Gold Capped: Using blacksmithing to make gold on the auction house

Want to get Gold Capped? This column will show you how, and is written by Basil "Euripides" Berntsen, also of outdps.com, the hunting party podcast, and the call to auction podcast.
Blacksmithing is a crafting profession that has made me a lot of money. Today, we'll talk about how you can use blacksmithing as something more than a couple of extra gem slots for your main, and actually make gold! Many people with crafting skills invariably have tried linking their profession in trade and saying "tips appreciated." Has that worked for you? Me either. If you want to make money with any crafting skill, the true profits are from acquiring the mats yourself, crafting, and selling your wares over the long term. As I mentioned in my previous post, the default UI won't cut it for our purposes, so let's get cracking and set you up with a proper crafting UI.
Tools of the trade
To start with, you absolutely must have auctioneer installed. There are other addons that would work, but auctioneer is what I use, and it's widely supported with other addons we'll need. I'm not going to go into too much detail on how to use it for now, but you should download and install it. Once it's working, go to an auction house and click the blue fast forward arrow at the top of your screen. Note: that button really is blue in game :P

This process will take a little time, so be prepared to do some blank staring. What it's doing is grabbing a complete list of every auction on the auction house right now, and what you will be doing with this information is deciding what items are profitable. When it's done, auctioneer will be able to tell you the current price of any sellable commodity.
Now that auctioneer is installed and you've done a first scan, let's get an addon to apply all this data to our crafting window. Go and download the LilSparky's Workshop addon. Now when you open your blacksmithing window, you are presented with a list of recipes you can make, as well as two new numbers: their cost and price, and the difference is your profits. Now the first thing we need to be aware of is that, out of the box, these addons will be telling you what they think you can sell something for if you're firm on price and there's a fair bit of demand. If, however, you plan on undercutting to make a quick sale, you need to change some configurations. Right click on the first of the two numbers (your sell price), and click the following option: value module- auctioneer min buyout.

Now right click the right number (your cost) and choose cost module- auctioneer market:

What you just did was tell Lil'Sparky to approximate the cost based on auctioneer's market data, and calculate how much you can sell it for based on if you undercut the lowest buyout. If you only have one scan, you should double check the cost data for a while, and auctioneer might feed some wildly skewed numbers out until it's seen a few weeks of data.
Crafting for profits
Now when you look at your crafting window, you see when something is profitable, and you can focus on crafting these. That wasn't so hard, was it? Here's the interesting part. You'll probably note in a couple of days that some of the most profitable items come back unsold, even though you were the lowest price and weren't undercut. This is because these items are niche items with a very low demand. For example-- BoE blue equipment. The real skill in managing a crafting profession like blacksmithing is learning (or being able to predict) what items are in high demand and are still profitable. If you have the inventory space, auction house listing fee money, and patience, you can list high profit/low volume items on the AH and serve what people like to call the "long tail" of the market. Most of your auctions will come back unsold, but the ones that don't will have sold for considerably more profit than something where you have lots of demand (and lots of competitors).
Now let's look down the list a little bit until we find the high demand items. Typically for any profession, the consumables are where the money is. Since the majority of blacksmithing's recipes are going to be gear, I'll save you the time and tell you the consumables you want to focus on:
- Eternal belt buckle
- Titanium shield spike
- Titanium weapon chain
- All the skeleton keys
- All the enchanting rods
Making profits on the buy side
Learning to increase your average sell price is hard, and beyond the scope of this post. You can, however, always make more profits by buying lower priced mats. The tried and true methods for this are to advertise in trade chat, however if you simply post a "WTB x [cheap], pst" you'll probably meet limited success. Most people responding to trade WTBers are looking to sell for more money that we're willing to spend. Also, even when it's really cheap, it's usually a one time thing. Your best bet is to advertise something like "Looking for miners, pst" and to everyone who sends you a tell, ask them whether they'd be willing to farm saronite (or cobalt, or whatever) for you, and how much they would charge. Tell them it would be a long term cash on delivery relationship, that you collect mail twice a day, and you tip for large batches.
[Image credit: Flickr]
Being an auctioneer is like being able to print money. Or gold, as it were. Wait, that doesn't make sense... you can print on gold, but you can't print gold. That would be closer to transmutation? I can transmute titanium, but that's only worth it if the price of saronite is low enough to justify the time spent making it. I need some sort of analogy here. Whatever, I'll figure it out later. Making gold? Every week, Gold Capped will teach you the tricks of the trade. From setting up your auction addons and user interface, to cross faction arbitrage, to learning how to use your tradeskills.
Filed under: Gold Capped






