Drama Mamas: Overpulling your love life

Most of the troubled souls who write in to Drama Mamas already know the steps they should take to free themselves from their predicaments. They simply want to hear their conscience speak aloud, to come face to face with the writing on the wall. Things are no different this week for lovelorn correspondent A Troubled Tank. Although his plea for help is more eloquent than most, his sticky situation (and subsequent avoidance of the issues he lays out with clarity and precision) is all too familiar.
Dearest and Revered Mamas of the Drama, This warrior finds himself in the prickliest of predicaments. On the server Earth, my main is a pretty normal dude; what is relevant is that he is in a relationship. My alt in Azeroth is getting him into trouble, however.
Viewed as objectively as possible, my main relationship is a good one. However, it leaves me feeling unsatisfied. The problems of the relationship, which do not bear additional mentioning, are primarily external to the relationship. That is, if whoever runs the Earth server would nerf various things, it would be rather good. However, context and circumstance delegate it to a troublesome bore.
Enter my alt's crush on a guildie. She is beautiful, charming, funny, intelligent and never bugs, scolds or annoys me. O would that she would reside in my zone, or one neighbouring mine! Yet alas, she resides on a foreign coast. She who is of relationship ilevel 277 is beyond my reach. Nonetheless, I daresay she adores me. Though as a warrior my Intellect is low, even I can tell she is my perfect match.
What's worse, my guildie crush is unaware that I am seeing someone. Our friendship started innocently enough, but soon it was clear that we fit like a tank and a healer. My Earth server girlfriend and I are like two DPS, laboring in a 30-minute queue. My alt's heart's desire completes my set bonus.
I have not the Eagle Eyes to know what the Light would have me do. On the one hand, my Earth relationship is not a total train wreck and may be worth salvaging; furthermore, it would take many moons (even astride my epic mount) to even reach the place where my Azerothian flower sets her hearthstone. All the same, my Earth counterpart does not make me feel like a credit to the raid, whereas my Azerotherian dearest, in her sublime grace, drains my rage bar even when it is at its fullest.
I am between a kobold and a hard place. I don't want to give up on IRL girl because it is only external circumstances which stand between us, but I would gladly roll a 1 on every Need roll until the end of time to be with my Azerothian partner. Furthering the difficulty is the fact that I know my Azerothian lady is ignorant of my Earth relationship, and I fear -- a fear so strong it may be broken by neither Berserker Rage nor trinket -- that she will, contra my pure intentions, feel misled if I inform her that I am already soulbound. What's worse, enmity between us might cause drama amongst the guild. Light forbid it! I know not what course to take.
I prithee, O Ladies most knowledgeable of Drama, weigh in with your sage advice. Consult whatever unsavory oracle you must, so that I may know the way and the path. Yours sincerely, A Troubled Tank

Do not mock your own meager Intellect, Sir Tank, for you have obviously made several accurate assessments of these encounters. A few observations are in order, however, regarding the strategies you've chosen to apply.
"My main relationship is a good one. However, it leaves me feeling unsatisfied." Surely a warrior of your stature has some measure of control over his encounters. You pulled, yet you remain on auto-attack? You allow environmental effects to control your reactions and those of your target? This is sheer neglect to the matter at hand. Position your pull, and engage your skills and abilities. This is not a trash mob, and your reliance on auto-attack is simply inexcusable.
"Context and circumstance delegate (my current relationship) to a troublesome bore." No instance is as exciting on the 300th run. It is your enthusiasm for sharing the adventure with your groupmate, along with engaging in the encounter by using more than auto-attack, that will keep you logging in. The alternative is logging out -- admittedly, a potentially difficult move. Nonetheless, the choice stands clearly before you.
"She is beautiful, charming, funny, intelligent and never bugs, scolds or annoys me." Even Lady Vashj appears beautiful before the first casts of Entangle and Shock Blast. It's all about proximity, Sir Tank. The perspective will change considerably once you're actually tanking the target of your affections (and you'll be at a disadvantage, since you're already taking considerable damage over time from heedlessly standing in the fire)."What's worse, my guildie crush is unaware that I am seeing someone." An appalling lack of crowd control.
"My Earth server girlfriend and I are like two DPS, laboring in a 30-minute queue." Two DPS? 30 minutes? The world is your cherry. Why do you remain sitting glumly in Dalaran, stuffing your face with Aimee's tasty treats while dreaming of imaginary dungeons? Many Achievements await you, if only you'll take flight.
"I don't want to give up on IRL girl because it is only external circumstances which stand between us." That, plus the extra encounter you pulled, eh? Still, you have a point about the environmental hazards. Pop your trinkets, make a Last Stand and get to work clearing the trash.
