Know Your Lore: The Alliance

This week on KYL, we move away from the Fall of the Lich King (although in the months to come expect more Icecrown related KYL's) and out to the larger world and the major factions that contend across it. I thought we'd start with the Alliance this week for a number of reasons, the first and most important among them being that the Alliance would not exist without the Horde, while the Horde's existence owes itself to forces transcending the Alliance. Because of this, doing the Alliance first will leave open questions that the Horde section next week will help answer.
The Alliance as it stands at this moment in time is a far different entity than the one originally known as the Alliance of Lordaeron. That Alliance was one of seven human nations (Azeroth, Lordaeron, Stromgarde, Kul Tiras, Alterac, Dalaran and Gilneas) with the Dwarves of Ironforge, Gnomes of Gnomeregan and High Elves of Quel'Thalas. This Alliance was born directly out of the statecraft of King Terenas Menethil of Lordaeron and the military leadership of Anduin Lothar, the Lion of Azeroth and last living member of the original Arathi bloodline.
Each member of this alliance had various reasons for being in it and varying degrees of loyalty to it (the High Elves, for example, were only in the Alliance because as the last Arathi, Lothar could compel their loyalty due to ancient pacts and abandoned it as soon as it was possible for them to fulfill said pacts, while Gilneas retreated behind the Greymane Wall not long after the end of the Second War over differences of opinion with Lordaeron) and it certainly lacked in coherence compared to the Horde it was opposed to.
In fact, it's fair to say the Alliance of Lordaeron would never have existed if the Kingdom of Azeroth (Stormwind) hadn't fallen to the Horde in the First War. Lothar's desperate journey away from the ravaged capital of the southern human kingdom with the child king Varian Wrynn in his arms and his arrival in Lordaeron at Terenas' court is the stuff of legends now, but then it was a very near thing, a flight from bloodthirsty marauders who dogged their heels at every step and could easily have caught and killed them all. Even after Lothar made that dread trip north and roused the other human kingdoms, got Terenas on board, convinced the dwarves, gnomes and elves to join up (and even there, the Horde helped by doing things like recruiting the Trolls and attacking Quel'Thalas) the lack of unity in the Alliance of Lordaeron nearly cost it the Second War, Alterac being the most obvious example. If not for Gul'dan's treachery, in fact, the Horde most likely would have won the Second War and destroyed the Alliance of Lordaeron.
The aftermath of Gul'dan's decision to take the Stormreaver and Twilight's Hammer and go get eaten by demons at Sargeras' tomb was that the Alliance finally had the chance to push the Horde back, confronting Doomhammer and his forces at Blackrock Mountain, where Lothar met his death and Turalyon took up his shattered sword, defeating the Orcs and capturing or pushing them back through the Dark Portal. While the Alliance managed to exist long enough to mount the Alliance Expedition to Draenor following Ner'zhul and Teron Gorefiend's theft of the Book of Medivh, it disintegrated into squabbling and infighting not long after as Genn Greymane pulled out entirely over the question of letting the Orc prisoners from the Second War live in internment camps rather than exterminating them.
It's also necessary to mention the effect Daval Prestor had on the Alliance at this time. An unknown nobleman claiming relation to the deposed Perenolde dynasty of Alterac, he nearly managed to get himself married into the Lordaeron royal family and placed on the throne of Alterac at the same time. Luckily for Calia Menethil, for some reason Daval Prestor disappeared and she never had to marry him. Unfortunately for Alterac, this left the place to the mercies of the ogres and the Syndicate.
Ironically, the Alliance as a cohesive entity basically didn't exist during the Third War. Ner'zhul as the Lich King struck at Lordaeron alone, using Kel'Thuzad (a former archmage of Dalaran) to help corrupt Prince Arthas, who sailed to Northrend sans his father's approval after the atrocities at Stratholme, and returned, Frostmourne in hand, to slay his father and destroy his kingdom. The loss of Lordaeron and the creation of the modern Plaguelands spelled the end of the Alliance of Lordaeron as it stood, as did the destruction of Quel'Thalas and the pollution of the Sunwell to raise Kel'Thuzad as a Lich. The destruction of Dalaran followed hard upon. Jaina Proudmoore's flight to Kalimdor helped sever Kul Tiras from the remnant as well, as Admiral Daelin Proudmoore soon took the Navy to find her. This left a rebuilding Stormwind in no position to take action against the Burning Legion and the Scourge, and ragged bands of survivors throughout the Plaguelands under the command of men like Garithos acting on their own.
