Breakfast Topic: The Personal Aesthetic

Recently, a commenter on a post mentioned that I use a similar screenshot for a lot of my The Care and Feeding of Warriors posts. I looked over it, and he was right: since I race changed to draenei, in fact, quite a few of the screenshots have been silhouetted, facing downwards shots that I often take just because I am playing my character and suddenlt stop and say "wow, that's cool" - I'm not a terribly sophisticated visual thinker (for that, I go to my wife, who has a landscape artist's eyes and a remarkable grasp of light and nuance) but I know what I like.
One of the reasons I like playing draenei and tauren are connected to the classes I like to play: shamans, warriors and DK's are the only classes I've consistently gotten to max rank, and in all of those cases I tend to play large characters. When race change became available I agonized over it (silly as that is) even though I'd always said I'd go draenei because I'd grown so accustomed to the way my human character moved, and watching old avi files of Burning Crusade fights I'd tanked really brought it home to me. In changing my character's race, I've changed his silhouette, I've changed the way he swings a weapon, I've changed the way he looks in every aspect of the game. I don't do that spinning one handed smash when I tank anymore, it's much more of an arching, down-angled slash. My Shield Slam is different.
Granted, I'm okay with that. But it got me thinking about why I choose the races I do and the classes I do.
One of the things I love about the warrior class and the races I've chosen to play is the sense of raw mass you get. Draenei are as big or slightly bigger than an orc who stands up straight, and tauren are even more enormous.Warriors just have a feeling of inexorability, of grinding, relentless and deliberate forward progression. There's just something in me that deeply enjoys the almost ponderous yet graceful way tauren move, to the point where I honestly have a very hard time playing any of my horde alts that aren't tauren. I'm looking forward to Cataclysm because I expect it will save my poor, lonely belf paladin: one race change later and I'll have a paladin I can finally endure leveling. Likewise, switching away from human cost me the moves and emotes I was familiar with, but it also cost me a freakish upper lip.
I know there are plenty of people who enjoy completely different aesthetics for their characters... I have a friend who swears by undead for her rogues and warriors because she loves to see the female undead combat animations (which are, I have to admit, impressively frenetic) and I've actually grown to enjoy the way an orc shaman looks as enhancement: orcs seem tailor made for going totally buck wild with two fist weapons or axes or maces, it's really almost poetic the way they just shred things. And when I was on the test server I grew tremendously fond of watching my gnome proxy tank via continous hurling of his body into the air and overbalancing every weapon swing or shield slam. Each race (and even gender within each race) has detailed casting animations as well... I've always thought troll females just looked the most exuberant in the way they go about casting spells, although I'm not much of a caster myself.
For me, I always come back to characters I can identify with, and that tends to be big, almost cumbersome toons who take up a lot of space, who specialize in physical roles. I'm just not comfortable as a caster (healing was the closest I could get myself to go in that direction) for whatever reason, it just feels wrong. (I also kind of suck at it, but hey.)
So now I ask you: how much does the look of a character affect you? Do you even care? Did you pick your race for the racials and your class without regard for how it goes about doing whatever it does?
Filed under: Breakfast Topics






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
Caranthir Jan 18th 2010 8:07AM
I always choose a race that I feel fit for the class.
Dwarf Male Paladin
Human Female Mage
Draenei Female DK
and I have a Gnome Male Warrior... but that's just wrong
Jamie Jan 18th 2010 9:05AM
My first main was a male Dwarf Paladin, but I kind of considered Dwarves to be more Warriors than Paladins, so I switched to male Human Paladin & male Dwarf Warrior.
In Cataclysm I'd go for a Gnome Priest despite the fact I feel they're Warlocks & Mages, having said that I'm a plate melee player through and through.
I have a male Night Elf Rogue but I don't care so much for Night Elves and certainly not other players who are Night Elves... generally the most sense you get out of Night Elf Hunters is "wut!? lol..." and they're always the first to chuck their stupid cats into a mob the tank has yet to pull.
