Spiritual Guidance: Can Prayer of Mending be improved?

Every week (usually), Spiritual Guidance will offer practical insight for priests of the holy profession. Your host is Matt Low, the grand poobah of World of Matticus and a founder of No Stock UI, a UI and addons blog for WoW. Can the relationship between Prayer of Mending and Power Word: Shield be improved any further?
I received an email from a distraught yet dedicated Discipline priest the other day. He's a raiding priest, first of all. So what was he upset over? It's about the interactions between our Power Word: Shield and Prayer of Mending. There are times where a quick PoM hit will land on a shielded player which results in it fading off.
Why?
Well because the shield has to expire first before the PoM bouncing effect occurs. It's not so bad with Holy priests because the strength of their shields are no match for Discipline shields. It does suck though since the shield just has to wear off before the PoM can shoot off to someone else. Sometimes time just runs out.
For Disc Priests, Prayer of Mending is the best instant healing spell we have at our disposal. For Holy Priests, that award is going to go to Circle of Healing but Prayer of Mending isn't that far behind either. Prayer of Mending just seems to like jumping to players with low health. Coincidentally, I like to pop a shield on such players.
So on certain fights where priests are required to haul butt and heal as many people as much as possible, Disc priests are at a severe disadvantage. I guess the better term would be "balanced". To be fair, Disc Priests have to lose out somewhere. They take a hit in the group healing department with no access to Circle of Healing and a possibly less potent Prayer of Healing. It has to be done this way though other wise Discipline would just straight up be the healing spec. Could you imagine if Discipline priests had the group healing power that Holy has? As much as I'd love that myself personally, I know that even the thought of that is just too much to ask for.
Disc healing is meant for tank healing. It's designed to be satisfactory when it comes to group healing. Can it be done better without having to resort to something as drastic as inheriting Holy talents?
My fellow priest thinks so. Let me share with you some of his suggestions.
Prayer of Mending does not bounce to any shielded targets:
That would be a good idea unless you're a shield firing Disc priest. This would result in half the raid ineligible for PoM ticks assuming you're able to cycle and maintain shields on all of them. It seems too narrow of a solution in the sense that a priest can "control" who PoM can or cannot hit. I'm sure it would be possible to shield and then PoM that person deliberately. The idea here is that after PoM travels once, it is not able to hit a shielded person. Something tells me that this might be too complicated to implement.
Prayer of Mending bounces to a shielded target, registers an absorbed hit and the heal effect is activated before being fired off again.
This would be the most ideal solution to me personally. A PoM tick hits an already shielded player like a tank. They take a hit which doesn't break the shield but the absorption impact triggers the healing ability from Prayer of Mending before it shoots off elsewhere. Essentially what happens here is that the priority is reversed. Right now, the shield has to break before PoM does its thing. If this was in the game, then it wouldn't matter if a player was shielded or not. This would represent a huge advantage. Why? Because it means shielding a player with low health will not penalize either the player or the priest. A wounded player could get both PoM and a shield on them and then (don't faint now) run into a fire to trigger the effect without taking any damage since the shield could withstand it. Not only that, PoM would trigger healing the player with a shield still active! That would help tremendously in intensive group healing encounters.
Shield a PoMed target which causes Prayer of Mending to bounce off.
Here's one of the more intriguing solutions. If a PoMed player gets a shield on them, it forces the PoM effect to take place. How is this useful? In case PoM lands on a ranged player who isn't likely to take any damage, you can "shake" the prayer off of them by slapping on a shield. In essence, you'd be able to push it along.
This is all just wishful thinking. Maybe one day they'll make a glyph that can accomplish one of these effects or something. Sometimes I feel that Disc priests could use a slight bump in group healing ability but then I remember they're not supposed to be an all-star in that department. Perhaps I just need to get faster with shielding my group before an AoE hits.
Unmentioned Priest changes
There were a few things recently discovered for Priests that weren't in with the original version of the patch notes.
For one, Inspiration can now be triggered by Prayer of Mending if it manages to be a critical heal. Slight overall buff to both healing Priests. Nothing too major here. It's a very soft-ish type buff but we'll take it all the same.
