Conclusions from the WoW.com faction transfer survey

The other questions were a little hairier -- I tried to ask people not to answer if they didn't fit the criteria for each question, and there's no way to tell for sure that's what happened. Also, lots of people wanted to see the answers without voting, and unfortunately, our voting system doesn't allow a clear way to do that (I have since checked with our tech guys, who say that the solution we came up with, voting without choosing an answer, did not affect the poll). But after the break, we can try to suss some conclusions out of the data anyway.


Similarly, this question's answers don't add up -- 3210 people answered the first question, and 2735 answered the second, and clearly both of those numbers are higher than the amount of people who said they transferred factions at the beginning, not to mention higher than the number of people who said they transferred to each corresponding side (though it is interesting to note that the two numbers of total answers in these two questions show a similar ratio to the question above -- the ratio here is about 54/46, still in favor of Horde).
But there is still something interesting going on here: Blood Elves and Humans are the highest choice, and from what we've heard anecdotally, those are in fact the two classes that the majority of people have transferred to in both factions. Even if people were just voting for the faction they liked the best, the results here are pretty interesting. We can't call these conclusive numbers at all, obviously, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Blood Elves and Humans were really the most popular races being transferred to on either side.
But there is still something interesting going on here: Blood Elves and Humans are the highest choice, and from what we've heard anecdotally, those are in fact the two classes that the majority of people have transferred to in both factions. Even if people were just voting for the faction they liked the best, the results here are pretty interesting. We can't call these conclusive numbers at all, obviously, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Blood Elves and Humans were really the most popular races being transferred to on either side.