Meanwhile, the remnants of the Alliance under Jaina found themselves at first in conflict with, and then allied to, the Night Elves of Kalimdor. To this motley alliance were added the orcs, trolls and tauren under the young Horde Warchief Thrall, after subtle and not so subtle meddling by Medivh himself, no longer insane or possessed by Sargeras (and also no longer dead) - this assortment of mortals stood against the Burning Legion and its advance up the slopes of Mount Hyjal, but they fought at best a delaying action to give Malfurion Stormrage time to take action and make the ultimate sacrifice, destroying the World Tree Nordrassil and the night elves' immortality in the process.
To be honest, how we get from this moment to the current state of affairs between the Horde and Alliance is kind of vague. Part of it can be laid at Grom Hellscream's feet: while he and Thrall stood together against Mannoroth and earned Grom a hero's death, his previous actions in Kalimdor (drinking Mannoroth's blood in a tainted fountain and slaying Cenarius, the demigod patron of the druids and teacher of Malfurion himself) had earned the orcs a lasting enmity from the kaldorei. The Warsong Clan's further expansion north into night elf lands stoked the fires of hostility, and it's fair to say that without the actions of Grom and his Warsong Clan, the night elves would have had no compelling reason to join the new Alliance that rose after the Third War. Likewise, with the Scourge having destroyed Lordaeron by this point, human power was at its lowest ebb.
Gilneas remained sealed behind its wall, Dalaran was destroyed, Kul Tiras bereft of its ruler and most of its navy, Alterac a blighted land of thieves and ogres, and Stromgarde (already weakened by Thrall's campaign to free the orcs that destroyed Hammerfall and Durnholde Keep in occupied Alterac) found itself overrun with Syndicate from Alterac and ogres as well. This left only the former Kingdom of Azeroth (now calling itself Stormwind) as having any power and influence of the original seven, and Theramore Isle in Kalimdor populated by various refugees from the destroyed nations consumed by the Scourge and the Legion. We're still not aware of what, exactly moved the dwarves and gnomes to join the Alliance following the Third War (although we know the fall of Gnomeregan is what kept the gnomes out of the Third War) aside from general hostility from the Second towards orcs and trolls. It's possible one strong motivation to join was the existence of the Forsaken to their north, almost indistinguishable from the Scourge and slowly moving south through Silverpine Forest and the ruined lands of Alterac. Once the Forsaken joined the Horde, it only became more compelling to be part of an organization that could oppose them, one suspects.
At present the Alliance stands more united than ever. The admission of the shipwrecked draenei gave the night elves a closer ally in their attempts to reclaim Ashenvale and protect it from Legion demons and Horde incursions alike, as well as helping the Alliance make inroads with native draenei and lost ones in Outland. The return of Varian Wrynn spurred the Alliance into Northrend, where for the first time night elves, humans, gnomes and dwarves can all be seen fighting side by side against the Scourge and the Horde alike. Muradin Bronzebeard's return from seeming death has had a similar effect for Alliance unity, as has the more bellicose attitude of Garrosh Hellscream, Overlord of the Warsong Offensive and son of Grom, slayer of Cenarius. The very legacy of the Old Horde that serves to often unite the Horde seems often to unite the Alliance even more effectively.
Next week, we'll talk about the cost of all this: the deaths and worse of the Forsaken, the xenophobic betrayal of the Quel'dorei and their transformation into blood elves, the redemption of the orcs and their pacts with tauren and troll allies that helped create the New Horde from the ashes of the Old.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Odds and ends, Lore, Factions, Know your Lore
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 3 of 6)
Ben Dec 30th 2009 6:44PM
Good article.
Horde is still better, though :p
Tmoney Dec 30th 2009 6:52PM
I may have misremembered something but I thought when Sylvanas led her Forsaken to cleanse the ruins of Lordaeron from the Scourge and Dreadlords, she made a pact with dwarven soldiers there which she then turn against the moment they succeeded, claiming what would become the Undercity for her own. That could be a motivating factor for Ironforge aligning themselves with the current Alliance.
Please correct me if I'm way off.
kabshiel Dec 30th 2009 7:10PM
She allied with the humans led by Garithos and then fed him to her ghouls once she was finished with him. There were probably dwarven riflemen in his army, but it was a human-led force.
Ringo Flinthammer Dec 30th 2009 8:55PM
The orcs invading (but not conquering!) Khaz Modan during the Second War, along with long-standing economic, political and military ties to the human kingdoms in the Alliance, is plenty reason for Ironforge to be part of the Alliance of Stormwind.
Vaulkner Dec 30th 2009 6:51PM
Great article. I especially liked how you pointed out that the Alliance was mostly a reactionary measure to the Horde. A lot of players don't seem to realize that sometimes.
