Spiritual Guidance: 12 Reasons why you don't want to play a Priest

You know, I'm normally a huge proponent of my class. Don't get me wrong, I love my Dwarf Priest. There's all these great healing spells we have at our disposal. No one's ever going to turn down a Priest from joining a raid or a guild. I have to admit, we have it pretty easy. I'm used to giving newer players advice about Priests and reasons for selecting that class.
Every once in a while, I get extremely bitter about being a Priest. For those of you that want to roll a Priest, let me introduce some second thoughts.
Healing is thankless. From 1-80, you're going to be expected to heal something. And those players you work with aren't going to care how you do it as long as you do it. After all, you'll be riding their backs as they're blowing up Snobolds or Gnolls or Murlocs or whatever mob that you've been assigned to kill 50 thousand times. It's a fair trade off since you're keeping them up while they're doing most of the work. That is, until you're stuck with 1 mob left and they disband the group leaving you hanging.
Leveling can be a nightmare. You up for some Smite spamming? Because that's what you're in for as you slowly head up the ranks. It's the only real offensive spell you have at your disposal during the early levels. At least, it's not until you pick up Mind Flay at level 20 that you get some extra diversity among spells. Mind Blast? Yeah, every few seconds. Shadow Word: Pain? Eh. Cool. I guess.
Glorified whack-a-mole. When you start healing, you tend to drown out other things and focus exclusively on your role. That's the point. It's a giant mini-game of triage. Actually, I'd even go one step further and say it's team whack-a-mole in a raid setting.
Buff, buff and buff. Power Word: Fortitude, Prayer of Spirit and Prayer of Shadow Protection. The last two are offered by other classes (Warlock's Fel Intelligence and a Paladin aura respectively), but there's no other buff that will stack with Fortitude. Everyone loves Fortitude and we're going to be depended on to hand out our buffs.
Some mind control required. I suppose Priests only have to do this once in their raiding careers. I think it's one too many. Mind control? Really? Do we have to? I've witnessed many Priests struggle with this spell in particular. Some players like myself have healed our entire WoW lives from 1-80 and have no concept of what to do when we commandeer another NPC.
Survivability is a question mark. For one thing, we wear cloth. Yeah, I suppose we have healing spells to compensate for the all the pain we're taking in, but really! Once glance by a mob or 3 and you're effectively down for the count! We're given enough time and mana to either heal or shoot stuff. It's not like we've got plate, leather or mail to help absorb this stuff! When we get punched, boy do we feel it.
First target. Hitting some battlegrounds or PvPing in general? If the opposition finds out you're a Priest, expect to attract some attention. It feels as if though there's a giant, neon, flashing "kill me now" sign floating above your head with an arrow pointing downwards. If you're Holy, good luck. At least with Discipline you're alive a few seconds longer.
Where's the damage? I can't attest to this myself, but maybe some Shadow Priests can weigh in here. It seems our Shadowy brothers and sisters are having a hard time with damage since the 3.2 patch debuted. Are you guys doing competitive damage with other classes and players? I look at various logs and it just doesn't look right. Alas, I'm not a Shadow Priest and can comment no further other.
Chain Heal. The days of Circle of Healing dominance is over. We step aside for our Brain Chain Healing friends, the Shaman. For the time being, Chain Heal is expected to see even more improvements. Don't misunderstand me, I'm not bitter at all. As an aside, between laser beams or pulses of light, I'd lean towards laser beams. It's like phasers versus photon torpedoes.
Confusing stats. Cataclysm isn't here yet. Regeneration has not been reduced down to one exclusive stat. We're stuck with Spirit or mp5. Do I want X mp5 or Y Spirit? What's greater than the other? All this math work required just to figure out how much is worth what! Then you've got to take the spec into account. Are you Holy? Are you Discipline? Because Holy actually cares about Spirit while Discipline doesn't. Get ready for some gear juggling and some decision making on gear when it does drop.
Power Infusion. No caster seems to notice it. It's as if every time I cast Power Infusion someone and ask them if they noticed a DPS increase, they respond with disbelief and confusion. "You power infused me? Really?"
Hang up the plow and the pitch fork. Don't expect to be doing much in the way of farming. I distinctly created an Elemental Shaman and a Ret Paladin just to help with that aspect of the game. It's difficult with the lack of survivability and such. What happens if we get challenged for a node? We may as well just fall over and die!
There you have it folks! Do not roll a Priest! They're far too vulnerable! Try having some fun as a Paladin instead! I hear their leveling game is much more enjoyable. I mean, they do wear plate. Alternatively, try playing a Warlock! True they wear cloth. But they can manhandle most mobs out there and then some. But Priests? Oh man, they're so hard to manage and maintain.
