WoW, Casually: Playing with your reading-age child
Robin Torres writes WoW, Casually for the player with limited playtime. Of course, you people with lots of playtime can read this too, but you may get annoyed by the fact that we are unashamed, even proud, of the fact that beating WoW isn't our highest priority. Take solace in the fact that your gear is better than ours, but if that doesn't work, remember that we outnumber you. Not that that's a threat, after all, we don't have time to do anything about it. But if WoW were a democracy, we'd win.
Since I last wrote about playing with preschoolers, I have been having an extremely rewarding time playing Itchee with The Spawn. The benefits to both of us are even greater than I originally wrote about. I find that my Itchee time is making me appreciate all of my WoW time even more. Nurturing my child while enjoying my limited playtime is a win-win situation.
It's particularly nice to have this indoor activity to do together with the nasty heatwave we are having in the real world. And that leads me to something I want to address before we get into the guide for playing with reading-age children:
These guides are for parents who have made the educated decision to include WoW as one of the indoor activities to participate in with their children.
In no way am I suggesting that playing WoW or any other video game is the only activity to do with your child. Nor am I recommending that children only play sedentary, indoor activities.
Children require a variety of both active and quiet activities that include solo time as well as cooperative play. Just as the children pictured to the right are practicing important skills while quietly putting together a jigsaw puzzle, playing WoW with your child is just one of the many ways you can enrich both your lives while doing something you enjoy. I am also not recommending that you use video games (or television for that matter) as an electronic babysitter. Only you (or your designated caregiver) can properly parent your child and the benefits derived from guided play are very different from the results of children left to fend for themselves electronically or otherwise. Enough with the disclaimers, let's get to the guide.Children who are able to read and understand most of the quest text and chat have very different developmental needs, are entertained differently and are susceptible to greater dangers than preschool age children. Sure, my 3 year old can read Mo Willems and Dr. Seuss, but the quests and chat are just gibberish with familiar words thrown in. My playtime with her is much more relaxing because of this. Children who can read (and feel) insults are more vulnerable.
I do not recommend solo play to start
Teenagers are a different story, but younger children of reading age are very innocent and as parents, we'd really like to keep them that way. Grouping with strangers, whispers and the abomination that is Trade and Barrens chat are things we are unable to disable within the functionality of WoW. Sure, we can temporarily turn off channels, but a curious child left to her own devices is not always going to follow your rules. (Pay no attention to Captain Obvious guffawing.) If you want to allow your child to play alone in an MMO environment, hook her up with a game like ToonTown, that has nothing but canned chat and very small allowances for griefing. ToonTown is a lot of fun, actually, and I highly recommend it for any young child with an ability to use a mouse and basic keyboard functions.
Use two accounts to play
If you have the resources for the entire family to play at the same time, that is, of course, the optimum situation. Two computers with separate accounts should be the minimum for playing with your child because she is going to want to control her own character and play alongside you. Hanging out in vanilla WoW is still pretty easy on the computing power, so a minimum spec system should be sufficient for at least the first 60 levels.
Keep your child's screen in view
Setup your play area so that you can easily see your child's screen while you are playing together. This way you can keep an eye out for rules infractions as well as interactions from strangers. Again, trust is nice and all, but you already know that your child likes to test boundaries. A watchful eye will keep your together time in WoW safer for her and more relaxing for you.
General Chat (except in the Barrens) is probably okay
Seeing people ask questions and get answers will make your child feel more comfortable about not knowing everything that is going on in Azeroth. And any stray colorful phrasings (I assume you'll keep the profanity filter on) and adult references are probably no worse than what she hears on TV or even the playground. You will of course be monitoring the situation and adjusting things accordingly. Otherwise, you may get questions like "Who is Chuck Norris and was he really with Mommy last night?"
Make appointments with your child
Dedicating the time to spend with your child makes the time spent gaming (or whatever) so much more valuable. If you are distracted by other duties, the phone or the TV, your child is not going to feel the same kind of care and attention that a dedicated hour spent only with her will provide.
Level your characters together
Create a character specifically to level with your child and don't play that character otherwise. Choose a different server, if you like, so that you are not bothered by guildies during your dedicated time with your child. I particularly recommend this if you normally play on a PvP server. Being corpse camped is a frustration that your child doesn't need to experience and will reduce the amount of time spent having productive fun.
