Arcane Brilliance: Professions for Mages, the thrilling conclusion

Each week Arcane Brilliance brings you a column about Mages and all things Mage-related. That's right, Arcane Brilliance is nothing if not consistent. You won't find any server instability here. We're never down, we're always up, and you can always enter our instanced content. And the best part? Arcane Brilliance doesn't charge you 15 bucks a month. Although, donations are totally welcome.
So how's everything? Did you make it through patch day unscathed? Did you log in, like me, and find that your Mage's face, forearms, and feet were gone, and there was a hole through his chest (pro tip: upgrade your video card drivers more than once every three years)? Are you running out of mana at an outrageous clip? Are your crit numbers from Molten Armor up or down? Did your guild manage to make it into Ulduar yet, and if so, did you manage to snag any phat loot? Did you dual spec your Mage so he can now both DPS and DPS? I went Frostfire/Firefrost, myself. When triple-specs hit, I'm taking a Frarcano-fire spec. Mark my words.
All in all, I'd say 3.1 wasn't too bad. We have some new glyphs to play with, the Argent Tournament is good, clean fun, our mounts can swim, and we have a whole new batch of loot-pinatas to blow up. Our DPS seems to be down a bit, but we're still beating Warlocks, so I'm not going to mail any angry, expletive-laced letters to Blizzard just yet. I've written them--rest assured--but I'm not yet prepared to actually invest in stamps for them. Those things are like a buck apiece these days.
So now we turn to the third and final installment in our guide to professions for Mages. If you missed them, the first two parts can be found here and here. This week we'll investigate the merits of Blacksmithing, Leatherworking, and Engineering. As an added bonus, we'll take a quick peek at the three secondary professions and enumerate the reasons for investing in them. Yes, even though you can conjure Strudel from the very air around you with but a word and a snap of your fingers, you still need to learn how to cook
Blacksmithing
For Mages, this profession is flat-out horrible for approximately 79.99 levels. Then it becomes completely fantastic.
- Leveling
- End-game
A popular choice among min-maxers is to pair Blacksmithing with Jewelcrafting, allowing you the extra spellpower of the JC-only epic gems and the flexibility of the two bonus BS sockets. The bottom line here is that you can place an extra 38 spellpower's-worth of gems in those two sockets, and you have a lot more options as to which stats you gem for, due to the extra room. If/when the new epic gems get implemented, these extra two sockets become even more valuable.
Leatherworking
This is another profession that was obviously intended to be utilized by classes other than Mages. It's tough to recommend this profession, even at end-game. In fact, of all the crafting professions, this is probably the least useful to Mages.
- Leveling
- End-game
Engineering
From a standpoint of pure fun, Engineering shines. Unfortunately, until Blizzard adds in a talent that converts a percentage of your fun into crit rating or whatever, fun simply doesn't help us much. If you choose Engineering, you'll have access to toys and mounts and random conveniences that non-engineers will be jealous of, but non-engineers will have access to spellpower that will have you green with envy. If only you could attach a scope to a wand...
- Leveling
Goggles: These are awesome. As head-gear goes, these will often be the best options available at the level, rife with spellpower and intellect, and most importantly, made of cloth.
Trinkets and random trinket-like items: These will allow you to do a bunch of things that Mages can't usually do, from rezzing people, to summoning a combat pet, to stealthing. Plus, hilarious and deadly side-effects!
Explosives: You may not think that you need more ways to blow things up, but I'm here to tell you that you're wrong, my friend. Dead-wrong. I have two words for you. One is sheep and the other is explosive. In all seriousness, these actually help quite a bit as you level, providing a cheap and powerful AoE/stunning option.
I really don't have enough room here to describe all of the fun stuff you can make with Engineering as you level. The mileage of these gadgets will vary with each player, but suffice it to say that though it's difficult to quantify this profession's value in pure stats, you will be hard pressed to find anything more fun to level with.
- End-game
- A glove haste enchant that is probably the best glove enchant out there for Mages, but not by a whole lot.
- A cloak enchant that is the only way to get spellpower on a cloak in the game currently. It's not much better than the traditional haste enchant, but certainly isn't worse.
