What's taking the Battlecry mosaic so long?

It's come along rather smoothly, and some really cool player pictures have been submitted, with the seeming abundance of Horde-aligned pictures prompting us to ask where the Alliance pride was. But what really surprises me is how long the whole project is taking. When the site was launched, one of the first questions that actually ran through my head was how long it would take to fill up the whole mosaic. With over ten million active players, you'd think getting to 20,000 would be easy. Out of ten million, that's like a drop in a bucket. But after almost two months of the site being active, we're still only at 32% of the goal. Why?
The slow start might be attributed to the fact that submissions need to have the minimum resolution of 1024x768 pixels, a requirement inadvertently left out of the site in the first few days. Many of the first submissions might not have made the cut, and players who already submitted images that didn't conform to the minimum resolution might not have known and didn't bother to submit again. Another possible barrier might be the need to include a Horde or Alliance symbol -- the site originally suggests that players print out files of the logos which could be downloaded from the Battlecry page. Players without their own printers might've hit a snag, although a quick look through the submissions show that most players found creative ways to include their respective faction logos, either through an image editor such as Photoshop or actual items such as a J!NX shirt or paint on a car.
It's also very likely that the submissions are screened to prevent any unsavory pictures making their way to the mosaic, although the presence of multiple identical photos tends to counter that. One of the problems with submitting to the mosaic is the uploader sometimes doesn't inform the submitter if the file went through successfully, sometimes prompting multiple submissions (which make their way to the gallery). These little hiccups aside, we've still only got a little under 6,500 out of 20,000 submissions in this contest.
Considering the Warcraft Twitter account has over 68,000 followers and their Facebook account has amassed over 93,000 fans in just one month, I find it rather disappointing to see that a mere six thousand people have submitted to the Battlecry mosaic. Is submitting a picture really that difficult? Are players finding it hard to include a Horde or Alliance logo in their pictures? Could it be that players aren't comfortable sharing pictures of themselves? Or is Blizzard taking longer feeding the player submissions through their photo mosaic software?
Whatever the case, I'm personally disappointed that it's only at 32% of the 20,000 goal considering the number of players who supposedly play the game. With the mosaic barely a third of the way done after nearly two months, this might mean we'll only get to see the rest of the artwork by April or May. That's no fun at all. The mosaic is likely to be the complete and fully-lit painting of the background image in the Battlecry page, which depicts Varian Wrynn, Thrall, and what appears to be the various faction leaders. From the visible painting of Thrall and Varian, one can guess that the whole artwork is possibly another masterpiece by Son of the Storm Glenn Rane. How can players resist unveiling all that awesomeness?
Have you submitted your player picture to the Battlecry mosaic? Do you plan to? Given the speed of things, it looks like the mosaic needs all the help it can get, although another batch of submissions have come in featuring players over the holidays. One of the coolest things about this project for me is getting to see all the different kinds of players who play this game from all over the world from all walks of life. I'm particularly amused with the fact that Chinese players even have a distinct fingerprint logo on their submissions. Let's do our part to reveal that artwork. Download the Horde or Alliance logos on the Battlecry page and let your own battle cry be heard!
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Fan stuff, Blizzard






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Sichas Jan 6th 2010 1:10PM
In the grand scheme of WoW, does this mosaic really matter as far as day to day operations of Azeroth goes? Slow day at the WoW.com office. I like the idea of a mosaic, it's a really AWESOME way to look back 5 years and show your faction pride, but it seems like time could be better spent analyzing why Blink is still glitching out rather than why people aren't submitting pictures.
Paul Jan 6th 2010 1:42PM
Just to explain why you're getting downrated. The people putting the mosaic together are NOT game developers. Just so you can learn from this experience and not waste our time with such a pointless comment in future.
Sichas Jan 6th 2010 2:12PM
Because yours is so much more insightful? You must play Alliance.
travis Jan 6th 2010 2:43PM
So your telling me that you would rather read a 750 word article talking about why Blink isn't working? That would be much better.........