Can't say I stand the look of male Draeneis, but people who play they are fine enough.
Squirr3llywrath9 Jan 18th 2010 1:20PM
I too have a male gnome warrior. Don't you hate it when people /pat you or say "Aww he thinks he can tank". It annoys me to no end that just because I chose a small race they think I can't take a hit.
Sehvekah Jan 18th 2010 3:47PM
Honestly, it was the racials that lead to my Rogue being a Nelf. Granted, at the time I knew next to nothing about the game, but I figured better stealth to be a good thing to have, and for leveling it was. Having hit endgame now, I gotta say the racials are less useful than they were starting out. And then there's the fact that while male Nelf combat animations work for Rogues, they're nothing to write home about. Plus there's the goofy hands, the face, the idiotic jumping animation you get on the 90% of jumps that don't flip...
So, when it becomes available, a race change to Worgen is in order. I'll miss the jump-flip, and the combat animations are something I've had a lot of time to get used to, but in the end the Worgen are likely to have much more awesome animations, and better racials to boot(3 sprints on separate cooldowns? Yes, please!). Also, Worgen Rogue=Ninja werewolf, how can a frakin' Ninja Werewolf NOT be awesome? It CAN'T, that's how.
With that said, having more experience with the game, I put more consideration into my alts, including the base models and aminations. Racials still weigh in, but there's no way I'd ever roll a male Draenei as a caster, for instance(they just don't look the part, at all). Female Draenei caster, sure, if there's a better fit in the game I can't think of it offhand, but the guys are just too bulky for it. They make up for that by being awesome for plate and/or melee though. Doesn't mean I *wouldn't* roll a Gnome Warrior(sometimes going for the off-beat combos is more fun than the sensible ones), but it'd be much more likely for that Gnome to end up a caster, or the warrior to be a Dwarf or Draenei.
Oh, and Matt? "but it also cost me a freakish upper lip" would read better as "but it also spared me a freakish upper lip", given that you're trying to compare the cost(change of animations) to a benefit(No more hairlip!). Or at least that's my opinion.
Shigsy Jan 18th 2010 8:15AM
I always tend to choose the race depending on which starting zone I fancy levelling in. Which meant Teldrasill and Night Elves in Vanilla. Magical place :)
That said, I'd never roll a Gnome. ;)
slythwolf Jan 18th 2010 11:46AM
This, I think, is one of the really nice things about the boat route changes in Wrath and the more recent Thunder Bluff zeppelin. You can more easily level in any start zone, not just the one you actually start in.
RetadinMan Jan 18th 2010 8:16AM
Its all about the lore for me. That is why I chose Draenei Paladin and Blood Elf Mage. The Draenei Paladin is a natural fit, especially after seeing the BC cinematic. Blood Elf Mages are the epitome of Arcane ability.
Polecat Jan 18th 2010 8:22AM
Animations. The character animations are the #1 consideration when playing a character. It's why I don't have any human toons (male & female) and no female trolls. I don't play many Belfs, and gnomes are just creepy little kids. Tauren I love, but have some clipping issues with the tail that are like fingernails on the chalkboard for me. So I end up playing Dreanai & orcs, with a few forays into dwarves and forsaken. I'm looking forward to seeing the new animations for the Goblins...
- Polecat
Raze Jan 18th 2010 9:36AM
Not just the tail. It drives me nuts when I see this glitchy looking red line in the back of my female Tauren Shaman's head where the hair isn't properly covering the lack of "stuff" there, or her somewhat strange looking face.
Don't get me wrong, I like a lot of her animations (their bow especially, it's so regal looking I love it), the model itself is just really buggy and plagued with issues that get on my nerves. This is a game that doesn't look good when you put it under the telescope, unfortunately.
Cor Jan 18th 2010 11:17AM
NElf flip and BElf spin FTW!!!