- BoP epic goggles. For Mages, it's the hilariously named Visage Liquification Goggles. Prior to Heroic Naxx, these will be just about the best thing out there for your Mage to put on his/her head.
- Random assorted other junk.
If you're looking to maximize your performance, you should probably pick something else. If you're more interested in creating a tiny robot and then selling him all your trash, pick Engineering. Did I mention the motorcycle? You get to ride around on a motorcycle!
Secondary Professions
I'm not going to say a whole lot here, except to assert that if you are ignoring any of these professions, as a Mage (or any other class, for that manner), you should reconsider. All of them are worth leveling. Even Fishing.
First Aid
We're Mages. We just don't have that many ways to get health back. in PvP, especially, the ability to slap a quick bandage on is often invaluable. Keep your First Aid maxed out, guys.
Cooking
Now, don't get me wrong. I love Strudel as much as the next Mage. It's free, available in massive quantities, tastes great, and is less filling. Still, eating it won't increase your spellpower at all. Sad, but true. If you cook your own food, on the other hand, you'll be able to do just that, or your hit rating, or your crit rating, or your haste rating, or your whatever else you might want to increase. Level Cooking, seriously. Quit mooching off your guildies.
Fishing
I know it's mind-numbingly boring. I know it takes a million years to max out. I know. But leveling this will help you level Cooking, and allow you multiple options for making some tasty spellpower food. Plus, the new Fishing dailies give fun loot, and you can fish up a turtle and then ride it about town. Bite the bullet, grab your pole, and go fish.
So now that we've spent the last three weeks discussing professions at length, what better way to end than by condensing all of the relevant information into one handy table, rendering the previous five thousand or so words almost entirely moot?
Let's break it down, taking into account only the bonuses each profession offers above what is normally available:
Alchemy: +37 spellpower, and whatever you can squeeze out of your Crazy Alchemist's Potions.
Blacksmithing: +38 spellpower, plus the flexibility of two extra prismatic sockets.
Enchanting: +38 spellpower
Engineering: 340 haste rating for 10 seconds once every minute on your gloves instead of the 28 spellpower you'd normally have there, plus 18 spellpower on your cloak instead of the normal 23 haste you'd otherwise have there, plus a bunch of situational extras from trinkets and such. Seriously, your guess is as good as mine.
Inscription: +37 spellpower, plus you don't have to grind any rep with the Sons of Hodir.
Jewelcrafting: +59 spellpower
Leatherworking: +37 spellpower
Tailoring: Lightweave Embroidery, which now translates to approximately +60 spellpower, assuming it replaces the 23 haste enchant and procs normally.
Mining: 500 health
Herbalism: 2,000 health over 5 seconds, three minute cooldown.
Skinning: +25 crit rating
So, after all of that, what should you choose? Beats me. Do what you want.
Filed under: Mage, Patches, Analysis / Opinion, Jewelcrafting, Features, Raiding, Leveling, Guides, Classes, (Mage) Arcane Brilliance, First Aid, Enchanting, Tailoring, Herbalism, Fishing, Mining, Skinning, Alchemy, Blacksmithing, Cooking, Engineering, Leatherworking, Inscription






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Jamesisgreat Apr 18th 2009 5:06PM
Good old Dragonlance.... some of those were great books.
Apart from the ones written by Richard Knaak obviously!
Drager Apr 18th 2009 5:19PM
I recently found and re-read the Autumn Twilight/Spring Dawning/Winter Night trilogy and couldn't believe how poorly written they are. Should have just left myself with the memories of reading them as a kid.
Credwink Apr 19th 2009 1:17PM
"Our DPS seems to be down a bit, but we're still beating Warlocks"
Uhhh what warlocks are you playing against. I smash full 7.5 mages as 3/14/54.
Scilk Apr 18th 2009 5:27PM
Everyone gets to ride on a motorcycle though, engineers are just the poor saps who have to make them in the knowledge that a non-engineer will ride them. It makes me cry inside everytime.
Uriah Apr 18th 2009 5:27PM
My first post here - long time reader.
Another outstanding read. Regardless of useful information or hilarity, I always find myself coming back every Saturday to read this column. The funny thing is my main is a Paladin, but it did convince me to make a mage.
