 3 on the list was less than HALF of either of our total healing done. In fact, if you add up spots 3 - 7 on the healing list it would be close to the amount that either ONE of us healed. Holy priests rock, stop complaining about it and learned to heal better!
dawnseven Feb 6th 2009 1:27PM
I'm a healer (and always will be) because I truly enjoy it. That said, I do have to give this post at least some respect, though I know it begs to be flamed and some would be willing to do that even if it didn't.
There is a crumb of truth here though. There's the ACT of healing, and the ART of healing. These two things are completely different.
As a holy paladin I will admit that I'm having more fun healing in Wrath than I did in TBC. I'm judging, using the reduced cool down on holy shock, making good use of BoL, spamming Divine Plea when possible, etc. Much busier. Much better.
A lot of people were upset about potion sickness. Since I had DP it didn't bother me much at all. But if you leave potion sickness in and do things like seriously nerf Plea (and Spirit) you're not really doing anything to make healing more fun, you're just making it harder/more frustrating. Wasn't a lack of fun something GC said the devs were going to look at? Don't get me wrong, I don't mind thinking about what I'm doing (God I hated spamming FoL 90% of the time for 3 hours on end in TBC), but there's a difference between making things more interesting/fun and just plain making them harder.
So many healers respec'd to DPS roles "for leveling" when Wrath came out and refused to spec back. I personally couldn't do that, but I understood the reasons of those that did. I'm not seeing anything in these healing nerfs that in any way actually makes things more exciting/fun/interesting. It just makes it harder. You can't realistically expect the majority of the healers that are left to be throwing confetti over this. I know I didn't log in to read the news and think "Yay! Now I get to decide if the tank can take a 30% nerf to my healing or whether I choose to go oom! Woo hoo!!"
ROFLAMO Feb 5th 2009 9:44PM
after i read the spirit nerf thingy i respec feral
ckipel Feb 5th 2009 10:00PM
Thank goodness my guild only does 10man encounters. Sounds stressful to lead a 25man raid..
PS. I would've never thought of seeing my picture being used on the internet. Cheers to Matticus :)
Perringaiden Feb 5th 2009 10:16PM
Firstly, thankyou "bigepeen" for your rousing but mostly pointless speech. Please STFU.
Now back to the ACTUAL topic (which is NOT healers being nerfed).
Nice writeup Mr Low, I just wanted to add two other points.
* Discipline - Make sure that your healers are clear on their roles, but make sure they understand that they need to focus on those roles, or they will be benched/kicked/cleaning the latrines with a toothbrush. When first starting to get more organised about healing, I've seen a number of guilds healers just ignore the orders and keep healing like a 10yr old carrying a machine gun. i.e. Aim in the general direction and just keep mashing the button. They need to understand that for example they're the only one responsible for that person, so the only way that person will get heals is them (unless there's another 10yr old with a machine gun in the raid).
* Feedback - During my various times as HL, one of the hardest but most useful things I've found is to get healers to comment on your healing orders. Were they too stressed, were they sitting back watching a video etc. It can take time to get in the swing of things, but getting your healers to critique your orders will get you better at assigning them, especially if you don't know their class well. If a pally healer says "On this fight, I don't really have much use as a raid healer" try putting them on MT healing and see how the numbers go. They *should* know their class and how best to be utilised, better than you, so in working on the "Trust your healers" bit, make sure they get used to actively suggesting changes, and act on those suggestions. If everything's working fine and they just want to be critical, sure, but they may just want a change to "I do the same thing every fight". Shaking it up a bit is a good way to reward someone who gets bored and feedback is a great way for them to ask for variety.
Rhys Feb 5th 2009 10:47PM
Mathematics is largely trial and error? Er, what?
daxaar Feb 6th 2009 6:54AM
Not Applied but Pure is indeed mostly trial and error.
nav Feb 6th 2009 6:31AM
"I've heard being the only woman also helps since everyone quiets down rather quickly."
Things to do this week:
Regear
Regem
Reenchant
Respec
Reglyph
Regender