"Furthering the difficulty is the fact that I know my Azerothian lady is ignorant of my Earth relationship, and I fear ... that she will, contra my pure intentions, feel misled if I inform her that I am already soulbound." Indeed, the damage is done. You have pulled two encounters at once. There's no resetting this. Time to man up, Shield Wall and soak whatever damage you've got coming to you.
"What's worse, enmity between us might cause drama amongst the guild." Quite true. Guilds generally dislike tanks who overpull and then stand listlessly adrift. The longer you allow these mobs to run free with no crowd control, the worse this situation will become.
Troubled Tank, I'll be frank: You've been caught auto-attacking while streaming pr0n during the boss fight. It's time to engage with what's actually in front of you right now. You're going to have to turn off the virtual entertainment -- definitely your long-distance flirtation, and probably your gaming for a time, as well -- and focus on what you've already pulled. That encounter will stand or fall on its own merit, but you cannot avoid engaging. Good luck prioritizing it all, but I suspect you'll be just fine. I think you already know what to do.

Drama Mama Robin: Mama Robin enters her library and walks toward her cabinet of scrolls and artifacts. She is disturbed by the images in her mind, conjured up by reading Troubled Tank's missive. She chooses two scrolls of Empathy and her Magic Mirror and then sits in her comfy chair.
Robin focuses her mind on the location of Troubled Tank's Earth lover and summons forth a view of the lady while casting Empathy. Now in tune with the feelings of the lover, the Drama Mama searches for the ones regarding the Tank. As suspected, the Earth lover wishes she could live in a magical world with no physical constraints and where wealth is easily achieved. No chores to do except dailies, no schedule to keep except raids and no messes to clean up except perhaps the ones in her inventory. In a world without worries, a relationship with her Tank would be heavenly. But instead, the inconveniences, annoyances and obstacles of the physical world require mundane realities. The Earth lover wishers her warrior would focus on helping to tank these external problems, so that she does not have to nag him and they could live something close to a fantasy existence. She suspects but is not certain that she is no longer the one upon whom her warrior spends his dreams and longings.
Enough. Robin clears the Magic Mirror with an impatient wave, then wipes a tear from her eye. She changes her focus to the Azerothian lover and re-casts Empathy. First thing she sees is that, unlike her avatar, her Earth persona is not physically perfect. She also has some idiosyncracies and annoying habits, as does any other Earth human. This is not surprising, but these are realities that never make it to Azeroth. Robin searches this lover's feelings and also finds no surprises. She is in love with an idealized version of the Tank and is unaware of the annoyances his Earth lover must deal with on a daily basis. She also trusts that she is his only love in Azeroth or Earth and has no idea of the warrior's lies.
Mama Robin clears the mirror and begins to formulate her suggestion. Regardless of what she says and what the warrior does, there will be suffering. Robin speaks:
Warrior, you must choose a lover. Your physical difficulties in reaching your Azerothian lady should not factor in your decision, as it is not fair to the one with whom you currently share your responsibilities and troubles. If you decide that your feelings for the Azerothian Lady are real, then you should leave your Earth lady, taking care to make sure all properties and lingering issues are distributed fairly -- assuming a greater burden onto yourself, as you are the one who has gone astray. If you decide that the Azerothian Lady is delightful, but that you wish to bring the fantasy back to your Earth romance; then you must take Drama Mama Lisa's advice and exit Azeroth until you have rebuilt your foundation with your current love. You are a strong, creative warrior and I am sure that you will do well along whichever path you choose. Though the journey will be arduous, the rewards will eventually be great and your honor will be regained.
Filed under: Drama Mamas
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 4 of 6)
Shevek Mar 26th 2010 2:59PM
Make your real life relationship work by getting off the fake one. It is not worth giving up the real thing for a "crush". You actually think your crush would want to still be around you after knowing you're actually with someone? The fact that she doesn't know and here you are spouting she is a "soul mate" means you don't even know her enough to make such a claim.
Respect your R/L relationship first before you run off with someone on a video game.
Bad form.
Gimmlette Mar 26th 2010 2:59PM
It's not that unusual. I know of a handful of people for whom the avatar in the raid becomes the persona they are smitten with. I'm sure it's happened in Everquest and Guild Wars.
This, however, is the best advice on handling this I've read. Guild members like to confide in me. I'm going to do my best to remember this and spread Lisa and Robin's wise advice to those in this predicament.
Bravo, ladies.
Kalier Mar 26th 2010 4:33PM
I agree that it really does seem people online only see the avatar as the person behind the computer. I can't count the number of times that people are surprised when I get on Vent that I'm a guy. I have a vast majority of female characters because they tend to look better in gear than the males that look like they are bench pressing drakes to keep from roid rageing.
