Guardian talks to Chinese goldsellers and UK buyers
UK paper The Guardian has a look at what life is like at a Chinese goldselling company. It's interesting, but we've basically seen it before -- the small room of young people working almost 24/7 to make and deliver gold in-game, the concerns about worker livelihood and the supposedly large amounts of money going through these businesses (there's one figure quoted of £700m, which is about $980 million, but that's an estimate -- no one really knows how much these companies are making).But what's really interesting about this piece is that it seems to treat goldselling as more of an "opportunity" than anything else. The people running the companies are making money, the employees are getting a roof over their head and a steady paycheck, and even the guy making the film talks about how governments should start taking a cut of this industry. Nowhere is it actually mentioned that Blizzard considers these companies to be against the terms of service, or that many times the gold obtained by these companies isn't earned through simple grinding, but by hacking, keylogging, and exploiting. Even if (emphasis on the if) these companies are making millions of dollars a year, they're stealing accounts and cheating in-game to do it.
Rowenna Davis also did interviews with both the gold farmer and a player in the UK buying money from him (bannz0red?), but again, there's no insight at all from the player whose account was hacked and bank was looted, or the player who is able to earn as much gold as they need and have a life outside the game (there are plenty of those to go around). Would have been nice to see the issue from players who aren't actually breaking the game's terms of service.
Thanks, Bryn!
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Odds and ends, Blizzard, Leveling, Making money, Wrath of the Lich King
Transmog yourself into an Avenger!
6 blue posts to read before Diablo 3's launch
Cross-realm zones coming soon
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news







Reader Comments (Page 7 of 7)
a average player Mar 6th 2009 7:49AM
blizzard doesn't care if you buy gold, just don't buy too much
i bought gold twice, and everything went down ok.
Mohrlock Mar 6th 2009 1:17AM
As much as I would love to give my 2 cents on the issues of gold farming I'm feeling a little lazy right now :P
I just wanted to stop by and give Mr. Schramm a big /highfive for using the word "bannz0red"... pure win!
And forget SusanExpress for your gold needs (this one floods our server) all you gotta do is pick a markettable item/material and farm your little ass off!!! Mmmmm gold!!!
shoemanchris Mar 6th 2009 7:39AM
I think the comments about hacked accounts are over blown. I was in a very large Guild for 2 years and in that time only two accounts were hacked...at least one through stupidity and the total gold stolen no more than 10,000g
Hacking, Keylogging and botting are all fundamentally wrong, morally and ToC, but I have less of an issue with people who farm gold to sell especially is they are doing it the 'hard way'.
Let's face it, you can't buy 'real' epics just 2 or three crafted ones per class, so the real work goes in to instancing and raiding. Unless we want to eliminate the time restricted but high quality players from the game (and some of you may do) I see no reason why those who choose to, cannot buy gold. In fact I am surprised that Blizzard don't have official sources for this the same as many other games do (see many Facebook applications, Mafia Wars for example)
The choice is there people. Do it or don't do it. I really truely do not support cheating through hacks, bots and cheats, but trading your time and effort in return for real money and by providing a product and service for which there is a demand... isn't that called capitalism?
Ascote Mar 6th 2009 9:19AM
I think there are a few missing facts here.
You can say that not all of the goldfarming money comes from hacking, but I bet 99% of the money from hacking accounts goes to gold farmers and 1% goes to stupid teenagers that should be thrown into military service.
The game and its economy is designed on equality. It might be fun for you that in real life because your father was a rich bastard you don´t get to work half as hard as someone who isn´t. It is not fun at all for those who are not born into such conditions and have to face a much harsher reality. Its not hard for someone with the minimum marketing skill to see that you will get more subscribers with an equality designed game than on a cash based.
That aside, I do find the article interesting, even if it lacks all of the hacking dilema and its consequences.
Verit Mar 6th 2009 11:02PM
I'm clearly in the wrong business (unemployment...). Time to get some accounts, some bots and make some money.
Nicole Mar 10th 2009 2:28PM
I have to put in my 2 cents worth on this issue. Even though I'm sure that there exist some gold selling services that have nothing to do with the scamming and hacking of accounts, the sheer volume of accounts that ARE hacked for the sole purpose of obtaining gold or characters to farm gold on is damning enough. After I have spent the last week dealing with a hacked account, I have nothing but contempt and distaste for anyone who takes any part in the gold selling/character selling/powerleveling industry. This game is easy enough as it is. It's depressing to me that some people act so casually about, for example, buying gold when I doubt they are considering the full implications of what they're supporting.
I've played WoW for 2.5 years and had amassed quite a fortune in-game, both of gold and of items. I watched as my characters were paid-character-transferred off to random realms, all of my things were either stolen or destroyed, and my account was used to exploit, scam, and farm gold. I've finally gotten control of my account now after buying a stupidly overpriced authenticator off of eBay. I was already taking every security precaution that Blizzard recommends to keep your account safe and many more, and I am positive that my system was not compromised for many, many reasons. Yet every time I had my password changed, it was rehacked within hours and the password was changed back. Anyhow, as of last night I finally have control of my account and my stuff has been restored fairly completely. But I'm still shaking with rage over the whole deal. After doing a bit of research on the going rate for various WoW-related things on the "black market," I'd say it's quite possible that someone made $1-2 grand off of me and my hard work.
I hope that the people who buy that gold greatly enjoy their Traveler's Tundra Mammoths care of the efforts of yours truly, and I hope your small amount of in-game satisfaction is worth all of the real-life grief, frustration, anger, and confusion that I've had to experience because the gold market is such a thriving business. I would love to personally thank each and every person who supports this industry and let them know exactly what they are supporting. Maybe you found the only gold selling site that doesn't use ANY shady means of obtaining its gold whatsoever! Yeah, I'm sure that's the case. Believe it if it'll keep your conscience clean, I suppose =\