Spiritual Guidance: Food, flasks, and potions

I'm the fish girl.
I never wanted it to be this way. I never wanted to be that girl. You know, the fish girl: the woman in the raid who takes it upon herself to make sure all her fellow raiders are eating right by supplying Fish Feast after Fish Feast. Sure, sometimes it's a fish guy (in fact, just the other day my heal captain joked that he had brought Capri Sun and orange slices for the raid) but usually it's a woman. I guess it's a maternal thing, or maybe it's wanting to save time by always going in with max buffs. Whatever it is, I wasn't always like this. In fact, I used to wonder why my raid leader's wife would so willingly spend her feasts on our raid as we wiped all over 3-drake Obsidian Sanctum. I admired her generosity, particularly because I felt they were going to waste on stupid mistakes, and her efforts deserved better.
Then one day, after I had moved onto another guild, I found myself surrounded by raiders who were lacking vital nutrients in their diets. That's how it began: first I was helping with the fishing, then I started spending my own precious spices. The first day I laid a feast in a raid, I felt my feminist side cringe. But before I go off on that tangent, let me clarify that this article isn't about fish (not exclusively anyway), it's about the various consumables available to priest healers.
For veteran raiders, different consumables are probably nothing new, but if you're fresh to raiding the idea (or the available options) might be foreign. I remember when I first started raiding I didn't flask because I didn't know I had the option to. Even as a noob, I wanted to do everything I possibly could to be considerate to my fellow raiders. I was already accustomed to max enchanting my gear from arena, so most of my efforts consisted of trying to buy or craft PvE upgrades to my resilience gear; flasks weren't even on my radar. Then one day, when my raid team was hitting its head against a boss, my best mage friend opened trade with me and gave me a flask. I read the description and asked him if should use it right then. "Yes, absolutely." And I've stocked up on consumables since.
I view consumables as a form of customization, like gearing, gemming, or enchanting. Each encounter is different, and by toting around a lot of consumable items I can customize my character for the demands of different bosses. It's infinitely cheaper than swapping out gems each fight (unless you're a JC maybe) and ideal if you don't have different gear sets. To me, finding the perfect combination of food, flask, cloak enchant, and trinket so that I'm most effective as a healer, is one of my favorite games inside the game. Perhaps viewing it as an encounter-by-encounter puzzle to solve is something exclusive to me (I am easily amused, after all) but knowing the options you have available might help you on a fight your raid is having trouble with.
Let's look at the different options, starting with flasks.
Flasks
- Flask of the Frost Wyrm -- This flask probably needs no introduction since it is the most popular. This is the best option you have for throughput. 125 spellpower is more than 5 epic spellpower gems, so the buff is definitely a huge boost. I use this flask as much as I can, usually choosing to swap out a food buff or cloak enchant before I switch to a regen flask.
- Flask of Pure Mojo -- This flask isn't often given enough credit because I think most people prefer the extra output from Flask of the Frost Wyrm. Pure Mojo has its place though. When my guild first started working on Iron Council hard mode last spring, I immediately noticed mana would be an issue. I took it upon myself to stock up on these flasks (as well as mp5 food) and as such, was able to make it through to the end of the kill without going out of mana. I remember throughout the 'headbashing' phase of the progression, my fellow healers were desperately calling for Innervates and Mana Tide Totem because they couldn't make it through all of phase 3. I, on the other hand, got put in group 4 (where there was no Mana Tide Totem) and kept healing my heart out. When I suggested people switch to this flask to alleviate mana issues, some of the healers responded with disdain, but when everyone finally switched over to a regen flask we got the kill.
- Flask of Distilled Wisdom -- If the Flask of Pure Mojo isn't enough mana regeneration for you, this flask is the regen flask for the most dedicated raider. The idea is that since mana regeneration cooldowns and replenishment work off our mana pool, more mana from intellect will equate to more regen. Disc priests also benefit from the extra intellect because of the Mental Strength talent. These flasks will be harder to obtain due to the materials, but if you're the sort of player who wants the best of the best, I'm sure the benefits will justify the costs.
For those of you wanting even more customization options, two elixirs (one battle and one guardian) will give you a greater diversity of buffs, but will not persist through death like flasks. I like to use elixirs during farm content since the likelihood of dying is much lower. Here are some good options to consider.
- Battle elixir: Spellpower Elixir, Elixir of Lightning Speed, Elixir of Deadly Strikes, and Guru's Elixir.
- Guardian elixir: Elixir of Mighty Thoughts, Elixir of Mighty Mageblood, and Elixir of Spirit.