Note: With the exception of Shadow Priest damage (I do feel that it does look a bit low but maybe that's just me), all the points were made in jest.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 9 of 10)
treise Sep 7th 2009 11:31PM
I play a priest, a holy priest, i don't even bother duo speccing her as..well...none of the priest classes really does as much damage as the other dps classes, so why bother? Even in shadow nimrods want you to heal them, and if you don't, whatever wipe they cause thinking, "oh we have a healer who never runs out of mana we can just ignore the aggro meter and pwn away they will keep us healed" ends up blaming you for the wipe anyway.
PvP? ive been pvp'ing with my holy priest for nearly 3 years. The day that bloody patch came out i stopped. I cant hide behind a tree and heal everyone near me, i cant hide under the the eves of the guns in Wg shoot my healbot doesnt even register ANYONE in the BG so why bother? And for those of you lovely people who have mass amounts of sarcasm, keep it to yourself, i dont care, ive fixed my healbot and it still sais im not in a raid. YOU tab target and manage to heal someone before they kill you. You tab everyone BUT hurt people including the bloody enemy. I play both sides, horde and alliance, and ima bloody good healer. I refuse to pug, as every group i get into has an issue with the affor mentioned invulnerable syndrome.
I Just started playing the new game we wont mention here, and their HOLY priests (called clerics in this game) actually get to wear mail.
Wow quickly killed my favorite class, but not only making us the WEEKER healing class, and frailest of toons, but someone else is doing it right, and prettier. WoW is now a secondary game to be sure, as i am a healer in my heart and in my games. The points here though made in jest, are 100% accurate.
volrathy Sep 8th 2009 1:31AM
Im sick of being the most nerfed class in the game
getoff Sep 8th 2009 3:37AM
Matt, please stop this priest column, you obviously fail at it!
treise Sep 8th 2009 7:28PM
To get off...this may not be a subject you like, then please, be an adult and dont read it, you cannot tell people to stop doing something just because you don't like it.
If that was the case you couldnt watch cartoons because most adults don't like them.
xdkyx Sep 8th 2009 6:05AM
the part about farming and leveling up is SO wrong it makes me want to cry.
1. farming - this is the single part where shadow priests ROCK HARD. Dailies from argent tournament, killing cultist and such? Power word shield, renew, pull 8-10 mobs with vamp embrace, use mind sear till dead. You can solo TFA with decent gear.
2. leveling - you have got to be joking. Holy nova? vamp embrace? I soloed 99% of group quests while leveling. I got a rogue, hunter and shadow priest. The priest was BY far the fastest one to level.
Healio Sep 8th 2009 6:29AM
I never had much problem levelling as shadow past 45ish, but vanilla wow was a hell for me and don't expect to be soloing those group quests as easily as pallys. All classes need perseverence to get going, maybe priests a bit more than most... Plan B was always: fear and run away!!!
My worry is what happens after all your hard work to get to 80. With Blizzard's good intentions of wanting people to bring the 'player not the class' and evening out healing they seem to be missing that you need to even out the utility too. Out of two equally matched players why bring a priest over a shaman/druid/pally if they can give equivalent healing but bring more to the raid table? Being able to buy utility off the AH is not the answer for me. The consensus of opinion among non priests seems to be SP is the worst caster dps (which it is but go look at the damage meter) and with all the healing classes levelled out are we going to become the least desirable healer too...? We wear cloth, don't have survivability, don't bring obvious benefits like auras, bloodlust and elementals, or handy druid tree business. Something needs to balance that a little if we're not going to be the straight up gods of healing.
A prayer of strength?
Have our SOR turn into a spirit healer after the 15 second free heal is up so you can res your raid after a wipe?
For SPs i read a suggestion of making VE targettable now that would be useful.
Not really on topic... oh well stopped me from doing any work. Result!
SiN Sep 8th 2009 6:43AM
I agree. Priests can be a really satisfying class and an unbelievably frustrating one! I've always been Shadow, but had to heal a few raids here and there. Disc for bg, arena of course.
Priests as Shadow are easy to level, and quite enjoyable. Especially with levitate, always have fun with that.
For raiding and heroics were pretty average, unless were in a heavy caster group. I wish they left Shadowform adding crit chance as bonus damage or even just added crit chance on.
PvE is enjoyable, I like the rotation. PvP as Shadow is *hammers head against a wall* until your in the top end gear, then it's quite good. It just sucks how other classes can be in running around in pve gear with a bit of PvP and smash face, god forbid we do that :P.
Ben Sep 8th 2009 6:55AM
All priests
Inner Fire helps priest squishiness and increases damage/healing output. Keep up at all times.
