Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria newsInsider Trader: Jewelcrafting nerf incoming
by Amanda Miller 
May 22nd 2009 at 4:00PM
Insider Trader is your inside line on making, selling, buying and using player-made products.Bornakk just announced on the forums that Jewelcrafters are about to see a new nerf, and as a result, people are already beginning to weigh the benefits of switching to a different profession for min-maxing, or working out how they are going to re-itemize their gear.
Bornakk:
In the next major content patch we will be removing the prismatic quality of the jewelcrafter-only Dragon's Eye gems. Like other gems, they will have to match the socket color to receive a socket bonus. When this change occurs, players with qualifying jewelcrafting skill will be provided a yet to be determined amount of Dalaran Jewelecrafter Tokens as compensation.
This probably won't be enough to entice players to drop the profession, but it is a bit of a blow. Stratfu points out that because Mage T8 is equipped primarily with yellow and blue sockets, the only way to actually meet socket bonus requirements will be to use sub-par gems.
The JC-only Runed Dragon's Eye offers +32 spell power, and currently fits into any socket, conforming to meet the necessary color requirements. This is compared to the +19 spell power that the rest of us folks get from Runed Scarlet Rubies. While Jewelcrafters will still be able to use these gems, they won't be able to stick them just anywhere.
Breaking it down
Jewelcrafters can equip three of these soon-to-be-not-prismatic gems, and the fact is that for many classes, red gems offer the best stats in many cases. That is the main reason that Scarlet Rubies sell for often double the price of any other comparable gem on the market. For some classes, their gear simply will not include three red sockets.
Another example would be tier 8 and tier 8.5 sets for protection Paladins. While they benefit most from blue gems, their sets have only one blue socket!
While it may seem to some to be an easy compromise to forgo a socket bonus or use a different gem, it does mean that some classes simply won't benefit from being Jewelcrafters as much as other classes. Not being able to take advantage of your own profession's rewards for leveling it seems counter-intuitive, and unfair to the affected classes.
Would this mean that min-maxing guilds would suddenly prefer, for example, a Jewelcrafting prot Warrior over a JC prot Paladin, simply because the Warrior can squeeze more out of his/her stats? After all, tanks are becoming increasingly homogenized. Many fights no longer require a specific class. Unfortunately, many high-end guilds do block people from raid slots for not having the right profession, for example.
Compensation
The Jewelcrafting Token compensation is also a curious mechanic. Will the Dragons Eyes disappear entirely, or will your equipped and/or cut gems disappear? Unlikely. Most likely, you will log in to find your once prismatic gems converted into their corresponding colors. The tokens will be handed out as a means of compensation for the fact that many players will have to replace them.
But why JC?
Presumably this nerf comes as a response to the popularity of the profession. Not only is it one of, if not the, best gold making professions in the game, it is also considered a must for min-maxing your raiding gear. In fact, many high-end guilds require that their raiders become Jewelcrafters and either Enchanters or Blacksmiths in addition.
When Blizzard finally decides to add epic gems into the game, this nerf will hit the JC community even harder if the gems aren't buffed significantly, as Stratfu mentions. After all, each profession has its profession-only perks, and if they don't scale, and new ones are not introduced in their place, we'd all feel like Engineers carrying around old Arcanite Dragonlings and the like.
Of course, there is no need for panic. Patch 3.2 may not be the epic gem patch, meaning that we may yet see buffs to the Dragon's Eye gems that have not yet been announced.
Discussion
What do you think about this change? How are you going to have to re-work your gear? Is this actually going to affect your decision to take up, or keep, the Jewelcrafting profession?
We want to know your take on the matter. Hop on Twitter, leave a comment here, or blog about it with your new WoW.com profile feature! Don't forget to add the #wowcom tag to the end of your tweet!
Each week, Insider Trader takes you behind the scenes of the bustling sub-culture of professional craftsmen, examining the profitable, the tragically lacking, and the methods behind the madness. Check out our analysis of patch 3.1 profession changes, or read through our in-depth analysis of the changes to flasks in 3.1. Filed under: Mage, Paladin, Enchanting, Items, Analysis / Opinion, Economy, Jewelcrafting, Features, Raiding, Enchants, Insider Trader (Professions)
Reader Comments (Page 6 of 6)
Amaxe-1 May 31st 2009 9:17AM
I believe I clarified as well:
"As for Epic gems, Blizzard has two choices:
1) Make them less than our Unique (3) Dragon's Eye gems
2) Make them equal or better
In case 1) the nerf becomes more bearable. I don't use them for the stat bonus, but at least they remain "best in slot."
In case 2), Dragon's Eye gems become worthless. We can only have 3 of them and they are now based on slot color. The epic gems would then become better and have no restrictions on how many you could have."
You have no way of knowing what the upcoming epics will be like.
Rilgon's reading comprehension FTL and troll behavior of a 13 year old
Amaxe-1 May 31st 2009 9:18AM
supposed to be responding to Rilgon's troll. WoW.com still as bad as WoWInsider comment system
Milney Jul 12th 2009 7:33AM
The Prismatic loss does suck, but JC's did not have much more of a buff than other classes. This should actually bring them in-line. Though to be fair they should scale them for epic gem releases. Lets look at the benefits for JC's besides the prismatic quality. I will use SP as an example.
Runed SR= 19sp
Runed dragon's eye = 32 sp.
A net gain of 13 sp per gem. Multiplied by 3 gems =39 sp.
BS = 2 gem slots = 38 sp (2 runed SR)
Enchanting = 38 sp (2 19 sp enchants)
Alchemy Mixology = 38 extra sp from Frostwyrm Elixir.
Are we seeing a pattern? As long as they keep the ratio correct on an epic upgrade to gem quality, the loss of prismatic nature should simply bring it back in line with every other non-gathering Profession.
amnh Aug 5th 2009 4:34PM
I didn't originally think this would be a bad idea, I have to admit JCs were pretty overpowered since I am one. When I logged back in today and noticed that my metas were no longer active I thought it would be as simple as going and buying some new gems with my emblems of heroism and resocketting to activate my metas and socket bonuses. Little did I know that none of the vendors that used to sell rare quality (blue) gems before would be selling them anymore. Go figure, you can only buy the epic quality gems now, but too bad if you don't have enough daily JC tokens to buy the recipes because you are basically useless now as a JC. Rare quality gem prices have shot through the roof on my realm because of the newly limited supply, and epic gems are going for nearly 400g each. The daily quests are easy but quite annoying having to fly out to BFE for a monotonous quest and pay extra money for green gems to complete those quests every single day is a lot more hassle than it's worth. I leveled Tailoring on another toon and never had to go through all of this crap. To get enough JC tokens to buy all of the recipes, you need to spend weeks upon weeks doing dailies, and no other professions are like that. Jewelcrafting seems hardly worth the trouble of all of these endless dailies and other annoyances for such a small payoff.