- Runic Mana Potion -- The utility of this potion should need no explanation. That being said, consider this a reminder to stock up if you're running low.
- Potion of Nightmares -- I love this potion. It's certainly not for every fight, but when you can spare 6 seconds and non-movement, it's much better than a normal mana potion. As I write this, I am suddenly struck by a question I do not know the answer to. I will test it out this coming raid week, but I encourage anyone interested to do the same: Is the Nightmare Slumber buff given by this potion, broken by fear effects such as Onyxia's Bellowing Roar or Queen Lana'thel's Incite Terror? If anyone isn't locked out for the week, and is interested in testing this, please leave a comment with what you find out!
Food
- Firecracker Salmon / Tender Shoveltusk Steak / Fish Feast -- These food options all give priests the same spellpower bonus. Personally, I do not use this particular food buff since I've never seen 46 spellpower make the difference between saving or not saving a target I was healing. If you value overall throughput though, this is going to be your food buff of choice.
- Spicy Fried Herring / Mighty Rhino Dogs -- When I said earlier that I try to swap out a food buff before a spellpower flask, this is what I was referring to. This is ideal for endurance boss fights or when your gear doesn't quite make the mark and you have to cast a lot more to heal up your targets.
- Imperial Manta Steak / Very Burnt Worg -- This is the food I use most. 40 haste might not be much if you're in the best of the best gear, but it's a lot when you have little or none. Since haste effects GCD, casted, and channeled spells, I feel a haste food buff is the best way to put my targets first. Depending on your own opinions or raid role, this might vary, but it's nice to have a few of these around.
- Spicy Blue Nettlefish / Spiced Worm Burger -- Crit food is invaluable when your gear is awful and you don't have any to proc all of those important talent abilities. I used to eat nothing but Spiced Worm Burgers (back when they were Wyrm Burgers) but now that my gear is better I don't feel the need to purposefully stack crit. Crit can do a lot for your throughput though, so depending on your preferences this might still be a good alternative option to the 46 spellpower food buffs.
- Cuttlesteak -- I haven't heard of anyone using this food since before Ulduar, but it's there as an option if you didn't know about it.
Oh, and to all the other fish girls and fish guys out there: I salute you.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance, Wrath of the Lich King






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Adeany Jan 31st 2010 7:12PM
I tend to prefer the Powerful Rejuvenation Potion to the two listed, but only because it lets me not have to worry about picking between health/mana pots when I need them.
One special thing about Cuttlesteak though, is that the Moonglow Cuttlefish that are used to cook it are incredibly cheap compared to the fish that go into the other foods, so it's a decent economic alternative, at least for holy priests.
Chris Anthony Feb 1st 2010 1:07AM
Protip: check the fishing daily before you go to the auction house. If it's Monsterbelly Appetite, the AH will be flooded with cuttlefish, and you'll get a better price. :)
Man, that brings back pleasant memories of long hours spent fishing off the shore of Borean Tundra, with /cast Fishing bound to mousewheel-up and /use Aquadynamic Fish Attractor /use 16 bound to mousewheel-down...
Wyred Feb 1st 2010 6:35AM
Sodding cuttlesteak. I went out of my way to farm a crapload around the time 3.08 dropped. Is spirit officially the worst stat in WoW now do people reckon?
Bonksy Jan 31st 2010 7:13PM
I definitely prefer the Firecracker salmon / Frost wyrm spell power punch as a Discipline Priest
Moketronics Feb 1st 2010 7:15PM
Yeah, I second that. I'm in all ilvl 245+ pretty much, and I focus entirely on building SP, Crit, Int, Haste. It is so rare that I have any issues with mana running out that I'd never think to use anything but spell power flasks and food (barring a few fights, mostly in 10 mans).
Then, with ~33% holy crit, and almost 600 haste unbuffed, there's not much to be gained from using either food buff over the spell power one. The haste is already overkill as disc, I like having it for holy mostly.
Switching over to Holy I do run into mana problems a bit more with my disc-centric gear choices, but even then, I'd expect it to be worse then it is. My 32k+ mana pool (buffed) shrinks a fair bit in the switch, but between mana fiend, hymn of hope and a mana pot I can last pretty well.
Jeramiahh Jan 31st 2010 7:24PM
I play as a Disc priest, and I almost exclusively use Mojo flasks, except on gimmick fights that don't last long enough for regen, or have special forms of it. The main reason I do? So I can use items that cut my mana regen, and give both crit and haste.
