Guildwatch: Min-E3 edition

Apologies for this week -- I'm at E3 working like crazy, and Guildwatch has ended up on the low priority list. But I'm not going to leave you with nothing: though it's a little shorter than normal, we've still got your downed, recruiting, and dramatic news of the week. Click below to read on, and we'll be back to full strength next week.
Got more tips for us? Just send them along to guildwatch@wow.com, and you might see them right here soon.
Got more tips for us? Just send them along to guildwatch@wow.com, and you might see them right here soon.
DRAMA
- The Village People on EU Doomhammer apparently broke up this past week -- the guildleaders split, we hear, and robbed the guild bank dry as a bone. The good news is that they've reformed in the form of Avalon. Our tipster says it's one to avoid, but we think it might be exactly the guild to join. When you hear about a restaurant failing a health check isn't that the time to go eat there? Aren't they super vigilant right after they have a major problem? Wouldn't a guild that just broke up and reformed be much more likely to try to stay together?
- Eastside on Moonrunner is a ninja. But Oblivion kicked him from the guild when they found out, "so they are not a ninja guild." Well that's good to know.
- Strendar on Ascension from Shu'halo kicked a 13-year-old girl out of the guild for supposedly leaking private comments to people who applied to the guild. The girl and her mom appear in the thread, and boy are they unhappy. Not just because the girl got kicked, but also because Strendar is calling her out for something he had a problem with, not her. A messy (and captivating) read.
- More progression thread drama, this time from Nagrand. Things really get good on page 3. why is it that these threads lend themselves to arguing so easily -- is it that hard to simply just track and report who's killed who?
- Apparently Project Flying Monkey, the drama-prone guild on EU Bloodfeather, is getting a little help, from none other than Ensidia. We hear their advice so far has pushed them up to the top of their server, and that they've even beat one of the better guilds on the realm, Aspire. But isn't getting and giving advice fair play? You tell us.
- Coca Cola, arguably the number one guild on Proudmoore, we hear, is closing up shop, after their leader kicked all the guild's members and took the entire gbank (24K in gold and another 2K in items). Apparently the members are scattered, a sad end for a worthwhile guild.
- Finally, one bit of guild goodness: The Crew on Blade's Edge held a baby shower for founding member Chloezelot a few weekends ago. Members met at the Beer Garden in Dalaran and showered the guest of honor with rose petals, in a spotlight and gave gifts including the Nurse's Gown and toys from the Dalaran Toy Shop. Cake was served and drinks enjoyed. Sounds like fun! Good luck with the kid!
- Clam Stackers on Ravencrest thought about sacrificing a Gnome for victory, but instead, they just threw guild members off of the shattered walkway for good luck. And it worked: Auriaya, and Iron Council downed in Ulduar. Woot!
- Vice on EU Quel'thelas has been rocking -- they took out 25-man Flame Levithan in Ulduar, and dropped Kologarn as well. Grats!
- Deadly Omen on Echo Isles finally finished 10-man Naxx.
- Forlorn Legacy of Windrunner has crushed some hard mode bosses lately -- Assembly of Iron, Hodir, and Thorium have all fallen to their swords.
- Surrender or Die on EU Aerie Peak got to Razorscale the other day, and had an inevitable wipe on the second try. But for some reason, she didn't despawn, due to the Expedition Defenders still fighting. After cheering them on in raid chat a lot, they got her down to about 2k HP... resulting in a dreaded 0% wipe. Bummer. But they'll get her next time.
- Slightly Wicked of Draka cleared Naxx 10, this was the first week they were able to down Gluth, Thaddius, 4H and subsequently and quickly Sapp and KT.
- Dragon Knights on Area 52-A killed Flame Leviathan, and has Razorscale on notice for 25-man. In 10-man, they're up to Kologran, with Ignis on notice for next time. They're also recruiting -- quailty DPS are welcome.
- Aggro My Own Vegetables (EU Chromaggus) has cleared out Malygos -- they've also finished off Flame Leviathan and Razorscale, and completed OS 1D the week before. Grats!
- Irritable Vowels on Bronzebeard is a small, casual guild of friends that usually just raids 10-man content and found they had fifteen members online and bored and decided to mess around in BC content they hadn't seen. They easily downed Archimonde in Hyjal, and then rolled into 25-man Naxx and cleared Arachnid with just 19 people. Way to go!