I'm looking forward to the next article as well. These are helping me fill in my gaps in knowledge after playing warcraft 3 and the frozen throne expansion. I'll be a lore nerd in no time :) !
Janaa Dec 30th 2009 8:06PM
Well of course - you don't form a military alliance if you're not fighting against anyone. ;) In times of peace, at best you have a non-confrontation peace treaty, trade agreements, etc, but the state of an "alliance" is always in response to a perceived threat.
Though, it constantly bothers me that early on "The Horde" referred *almost* solely to the Orcs, whereas the modern-day "The Horde" refers to factions who joined up during and after the Third war. Sure, there were always troll mercenaries, but these sold their services to anyone - Human or Orc - and lorewise, are not the same Trolls that make up the Horde membership today.
I'm very happy with where the Alliance is today. Fairly strongly united, even managing to convince an outside race who had nothing to do with Azeroth's former battles, to join them in taking the fight to the Lich King. Certainly preferable to an alliance where two factions (undead/blood elves) would happily slaughter every other member of their alliance if they could only figure out how to do it.
Vaulkner Dec 30th 2009 8:12PM
Agreed - but "The Horde plus a few autonomous malicious factions" just doesn't have the same ring to it :p.
Then again, these days you could pretty much call the alliance "The Alliance plus some purple people and werewolves."
jasonkidd1234 Dec 30th 2009 6:53PM
I still don't entirely understand how the Night Elves went from hating everybody not Night elves, to liking the humans. I realize they don't like the Orcs that much (Grom killed Cenarius after all) but they put aside thier differences long enough to kill Achrimonde, and they spent enough time with the Orcs to realize that they aren't all like that. Not to mention you think the connection they have with the Tauren would have at the very least made them NOT fight against the Horde.
Logically speaking I think the Night Elves seem like the type who would have stayed out of the factions. After all, they really just wanted to do is rebuild.
IDK I know why they joined from a game standpoint and somewhat from a lore standpoint, but I think realistically it probably woulda made more sense for them to stay out of the war.
Even with Grom's actions, you'd think the Night elves would have had sense to realize that the Orcs aren't all evil, and coulda made some sort of treaty with them.
Perhaps Tyrande isn't as peaceful as she seems though.
DruidGuard Dec 30th 2009 7:06PM
I'd guess the majority of their tension comes from the Warsong lumber operations that continue in Ashenvale. The humans haven't done anything remotely as invasive to the Night Elves and for the most part have left them alone as they wish. Add into the fact that it was indeed the Orcs that upset the Night Elves balance of nature with Grom and his actions, and its not hard to see why they harbor such a grudge. And I wouldn't say the Night Elves blame all the horde from Grom's actions; the Cenarion Circle in Moonglade with its pack between the Tauren and Elves prove they haven't closed their doors to those who ally with the Horde - as long as they share the same values.
kabshiel Dec 30th 2009 7:12PM
I'd guess the majority of their tension comes from the developers wanting to make Night Elves a playable race and deciding that the Alliance would be the best fit. The Night Elves and Forsaken are sort of the original "lorelol", along with Tauren druids and playable warlocks.
jasonkidd1234 Dec 30th 2009 8:08PM
Well I understand that they harbor ill-will towards the Warsong clan, but considering Grom's actions took place before they throw aside thier differences to take down Achrimonde, I just think it would make more sense for them to stay neutral.
I guess since the Horde still continue towards chopping down Warsong that would be a reason, but I'd like Blizz too officially describe Tyrande's decision. If the Night Elves decided to stay out of the conflict alltogether, I think the Orcs might not have forested Warsong. They woulda got thier lumber elsewhere, which I guess isn't much better in the Night elves Eyes, but I think that's something they could elaborate on. Perhaps in Malfurions book it describes some of the ill-will towards the Horde. He looks pretty pissed so I guess maybe the horde had something to do with that.
splodesondeath Dec 30th 2009 8:34PM
The Warsong Clan's position in Horde politics remains confusing at best, even now that Garrosh is up and being grumpy. Originally they were just Hellscream's orcs, fighting the night elves in Ashenvale because they want lumber. Now, they are all over the place, being Warsong guards and such. It's somewhat unclear, but I think originally, after Grom's death and the World Tree gets blown, the Warsong orcs just get ignored and go back to getting lumber.
Thrall never seems to make any sign of caring, but if he had in the beginning, they could have probably saved themselves from getting the night elves into the Alliance.