As odd as this sounds these animations are points of consideration when I make a character.
Neyssa Jan 18th 2010 8:23AM
I started my 10th alt on my main server, a female ork shaman. I have a Tauren male druid (see i he is my only male character, and although i always make females, for the tauren it just didnt fit for me).
I love her totems, the way she is casting heal, and how she swings with her two-handed axe. I am so happy that i made my shaman an orc, it just fits it so well. My bf made a female orc warrior, and they look so great together, hitting and casting, and wolf-riding.
They are already lvl40, on the way to become new mains :)
When I played ally, I also had about 8 alts, but all of them were night elf and draenei females. I dont like human forms and gnomes and dwarfs.
Mau Jan 18th 2010 8:25AM
My favorites:
Tauren druid for the win!
Orc shammy
Troll priest (witch doctor)
Forsaken warrior
Blood elf warlock
Goblin mage
Draenei DK
NE hunter
Human Paladin
Dwarf shammy
Worgen rogue
NO gnomes, they suck
SunwellVialist Jan 18th 2010 8:33AM
Tauren Druid
Undead Warlock
Orc Hunter
Draenei Mage
Each of them, to me, seems to fit perfectly. I play them and have tons of fun.
They seem natural in the roles they have.
Now, I also have a troll Shaman, but I have him on level 13 or so since 2 years, and I just don't like the way he moves and fights, so I'll probably delete him and play an Orc Shaman instead, which seems to fit far better to me.
All other races don't really do it for me.
x14flag Jan 18th 2010 8:46AM
Gnomes will rule the world!
Kuno Jan 18th 2010 10:28AM
A very tiny, annoying, gear beeping, springs clicking and lil' momma spanking world.
Let them take it - nobody wants that thing anyway.
Drocket Jan 18th 2010 3:21PM
Trifling gnome, your arrogance will be your undoing!
Reinette Jan 18th 2010 8:38AM
My first character was an undead male warlock. I chose the combination because nothing screamed "cool" to me quite like a walking corpse who sacrificed his own dwindling life energy to make pacts with beings beyond mortal understanding.
My second character was a human female paladin. I chose the combination because I wanted to portray a survivor of the third war who was an innocent, suddenly forced into a conflict beyond her control - but with a newly found taste for vengeance. The cold stare of a human female worked perfectly for this.
My current main is a female Night Elf Death Knight. I knew as soon as it was announced that I'd be rerolling Death Knight, and it hasn't disappointed me. I chose my race and gender for the character because I wanted a DK that moved and fought gracefully. I didn't want a human or dwarf who used their big 2h weapon as a cleaver, I wanted someone who used it as an enormous runed scalpel. Also, bright pink hair.
videvekartuspaan Jan 18th 2010 3:55PM
cold stare of a human female? I always thought they looked like jailbait.
Teknopathetic Jan 18th 2010 4:40PM
Probably meant before Blizzard changed it. It was one of the same reasons I rolled a human female.
Chrissie Jan 18th 2010 8:48AM
It's a mix of things for me. I like my characters looking nice, but there's also the starting area aspect and the lore aspect (even though night elf is my favorite, I will NEVER EVER play a night elf mage. I don't care what they're doing down in Dire Maul. NEVER.)
This has brought me to a race hierarchy that basically looks like this:
Night elf > blood elf > draenei > human
I refuse to play anything else, and all 4 of my characters at 70 or above (priest, druid, rogue, DK) are night elves.
The animations aspect does play into it though, for example while I was raiding on my resto druid in BC, I admired the draenei priests' graceful casting animations, but I have little desire to play a draenei non-caster (also, robes hide the weird-looking legs. While I'm at it, I like playing blood elf casters but their legs are just way too skinny to be any class that does not wear robes.) Meanwhile, what I dislike mostly about humans (which put them below draenei in the hierarchy) is the klutzy way they walk and cast. Graceful is really something else.
(In all instances here I am talking about females, I do not play male characters.)