Spiritual Guidance: Can Prayer of Mending be improved?

Every week (usually), Spiritual Guidance will offer practical insight for priests of the holy profession. Your host is Matt Low, the grand poobah of World of Matticus and a founder of No Stock UI, a UI and addons blog for WoW. Can the relationship between Prayer of Mending and Power Word: Shield be improved any further?
I received an email from a distraught yet dedicated Discipline priest the other day. He's a raiding priest, first of all. So what was he upset over? It's about the interactions between our Power Word: Shield and Prayer of Mending. There are times where a quick PoM hit will land on a shielded player which results in it fading off.
Why?
Well because the shield has to expire first before the PoM bouncing effect occurs. It's not so bad with Holy priests because the strength of their shields are no match for Discipline shields. It does suck though since the shield just has to wear off before the PoM can shoot off to someone else. Sometimes time just runs out.
For Disc Priests, Prayer of Mending is the best instant healing spell we have at our disposal. For Holy Priests, that award is going to go to Circle of Healing but Prayer of Mending isn't that far behind either. Prayer of Mending just seems to like jumping to players with low health. Coincidentally, I like to pop a shield on such players.
So on certain fights where priests are required to haul butt and heal as many people as much as possible, Disc priests are at a severe disadvantage. I guess the better term would be "balanced". To be fair, Disc Priests have to lose out somewhere. They take a hit in the group healing department with no access to Circle of Healing and a possibly less potent Prayer of Healing. It has to be done this way though other wise Discipline would just straight up be the healing spec. Could you imagine if Discipline priests had the group healing power that Holy has? As much as I'd love that myself personally, I know that even the thought of that is just too much to ask for.
Disc healing is meant for tank healing. It's designed to be satisfactory when it comes to group healing. Can it be done better without having to resort to something as drastic as inheriting Holy talents?
My fellow priest thinks so. Let me share with you some of his suggestions.
Prayer of Mending does not bounce to any shielded targets:
That would be a good idea unless you're a shield firing Disc priest. This would result in half the raid ineligible for PoM ticks assuming you're able to cycle and maintain shields on all of them. It seems too narrow of a solution in the sense that a priest can "control" who PoM can or cannot hit. I'm sure it would be possible to shield and then PoM that person deliberately. The idea here is that after PoM travels once, it is not able to hit a shielded person. Something tells me that this might be too complicated to implement.
Prayer of Mending bounces to a shielded target, registers an absorbed hit and the heal effect is activated before being fired off again.
This would be the most ideal solution to me personally. A PoM tick hits an already shielded player like a tank. They take a hit which doesn't break the shield but the absorption impact triggers the healing ability from Prayer of Mending before it shoots off elsewhere. Essentially what happens here is that the priority is reversed. Right now, the shield has to break before PoM does its thing. If this was in the game, then it wouldn't matter if a player was shielded or not. This would represent a huge advantage. Why? Because it means shielding a player with low health will not penalize either the player or the priest. A wounded player could get both PoM and a shield on them and then (don't faint now) run into a fire to trigger the effect without taking any damage since the shield could withstand it. Not only that, PoM would trigger healing the player with a shield still active! That would help tremendously in intensive group healing encounters.
Shield a PoMed target which causes Prayer of Mending to bounce off.
Here's one of the more intriguing solutions. If a PoMed player gets a shield on them, it forces the PoM effect to take place. How is this useful? In case PoM lands on a ranged player who isn't likely to take any damage, you can "shake" the prayer off of them by slapping on a shield. In essence, you'd be able to push it along.
This is all just wishful thinking. Maybe one day they'll make a glyph that can accomplish one of these effects or something. Sometimes I feel that Disc priests could use a slight bump in group healing ability but then I remember they're not supposed to be an all-star in that department. Perhaps I just need to get faster with shielding my group before an AoE hits.
Unmentioned Priest changes
There were a few things recently discovered for Priests that weren't in with the original version of the patch notes.
For one, Inspiration can now be triggered by Prayer of Mending if it manages to be a critical heal. Slight overall buff to both healing Priests. Nothing too major here. It's a very soft-ish type buff but we'll take it all the same.
Silence has been changed and made more potent. In addition to preventing a target from casting any spells for 5 seconds, it can now interrupt non-player spells for 3 seconds. This feels like more of a raiding or a PvE addition. Most bosses can't be silenced or preventing from dishing out spells. Shadow priests now have a method by which they can participate in interrupting casters.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Save Oct 5th 2009 4:09PM
I think it should be louder.
Ivokk Oct 5th 2009 4:34PM
I would make it so it increases the potency of Divine Shield when the target is hit, then bounces off with a maximum of one increment per shield and consuming a charge.
Ivokk Oct 5th 2009 4:34PM
On reconsideration this would cause balance problems. Adding more absorption points to an already strong shield... never mind my suggestion, I was just brain-storming.