Have your child lead
Reading the quests (with your help as necessary), determining where to go and what needs to be done is fantastic practice of mandatory life skills. Your child will learn to follow directions, read maps, develop strategies -- all while gaining the self esteem of leading your playsessions.
Teach her to be self sufficient in-game
This is a really big pet peeve of mine. Young children are dependent in real life on parents, teachers, etc. for almost everything and if left to their own devices in Azeroth, will believe that the players around them are there solely to help them, as well. Just today, I was playing Itchee with T
he Spawn and a Human Warlock started following us around, asking for help leveling. When I explained that I was busy playing with my three year old, he asked me if I could help him get some levels when I was done. This showed me that while he was very polite and articulate, he was also very young. I told him to ask his parents for help and he said "Okay." and finally left us alone. It is not other players' responsibility to entertain, guide or even be civil to your child. In Azeroth, we all look the same age and many players just assume laziness or noobishness rather than extreme youth. When you teach your child how to do the fundamental things like shopping, selling, getting around, etc. -- you are not only building her confidence and teaching her personal responsibility, you are also making your child a better player for others to be around. This, in turn, will make sure she will be treated better when you are not around. The translations to real life are obvious.Have fun!
Parenting is hard! We have to keep all this important stuff in mind while our children don't even notice the effort or positive effects. While I believe strongly that we should be mindful about spending our together time nurturing our children and teaching them values, if you aren't having fun doing it, it won't be as valuable for either of you. So steer your child toward in-game activities that are fun for both of you while remaining tolerant of mistakes. It's all about fun.
In my personal opinion, the majority of bad things that are attributed to video games come from parents/caregivers who use games and television to babysit their children because they are too "busy" to vary their children's activities and interact with them properly. Older children and adults also suffer if they were never taught to balance their lives properly and schedule their time intelligently. If, as a conscientious parent, you choose not to expose your children to video games or television, that is your right and there are many parental experts to back you up. However, those of us who decide to use video games as one of the ways we interact with our children are making an informed decision, backed by research and our own experiences. I think that parents who include their children in their hobbies are both nurturing their children and spending their limited playtime wisely. I hope the above guide is helpful for those who feel the same way.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, WoW, Casually







Reader Comments (Page 3 of 5)
Maria Jul 30th 2009 6:42AM
Good point about violence, but there's a catch: Children DO know what's fantasy and what's reality. It's just a fun game for them, but they are sure to know it's not okay to kill or throw rocks at other people in real life. If not, who's the one we should be pointing fingers at, really?
I've seen a semi-documentary about video game violence and there was a 9-year-old boy who played a lot 1st person shooter games (his mom allowed and monitored this and the time the kid spent doing so). So the they wanted to figure out was the kid now trained-to-be-killer because of those violent acts he commited everyday ingame, so he was brought to a shooting training place and he was taught how to shoot some really heavy looking weapon that made a huge noise. The kid was allowed to shoot. One shot, and he didn't want to do it anymore. Later he was crying on his mother's shoulder. The kid was absolutely shocked by the experience. Yet he continued to play violent video games. Kids DO understand the difference. If they didn't, it would be questionable even to tell bed time stories that are not simply true.
Great article!
ZakuraX Jul 30th 2009 4:12PM
My point exactly Maria.
Kids are not as stupid as many people think that they are.
And btw. That was the show named Bullshit.
Malkia Jul 29th 2009 5:13PM
A very good article. Supervise your children in WoW definitely. I know some young children (7 and 10) who play WoW with their mother. I personally grew up before mmos, but my mother played nintendo and supernintendo and playstation and playstation 2 WITH us. She took an interest, she'd make comments about it, she wouldn't help us by the time we got to the supernintendo level, but she'd contribute as we talked about the games we played.
WoW would be a wonderful way to do this in today's world. Gaming with your children can be a very rewarding experience for both the parent and the child, and is generally more productive in terms of critical thinking and communication skills than watching tv.
Graham Ribchester Jul 29th 2009 5:41PM
By a very good article you meant a terrible article.
WoW is NOT a game for 10 year olds. That's why it has a 12+ rating.