- Shadow Exiles (EU Earthen Ring) downed Flame Leviathan, Razorscale, Ignis, XT-002 Deconstructor, Iron Council, Kologarn, Auriaya and Freya in Ulduar 10 in just three runs so far. Nice job.
- War Ensemble on Silver Hand-A is recruiting dedicated players committed to clearing new content in Ulduar. If you can raid with them Friday through Sunday, check 'em out.
- The Knights of the Shadows on Kalecgos-A is looking to expand their active roster of level-headed, easy-going, and capable raiders. They like to think of themselves as a "casually serious" raiding guild, and are specifically looking for Rogues, Warlocks, Feral Druids, Mages, and Shamans to complement the 25-man Ulduar progression core.
- Slave to the Grind of Sen'jin-H is looking for more members for 25-man raids and Ulduar. They're currently recruiting all classes that don't begin with "Death" or end with "lock". Potential recruits must like cheese and be capable of not standing in fire, please.
- Synergy on Scilla is a casual raiding guild recruiting players level 75 and up. They are looking primarily for healers and DPS so that they can advance past the Loot Leviathan and consistantly run 25-man raids. Transfers are welcome. Apply for an interview right over on the website.
- Revision on Khaz'goroth started up recently with the goal of having about 30 raiders tackling Ulduar at high speed. They're seeking experienced players who want a good spot based on performance -- no one gets a free ride, but if you're good, you'll always have a place in the raids. If you can stay out of AoE and get better, they're looking for sure.
- Dusk til Dawn Khadgar-A is recruiting all classes and roles other than Death Knights for 10-man Ulduar progression. They are a casual raiding guild with no raid atttendance requirement, Suicide kings for loot, and a mature, winning attitude. If you can't handle a wipe or two, this isn't your bus stop. But if you are looking for a mature casual raiding guild, this may be the place for you.
- Eucatastrophe of Thorium Brotherhood is currently recruiting more raiders to flesh out their ranks and take the dive into 25-man content. Focus on ranged DPS and healers, but all welcome to apply. Currently blasting their way through Ulduar.
Filed under: Guilds, Odds and ends, Raiding, Guildwatch, Bosses






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Imapieceofgoo Jun 3rd 2009 5:33AM
Wooo alright deadly omen
I happen to be the new leader of that guild (i'm the person who sent it in) but that drama is for another day.
We cleared 25man shortly after our 10man finish
hcampb3 Jun 16th 2009 10:05AM
Hey, I'm having trouble finding Guildwatch. Right now, I just do a search and click on a tag to find the latest issue. I will humbly admit to being a blind noob if someone could point out the link to this blog. Thanks!
heroman12121 Jun 3rd 2009 5:45AM
Wow....Thats alot to insert into my brain.....
13 old girl got kicked out of the guild....
My words: Thats Harsh...
Dhearic Jun 3rd 2009 6:38AM
What kind of mother lets her 13 year old daughter raid?
Shouldn't children of that age play outside with friends?
I have the feeling that this mother takes the wow-life waaaay too serious.
Aarkan Jun 3rd 2009 11:16AM
I read a bunch of that thread and I heard that "go outside" repeated a lot. I don't know about you guys but when I was 13 I wasn't going out on weeknights I was doing my homework and then playing Dreamcast or Tribes or whatever the F it was until i went to sleep. I went over friends houses on weekends and stuff. It's not abnormal AT ALL for a kid to be home on weeknights. A few pages in someone said she was on till 7am every day and then slept till 4pm so that leads me to believe something weird is up but for a kid in middle/high school to be on every night? There's nothing weird about that at all.
artifex Jun 3rd 2009 1:26PM
Aarkan: who knows, she might be home-schooled. Regardless, kids are probably all out of school now, anyway.
I rolled a female hordie alt on Anetheron while waiting for my main's server to come out of maint, and kept seeing people spamming trade for "WTB girl to talk dirty to me for gold," and one moron asking me if I was a prostitute, following me around offering me "coins" and running back and forth into me. The brats are definitely out of school.
dotorion Jun 3rd 2009 5:51AM
"Apparently Project Flying Monkey, the drama-prone guild on EU Bloodfeather, is getting a little help, from none other than Ensidia. We hear their advice so far has pushed them up to the top of their server, and that they've even beat one of the better guilds on the realm, Aspire. But isn't getting and giving advice fair play? You tell us."