The tauren's standpoint with the Night Elves stil remains extremely unclear as to why they are both such buddies since the start, as their respective pasts are relatively mysterious. The tauren have probably existed since the Great Sundering and they must have interacted with the night elves or something. I assume the appearance of Light/An'she-following Tauren in Cataclysm might explain it more.
staffan.johansson Dec 30th 2009 9:00PM
Where would Orgrimmar get their lumber, if not from Ashenvale? Mulgore consists of grassy plains, and Durotar, Barrens, Stonetalon Mountain, and Thousand Needles are all rather barren. Azshara has some wood, but nowhere near Ashenvale's resources. Felwood's infested with demons. Dustwallow Marsh's trees don't look particularly suitable for construction, and going further away than the zones mentioned would be much too far to go for lumber when you have a whole forest right on your doorstep.
Telwar Dec 30th 2009 9:12PM
@staffan:
Stonetalon actually has quite a few trees in it, as evidenced by the Venture Co. logging operations there.
Now, if the orcs were interested in peaceful relations with the night elves, they'd shove the Venture Co out and log there. Maybe get some dr00ds in for reforestation, sustainable logging, all the kind of things that give hippies a tear in their eye, etc.
But they're not. Perhaps the Horde likes goblins, despite the Venture Co. being a bunch of murderous amoral punks. Perhaps the Horde likes TAKING wood.
Al Dec 30th 2009 9:34PM
"Where would Orgrimmar get their lumber, if not from Ashenvale?"
How about Silverpine or Stranglethorn, especially since they could use the zeppelins to carry it in large quantities? Such forward thinking probably goes against their Manifest Destiny conceit that Kalimdor somehow belongs to them.
It's their own fault for building a city in the first desolate wasteland they came across, anyway.
Lorekin Dec 30th 2009 9:58PM
Despite the druidic ties between night elves and tauren currently, they are not very "buddy buddy". During the sundering, the night elves didn't even want to utilize tauren in the war against the demons and they regarded them as brutish beasts incapable of grasping the concept of civilized society.
That aside, I agree with your point that the Night Elves allying with the humans doesn't seem to have a strong motivator. They have always been a solitary race and they do not like to depend on other races at all. I'm sure the sundering knocked a lot of that arrogance out of them, but even after those events they've been withdrawn and prefer to keep to themselves.
I'd love to see a more in depth look at the Night Elves motivation to be a part of the Alliance. The other races that make it up I can understand, even if just from a unifying religious standpoint (via the Light).
Will be interesting to see the lore behind the Worgen, though. After all, when Forsaken regained their free will they tried to return to their homes and families and were chased away, which made them bitter. Yet the Worgen are monsters and affected by tainted magic and generally seem like something unacceptable that would be chased off, as well... get accepted with open arms? Really can't wait for Cata, if only for an answer to this! lol
jasonkidd1234 Dec 31st 2009 9:31AM
I forgot entirely about the Great Sundering and the Night Elves treatment of the Tauren at that point of time.
Guess it still gives them a little more ground.
I'm assuming that Malfurion's book will have at the least a tiny bit of info of the happenings between killing Achrimonde and the start of WoW, maybe that's where Blizzard will finally decide to make the connection. Perhaps the Night Elves asked the Warsong clan to stop, and they didn't, which is why Warsong Gulch is so heavily contested, maybe the Alliance promised to help them defend Warsong in exchange for them joining the Alliance, or something deeper. Though I think it's probably a combination of Warsong refusing to stop cutting down the forest, and the Alliance's willingness to help them defend it.
Though I'm starting to wonder where the Horde is going to get thier lumber at beyond Cataclysm. It seems Ashenvale is empty, so they'll have to start moving on to some other place. Maybe Stonetalon will have grown back during the cataclysm, or even better the new Desolace is full of trees that reproduce quickly due to highly enriched soil. Or something like that.
MightyBurebista Dec 31st 2009 2:06PM
I'd just like to go out of my way to point out that as far as the illegal Warsong deforestation operations in Ashenvale are concerned: Thrall and Varian (back when they were on speaking terms) were actually about to come down to an accord whereby Varian took into accountability the Horde's need for lumber, so they were supposed to agree to a trade deal where the Alliance provided lumber to the Horde and the Horde provided copper and pelts to the Alliance.
...but shit came up and Varian was urgently called away before the accord could be signed. -_-
Azradesh Dec 30th 2009 7:12PM
Don't forget about the dwaves of Aerie Peak. Poor WildHammers, everyone forgets about them. I wish Blizz would give Aeris Peak an massive upgrade, it's meant to be the next biggest dwarf city/town after Ironforge, but it's smaller then the Wildhammer outpost in Outlands.
Alanid Dec 30th 2009 7:36PM
Yeah, I love the Wildhammer's, being dragon hunters during the second war and all. WTB option to be a Wildhammer Dwarf who happens to live in Ironforge. Racial - THROW BIG ASS HAMMER