Breakfast Topic: Most frustrating non-drop
Unless you are a Ridiculously Lucky Bastard, odds are good that you've gone the length of your time in the game without managing to get a particular drop you really wanted. It's been a running joke in my guild that, try as I might, I can never get Pillar of Ferocity to drop from Anetheron. It didn't once drop in the near-year I ran Hyjal during Burning Crusade, and it sure isn't dropping during our occasional fun runs now. I don't even know why I want it as badly as I do. It wasn't a giant upgrade back in the day given how oddly it was itemized for Druid tanks in comparison to the Wildfury Greatstaff, and it's sure as heck not an upgrade now. But every so often I find myself staring at Atlasloot in celebrated Captain Ahabesque fashion, being driven to the brink of madness over an elusive
A Restoration Shaman pal spent each Hyjal alongside me waiting for a pair of Howling Wind Bracers that never came (let's face it, Hyjal hated us), and our Holy Paladin colleague went more than a year in Karazhan without ever seeing a Shard of the VIrtuous. With gear consolidation in Wrath and generally smaller loot lists all-around, you get the slightly more exciting problem of being more likely to see a drop but losing it to someone else, possibly multiple times (see: Illustration of the Dragon Soul, enormous popularity thereof). Spill, folks; what are your horror stories?
Filed under: Items, Breakfast Topics
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 11 of 11)
Jason Aug 6th 2009 6:32PM
Helms in the BC era. I went through, SSC, TK, Hyjal, BT, ZA, and to Muru in Sunwell tanking in my t4 helm.
Azuredream Aug 6th 2009 6:26PM
I spent 12 months of doing Gruul week in week out for DST. It never dropped. 54 weeks at a boss with 3 drops per run, a reasonably small loot table, and it dropped. I was victim of the loudest cheer I've ever heard over Ventrilo from my disillusioned and pitying guildmates.
Scott Aug 6th 2009 6:27PM
Perhaps not the most compelling story of loot woe here, but here goes. I didn't really get into the game hardcore until LK dropped.
So here I am running Heroic Utgarde Keep on my mage at every opportunity, trying to get Annhylde's Ring off the final boss. The one time I see it drop I'm in a PUG, and a Rogue rolls need on it, wins it, shards it, and hearths.
Riley Aug 6th 2009 6:59PM
Greed, the MH fist weapon from heroic caverns of time, after i decided i wanted to go with cqc, i started running it to get it, i ran it for at least 3 weeks and never saw it drop once
Scott Aug 6th 2009 9:59PM
Warrior:
Ran UP 20 times and never saw the sword until went as a dps tag along - luckily was a bear tank so no need for the sword :)
Shaman (Enhance):
Ran Nexus 3 times = 3 bracer drops
Ran CoS 3 times = 3 fist weapon drops
Ran CoS 1 extra time and comment from tank was "not trying for timed run" we of course do the timed run and I get the mount :)
Warrior never gets first time drops whereas shaman gets them all the time!
Gelinka Aug 6th 2009 11:15PM
Finkles Skinner in UBRS. Only ever dropped once for me in Pre-BC days, and it was ninja'd by a lock who didn't skin but was "thinking of taking it up".
Even soloing it now at 80 the knife hasn't dropped for me.
I'm not a skinner now, but i still really want that blade.
On the upshot, my first UBRS run yielded me my tier 0 Magister's Robe.
wolgan Aug 7th 2009 1:13AM
Wildheart Vest.
I've run UBRS more times than I can count, I completed the entire 0.5 upgrade chain, all done pre-BC when it was an epic quest chain. All I need is the chest, and 2 and a half years and hundreds of runs later... nada...
To add insult to injury, I solo'd it on another character for the first time.. and it dropped. I don't usually take games seriously, but I swear I teared up.
Scritch Aug 6th 2009 11:45PM
I ran Heroic Gundrak for the Hemmoraging Band 208 times before I finally got the drop on my druid. I was so desperate towards the end I started doing 'rituals' before we pulled the last boss. When it finally dropped I screamed like a mad woman and vowed never to set my furry little paws back in that horrid place!
Mogster Aug 7th 2009 4:40AM
A priest in our MC raid, who already had his Tier 1 pants, took the Tier 2 pants off Ragnaros. If I had know he had his Tier 1 I would have asked him to pass; I ended up chewing him out later. I had to wear a blue until they dropped again, which didn't happen for THREE MONTHS.
Sl0th Aug 7th 2009 6:31PM
There have been many items that have never dropped for me on various characters. But I think the one that sticks in my mind is the Halberd of Desolation of High Warlord Naj'entus in Black Temple. That damn thing only dropped once for my old guild. Once. And of course I didn't win it. We spent months killing that damn toga-wearing wanna-be hermit crab of a naga. And it never dropped a second time. Most of my guild's hunters, myself included, resigned ourselves to use the old Arena Season 3 hunter axe for the rest of the expansion. The guild broke up before Sunwell was released, but I'd bet we'd have equally bad luck with Shivering Felspines had we been still raiding.
spartan_e58 Aug 8th 2009 4:48PM
those damn swords in ZF, for the love of god, get one and you'll never see the sister sword.
Irontoof Aug 12th 2009 8:46AM
any 2-handed weapon with more than 200 dps. and when it drops a DK takes it for tanking.
Sialiten Aug 14th 2009 8:10PM
I have horrendous luck with feral tanking weapons as well.
I could NOT get Wildfury OR Pillar to drop for me. Seriously, I was in SSC for 5 months or so...not one damn drop until VERY late BC. I was OTing Mother with Earthwarden. Then, one day, it dropped on a mostly guild run on an offnight and I rolled a 98. Damn straight. I wanted to strangle the guildies who jokingly rolled against me. >_> Oh, not that it mattered since I still needed the Defense on EW to tank the flames....sigh. Oh, and I only saw Pillar once in a Hyjal pug...and I got outrolled by an alt cat druid /wrist.
I was happy this expansion when Origin of Nightmares dropped fairly early on...but no luck since then. I've killed XT nearly every week since Uld dropped. Twisted Visage dropped ONCE....the one kill I wasn't there. Tanking Coliseum with my 213 weapon while all the DPS are rocking 232 (and soon to be 245) weapons? Sucks.