Ravdoss Jul 29th 2009 5:25PM
I tried playing WoW with my son in front of me and it just wasn't worth the time. Ability to read is one thing but comprehension is something entirely different. WoW quests are cryptic enough given the font style alone but many quests are just vague enough to drive one batty. Hence, the plethora of websites to clue players in about where to go to find this, that and the other for xyz quest. Were it easier to pickup without so very much hand holding, guiding, protecting, pointing things out, reliving quests for the Nth time (/groan)... I'd be all for it.
However, WoW just isn't all ages friendly unless of course you don't mind doing a good bit of guiding your kid around and explaining what quests mean, how to navigate, setup talents, spells, etc to infinity. A more friendly option with far less potential to frustrate is Free Realms. It's essentially WoW-lite and is littered with inspirations from the king of mmo's which makes it cute. I think I heard a Grell sound in one part of it (copyright infringement?) and there's plenty of other elements clearly lifted from WoW designs. It's simple without being too simple and fun without the type of grind factor most of us with a few years of WoW can attest to.
I started playing it with my son as creating accounts are free without time limit unlike ToonTown. Being that it is a Sony product, buying things is built into the game and parents can whip out the credit card, paypal or game cards to get the "good stuff". While that and a number of things are members only (subscriptions are $5 a month) there's plenty to be enjoyed and explored for free. My son's already gotten levels ahead of me and is pining away for a paid account which I'll get around to sooner or later.
Archimald Jul 29th 2009 5:30PM
ToonTown is an awesome game! I played it from age 9 - 12 before I found WoW. My 3 year old brother can play it even though he can't read. He loves it too.
Dblade Jul 29th 2009 5:31PM
I can't really see this.
If i had a kid, and I wanted to play videogames with him, I'm not going to play with him a game where most of what he sees is gibberish, that he has no even basic idea of the gameplay beyond "do what daddy says," and that you have to police heavily due to player interactions. I'd just rather go out, buy rock band, and let him whale on the drums.
Even then, I really think we place too much emphasis on electronic media, and I'd rather take him to the library, give him a sketch pad, take him to a bowling alley to play bumper bowling, or even just build legos together.
I love gaming as a hobby, but I don't think it's a good idea to encourage it at that young of an age. It's not like he will be deprived from the lack of it, and I don't really want my son to get the idea that fun with daddy indoors means an MMO.
Ravdoss Jul 29th 2009 6:14PM
To each their own :)
As for placing too much emphasis on "electronic media", that's a rather broad reaching term beyond our happy little mmo here. Besides which, there's nothing wrong with the media in general but rather in some cases content and how the media is applied. There's nothing in the posts here to indicate that any parent *solely* uses videogames to interact with their children.
Speaking for my situation alone, not only have I done all the things you mention with my son but I've done them to death +more and videogames to boot. It's all a matter of moderation both in terms of what is being done as well as for how long. There are any number of studies out there to show that children (heck even adults) can benefit from the increased hand eye coordination skills that videogames can develop. So it's not all bad and to be wholly avoided in favor of frisbee tossing at the park... there's room for all types of entertainment and value in it too.
diatkeon Jul 29th 2009 5:47PM
i originally purchased WoW as a teaching device for my then 10yo nephew. he was reading at third grade level, and his parents & teachers were justifiably concerned. after much discussion, he suggested i buy WoW and we could play together. his father played WoW, but wouldn't let my nephew play because there were guns in the game. so, yeah, he was pulling an end-around. fully cognizant of this, i bought the game and two accounts with the understanding that he would have to take reading lessons from me and do homework i assigned, and then WoW would be the "treat." after about two days of playing solo so i could figure the game out, i realized that WoW itself was a huge reading lesson. there would be no way my nephew could navigate this world well without reading. so i changed my tactics and WoW became the reading lesson. i did all quests on my "main" before he visited each week, and then he and i would do the quests on toons we were leveling together. he was in the same room with me. i could see his screen. i could help him with difficult quest text. i kept the parent filter on and eliminated Trade and Gen channels. i developed vocabulary lessons around the quests we would be doing that week. together we raised his reading level to SIXTH grade in less than a year. he doesn't really play WoW much anymore, but his success in reading hasn't slowed. i think the game can be adapted to any age group, but... incidental to the reading lesson, one of the best parts of playing with my nephew was that we were finally on an even playing field. i'm almost fifty. i don't have the energy to run around with him. but i CAN run around with him in the game. we could take on opponents together. find things together. explore the world. learn professions. make money. it made us, in some small way, equals. it erased some of the "age" gap and made us more than auntie/nephew or teacher/pupil; it made us friends.
