AddOn Spotlight: Battle of the Bags

Stuff. We sure do have a lot of it. Sometimes it's important stuff. Other times it's fairly stupid stuff that somehow accumulates over years. Somethings we just cannot throw away. This week on AddOn Spotlight, we dive into what makes our stuff manageable, from tabards and weapons to gems and ores. This week's Spotlight features addons, sure, but we will be grouping these addons by philosophy, not necessarily function. Let's roll.
Inventory management is a topic that will never die as long as we have stuff in World of Warcraft. Few addon categories contain individual addons that serve very similar functions but have wildly different philosophies surrounding their implementation. Inventory and bag management addons are some of the most useful, complicated and customizable addons in all of World of Warcraft. Having that type of freedom means you can lose yourself in the configuration. Bag addons range from the simple and plug-and-play to the robust and deep. Your mileage definitely may vary, so choose appropriately!
Before we jump in to taking a look at bag addons, I wanted to make a statement about a certain feature that I feel is essential. The ability to search your bags through text is invaluable. I give higher praise to a bag addon that allows you to search. There is nothing more convenient than being able to do a simple word search for the item you need in case it is not readily apparent where it is.
We will discuss three different types of bag addon philosophies in this article: one bag, one bag plus and inventory management.
One Bag
One Bag inventory addons are fairly descriptive in their function -- these addons turn your multiple bags into a window of all of your items, usually highlighted by color of item quality. Single bag inventories are simple creatures for the most part. Installing a one bag inventory does just what it advertises and leaves you with a large panel showing your items.OneBag3 and Bagnon are the prominent one bag inventory addons. OneBag3 gives you a simple interface and simple options when dealing with your one bag. You can set the number of columns to make your inventory the size and shape that you want as well as the UI scale. Bagnon has a great feature that can highlight quest items, making them very easy to spot. OneBag3 or Bagnon are both good choices for your first one bag addon, especially if you like fire and forget addons -- the basic set up that you get when you install either package works well. OneBag3 has some excellent coloring options as well. In addition, the extra addons part of the OneBag3 and Bagnon provide good solutions for your bank and keyring as one bags themselves.
Bagnon is also searchable, which I like. There is a very nice search syntax available to the user and summarized on the Curse page, so if you're interested in anything but simple search strings, take a look.
OneBag3 - Download at [Curse] or [WoWInterface]
Bagnon - Download at [Curse] or [WoWInterface]
One Bag Plus
The second category I am calling One Bag Plus because of the single pane nature of the addon combined with a secondary sorting system like tabs. The "Plus" nature of these bag addons add a new layer of complexity and customization that makes navigating a single pane inventory a little easier.Combuctor is my addon on choice in this category. WoW.com talked about Combuctor a long time ago, but I think it deserves a second go. Combuctor is the refined and advanced version of Bagnon. So why, then, would I recommend Bagnon as well? Simple -- if you do not want the options and the customization available in Combuctor, I would stay with Bagnon or OneBag3.

I like Combuctor a lot -- the single pane plus side tabs allows for easy navigation with larger inventory icons. Enter the options for Combuctor and you can set the tabs on the side that you want shown. It is as simple as that. In addition, Combuctor has search functionality and the ability to choose which tabs you have visible. The item quality circles on the bottom left of the addon allow you to choose what quality item you want to be viewing, and the entire addon is couched in Blizzard bordering and art, making it a nice addition to many basic user interface components. The search functionality can also be used to look for item slot, item type or just the item's name.

Combuctor also searches through your inventory based on the bag type. If you are an enchanter, for example, you can select the "Trade" bags at the bottom of the addon to only show what is in your enchanting bag. For crafters in general, I think Combuctor has many good options and little tweaks that can make finding materials easy. Finally, using the Bagnon modules like Bagnon Forever allow you to view your alts' inventories as well, making sure you never lose track of your items across characters.
Combuctor is by no means the only bag addon to fall into this category -- it is just a personal favorite recommendation.
Combuctor - Download at [Curse] or [WoWInterface]
Inventory Management
Inventory management systems are the cream of the crop. These addons offer increased customization while being harder to configure. Combuctor, discussed above, does the job and does it right for most people. If you are like me and you like having everything your very own way, then it might be time to sit down, take some time reading over simple rule syntax, and get yourself a robust inventory management system. We will be discussing virtual bag mod ArkInventory. Baggins is another choice for a virtual bag inventory, but I am personally a fan of ArkInventory more so, as I enjoy the greater flexibility.ArkInventory is a virtual bag mod. Virtual bags are just areas of the screen that have rules applied to them, like "All gray items go here" or "Quest items go here." ArkInventory allows you to customize and create these rules, and then add rules to bags so that everything sorts for you as you want it to. For instance, creating a category in ArkInventory for "Potions" would require you to select the category that ArkInventory categorizes a potion as and have that sorted to one of the virtual bags, or create a rule for potions (i.e. search for all items with the name potion in them) and sort that query appropriately. Let me show you my ArkInventory so you get an idea of what I mean.