Hansbo Oct 6th 2009 1:17AM
You hear that sound? That is the sound of mana efficiency!
mijody1 Oct 5th 2009 4:17PM
If a priest doesn't notice his PoM staying on a target for longer than 10 seconds... that priest isn't doing his job.
Should always recast it on MT if its not bouncin around like a bat out of hell, even IF it is on the OT with 4 charges.. its one of the cheapest mana cost spells ever for healing 7-9k each heal (5 times nonetheless) so should be spammed on MT if its not moving >_>
and if yer wondering --> Forticator (Shattered Hand - US)
Celeane Oct 5th 2009 4:28PM
Agreed-recast on tank ASAP if it's not bouncing.
Candina@WH Oct 5th 2009 4:36PM
Agreed.
I expect my PoM to bounce to a sheilded melee player. it is a safety valve if the sheild fades or breaks.
I recast PoM basically on or near the cooldown, regardless. between the Glyphed PW:S, renew and PoM you can keep a continious stream of healing on the main tank. And keep your options open for Pennance and PoH.
Secondly, on tanks you can't/shouldn't sheild (I'm looking at you Pallys), PoM on the cooldown is a necessity.
becky Oct 5th 2009 4:53PM
you can shield a pally tank no matter what as long as they are half decent. i'm a disc preist and my fav tank is a pally.
Heilig Oct 5th 2009 5:00PM
ANY tank that tells you not to shield them should be benched.
Eskarel Oct 5th 2009 6:01PM
@Candina
Since Divine Plea and Guarded by the Light were introduced, Pally tanks are a lot less dependent on Spiritual attunement. So much so that most tankadins only take on point in SA and almost no one uses the glyph.
That's not to say that healing isn't a part of our mana return, or that we don't have occasional problems on some kinds of fights(skadi being a specific example from my experience) where we have to burn a lot of mana but the fights aren't continuous enough for DP to stay up, but I know that as a tankadin I very rarely have any mana issues on boss fights, and mine are a lot easier to deal with than a healer going OOM or another raid member dieing because the healer had to focus on me when they didn't need to.
Wyred Oct 6th 2009 2:41AM
Once downloaded PoM tracker so I could know when exactly I should be refreshing PoM, but found no advantage over just bouncing one off the tank every cd. TBH, I don't see this as a spell that needs improving. One of the best things us priests have, with or without disc shields in the mix.
vern Oct 5th 2009 4:17PM
The spell is already nice you know ?
I would keep the CD and the output the same, but I would just improve the AI of the spell.
Don't jump to a shielded player and don't overwrite or let overwrite another POM.
maybe tweak the 30s to 40s too: save on mana with a later expire.
soul Oct 5th 2009 4:25PM
PoM is fine.
raukus Oct 5th 2009 4:31PM
This is a skill issue, not a mechanics issue. Disc priests have to know when and how to use PoM for it to regularly get it's maximum effect. Don't toss out a PoM after shielding half the raid, unless you only really care about the healing done to your first target. If you want your PoM to bounce like crazy, use it with renews.
Dharmabhum Oct 5th 2009 4:30PM
I'd be inclined to disagree with all of your suggestions Matt. I know its not ideal that it sticks to a shielded player, but is it really that bad? The mechanic works fine IMHO.
The biggest one is when a shield registers an absorb and jumps off, triggering the PoM heal and leaving the shield if its still got some power left on it. That would really mess up some of my good tank healing methods. As it stands, a combo of PW:Shield/PoM/Renew can let me leave a tank for a few seconds to as much as 8-10 seconds, knowing I've got the Shield to eat first, then an extra heal, plus a likely Aegis proc, and finally a few Renew ticks maybe. I just think that the way it works now is fine. If it sticks on a shielded player for more than 10 seconds, just recast anyway. Yea you might not get the most out of it, but its already an efficient spell anyhow so I don't mind recasting.
I guess I just like it the way it is.
elvendude Oct 5th 2009 9:09PM
Yes, this. I very commonly stack a PoM behind a shield. Once it eats the shield, the tanks is still full for another tick. =)
Bravofox Oct 6th 2009 1:51PM
@ Dharma
That is the exact method that I use on a tank when I am disc. I for one appreciate the spell for those very same reasons.
Cyanea Oct 5th 2009 4:32PM
PoM is annoying in Malygos.
I once went in on my priest in a group with a large number of pugs. The other two healers? Priests.
The pinging of the prayer during the Vortex made me have to turn my speakers down when that started.
To stay on topic, I definately advocate the solution where it'll bounce off the party member when they take a hit, even if their shield absorbs the whole thing.
Theyas Oct 5th 2009 4:33PM
Improving an already awesome spell would melt the World of Warcraft as we know it, and everything would cease to exist from the overwhelming amount of AWESOME bouncing around.
BING!
Doellman Oct 6th 2009 7:36AM
Lol brilliant! On a more serious note, I think PoM is just fine :-D