Silence has been changed and made more potent. In addition to preventing a target from casting any spells for 5 seconds, it can now interrupt non-player spells for 3 seconds. This feels like more of a raiding or a PvE addition. Most bosses can't be silenced or preventing from dishing out spells. Shadow priests now have a method by which they can participate in interrupting casters.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 3)
vern Oct 5th 2009 4:34PM
Also all priests need to use this mod: Prayer of Mending Tracker.
This is the holy Graal of POM healing!
Curse URL:
http://wow.curse.com/downloads/wow-addons/details/prayer-of-mending-tracker.aspx
Amapele Oct 5th 2009 4:44PM
Or save some memory and just use raid frames that track it for you (x-perl)
vern Oct 5th 2009 4:56PM
My group has between 2 and 4 healing priests. I have better things to do than guess if my POM expired or not. That mod does it for me and it even does it with a sound instead than visually.
elvendude Oct 5th 2009 9:10PM
God I love that addon. Very small memory footprint, too.
Pharoah Oct 5th 2009 4:35PM
I usually don't write on here but here goes.
I used to be all about the Prayer of Healing and Circle of Healing through naxx and Ulduar. It usually was 50-60% of my heals, the rest being flash/greater heal, binding heal, and on the rare occasion PoM.
When I got the tier 7, 2-peice set bonus of PoM jumping an extra time I though..." oh wow now it will hit one more time on the cyclone on EoE phase 1." I really didn't think of it as a major spell to use.
Now that I am raiding ToC 10 and 25 man weekly and now have gotten the tier 9 2-peice bonus I thought to myself as I struggled through healing ToC, well I should throw in PoM and see how it does. So seeing it only costs less that 500 mana I thought why not.
So after 2 weeks of throwing it in the mix, it is now my favorite spell. For example, I was running heroic TOC 10 man this morning, for the northrend beasts it was 47% of my heals, thats right 47%. And no I wasn't barely healing, i had 3,700 hps, with a 20% overheal.
So long story short, I understand where disc priests are coming from, but for a raiding holy priest PoM does not need any changes.
Dharmabhum Oct 6th 2009 9:34AM
To be fair, this is the opinion of one disc priest, the author. I think the majority of comments here, whether they be a disc priest in disagreement or a holy priest (like you) who likes the spell as is, are not of the opinion that this spell needs changing.
(mostly) love you Matt, but thank you interwebz for letting me disagree with you wholeheartedly.
Blizz, please don't break a great and functioning spell.
Jon Do Oct 5th 2009 4:38PM
"Disc healing is meant for tank healing."
Has Blizz said this? I've always gone Holy and was under the impression that while Disc was a very good single-target raid healing build, that Disc was actually meant as a PvP healing spec with survivability.
As for PoM --
If your PoM bounces to a shielded toon that's just the breaks; it's completely out of your control.
On the other hand, if you're casting PoM onto a shielded toon, then you're taking your chances as to whether the PoM will bounce or expire.
I don't think it's worth Blizzard design and development time to bother with PoM unless they're doing an overall class review.
Phaea Oct 5th 2009 10:44PM
No, Blizzard did not say that Disc is meant for tank healing. Nor did Blizzard say Disc is only meant for PVP. Blizzard would never come out and say that one class and/or spec is only meant to do a certain thing, because no tree is ever ACTUALLY meant to be only PVE or PVP. Talents are customizable enough that you can go either way. Disc may have been used for PVP in the past, but welcome to WOTLK where Disc is perfectly viable for PVE healing, and does a great job of it at that.
Arkkangel Oct 8th 2009 8:21AM
"Disc healing is meant for tank healing."
This should have said, "Disc is great for tank healing but also mitigates a lot of raid damage if your priest plays smart."
On a typical TOC 25 run I'll throw over 1000 PW:S. When you do the math that accounts for a gigantic amount of damage your other healers don't have to heal. When tracking mitigation in with other total healing, (when are they gonna fix recount to do this?) most of the time I finish on top of total output and have the lowest % overheal. A good Disc priest knows that his/her job is to buy the AoE healers time to respond. Shielding does just that.
thebvp Oct 5th 2009 4:40PM
While it's great for the job, I'm not sure I agree that disc is meant exclusively for tank healing.