My inventory is set up to have my miscellaneous items in the far right bag, gear set items, grays, tabards and tradeskill items on the bottom row and class items, food, potions and quest items on the top, arranged into virtual bags. It's a system that works for me and was not too difficult to set up.
Here are some quick ArkInventory tips.
- You can set the category ArkInventory sees an item as by going into edit mode (the gear on the upper right part of the addon) and left clicking any item. This will bring up the classification menu, where you can set what ArkInventory sees an item as. For instance, my tabards are under a unique self-created heading called Tabards which I assigned to them and then sorted into bag 2 (not all tabards have tabard in the name, wanted to exclude other 'shirt' type items, etc.).
- You can create a rule for a bag to add items in a set as denoted by Blizzard's equipment manager. My bag 4 is any gear in Set-Tank or Set-DPS, and it accordingly moves that gear into bag 4 when I swap sets. The syntax for the rule looks something like: The rule: outfit( outfitname1, outfitname2 ) and then add that rule to a bag.
- ArkInventory is very robust, and reading the wiki can help greatly.
ArkInventory - Download at [Curse] or [WoWInventory]
So there you have it. Three distinct types of inventory addons ranging from the simplest to the more complex. ArkInventory is still my preferred inventory addon, despite running a little heavier than the other addons, because I have been using my setup for so long and spent the time putting it together. Again, play around. See what you like. I did not talk about a wealth of other bag addons here today, and I am sure the comments will light up with people's suggestions, which is awesome. Share the wealth and spread the word about your favorite bags. OneBag3, Combuctor and Bagnon however had the best 'out of box' experience for me, and I think a good amount of people value that immensely. The inventory is a crucial part of your gameplay experience, so why not invest a little time and effort into making your stuff have a nice home to live in?
Addons are what we do on Addon Spotlight. Have you ever really thought about how many things Automaton could do for you? You'd save a million, billion hours. Maybe. And remember, Addon Spotlight is fueled by viewers like you, so if you have a mod you think we should take a look at, send Mat an e-mail! Filed under: Add-Ons, AddOn Spotlight






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
Gridpoet Mar 4th 2010 5:04PM
I prefer Bagnon for my bag needs... its clean, effective and light....
Edge Mar 4th 2010 6:10PM
I like the idea of combuctor but man I got rid of the default Blizzard scheme for a reason. I use Bagnon and it's really great, especially at looking at your alts inventory from the last login as well as your bank and for searching. To organize I just let MrPlow take care of it, not the greatest at organizing but it does ok.
elstor Mar 4th 2010 6:29PM
TBag wins, and always will. If its giving you errors there is a fix someone developed for it...
Mognet T Mar 4th 2010 7:22PM
I've always preferred Bagnon, with Jpack to sort things for me.
Bohijucka Mar 4th 2010 9:22PM
i've tried almost all bag addons available and bagnon was indeed the best.
Jamie Mar 4th 2010 9:36PM
I like the default UI look so unless its for something the default UI doesn't provide I rarely get addons which remove that look.
Anyways, I tried ArkInventory a while back and I found it overly complex, after reading this article and the original comment posters comments I tried Bagnon and I'm very happy with Bagnon, thanks guys :)
Mourne Mar 4th 2010 9:40PM
I've always been a fan of Bagnon, and it's never let me down. Eventually I added a bag and bank sorter (I think called Bankstack). I think, however, that it's time to try out something new, and Ark sounds like the way to go. Can always switch back, right?
FlameFlash Mar 5th 2010 8:27AM
Bagnon for the win!
csarcops Mar 4th 2010 5:08PM
I'm still sticking with Baud Bag, it does just what I need.
Thomas Mar 4th 2010 5:13PM
Yeah, Baud Bag get my vote also. I have used it for a long time.
Ragen Mar 4th 2010 6:49PM
I really can't play without Baud Manifest:
It would be in the invetory managment section, as it puts everything in a neat little list that can be auto catagorized. The list is color coded of course.
hduckie18 Mar 4th 2010 8:03PM
Vote for baudbag here. I like how it can keep the skin of your normal bags. I also like how you can choose to not let it affect your bank or the guild bank, which is a very nice feature.
Truffled Mar 4th 2010 5:10PM
TBag needs to be mentioned in the Inventory Management section. It works a lot like Ark, but I prefer it, even with it's lol-able name. ^_^
http://wow.curse.com/downloads/wow-addons/details/tbag-shefki.aspx
http://www.wowinterface.com/downloads/info7244-TBag-Shefki.html
Finnicks Mar 4th 2010 5:30PM
Seconded.
jontombarnhart Mar 4th 2010 5:35PM
Plus one for Tbag. The interface just looks so clean.
Oscar Mar 4th 2010 5:53PM
I love TBag been using it for a few years now it's great
slunk Mar 4th 2010 5:57PM
TBag is by far the best bag mod around. It auto sorts everything into logical groups. You can modify the groups if you like, but there is truly no reason to do so. It works great out of the box.
cmichaelcooper Mar 4th 2010 6:04PM
I agree as well. T-Bag is not often updated, but it still works, and has an intuitive, logical item sorting configuration right out of the box. ArkInventory is great if you want to take the time learning syntax, but if you just want one window of stuff separated logically from the start, T-Bag is the way to go.
Nick Mar 4th 2010 8:49PM
I can't imagine using anything other than tbag. As an addon poweruser, I've tried many different bag mods, but this one tops all for me.'
Intelligent one bag autosorting, search function, and viewing other charaters inventories and banks, all without the need to configure it at all, but the ability to do so if you desire, is all I could ask for.
JustinM Mar 4th 2010 10:09PM
@cmichaelcooper
Funny you should say that...it just got an update today!
I use TBag (Shefki's version) and wouldn't switch even if you paid me to.