Great 3-part Christian, really helped me iron out the decisions once I finish my last 12 levels. I think most people will be stuck between the all-time favorites of Tailoring/ Enchanting versus Jewelcrafting/ Blacksmithing. I personally plan to milk out Enchanting for its Disenchant properties and then swiftly replace it with Jewelcrafting. The new lightweave cloak change is just too appealing to me, as well as flying a friggin carpet around, and if that ever gets old, I'll just swap back to Enchanting.
Thanks for the read, keep up the great work. Oh and while I truely do hate facing a lock, they sure do make great leveling buddies. (Heresy, I know!)
Misha Apr 20th 2009 10:33AM
Hehe, I agree completely on what you say about this column- I too am a non-mage main (Shaman, to be exact) who reads this column diligently while other ones I may not read all the way through. Why? Because of the witty style, and perhaps the Warlock bashing. Rivalries are always fun. :D
Sadly my little mage alt is only 32 or so. But because I read this I'm able to give out some advice to our raiding mages!
Keep up the good work, yo!
Thander Apr 18th 2009 5:32PM
Don't forget about the new cooking recipe. Black Jelly heals more health/mana than mage food. I think this is actually the first time mage food has become inferior. I always remember the best stuff being equal to mage food.
Ametrine Apr 18th 2009 6:25PM
Yeah, but it probably tastes awful... I mean, would you really wanna eat something called "black jelly"? It sounds like some sort of fungal growth.
Candina@WH Apr 18th 2009 10:34PM
Brits eat 'Black Pudding', FWIW
Zonique Apr 18th 2009 11:02PM
Some of us might eat Black Pudding, but at least we dont eat so much processed rubbish that around a quarter of us become obese.
placebo Apr 19th 2009 12:06PM
@Zonique
Actually a quarter of you ARE obese.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-301419/Fat-Britain-Tackling-obesity-epidemic.html
Both sides of the pond are fat.
Chryso Apr 18th 2009 5:34PM
Yah... little tip: if you're going to try to extol the virtues of engineering, don't cite one of the top 5 items in the Litany of Lies and Failure that is post-classic engineering.
The CritterEnlarger was never implemented; Blizzard just put it o nthe PTRs to trick us into testing it for them before they gave it to the TCG instead.
Algathar Apr 18th 2009 5:34PM
lol, that thing about Mages beating Warlocks DPS made me lol. Class has nothing to do with it, and besides, I completely hammered a Mage in a group tonight, so dunno where that statement came from, but that's just my two cents. :P
Dah Apr 18th 2009 5:42PM
Tl;dr version: For end game, the best min/maxed profession choices in 3.1 are Tailoring and Jewelcrafting in that order.
SunwellVialist Apr 18th 2009 5:43PM
I'm not even playing a Mage and I thoroughly enjoyed reading this.
Kudos.
Awesome post.
zetathran Apr 18th 2009 5:55PM
Another benefit to Engineering is that it has far and away the best benefits for PvP. That glove attachment is good for burst, grenades are nice for BGs, but what really puts it over the top is the Gnomish Lightning Generator and the Rocket Boots, both great for arena (though the GLG did get nerfed...). Makes me wish I'd realized it was such a good choice when I was picking professions.
Ametrine Apr 18th 2009 6:28PM
Engineering hasn't been good for PVP (or much else) since pre-BC 60.
The best PVP stuff is BS/JC for the bonus gems and sockets.
Firestride Apr 18th 2009 6:08PM
I'm a Druid who's been LW/Skin since Day 1, so I might be speaking out of turn, but didn't Engineering just get a couple of DPS items taken off the GCD and put on their own cooldown? Wouldn't casting those every time they come up add some sort of DPS benefit that you're not mentioning?
sikyon Apr 18th 2009 7:28PM
"Jewelcrafting: +59 spellpower"
NO!
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!
32 (runed dragons eye) - 19(runed scarlet ruby) = 13
13*3 = 39
Dailen Apr 19th 2009 3:07AM
Perhaps if you had read the installment with JC you'd realize he's counting an extra 20 spellpower from not having to use two glowing twilight opals to activate the meta:
2 runed instead of 2 glowing = 20 + dragon's eyes = 59