Everything else is about learning to use your large arsenal of abilities. If you are repeatedly only using 3-4 different spells, then you aren't getting the most out of your priest.
Healing priests
Most flexible healing class. Good at group or MT heals. Most other classes specialize in one or the other.
Shadow priests
Shadow priest can deal significant damage when properly geared. However, they will always have lower raw damage compared to other dps classes because they provide utility other classes do not. They restore health (Vampiric Embrace) and mana (Vampiric Touch, Hymn of Hope ) to keep a raid going during long encounters. They also increase a raids hit chance (Misery) so that the raid can trade hit rating for +damage/crit/etc. stats.
On my shadow priest, I recently solo'd Onoxia. This would not be possible w/o those utility spells because I would have drained all of my mana to get her to 80%. VT allowed my mana to drain slow enough for me to wage constant dps between Shadowfiend/Dispersion cooldowns. I did not have to heal myself the entire encounter because of VE.
Ben Sep 8th 2009 6:55AM
Inner Fire + PW: Shield + Mind Sear/Holy Nova = Aoe priest. It works quite well in any spec.
Loudfiero Sep 8th 2009 7:22AM
I had no trouble levelling my disc priest currently at 75.
I remember being 48ish earning Timbermaw Hold rep taking on 3 or 4 mobs at a time thanks to a glyph that makes my shield do damage when hit.
Disc is OP but please don't tell the developers that. I can heal a Northrend regular instance and still do 400+ dps to help speed things up. Holy Nova I love you!
shadowQQ Sep 8th 2009 11:51AM
IDK if someone has mentioned this, but itemization on Shadow Gear is really lacking. The tier pieces seem to be loaded with +hit and haste... I've resorted to abandoning shadow focus and sitting at 371 Hit Rating while prioritizing +Crit... even over at Shadowpriest.com's best raid gear available the Holy/Disc T9 is ranked higher than it's Shadow counterpart because SP's scale better with Crit than Haste once you reach ~350 haste which doesn't take long at all with the way gear is itemized these days...
Amapele Sep 8th 2009 12:21PM
Jest or not, I don't think it's really that great that the priest's bi-weekly column (if we're lucky) should've been wasted on this. But maybe that's just me.
And now a defensive stance...
There's so many tangents I could go off on here and I could talk about what I do and don't do but I'm really just kind of bummed to see the number of priests there are out there that don't even like the class they've chosen. Well of COURSE it's going to suck if you don't like healing, why the eff would you chose a priest if you didn't want to do that? Of COURSE your DPS isn't going to be that great, that's what mages and locks are for...why didn't you roll one of those?
Farming? Uhm, Holy Nova...or even better Mind Sear (which granted you can't get until like 76 or something...still an amazing spell). I can DoT up 5-8 Cultists and Mind Sear them to death no problem. Even when I was lower I really didn't have much of a problem farming. One thing that sticks out were the Ogres in Tanaris, I think I got a whole bar of XP simply from farming them for cloth. As for the viability thing, I put up a mean fight in BGs and I dare someone to cross me now in Icecrown (although I will admit Rogues are still the definition of evil). Yea, I'll get knocked down, but at least I made it a bitch for them to get the job done.
It's all in what you want to do in the game really. If you want to pewpew then you really shouldn't be rolling a priest. If you did roll a priest, don't whine because people are expecting you to heal. Yes, people could be nicer in groups (I don't care if people thank me or not but don't respond to my "How does this fight work?" with a "Just keep us healed" unless you want me to watch you die) and yes it seems we've gotten the nerf hammer more times than necessary lately but in general I think priests are awesome! My priest is always the first on a who list because of her name so I'm always getting whispers from newly rolled priests and I'll always leave them with a "Priests are awesome and well worth it in the end, keep at it!".
/2 cents
Oh and as far as Mind Control is concerned, hide yourself and MC a mob . Then send it after an enemy (in my case Horde) and try to tell me that's not fun.
Blue Sep 8th 2009 8:44PM
I've been leveling my Priest alt. through 73, in Shadowform, and, compared to my main Warrior, it's been incredibly easy. I can go into areas 2-3 levels above me, and still solo! True, there is no quick damage dealer in my arsenal, and I wear cloth, but I can bubble, fear, Vampiric Touch (heal while damaging). Unless I'm very unfortunate, or asleep, I can handle three or four mobs at a time. I am dual-specced in Holy, now, but, I've not done many dungeons, and the few I have were low level, where Holy was just overheal--found I could stay in Shadow most of the time...I do need more practice at healing--I could tell immediately that I used way too much mana for heals, and didn't have the right "sense" of when to use them.