Yeah, Ensidia has THE SEKRUT TO SERVER DOMINASHUN.
*rolleyes*
Seriously, they know nothing that the rest of the world doesn't know. What they have is time and money. That's it.
docisemo Jun 3rd 2009 6:28AM
Time and money?
Please know what you are talking about before jumping to conclusions. Not one person in that guild is paid to play WoW.
dotorion Jun 3rd 2009 7:29AM
I haven't followed up on them since they merged, but I do not see a reason why Nihilum (who did receive sponsoring) should not receive any more sponsoring when they go raid under a different name and with more people under that name. If anything, they should receive more.
And even if they don't, my point still stands. They don't have some kind of supersecret strategy or something, they are just another guild. Stop the damn fanboyism already (this is not directed at you, docisemo, but the general public)
Bubsa Jun 3rd 2009 7:53AM
Your rock, docisemo, how long have you been under it?
holypaladin Jun 3rd 2009 9:57AM
Here's my two cents: 13 year old girl gets kicked from a guild because she's repeatedly leaking confidential guild information that she *knew* she wasnt supposed to leak and GM posts a forum about it and so everyone flames the GM.... I dont mean to be harsh but why the hell is everyone flaming the GM just because she's 13? I played wow at 13 and I didnt get any special treatment and I'm a girl! Leave the GM alone people, if it had been a 13 year old boy no one would give a rats a**...
If you want to insult the guy or call him an a**, don't do it because of her being a 13 year old girl...
Allison Robert Jun 3rd 2009 10:18AM
I'd have to agree. Strendar is in a true no-win situation here. Equally disturbing is that the 13-year old's mother appears and argues that the guild is responsible for teaching her child life lessons.
She was just *taught* a life lesson; betraying things said in confidence despite being warned about it pisses people off!
SunwellVialist Jun 3rd 2009 10:37AM
I think the problem here is that it has been dragged onto the forum, instead having been dealt with professionally. In other words, the intend was to prevent drama -with- drama, which is... a bit backwards. It made the Guild Leader look bad, and it made the 13 year old look bad. All around just bad.
Elry Jun 3rd 2009 11:29AM
Gotta agree with the parenting tips laid down at the bottom of the first page too. The mother's posts seemed to imply she was allowing (possibly even encouraging, though that might be too strong) her daughter to take the game far too seriously. If she'd really been watching all the guild drama unfold for a while, then she should have warned her daughter away from that guild, or limited her play-time. That what my mum would have done when I was 13!
But then, its probably not really her mum, just the girl herself trying to make her posts seem more authoritative.
Anyway, if the GM had said whoever it was will get the boot, they can't back down based on age. That would discriminate against all us oldies! :P
Kim Jun 3rd 2009 12:22PM
He kicked her and that should have been the end of it. Instead he took it server wide and there is a whole other thread about guild drama with Strendar. Oh his guild now jumped servers so have fun with them!
Luke Jun 3rd 2009 12:59PM
you comment makes clear logic! no im not being sarcastic. and i have read far into the thread seen his scrn shots and tbh, i think he was doing the right thing. in RL law, ignorance is no excuse, why should it be in intellectual property, such as WoW?
about the public humiliation on forums, it should be notification, not dragged out turning into drama. eg she blabbed several times, ignored warnings and so was kicked.
I also agree with Elry and Allison Robert.
Luke Jun 3rd 2009 1:01PM
edit: at start of my post where i his/her post made logic, i was referring to holypaladins, not kims.
Niyaki Jun 3rd 2009 11:14AM
Niyaki from PFM here. We didn't get information from any guild, and Aspire are just butthurt we beat them. If i was in Aspire even i would try to flame the newly best guild a lot and accusing them of cheating aswell. Also they have ex members of Nihilum and they still have contact with Ensidia.
I think i made my point :|
corvaal Jun 3rd 2009 12:13PM
On the 13yr Old Girl issue.
Sometimes the only way to get through to a drama w**re is to slap drama back at them. Put them in the center of something where they can't really back out of or deny the issues.
I would not have tolerated the actions as long as they did. It would have been a 1 strike your out sorta deal. If not a gkick it would be alteast forum access removal.
Alkatraz Jun 3rd 2009 12:28PM
No love for the 10 man only guilds. of Frostmane. We downed Vezax last week and are dilligently working on Yogg and other hardmodes.