Flad Jul 29th 2009 8:46PM
Awww, that's super sweet. And that's the only way I would ever recommend anyone play WoW with a pre-teen - supervised and with chat channels off. It can be a valuable learning tool, but I have a feeling most kids who play are not chaperoned by such a responsible adult.
Zasziden Jul 29th 2009 6:01PM
"Otherwise, you may get questions like "Who is Chuck Norris and was he really with Mommy last night?" "
I LOL'd.
Saylah Jul 30th 2009 7:53AM
My son started playing MMOs with me at 9. I got my nephew started at 7. Within months they were both adept typists and in my nephew's case, typing in fuller sentences that before they started gaming. Sure, they use the leet speak they see other use but, they've both grown by playing. Forming groups, joining groups, joining guilds, finding other kids and adults who don't mind having them in groups. It's all good.
mibluvr13 Jul 29th 2009 6:41PM
I don't really understand. How young of children are we talking about here? How stupidly innocent have you kept/think your children are? Stop censoring what your spawn can see because you can't handle the fact that you brought HUMANS into the world and not clay dolls.
impurezero Jul 29th 2009 7:02PM
Yeah...I guess all those generations of parents who have tried to guide thier childrens' development and growth in a healthy direction were just idiots. What those kids really needed was 5 minutes straight of the words "anal" and "faggot" every evening.
mibluvr13 Jul 29th 2009 7:10PM
Children whose parents have sheltered them will have a rude awakening the first time they realize how much different the world is when they finally get a taste of it.
impurezero Jul 30th 2009 4:51PM
Yeah...truly "sheltered" kids will have some issues later on. This isn't about such an extreme stance, though. It's about working them into the world (of Warcraft) in a reasonable way, so that they ARE prepared for the harsher elements when they get to them.
You do realize that there are areas between the extremes of "Shelter the kid from everything!" and "Throw it in with the wolves from day one and let it fend for itself!" right?
elvendude Jul 29th 2009 7:15PM
Thanks Robin. I have to say, I'm not a parent, and I never will be, but I'm actually following this series of your articles with great interest. It's fascinating!
Also, your responses to comments are very excellent. Thanks for a great article. =D
areyouserious? Jul 29th 2009 7:23PM
I have to say that as a general rule (general mind you, of course this doesn't apply to everyone), gamer parents are just as arrogant, reprehensible, and full of themselves as the leet hardcore gamer types they love to make fun of.
Case in point is this gem from the first paragraph:
"Not that that's a threat, after all, we don't have time to do anything about it. But if WoW were a democracy, we'd win."
Aside from the general smugness and flamebait qualities of this preamble, its clear the author knows precious little about how a democracy works. The majority doesn't win. The special interest groups with the most money win, one need only look at contemporary American politics to see endless examples of this fact.
As far as my comments on the article proper, my feeling is that the author is one of the millions of people out there responsible for turning a genre rife with virtual world possibilities into a disposable kid-friendly amusement park. Its too bad that mmo's have veered this far into the main stream; I actually cringed when I saw the title of this article.
I'm a parent myself, and I regularly play both Vanguard and EVE with my twelve year old son, but I don't go out of my way to scream 'hey look at me, I'm a parent' from my blog or whatever. I really can't stand the type of grandstanding behavior that young parents seem to be infected with. I don't know if its a product of our society becoming more voyeuristic as a result of social networking technologies, or if its just the self-centered nature of many 'journalists.' Either way, its well beyond tiresome.
Honestly, most people don't give two shits about your kid, and chances are high that he/she will grow up to be the same average-Joe mmo player that you are, and nothing even remotely approaching remarkable will come of his/her existence. Yes, parents think the universe revolves around their kid, but thankfully not all of them feel the need to crow about it on a gaming web site.
What a self-indulgent piece of narcissistic garbage.
Ugh.
Ryan Jul 29th 2009 7:29PM
Holy shit, marry me please.
Dierna Jul 29th 2009 7:44PM
I recently read a book I think you might like. The Narcissism Epidemic - Living in the Age of Entitlement by Jean Twenge & W. Keith Campbell