this, all the top guilds in my server are doing this and getting server first in 1 try

I think it has more to do with the fact that people hated them than that they didn't work (although they really WEREN'T 'working as intended'). Half the threads on the D&R forums to some extent contain some sort of complaining about how limited attempts suck. That majority of players see them as a cheap way of increasing encounter difficulty without actually making the encounters difficult.

Not to mention the endless frustration of lolbugwipes.

@zurkka All the top guilds on your server have gotten server first?

Is it just me, or does that sound every bit as exploit-y as using Saronite Bombs? What it might lack in terms of direct impact on the boss fight itself, it seems to more than make up for in clear premeditation to subvert Blizzard's intent.

(Which is not to suggest that Ensidia likely didn't do it too.)

@Dudegar

lol sorry was sleepy when posted this, they are racing each other sometimes is one guild in one boss and sometimes is another one, real competition there, last first kill was 4 minutes before the econd kill real insane