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Eston Feb 20th 2010 4:13PM
Every time I see a Gold Capped article I get excited, but I still haven't learned anything new yet.
Skippy Feb 20th 2010 4:16PM
This is only the 2nd article you know. Patience is a virtue.
Noah Feb 20th 2010 4:42PM
See? Look, you just learned something. :)
Merkavar Feb 20th 2010 6:22PM
yeah i think ive tried all this before. maybe my server is just wierd but if i want to invst time to make gold i still think the best thing is dailies. It gurenteed income. ive tried collecting mats and the profit i get for the time invested isnt normally good enough .
Methuus Feb 20th 2010 6:44PM
Well, there aren't any real secrets. It generally boils down to:
Find some item that you can craft that meets the following criteria:
1. The mats to craft the item are readily available on the AH.
2. The item sells fairly frequently on the AH.
3. The mats cost less than the item sells for.
There, just buy mats, craft item, sell. Repeat as long as the criteria remain true and you get to gold cap. Having several items that meet the criteria cuts down the time required, of course.
What is really being covered in this column seems to be more about how to make the process I've described as efficient as possible.
Ben Lewis Feb 20th 2010 4:25PM
I like the picture of Rossi blacksmithing up there.
Darasen Feb 20th 2010 4:25PM
I had never heard of the workshop add-on. thanks for the tip.
Rasman Feb 20th 2010 4:32PM
I'll have to check out the LilSparky's Workshop addon, I have a lot of profession alts that just kinda sit there right now, but I'm on the AH all the time, selling enchanting mats I pickup from dungeons, so I could really get some more work in on this stuff this way. Thx for the heads up, a Gold Capped dedicated to JUST add-ons that help would be AWESOME to see.
Ominous Feb 20th 2010 4:38PM
"you absolutely must have auctioneer installed"
You can say a lot of things, but don't spew the party line. You don't need it. It is not a "must have". There are plenty of light-weight addons that can be used in cash generation to a far greater degree. You must, because you use it. Not having used auction addons, a beginner might want to choose something more efficient. Have a look at Kripparrian's YouTube Channel, for starters.
Tordenflesk Feb 20th 2010 4:56PM
Many "required" gold-king addons hook into auctioneer, so without it you won't get much use of KTQ, Skillet LSW etc.
Bronwyn Feb 21st 2010 1:09PM
Thanks for your useless comment. I'm really sick of people talking about how auctioneer is so bad and there are better addons out there..
And then they don't mention them. Thanks for pointing me to a youtube channel- I'm not going to give it more views, though, on the off chance that it has the information I'd like.
Soldinn Feb 20th 2010 4:59PM
I still prefer Auctionator over Auctioneer. Auctioneer is nice don't get me wrong, but it does too much in my opinion, I never use half the things it gives me. Auctionator is a nice small addon and does exactly what I want it to.
Razorlution Feb 20th 2010 4:59PM
I like Auctionator
karatheya Feb 20th 2010 5:19PM
What's the reasoning behind crafting keys? Unlike the rest of the consumables, they require Blacksmithing to use, and the same level of skill to craft as to use.
Is there that much of a market for people who have blacksmithing but don't want to use mats they've farmed or purchased?
Some of them are great leveling items (Titanium in particular), but I've got nearly a hundred sitting on one character because they never jumped out as anything that another person would buy.
Eddy Feb 20th 2010 7:02PM
I believe the keys were used by people who weren't engineers or rogues to break into locked chests in instances. There aren't really any locked chests in instances anymore, so keys have fallen out of use.
Banic Rhys Feb 20th 2010 9:08PM
Don't you need to be a blacksmith to use those keys anyway? So what's the point of selling them if the on;y people who use them can make a Deathwing load of them (see wut I did thar) for a tiny price.
trefpoid Feb 20th 2010 5:31PM
auctioneer light is awesome IMO
d_brinson68 Feb 20th 2010 5:47PM
my bank alt got auctioneer instealed and it great course its gonna be broke for a week every new patch but big deal
most of the gold capped players have all prfessions covered and seel alot of items to everbody flasks, belt bucklers, gems, scrolls, glyphs, bags, purple gear it sells and just keep doing that over time
Rob Feb 22nd 2010 10:35AM
Wow, just....wow.
steak Mar 17th 2010 1:37PM
spell check isle wtf did he say no really i didnt understand it