Gold Capped: Making money with jewelcrafting

Hi folks, this week we'll be going over jewelcrafting. Making money with jewelcrafting can be a challenge, but it's a rewarding one. In fact, very few professions have as much earning potential as this one does. We'll start with the easy part: if you have a jewelcrafter, where's the low hanging fruit? I like to call this "reactive" profits. Anything where you can get a fixed income sort of profit for minimal effort, but you can't grind falls into this category for me. Alchemy has daily epic gem transmutes, mining used to have a daily Titansteel cooldown, tailoring has a bag cooldown, etc. What does jewelcrafting have?
Low hanging fruit
As Michael mentioned in a recent Insider Trader, each and every day, jewelcrafters can do the jewelcrafting daily quest. This will reward them with a Dalaran Jewelcrafter's Token, which can be turned in for a variety of recipes or a Dragon's Eye, which is importantly cut by jewelcrafters into their better than average epic gems. This means that, just like regular epic gems, Dragon's Eyes are a raid consumable of sorts, and will be purchased every time a jewelcrafter upgrades certain pieces of gear.If you are looking for easy money, cooldown style, this is the closest it gets. Each jewelcrafting daily, in addition to the smallish amount of gold you get for doing the quest, rewards you with a highly sought after commodity that you can choose to turn into gold immediately. On many servers, Dragon's Eyes sell for hundreds of gold.
That fruit at the top of the tree
Of course, the alternative is to not use your tokens for gold, but for those recipes I mentioned before. There are pros and cons for each side. If you "take the money and run", you're guaranteeing yourself a decent return on the 10 minutes you spend flying to and hearthing back from the daily quest. If you buy a recipe, however, you could use it to make more than that over the long run! This is "proactive" profiteering. You have to make a conscious effort to squeeze profits from the ability to cut a gem, but there's no artificial limit on your volume, like there is for selling Dragon's Eyes.If you want to know whether there's a recipe that's worth it, you'll need to do some research. Ideally you'd have a clear idea of what you can realistically buy the uncut gems for, an idea of what the cut gem goes for, and some sort of clue about how much demand there is for a cut. If you had all this info, you could make a very well informed decision about whether those tokens are worth more as gold in your hand now, or as the ability to cut a gem. Unfortunately, this information is probably harder to get than it's worth. I don't know of any easy way to export Auctioneer data to a file, and unless you happen to have Market Watcher installed and are storing the historic prices of all the gem cuts you're interested in (which, by the way, would probably be a ridiculous amount of memory and not nearly as helpful as it sounds), you're going to have to guestimate it.
Some very useful data about gems can be found at the WoW Gem Finder, a nifty little site that lets you filter gems by basically any statistic, as well as WoW-Popular list of gems. Assume that the most popular gems will be the lowest margin, but if you look at what they're selling for on a Tuesday night, you'll see whether it's worth the competition. Also, some of the lower volume gems (the annoying off color ones we need to socket to activate our meta gems, for example) can sell at very nice margin when your competition forgets to keep theirs for sale on the auction house.
Don't forget to look at the meta gems! These days, everyone is so caught up in the trendy high volume epic cuts market that they forget that every time someone gets a helm upgrade, they need to get a meta gem. If you have access to a friendly alchemist (ideally a transmute specialized one), you can transmute uncut meta gems out of base mats. From there, just look at that WoW-Popular link to see what people use.
Working the angles
Jewelcrafters all start somewhere. Specifically, at 1 skill. Getting from there to where they want to be is a long and, when done incorrectly, expensive prospect. How to do this profitably is another post, but today we'll talk about a big part of jewelcrafting's biggest money maker: Prospecting.This ability is the cornerstone of jewelcrafting, and is the main way that uncut gems enter the marketplace. Since there are a ton of places when you're on the way to 450 skill that you need uncut gems to level, the demand is quite naturally high. The angle is that regardless of the highest level ore you can prospect, there's money to be made prospecting lower level ores. Try out:
These can all be prospected into gems that may or may not sell for more than the ore you bought to make them. Take a look at the prospect tab on the Wowhead.com pages to get an idea of the yields, and then look up your uncut gem prices. If the yields times the gem prices are more than the ore, you're in the money. Some of these used to be so profitable that a single high demand, uncommon uncut gem would pay for the ore on its own, and the rest was all profit. There's a lot of management overhead in this business, however. You need spreadsheets, research, and constant buying and selling of a large quantity of different types of items.
