Dodge =/= mitigation. Dodge=avoidance, mitigation=armor/block.

Yes, I am sitting really high currently with my defense rating on my tankadin, and I have nothing gemmed/enchanted for defense right now. That does not mean that I would not like a tank weapon. I would love to see something perhaps with less defense and perhaps more armor on it...something more like Crusader's Glory is. Meh, until I get that to drop on heroic 10 ToC or one of the tribute weapons I will stick with my burnished Quel, looks a ton better then many of the other weapons out there, does the job, proc is up like 80% of the time, and not really that many weapons better for a tankadin at this moment.

Again with the non tanks speaking as if they understand ICC Radiance. It's been explained enough I thought folks would understand. You're basically saying casters have enough SP, so they shouldn't get a reward.

First off, this is from a 5 man. Most people who would really want a weapon of this ilevel are casual, who I assure you are unaware of what Mitigation, EH, and Avoidance are. Even with high Avoidance, its from a 5 man, and tanking 5 mans is EZsauce with or without high ilevel gear.

It sucks every class/spec couldn't get served, but again it's from a 5 man that drops a metric asston of epics. I assume it would be pretty easy to find an alternative.