Okay fighting off ADD now and on to my comments of the article. :D
I really enjoyed the format as you can't find many people willing to RP and since this is a wow related site it's refreshing to see. I wish circumstances were better for Troubled Tank but he truely needs to examine his relationships to see what problems he can expect from both relationships and if he can correct the problems or at least find means around them that don't anger whichever partner he seeks to be with.
If you decide you want an open relationship where you have the freedom to see others then don't be surprised to lose both partners. Changeing the rules of a relationship in the middle of it is never an easy thing to do/hear and can be disastorous. As of right now whichever you choose you will have to beg forgiveness for you have wronged both parties and in the end depending on the circumstances you may find forgiveness but don't for the love of Azeroth/Earth expect forgiveness to be owed to you.
I hope to see more articles in this fomat but I'll be happy probably with any future article since I tend to agree with the advice given as it is. It also helps that others can elaborate on the advice and offer their own experiences through the comments.
Kroof Mar 26th 2010 11:23PM
The RP writing on both ends was entertaining, ha ha, good times.
On the other hand, I think it was not a good choice to ask for relationship advice (or give it) in a way that isn't exactly clear.
He's not telling you everything, (external issues?) so you couldn't give him exact advice.
I'd rather see a "Hark unto you poor lad. Okay, that is out of our system. What you need to do is figure out whether or not you are willing to work on your relationship right now. Keeping in mind that this wonder woman from across the world may not be quite as awesome when you're waking up every morning to bad breath and stepping on her toe nail clippings. Find someone you care enough about that things like fixing toilet disasters or putting out stove fires is perfectly okay with you."
Mike Mar 26th 2010 3:14PM
Sir Tank, you owe it to yourself to independantly evaluate your real life relationship. If external circumstances make your relationship not worth while, maybe its the wrong one for you. Take your Azerothian darling out of the equation. Is your relationship , as it is, worth keeping, if not, make that decision, without considering whats better out there. If you choose to end real life relationship, by all means, pursue your virtual sweetie, but then tell her you just broke up with a real girl, and give her the chance to evaluate YOU honesly. Your own behavior here hasn't been entirely honorable, it happens sometimes, we get caught up. But now, its time to make decisions and not wait, there are real feelings at stake for all parties. Good Luck, to all of you.
Gemini Mar 26th 2010 3:21PM
I think I just threw up a little in my mouth. I was going back and forth between groaning and laughing every 2 seconds.
I think the joke got overdone.
channingr Mar 26th 2010 4:05PM
stupid....get a life you dork
Galaden Mar 26th 2010 4:07PM
Violent passions have violent ends.
Grovinofdarkhour Mar 26th 2010 4:07PM
Need clarity on a couple things.
"Enter my alt's crush on a guildie. She is beautiful, charming, funny, intelligent and never bugs, scolds or annoys me." Most of these adjectives could apply equally to the R-L person or the I-G toon. But not "beautiful". Are you describing the person (seen pictures, had webchats etc.), or only their avatar? If you don't yet know for sure that you're physically attracted to the RL person the entire conversation is a non-starter.
"She who is of relationship ilevel 277 is beyond my reach." Are you saying she's married, or just referring to your strong feelings toward her? Sometimes the gamer code is hard to decipher.
Answers to these notwithstanding, my first instinct is to tell you that any form of straying is merely a symptom. This has nothing to do with the guildie and everything do with your RL relationship, and trying to put the apple and the orange on the scales to see which is better is a really bad place to start from. A partner is not gear you should be looking to upgrade. Evaluate the RL relationship in a bubble - on its own merits, not comparing it to anything external - and decide what you want to do with it. When something is broken, it needs to be repaired, or discarded. The choice is entirely yours.
Only once you've not only made that decision, but taken action on it as well, should you decide a next course of action. Finally I must advise that if you throw away what you've got for something you MIGHT get, and end up not getting it, and are left with neither... you'll be kicking yourself for a long, long time.
Newbie McNewb Mar 26th 2010 4:23PM
"Beautiful" isn't a word used only to describe physical appearance =)
Grovinofdarkhour Mar 26th 2010 4:29PM
I fully get that, but it did seem pretty clear to me he meant physically since he made a point of giving specific, separate mention to several other qualities that would also contribute to "big-b" Beautiful.
droknar Mar 26th 2010 4:26PM
As someone who has lived in a relationship for nearly 12 years where health, finances, and 'external circumstances' have stagnated it to the point of nonexistence, I need to reiterate some things that have already been said.
Given the 'dream woman' without a care in a virtual world and the cess pit that is real life, anyone will pick the 'dream woman' if it were true.
But it isn't. It never is. I dated my wife for 3 years before marrying her, and despite that time still didn't see some of the habits and little things that would start to eat at me nearly 9 years later. Life sucks. That's why people escape to virtual worlds, or go for long bike rides in the hills. To escape. At some point, though, you have to come right back to reality. You may go get your 'dream woman,' then realize that she only showers once a week, never saves any money and refuses to lift a finger to assist you with those 'external' circumstances.