As good as your tools
As always, your ability to play the AH profitably will depend on your tools. Addons and mods make the auctioneer! For this business, Auctioneer is (of course) very handy in that you can automate mass buying and selling of lots of types of product. Your snatch list should have all these ores on it with the threshold set to lower than what you make by selling the uncut gems. You can use appraiser to automatically mass post and price the gems. Don't forget, the demand for these are sporadic, but heavy. Every time a budding jewelcrafter makes their way through the ranks of old world mats, they will have to buy large quantities of gems. Even if your auctions are not the cheapest on the AH, they can still sell.Filed under: Economy, Gold Capped






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Ferdi Mar 31st 2010 7:06PM
I'm a new jewelcrafter myself, and it almost looks like JC is only rewarding if you've been one from the beginning of Wotlk since you can get all the recipes then. Daily quest to get one token seems a bit harsh for new JC' ers. Only prospecting looks good to make money, but the cutting self, takes a while till you have the recipes for all the gems that are needed. :)
Methuus Mar 31st 2010 7:14PM
Well, one thing you can do to offset the late starter disadvantage is to do research on which epic gem cuts sell well. Check out the AH, research what people are wearing, research what cuts are popular with what classes.
Getting all the cuts is pointless; many of them just have almost zero demand. But if you get the cuts that people want first, you can start making gold right away.
trefpoid Mar 31st 2010 7:15PM
I think that's the point.. you can't get everything so easily. I spent days researching for new glyphs and I must have bought about 40 glyph mastery books to learn every single glyph the game has.. it took me a long, long time, but i felt great when I finally had them all. The same goes for enchanting, I spent a lot of time disenchanting stuff to get me enough Dream Shards and learn all the recipes from the vendor. It feels nice not to get everything in a silver platter :D
Aloix Mar 31st 2010 8:00PM
I agree with the investment/reward+satisfaction. There can be/seem to be a bit of an entry barrier. I started JC a while ago on 1 toon shortly followed by a 2nd and then a 3rd. Partly to maximize my tokens, but I keep the profession on my main for the jeweler gems/stats as well.
I decided to go for 'all recipes' just to be a completionist (all epic cuts). Met that goal quite a while ago. Still do the dailies on all 3 toons.
Helps to have your own xmute spec alchemist or 2.
And, as always, Know Your Market.
Rob Mar 31st 2010 10:17PM
I did really well in JC just doing the blue quality gems and a handful of popular epic gems. I never really pushed the profession that hard. I didn't do metas all that often, I didn't obtain all the NR recipes, i never prospected for profit. I found in the beginning it was quite easy to make gold, but recently not all that much. If i were to do it now I'd explore all these options and keep doing the dailies. Don't forget you can buy titanium ore and damaged necks for tokens.
And also it greatly helps to be on a busy server. On one of my servers, there is 20 ppl in dalaran on average, on the other there are 100+. One server is a huge profit, the other i sell maybe two items out of hundreds a day. I'll let you guess which one.
Elwoods Apr 1st 2010 5:14AM
I make a nice bit of change with JC even though I dont have time to play the AH as much as I used to.
For me its Meta gems, Relentless, Ember, chaotic and insightful. I post 3 or 4 every evening before and after the popular raid times and I dont get many back.
KukroΩ Apr 2nd 2010 5:32PM
Perfect timing, I just came back after a break from wow (usually 1-2 months every year, this was 1 and a half) And this is what I am gonna need.
im99sam8 Mar 31st 2010 7:12PM
Bonus points for using the word guestimate.
Hollow Leviathan Mar 31st 2010 7:15PM
JCing is my least favorite profession to work for serious money, discounting BSing which I haven't gotten cappd yet. The very high deposit and very low demand for non-epic cuts leave a bad taste in my mouth, and the fact that cut gems do not stack in my bags was the final blow. I guess I just came too late to the game, where uncommon and rare quality gems are nearly worthless.