Finally, this question is a little more legit -- the total answers of 7027 lines up much closer (relatively, of course -- I wouldn't trust my life on it) to the 7993 people above who said that they hadn't transferred yet. And perhaps most interesting, the number here is actually higher than the percentage of people who have transferred. It's probably a fair conclusion, keeping in mind that this is a completely unofficial and unscientific poll, to say that we'll see another, even larger round of transfers when players are allowed to transfer to the new Cataclysm races. It still won't be a majority of the player base by any means, but from these numbers, we can expect it to be slightly larger than the transfer totals we saw last week.
Then again, people are projecting into the future here -- by the time Cataclysm actually comes around, people will probably want to roll the new classes anyway, and if they've leveled a Worgen or Goblin up before Blizzard lets them transfer, they'll probably be less likely to actually transfer another character. So many people who say now that they will transfer probably won't anyway.
At any rate, no matter what the numbers, we can make a few solid conclusions:
Then again, people are projecting into the future here -- by the time Cataclysm actually comes around, people will probably want to roll the new classes anyway, and if they've leveled a Worgen or Goblin up before Blizzard lets them transfer, they'll probably be less likely to actually transfer another character. So many people who say now that they will transfer probably won't anyway.
At any rate, no matter what the numbers, we can make a few solid conclusions:
- Blizzard made a truckload of money off of the faction transfer service last week, and the service has definitely justified its existence.
- While the majority of players isn't interested in using the service, there is a nice chunk of the playerbase that's already jumped ship, and I think we can reasonably put that percentage at over 10%, if not higher.
- As for where players are transferring, the exact numbers are still unclear, but it's pretty reasonable to assume that Alliance to Horde is winning out, even if it's just by a few percentage points.
- And we haven't heard the last of this faction transfer service -- Blizzard can expect another burst of transfers, possibly bigger than the last, when they open up the new races after the expansion.
Filed under: Horde, Alliance, Polls, Realm Status, Virtual selves, Odds and ends, Blizzard, Cataclysm
Patch 5.4 patch notes
Virtual Realms feature revealed
The Proving Grounds are coming
The latest patch 5.4 news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 3)
Joseph Sep 10th 2009 9:26AM
does this mean that Blizzard gained atleast 55.000 USD since the release of this new service?
Way to go Blizzard.
BigBadGooz Sep 10th 2009 9:28AM
it's hard to track how much money blizz got from the service because how many of you have 2 characters...3 chracters....8? and how many people transfered one toon or multiple toons. i dont think blizz will tell either.
Retropally Sep 10th 2009 9:39AM
The reason i'm so unsure about this is because I have alts all on the same faction, to be suddenly split from their proffesions would be a big game changer for me.
Rin Sep 10th 2009 9:39AM
Once Cataclysm drops you sure as hell better believe I'm making my Druid a troll. But until then I'll sit back and wait.
Just a matter of time...
jamestaitdunbar Sep 10th 2009 9:41AM
That would be 1.7 million gross revenue not 1.7 million net profit.
theRaptor Sep 10th 2009 9:48AM
I am never hiring you guys as business analysts.
Do you know how much faction transfer costs to implement? Do you know how much extra support staff needed to be retained to support the service? Do you know how many people cancelled accounts because they disagreed with the new feature? Do you know how much money was lost due to people not buying a second account to RaF a cross faction character? What was the opportunity cost of developing this feature instead of something more player pleasing?
Blizzard made around 1.7 million USD GROSS according to your estimates. What they made NET (aka the profits) can not be estimated without answering the above questions.
Blacksabre Sep 10th 2009 10:09AM
Uh, Raptor, if you missed the misplaced decimal point in Schramm's post, it's fairly easy to predict no one is gonna hire you as a cost/benefit analyst. Decimal points are meat, expense estimates are salad.
Sadly, you drew the Olive Garden straw.
sprout_daddy Sep 10th 2009 12:32PM
"Sadly, you drew the Olive Garden straw."
I have never heard this expression before, but am now in love with it. Thank you.
theRaptor Sep 10th 2009 9:41PM
I never offered a financial analysis. I also skimmed the post and stopped reading when I saw "net profit".
gari.rogers Sep 10th 2009 9:52AM
I would bet the Belf numbers are skewed because you can't make Tauren Pallys yet. Some of it may just be the 'pretty race' thing, but if I'd had the option to Xfer my Human Pally to a Tauren Pally that's the way I would have gone. Similiarly anyone xfering a Shammy from Horde to Ally would have one choice of race.
Now... for my DK, yeah, I went Nelf to Belf so that it'd be a smaller cosmetic change.
Madski Sep 10th 2009 9:56AM
Figures will be allot higher also when EU gets the ability to change their faction.
Maelmordha Sep 10th 2009 10:07AM
Anyone think they will really let you transfer to a worgen or goblin immediately? I'm thinking some kind of forced waiting period until you have leveled one from the start, much like the initial DK restrictions. Blizz wants people to experience the new content, not just faceroll past it.
Zrob Sep 10th 2009 10:17AM
I'm not sure that this is the case here.
Say I'm a Troll Mage at 80 and cataclysm hits.
Whether I switch to Goblin or Stay troll or even switch to Undeaad on day one isn't that much of a difference. I'm still seeing the 80-85 content.
You're also almost certainly taking yourself out of the running for server first (is their that or is it only ?) because you're gonna find yourself locked down for a few hours while the transfer takes place.
People will see the new 1-60 content and Blizzard knows they will. In the end there's only so many server firsts for race and class. I just can't see that catering to or diminishing that crowd will be such a huge priorty to Blizzard.
Hasteur Sep 10th 2009 10:18AM
If that is the case an estimate of what we will have to do (or wait for) would be swell as I would gladly let the "First" achievements go by the wayside (and etc) before I retcon my warlock
Zrob Sep 10th 2009 10:20AM
Should read
"You're also almost certainly taking yourself out of the running for server first -class- (is their that or is it only -race/class-?) because you're gonna find yourself locked down for a few hours while the transfer takes place."
sprout_daddy Sep 10th 2009 12:40PM
I'd be shocked if there wasn't a sixty-day moratorium on transfer to the new races once Cataclysm hits - I think Blizzard will want the first 85 goblins and worgen to start as level 1 goblins and worgen, especially since a 1 to 68 leveling experience in cataclysm is supposed to be so different.
Sage Sep 10th 2009 10:30AM
It is only natural for the more timid elements to jump ship.
Goodk4t Sep 10th 2009 11:47AM
Let's analyze the results, shall we?
A vast majority of the players went from Alliance to Horde, that I would say it's mainly because in most battlegroups Alliance fails to win BGs and people wanna be on the winning team.
Also, most of these players went Blood Elf. Maybe because they like to be the "pretty boy" but in fact, I really think it's because they wanna be the Paladin boy.
It becomes easy to conclude why
1. Blizzard gave Taurens Paladin : it becomes tiresome to see so many blood elves around, specially because they do not fit the horde at all. I am sure I am not the only one who 'd like to see more taurens or trolls.
2. Blizzard gave Alliance Worgen : how much you wanna bet alliance population will grow a lot in next expansion? Maybe alliance start to win BGs in your battlegroup. ;)
Blistter Sep 10th 2009 12:27PM
Love it when Alliance transfers call Blood Lust Heroism. :)
/takes under wing
Almoderate Sep 10th 2009 12:46PM
The obvious conclusion of this poll:
People are incapable of following simple instructions. =P