Heather Jan 31st 2010 7:39PM
On my Shaman I almost always use Flask of the Frost Wyrm, unless there is no Replenishment available (and with the recent penchant of my guild's Hunters to go Marksman instead of Survival, I'm finding this more and more in our 10 mans). If no Replenishment is available, I go with Spellpower Elixir and Elixir of Mighty Thoughts.
For my Priest, however, I almost always use Spellpower Elixir and Elixir of Mighty Thoughts over just about everything else. The extra Intellect really seems to come in handy (although I admit that could just be in my head). If I'm working on progression content with my Priest (not often these days, since she's been relegated to an alt position, dammit), I will use a Frost Wyrm flask or a Pure Mojo flask just for the longevity factor.
On my Druid I just use Flask of the Frost Wyrm. Druids have mana problems? Never!
I almost always eat the Fish Feast/Firecracker Salmon, though. Mostly because it's there. When we were working on Anub'arak 25 man Hard Mode, though, I did start making Spicy Blue Nettlefish for the tiny amount of Crit. I know it seems silly, but my LHW wasn't hitting hard enough to suit my taste, and I really wanted to up my crit chances.
Then again, the Fish Feast didn't seem to help anyway... lol
Narshe Jan 31st 2010 7:59PM
I officially love Dawn Moore. Every column so far has been great and informative!
Wikwocket Jan 31st 2010 11:34PM
I agree, the new Spiritual Guidance articles have been excellent.
Darian Jan 31st 2010 8:15PM
I think in the Flask portion of your article you put a link to Mana Spring Totem, when I'm pretty sure you meant Mana Tide totem. Other than that, very nice read.
Dawn Moore Jan 31st 2010 8:48PM
Yep that is what I meant. Crazy shaman abilities! Thank you! Fixed!
Darian Jan 31st 2010 8:27PM
I think in the Flask portion of your article you put a link to Mana Spring Totem, when I'm pretty sure you meant Mana Tide totem. Other than that, very nice read.
Aunumator Jan 31st 2010 8:30PM
Well after reading this...i can say i use the cuttlesteak when healing 5 mans since i have to worry less about dying there than anywhere else.
when i heal i prefer the Flask of Pure Mojo with Mighty Rhino Dogs work since i am all about mp5 and getting the inside 5 seconds as high as possible for as long as possible
when i go dps, it's all about bang and Flask of the Frost wyrm and sp food is where i am at
ElliLe Jan 31st 2010 8:33PM
Another good guardian elixir is the Elixir of Draenic Wisdom (www.wowhead.com/?item=32067). TBC mats and recipe.
Cyanea Jan 31st 2010 8:33PM
Don't forget about Crazy Alchemist's Potions if you're an alchemist. It's the same amount of health and mana from the dream potion, without requiring six seconds of downtime. It also gives a random potion effect.
Tridus Jan 31st 2010 9:26PM
Yeah, this. They're also cheap.
Michelle Jan 31st 2010 9:39PM
I'm actually a little shocked to hear your feminist side cringed at all. Supplying a fish feast has never seemed like a mothering or nurturing thing to me at all - it's a way of making sure the people you're with have a base level of optimization for a kill. As a woman who plays a hunter I've always felt that if I couldn't provide a class-specific buff like so many others can, I could always be there to provide a buff that would better everyone's performance regardless.
Never there to coddle, always there to get the primo kill.
Salute.
Damarlen Jan 31st 2010 10:49PM
Lol. I healed H Occ once, quite a while back. It was before LFD, I got whispered an invite from someone who had picked up my name in a raid so I said sure and went in. Discovered I had 2 rogues and 2 warriors....negligible party buffs :-( We wiped a LOT of times. And after every single wipe, one of the rogues popped a fish feast. I thanked her for it once, she laughed and said "I figured that since I can't put any buffs on the party, the least I can do is provide a buff food." So to her, and to you, and to anyone else who goes out of their way to make sure they are contributing a parry or raid wide buff, many thanks.
lemur Feb 1st 2010 12:48AM
I'm the lock putting up piggy feasts and handing out cookies. Why? Because I used to play a rogue and felt left out in the buff-fests.
Dawn Moore Feb 1st 2010 11:16AM
Lemme explain: my all guy guild (there is one other woman now, but for a while it was just me) is not especially PC. There are frequently comments about how fishing and cooking are woman's work, and reminders that I better be on a laptop, raiding from the kitchen.
Of course, they're all (mostly) jesting, but you can see how that would effect a few things I do in game. IRL I'm not particularly bothered by cultural conventions vs my life. I love cooking, even if I make more money than whatever unfortunate chap is dating with me. (Unfortunate because I'm a PITA. =D)