Your a disgrace to the Horde.
Sichas Jan 6th 2010 2:56PM
So you see my point. They're both equally pointless and time wasting.
Kraf Jan 6th 2010 7:07PM
I think he's tlkin about wow.com guys...
Cloudbourne Jan 6th 2010 1:14PM
Considering the article was about 15 minutes ago, has the editor checked to see that the Mosiac is actually up to 41% with 8,277 photos submitted?
Twill Jan 6th 2010 4:28PM
I would assume that he checked when he started writing, and Bliizard has just updated it.
Blizzard loves to have things not get updated... and then do a large amount suddenly. If you browse through the site, most of it is outdated from vanilla lol...
Anyway...
Im a closeted WoW player... RL and WoW don't mix. Thus, no picture. Just my reason.
Vitos Jan 6th 2010 4:29PM
9% in 15 minutes... that means it should be done it about... an hour and a half
Andrew R. Jan 6th 2010 1:16PM
The people who are working on the mosaic are not devs. They are not paid to figure out why blink is still broken or as to why there are so many bugs. They work in the art department.
Don't be so quick to assume everyone at Blizzard is a dev. That's like assuming just because I work for a fire department I'm a firefighter....oh wait...
Josh Jan 6th 2010 1:24PM
Whilst this is very true, I see a way to get both departments involved:
When they fix Blink, I'll submit a photo.
...
See you in time for the 10-20 year anniversary mosaic.
Sichas Jan 6th 2010 2:10PM
I don't believe I said anything about developers. If you're going to waste time analyzing something that has absolutely no bearing on the game, how about use that time instead to analyze something that is actually useful to the WoW community and talk about why Blink is never going to work correctly because it would just take too damn much time to figure out, and that'd pull people off of real game development?
No, let's talk about why people aren't submitting pictures for some completely useless (albeit awesome) mosaic.
Agony Jan 6th 2010 2:17PM
Marketing department: Joe Porrie
Public Relations department: Mary Seichs
Game Development: Peter Marks and Frieda Levitz
Customer Service/Relations/Game Master: Ghostcrawler
Accounting/Receptionist/Janitor: Carlos LaPaz
It would seem that SOME people <cough>Sichas<cough> believe that Blizzard consists of only the above scenario.
Guess what? They have hundreds of people working for them that have nothing whatsoever to do with development of the game or fixing in-game issues!
Wow...whoda thunkit?
(cutaia) Jan 6th 2010 1:23PM
Is it possible that they just have to wait until they have enough appropriately colored photos for each square before they put it up?
cendrekai Jan 6th 2010 1:25PM
That is what I figured.
Tinwhisker Jan 6th 2010 1:32PM
I think this is most likely the case. Blizzard would probably rather use largely untouched pictures rather than try to mess around with colors and cropping unless they really have to.
snarkie Jan 6th 2010 5:02PM
I am leaning toward this explanation as well. I submitted three photos, all of which are now, after the latest update, in the gallery at the bottom of that page. I can search for them using the nick name I gave them. However, I can't find them in the actual mosaic itself. I've looked extensively in the two new tiles that went up with the latest update (the only two to be added since I submitted). I'm assuming that they just didn't fit in with the mosaic itself because of colouring and the like, and they intentionally weren't included. I would hope, though, that at least one of my photos ends up in there eventually.
On the other hand... I could just be completely blind and missing my photos in the huge mosaic. :)
Briz9 Jan 6th 2010 1:24PM
I was unaware that the photos were being arranged into a mosaic until this post. I'll try to do my part when I get home.
Elyneth Jan 6th 2010 1:30PM
Perhaps Blizzard fully intends it to be revealed in May - It might coincide with something about Catacylsm such as a release date or some other juicey bit of info? Fingers crossed anyway!
Kragragh Jan 6th 2010 1:29PM
Um, I can tell you I don't really care about the mosiac or the art that it will unlock. Maybe that's why it's taking so long, people don't care.
I'm not saying they shouldn't do it...just not my thing.