My guild has increasingly been running with two disc priests- one for the tank group and another for the raid. Having one just sit there and spam bubbles on aoe intensive fights (tantrums on XT, Ignis, Twink Valks, etc) makes life a lot easier for our raid healers.
On Twin Valks, especially, the amount of damage absorbed is just insane.
Az Oct 5th 2009 4:42PM
ProM is already one of the most powerful spells in the Priest arsenal (especially for Holy). There's almost no reason to keep it on CD. Mana is almost infinite (and it's a cheap spell), and in heavy constant AoE fights, it's consumed before the CD is up. Just keep casting it.
venomslife Oct 5th 2009 10:08PM
could anyone tell me exactly how to change, or disable just the sound of prayer of mending? it is the only reason i never play with the sound on in my game unless its to listen to some cool speech
Darkener Oct 5th 2009 6:31PM
Honestly, I don't see this as a big Disc shield problem. I think Disc priests are just noticing it more now that shields got so buffed. All healing priests have a problem with PoM getting stuck for whatever reason. It's very frustrating, but it is a balance to a very powerful "fire and forget" aoe heal.
How about the 30 seconds don't count while Weakened Soul or Divine Aegis buffs are present.
Here's my favorite. Maybe even make it a talented or Glyphed "Improved Prayer of Mending". If PoM doesn't proc after 30 seconds it returns to the ORIGINAL target and consumes a charge. This has the dual effect of "unsticking" a charge and giving preference to the original target.
Sayas Oct 5th 2009 5:02PM
I think PoM is just fine as is. Like someone else suggested I use PoM+renew and only shield the tank if it pops too soon in the CD cycle or things are going south in a hurry. Having the PoM bounced "wasted" doesn't bother me at all because it just means I'm ahead of the curve.
Aardin Oct 5th 2009 5:26PM
I actually like it the way it is now.
In the event that I am using PoM as an 'instant heal' on someone other than the tank, I throw it out, wait for the 'bounce', and once gone, throw up a PW:S with glyph for my other 'instant cast'.
If at this point the PoM bounces back to the shielded player (not uncommon), I usually have 3-4 seconds left before the spell CD is up. If the player in question is taking enough damage to burst my shield, and get the PoM to bounce again before the CD is up... the bounce serves as a *fantastic* audible telling me that I may need to send the next CD that direction again, and make more adjustments to keep that player up.
If I don't hear PoM bouncing ... well.. I do what comes naturally, and dump it back in on my MT.
Sure... most of the proposals in the article would up my numbers on the meters... but if I were worried about the meters, I'd probably be looking at a spec / class other than a Discipline Priest.
Carbon Oct 6th 2009 11:12AM
Discipline is the proactive healing choice for priests. Holy is the reactive. I do find it annoying when the PoM goes awry, but otherwise its a perfectly fine mechanic. If only all range classes had a tool to send an errant PoM on its way like a good SW:D. So many times it bounces immediately from the tank back to me. I need to pay better attention to it, most of the time I let it slip off into uselessness (either not on a tank or on a ranged DPS not taking damage) because I'm busy with other things.
Gerik Oct 5th 2009 5:27PM
This article is silly. Can't we think of better things to complain about?
Noscy Oct 5th 2009 6:19PM
CoH?
rawrawrawr Oct 5th 2009 10:17PM
I want to complain about lack of viability for a AoE DPS Holy Nova build. There should totally be a talent in Holy to increase our crit chance with the damage portion of Holy Nova if both feet are off the ground at the time of casting.
Also, i miss Wand Specialization.
Zo? Oct 5th 2009 5:55PM
This. There's not a goddamn thing wrong with this spell, so leave it alone. I'm a disc priest myself. It's fine. We're not holy priests, we're not supposed to have as easy a time passing the love around as they do. If you want to be able to use Prayer of Mending without worrying about it fizzling out behind a shield? Spec holy. Disc is good enough on its own.