They both have millions of users across the world. They both have made and broken friendships and relationships, and they both have raised millions if not billions of dollars for their respective companies. And chances are that they're both so popular even your grandma knows about them. Gamasutra has written
an interesting post comparing both World of Warcraft and Facebook of all things, and they say that the two are more alike than you might think: both enable you to create an identity, and use that identity to interact with others, and both give you a wide variety of options to do so (in
WoW, you can slay dragons together, and on Facebook, you can tag pictures or post on walls). Gamasutra wants to get to the center of where exactly the interactivity lies, and in doing so, figure out
what makes Warcraft a game, and Facebook a network.
One major difference is in the interface -- obviously,
WoW is wrapped in a fantasy world, so that in between all of the socializing, you're also fighting the Scourge or the Burning Crusade.
Facebook has games, but it doesn't have that overarching narrative.
WoW also
rewards group teamwork and coordination, while Facebook leaves collaboration to its own rewards. And of course the cost is another big difference:
WoW is still a subscription game, while Facebook pays in other ways. But the amount of similarities between the two are pretty fascinating. And comparing the two, as Gamasutra does, really makes you think about just what interactivity means, and how two apparently very different types of interactive media aren't that far apart after all.
Tags: analysis, facebook, friendships, gamasutra, game, identity, interaction, interactive, interactivity, post, relationships, social-networking, social-networks, subscription, wow, writeup
Filed under: WoW Social Conventions, Virtual selves, Blizzard, Forums
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Andrew R. Dec 18th 2009 11:03AM
Now the question is. How many of you have anything WoW related on your Facebook? Do you let the world know you're a geek at heart or is WoW your dirty little secret only the wife knows about?
I myself don't have anything on my Facebook but a few people I graduated from high school play and we leave comments about different parts of the game from time to time.
Riiya Dec 18th 2009 11:20AM
I'm keeping WoW as my dirty little secret. :P
Of course my close friends and family know it and time-to-time talk about it on fb, but it's not something I want to share with this, judgemental world, to which playing wow only means ur more or less a loser :/
Kate Dec 18th 2009 11:28AM
Total dirty little secret. I have a few guildies friended that will refer to me by my main's name sometimes. Those always get odd reactions from my other friends.
Tori Dec 18th 2009 11:29AM
All of my friends know I'm a WoW geek, it's not like I'm ashamed of it. xD I've got the Hearthstone application right on my front page saying who my characters are and on which realms. :)
snowleopard233 Dec 18th 2009 11:41AM
I’m openly geek and wear an alliance hoodie showcasing my pride. Several of my real-life friends play with me on a daily basis. As far as facebook goes, I have it listed as one of my interests, but I don’t go posting too much about my in-game status or anything. Most my friends won’t care if I get to level 85, let alone know what that means.
Mike Dec 18th 2009 11:55AM
The only game-related status I have ever posted on my Facebook profile was "Mike: 1 Malygos: 93328" after I finally downed that bastard.
Sedna Dec 18th 2009 12:05PM
I think fully half my Facebook friends are from my guild. I mostly like the WoW/FB overlap; it lets me get to know people better outside the game. (And occasionally it lets me know who I should put on my ignore list.)
Fyve & Boomstick Dec 18th 2009 12:18PM
Meh, I'm not ashamed of geeking out and having people know it, My facebook is locked down tighter than a bank vault so its only my friends anyway. Not only do i have a 'my characters' style app tucked away I've gone so far as the achieved! app posting to my news feed. I've several guildies on my Facebook too.
When warcraft set up their facebook page, it was one of my non WoW buddies that first commented on my becoming a fan of said page. "how is this news?" :-D
Tori Dec 18th 2009 12:39PM
@snowleopard233
Oh I fully wear all my WoW shirts and hoodies with pride. In fact, my boyfriend and I sometimes end up wearing our 'For the Horde' t-shirts on the same days and we laugh about how geeky we are as a couple. He's got the Horde hat and wallet as well, plus our vehicle has the Horde symbol sticker on the back.
....we're even getting the custom license plate 4HORDE eventually, lmao. We're WoW geeks and proud of it. :)
grauwyler Dec 18th 2009 1:45PM
I figure if I can handle seeing every time a friend finds a lost skunk or asks for help watering their crops then they can tolerate a few WoW updates from me without ridiculing me for it.
Stages Dec 18th 2009 2:38PM
A good number of my Facebook friends are my guildies, and they are the ones that comment the most on my status updates and whatnot. My guild recruited a tank based off of status update of mine (granted, I went to school with them, which is why they were on my friends list to begin with). The most recently tagged picture of me is the kill shot from Lord Marrowgar.
I earned my geek badge. I wear it with pride.
Evi Dec 18th 2009 3:18PM
I don't keep it a secret. I don't post nonstop about WoW, but I don't hide it from anyone. Some of my guildies are on my Facebook friends list.
G Dec 18th 2009 5:15PM
The Hearthstone app gives me away and reports my darings-do.
Mr. Tastix Dec 18th 2009 7:39PM
I don't put on my Facebook page as "Plays WoW" as I generalize it more and put "Is a gamer" (since that's true), I'm not going to never not talk about WoW though if someone else brings it up.
I'm a gaming enthusiast, I love games, I play games, and I have no problem with admitting that I do. Yes, I am a nerd but so what? I'm not the only one and you can either accept me for who I am or piss off. I probably won't want to know you if you can't accept me for me anyway.
Malcav Dec 18th 2009 11:12AM
1 big difference is that if you have a "solo" face book account is pretty pointless. however i have solo'd several character up to the level cap at the time and felt very satisfied and fulfilled.
Ratskinmahoney Dec 18th 2009 11:10AM
Wife? I'm only 43, I still live with my mum.
Lornicide Dec 18th 2009 11:22AM
Um, yeah.....Your mother and I came to a decision last night. We want you out of the basement so we can install a new media room. Best o' luck.
Ratskinmahoney Dec 18th 2009 11:24AM
Oh. Ok, I take it the loft still has my old shackles fitted.
Phil Dec 18th 2009 11:15AM
True Facebook gives us lots of stuff to do in a virtual community, but it does not give me the ability to kill stuff and get phat loot.
Xtian Dec 18th 2009 11:23AM
He's right. In Farmville, you specifically get zero phat loots if you kill things.