Aloix Mar 31st 2010 7:52PM
I don't really consider BS a moneymaking profession. I'm sure it can be for some, but I chose it just for the sockets.
JC on the other hand..gold and stats. Win/win.
Leviathon Mar 31st 2010 7:32PM
I love how I can buy a ton of epic gems every week with honor and just sell them at gouged prices every Tuesday and Wednesday :p
Oznak Mar 31st 2010 8:48PM
How did Icy Prisms not make your list of "low-hanging fruit"? After all, at the (now reduced) cost of one chalcedony, one shadow crystal, one dark jade, and a frozen orb, you now have a guarantee of getting a few rare gems, a chance at multiple epics, and a chance at the mentioned Dragon's Eyes. And you can do it EVERY DAY. What's not to love?
Babaloo Mar 31st 2010 9:29PM
I strongly recommend the addon Panda, which allows you to see every gem you know and it's price (in gold) in one screen. It's really simple to start making gems and you can clearly see which gems are more profitable (bought for more) on the AH. It works with Auctionator and most likely works with Auctioneer aswell. Hit it up on Curse or something.
Rodand Mar 31st 2010 10:05PM
I started JC on my druid because I liked the JC only gems you can use and seemed especially good for heals/tank dual spec. I do the dailies because they're quick (some days, that is all I have time to do, but they usually don't take more than 10 min).
Now that I have some cuts, I've been pleasantly surprised with the gold you cam make with minimal effort. Just hang out on eventide steps for a bit and you're sure to make 20 gold, and more often than not, 50-200 gold. JC has become my most consistent money maker. I'd probably earn a ton more if I played the AH.
TiM Apr 1st 2010 1:54AM
For jewelcrafting there are certain "givens" main stat gems for DPSers will always sell well(agi, ap, sp, str, hit, arpen) usually the cut version of these gems sell anywhere from 20 to 70 gold more than the uncut versions. Ametrines for DPs'er will also always sell well, as will 30 stam gems (tanks get upgrades too)
Also in regards to dragon's eyes. I didn't see it mentioned, but the nightmare tear is a good pattern to get. For a dragon's eye and 5 infinite dust you can turn around and sell that gem for 100 to 200 gold depending on your servers economy.
sjcpirate Apr 1st 2010 3:07AM
The recipe that brings me the most consistent sales are Solid Majestic Zircons. Tanks of all classes eat through these things like breakfast cereal.
Marc Apr 1st 2010 3:54AM
Definately use Panda for most (all?) professions, it saves so much time - something Blizzard should look into implementing into the game itself perhaps.
Ðøøm Apr 1st 2010 4:33AM
Can someone help me with the maths for prospecting?
If a gem prospects for example, fel iron:
18% Blood Garnet (1-2)
18% Deep Peridot (1-2)
18% Flame Spessarite (1-2)
Etc..
How do I work out the projected prospecting value?
Lets, for the sake of argument say that:
-Fel iron costs 5g for 5 to prospect
-Each Gem sells for 1g at the AH
Do I do (1*0.18)+(1*0.18)+(1*0.18) to work out the average propsecting price?
That makes sense but it would also be useful to know:
-The maximum possible profit
-The minimum possible profit
I'm trying to make a spreadsheet that I plug current AH values into and it works out what to prospect and how much i'm likely to make (if any)
Wordsworth Apr 1st 2010 4:59AM
it was most profitable to buy the recipes and sell the cuts but one thing to consider now, especially with those of us who already have the "main" recipes. . . is come cataclysm all these epic recipes will be worthless so any you buy now with your tokens you will have less time to profit from so if anything it,s best to go with the "grabbit & scarper" method as for-mentioned. Oh little side note . . . No such word as "guestimate" i kid you not. . It,s up there with those who say "i could care less" *rant over. Anyway other than that good job.
Uruloken Apr 1st 2010 4:14PM
Taken from Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary:
Main Entry: guess·ti·mate
Pronunciation: \ˈges-tə-mət\
Function: noun
Etymology: blend of guess and estimate
Date: 1923
: an estimate usually made without adequate information
— guess·ti·mate \-ˌmāt\ transitive verb
With a name like "Wordsworth" you should really know this, but I'm sure you could probably care less.