You have to fight to save relationships. You have to fight to maintain relationships, and you have to fight to make those relationships flourish. Take it from someone in one where mutual apathy has deteriorated it to a husk of what it once was.
Evaluate what *you're* doing for your RL relationship, not what your significant other is. And if you decide to move to greener pastures, realize that wherever you go, there's gonna be piles of 'external circumstances.' No one is perfect, no situation is perfect.
metrocake Mar 30th 2010 12:43PM
My dear,
You also owe it to yourself to get out of what sounds like an incredibly bad relationship. I've had to do it. My husband has had to do it. It's difficult, but in the end, will be so much more rewarding for you...
Spellotape Mar 26th 2010 4:28PM
It seems like people are sympathising with the letter-writer merely because he put his words "eloquently". He is misleading someone online by behaving like he is free and available, and he's misleading someone he's in a relationship with already by pretending he is loyal.
Be honest and stop acting like it's a game - people's real feelings are involved.
Cataca Mar 26th 2010 5:28PM
"Be honest and stop acting like it's a game - people's real feelings are involved"
Yeah, he did the nerdy move of wording his problem into gaming terms but I wouldn't say that he is acting like it's a game.
He wouldn't be writing in the first place if he didn't have serious concerns and conflicting emotions.
It's all too easy to fall into a very uncomfortable place when you meet someone you like. You can't help who you like, but you can control your actions. His actions may not have been the best. Him seeking advise sounds like he knows this and is trying to fix his mistakes.
So I sympathize with that because he seems like he is trying. If he went about flaunting his misleading behavior then he would deserve a swift kick to the head but that doesn't seem to be the case here.
Spellotape Mar 28th 2010 2:30PM
I'm not sure how writing this letter in the style he did to an advice column in a popular blog doesn't count as flaunting it. Similarly, that he exhibits any sort of we-could-be-together behaviour towards his online crush is kind of flaunting his non-existent availability. Part of what makes me critical of his actions is that he isn't available and I'm guessing the reason he hasn't told her he's with someone is because he very well knows that it's completely unacceptable to lead someone on in this fashion.
I hope the responses to this article help him stand up and be honest, which is really the only thing he can do if he cares about either of the women he's misleading.
Caelvah Mar 26th 2010 6:04PM
I must say, i was impressed, like everyone else, with the eloquence of both the 'Troubled Tank' and the Drama Mamas. I hope he manages to resolve it without too much drama. - Cae
Precaution Mar 26th 2010 4:36PM
Don't forget... Physical attraction does play in. Is your IRL girlfriend a jerk, but smokin' hot?
Do you know what your online connection looks like outside of game?
People like to think that personality and intelligence are all that matters, which I half agree with. But physical attraction has to be a part of it too.
frosstbyte Mar 26th 2010 4:33PM
Lots of people seem impressed with your purple prose. I'm not. It's a pretty obvious defense mechanism. By couching the situation in those terms, you've added a bunch of tongue in cheek barriers between yourself and the other people (especially your actual girlfriend) involved. I'm not sure I would've responded to your RP nonsense with more RP nonsense, since I think it encourages you to maintain that level of separation you're so desperately clinging to. This isn't a game for at least one of the people, and heaps of flowery language should not be used to lessen the impact it's having on your life and her life.
That said, Lisa is 100% correct. You need to disengage from the game and the guildy right quick. The most important reason for this is that your girlfriend definitely knows something is up and can definitely tell that your attention is elsewhere and, simply put, that's not fair to anyone. Turn off your computer, suck it up and talk to her. If you guys can't resolve your issues, then decide if pining after someone thousands of miles away is worth your time and energy.
Cataca Mar 26th 2010 6:26PM
His description of the situation and of his emotions where as you say "Purple Prose" and over the top. This is a very serious situation and he act so.
Given that, I would say to lighten up a bit. This is a gaming site so discussing relationship issues is a rare occasion. If (like many of others that frequent this site) WoW is a major part of your life, you may turn to others within the community here for help. And he has done so. The mere act of him seeking advise shows that he knows his actions have not been the best. That he has conflicting emotions of what to do.
The decision to write in Purple Prose gave his problem entertainment value. Not only did it probably sway the Drama's attention to address his actions and conflicting emotions, but it gave him a creative outlet to think about what to consider himself. I wouldn't call adding tongue in cheek terms "barriers" or "couching the situation" at all, merely an attempt to get his story to stand out. And by doing so is actually creating a target to draw attention to his problem instead of trying to soften or hide it. I commend him actually, it takes more courage to write for advise than it does to pretend everything your doing is ok.
If he was treating his problem as a game, he wouldn't have these emotions. He'd be playing his "game" with his two women grinning happily, not worrying over what to do.