As a main tank, I'm absolutely loving this Priest...totally different perspective of the same fights, and a whole new respect for my Guild healers, who've kept me up so many times. I'd recommend doing this to any tank I meet. I bring along extra mana pots to every fight I tank, now...just for my healer!
I also can't wait to do relevant level instances, as Shadow priest. I really don't know how much dps I can expect. The low level encounters were just too fast, for my spells to kick in, before enemies died...
One other aspect, that hasn't been mentioned, in the article...I buff as many players as I can, while leveling...even the ones who are rude enough to kill quest bosses before I can. I often get thanked, and sometimes, people will even buff me back, or hang around to assist. Yesterday, a warrior even bandaged me, after I buffed him--lol!!!
Iratio Sep 8th 2009 3:21PM
Power Infusion = killing mages, lol
See a mage riding the aggro curve skillfully for max DPS? Dead man casting, lol.
Ann Sep 8th 2009 8:01PM
I leveled my priest as holy for quite a while, but bounced back and forth between shadow. Even through most BC dungeons, you can heal as shadow fairly effectively. Leveling is a pain in the pre-30's bracket, but what class isn't? I had a similar "yawn" time with my shammie before storm strike.
As far as priest survivability in BG's, just go Disc. I put in several levels in the 70-80 bracket and outlived multiple horde easily. Sure it takes a while to kill someone, but you should be healing anyways. I found that... so long as I could stay hidden... I could keep even a boomkin, feral druid, or rogue up indefinitely against multiple horde. It was a lot of fun. I didn't feel that it was weak in the slightest.
End game shadow DPS is inferior. I have an arms warrior, a hunter, and an enhance shammie. All of them did far superior DPS in their starter sampling of epic crafted gear and blues than my shadow priest. Since my focus will be healing now, this doesn't bother me terribly. However, it would be nice to get a buff. :D
Fresca Sep 8th 2009 5:14PM
Honestly most of this comes with the territory, and if you weren't aware of this stuff when rolling then you probably won't make it past level 20 anyway.
As for the farming thing, I have a level 80 priest and a level 80 rogue and my priest IS my farming toon. My rogue has no gathering professions and my priest is the skinner, and it is so easy to farm with the priest. Gather stuff up and AoE it down, it probably even goes faster on that toon then it would on the rogue.
There really are way too many defeatist priests out there who would rather cross their arms and go, "I can't do that, I'm a priest" than try to be a little creative with their class. I don't have anything wrong with my priest, leveling was tough, but big deal, I never have trouble getting groups so it's a trade-off.
As for spells and other healing classes, I hate shammies' and their chain heal just as much as the next priest, but we really do have the most diverse arsenal of healing spells at our disposal and if you go dual-spec holy/disc then there is always a raid spot open for you.
Jashin Sep 8th 2009 9:04PM
Yeah, it is kind of bad...to the point I leveled up a shaman in the place of my priest. I pull him out every now and then...then I put him back and remember just how thankless a job priests have.
I wish priests were like Clerics in EQ. Plate wearing, ass kicking healers, with rezz sticks so you can save mana. I wouldn't mind playing one of those again.
Confucious Sep 12th 2009 1:11PM
I realize this was mostly a rant... but...
Priests are by far the easiest class to level (well, between them and a warlock).
Step 1) Go shadow - Make a good build for it too: EJ has some good stuff ;)
Step 2) VT- SW:P - VE
Step 3) Switch Targets
Step 4) Go to Step 2
You may need to throw in a DP or bubble every now and then... but... 2 globals... is not bad. And that VE healing usually makes up for ANY damage the mobs will do to you... the only real exception to this (besides elites /eyeroll) is the freaking Saronite Miners in icecrown... they hit like a bitch.
anne.visions Sep 13th 2009 2:07AM
Love it....my only input is POM is fabulous.....in pvp as a dis priest you can always count on pissing somebody off when they can't kill you, or at least it takes 15 mins. Yes it takes dedication to level a priest (try leveling as holy....the WHOLE way). Not too many ppl can do that! My first 80 was a priest, and while I have come to like other classes better, my heart is with the priest!
rainny Sep 15th 2009 11:17AM
Hehehe.... you might be public enemy #1 in a battleground, but DAMN can you make a difference! May it's because I usually play in premades, but, I find (disc) Priest to be the most fun class to PVP with by far. So many interesting things to do! You get focus fired because you're DANGEROUS.
And who says a priest can just heal? Off the top of my heal, I spend a lot of time doing non-healing things, like fearing or manaburning or MCing someone (usually an annoying healer) on the other team just to remove them from the fray - or send them over an edge/cliff.
I realize the comment was in jest but I had to respond - I don't do arena, but battleground priest is the shit!