Spiritual Guidance: Priest gems for raid roles

Every Sunday, Spiritual Guidance takes a step into the light to reflect on the subtleties of healing for discipline and holy priests. Your guide, Dawn Moore, enjoys bubble wrap, bubble milk tea, Bubble Bobble, watermelon bubble gum, water bubbles in space, and dolphins blowing bubble rings. She is lukewarm toward bubble spamming.
I have a 6140 gear score.
Don't get excited though; I just said that to rile some of you up. I loathe the concept of the gear score addon, and I actually had to look it up just to know what mine was.
The real reason I bring up my gear score is to give you, my fair readers, an idea of what kind of gear I typically work with as a player. If you have no idea what that number translates to, it is full 264 item level gear with a few 277 level items sprinkled in. So for the most part I have a fantastic set of gear. If I walk into a PUG 5-man, most players will glance me over and immediately feel at ease about their fate for the next 15 to 20 minutes. This is ironic though, because despite the quality of my gear being well above average, I am currently rocking a gear set far worse for healing heroic dungeons than I was 3 tiers ago.
Why, pray tell, is that? Because my guild and I have spent the last three weeks working on the heroic Lich King encounter and I've been slowly optimizing my gear for the past month in preparation for this one, single fight. How's my mana regeneration? Pathetic: I get all of my mana return not from trinkets, flasks or mustache-twirling meta gems, but from carefully timed Power Word: Shields and the Rapture trick. What about haste? Awful: my GCD isn't even close to 1 second if I cast two spells back to back. My sole purpose in the Lich King fight is to cast one spell, on as many people as possible, for about 10 minutes straight. As such, all my gear, gems, enchants, and glyphs are selected to work in this fight alone, even if it cripples me in every other aspect of the game.
And it is quite crippling. I used to love spoiling myself with haste. I loved the 1 second GCD; but now, because of my gear, I find myself having to smash my buttons frantically and repeatedly in the easiest of 5-man dungeons, because my inner sense of timing is all thrown off to what I'm accustomed to. I have trouble healing Halls of Reflection! (If you could hear me, there was a cry of shame in that last sentence.) So, what are we going to talk about today? Gems.
That was obvious before now, right?
For those of you who read along each week, you'll know I typically have issues telling people precisely what to do. I like to steer clear of the "here is some information that allows you to not think" path. (I have an even bigger issue trying to present my way of doing things as "the one true way.") This week though, I am going to gingerly approach giving more direction than normal. The inspiration for this comes from an application my guild received this week from a very peculiarly gemmed priest. He had selected a variety of gems that were by no means wrong for a priest to have, but it was impossible to understand the logic he had applied when he slotted his gear sockets. Was he a tank healer? A bubble spammer, like me? Did he share some of his gear pieces with his shadow offset? We couldn't figure it out, and neither could he really.
So, in an attempt to help priests who might be lost in a sea of options, I decided to write this short guide. I ask that you take everything into consideration for your own personal needs, and not blindly try to follow what I say exactly.
Holy caster The holy caster is a priest who uses Circle of Healing and Prayer of Mending at every possible instant she can. The rest of her time is spent healing raid damage through the use of Flash Heal (sometimes made instant by Surge of Light), or Prayer of Healing when she has a full stack of Serendipity ready. This traditional holy priestess would like the following gems:
- Quick King's Amber (or Reckless Ametrine) As a caster you'll benefit almost indefinitely from haste, but don't go overboard. Shoot for about 25% haste (that's about 800 haste rating.) With full raid buffs you'll get an extra 8%. This won't give you a 1 second GCD (it's about 1.2 seconds), but it is a reasonable amount of haste to have as a baseline. I don't recommend trying to get down to a 1 second GCD since it would require something around 1400 haste (with raid buffs.) This is just too absurd an amount to try for at our gear level. To attain it, most of your gear would have to have haste on it; you wouldn't be able to just gem for it. In doing this, you would short yourself crit, which is still a valuable stat even though you shouldn't need to gem for it. (For crit, you'll find yourself anywhere between 20% and 30% from gear. As long as you don't go below that amount - it would be hard to - you'll be fine. I personally like to stay on the high end of that range though.)
- Runed Cardinal Ruby Every healer can benefit from more spellpower. There is no cap to the effectiveness of it. When you feel sufficient on haste, pick up as much spellpower as you like.
- Purified Dreadstone Since holy priests can socket blue gems without throughput remorse, feel free to activate your good socket bonuses when they call for a blue gem. A good socket bonus, in my opinion, is anything that grants at least +7 spellpower (+9 is better). Socket bonuses with spirit or MP5 bonuses can be activated at your discretion.
Holy Renew spammer The holy Renew spammer plays just like the holy caster, except he fills in his time between cooldown spells, like Circle of Healing and Prayer of Mending, with Renew. This priest will find he likes the same gems as the holy caster:
- Quick King's Amber (or Reckless Ametrine) Though haste doesn't affect a priest's heal over time spells, aim for at least 25% haste to get your GCD down. Every Renew you cast will keep you locked in your global cooldown, so it's important that you get it down to a reasonable amount so you can get off as many casts as possible between your Circle of Healing cooldowns. According to the lovely theorycrafters at PlusHeal.com, who were conveniently discussing haste earlier this week, 26.09% is the percentage you want to get 5 GCDs off during your Circle of Healing cooldown. (6 GCDs within in a 6 second cooldown isn't possible, due to human and hardware delays.) Those of you who loathe my use of rounded numbers for haste calculations should enjoy that thread.
- Runed Cardinal Ruby For the same reasons as the holy caster, grab as much spellpower as you can when you're satisfied on haste.
- Purified Dreadstone Once more, the reasons a holy caster would like this gem are the same for a Renew spammer.
Discipline caster So you're one of those lucky dogs still healing a tank, are you? (Do I sound bitter? I'm not bitter.) Er... anyway, the discipline caster keeps up tanks and other allies through a full palette of abilities including Power Word: Shield, Penance, Flash Heal, Prayer of Mending, Renew, and sometimes big daddy Greater Heal. Since the discipline caster's diversity of spells will benefit from all major caster stats, he would probably like the following gems:
- Quick King's Amber (or Reckless Ametrine) Just like the holy caster, you'll want around 800 haste rating(25%) in order to cut down your GCD, and hasten your cast spells and Penance. The haste buff you receive from Borrowed Time is not guaranteed to always be available when you're stuck focusing on a tank, so you shouldn't skimp on haste as a caster.
- Smooth King's Amber (or Potent Ametrine) STOP! Before you socket this gem, examine your gear. How much crit do you currently have? Ideally, one should never have to gem for crit, as there is an abundant amount available through the raw stats of your gear. However, it is essential that tank healing discipline priests land crit heals as often as possible to handle the current content, so sometimes you may decide to gem this stat. How much crit you have to start will determine how much crit you need. You want to have over 30% crit on your character pane. 35% would be fantastic, but difficult to attain.
- Runed Cardinal Ruby Spellpower contributes to your shields as well as your spells, so after your haste and crit are in a good place, stack on the spellpower gems.
Discipline shield spammer
- Runed Cardinal Ruby This is all you will ever need as a shield spammer. You don't need haste, because with raid buffs, talents, and Borrowed Time, the magic number for haste is about 5%. (If that doesn't add up to you, it's because you have to multiply. Don't ask me to multiply for you.) 5% is far less than you will have on your gear's base stats, so you don't need to gem for it. For mana return, you can regen mana through Rapture and properly timing your use of bubbles on most fights. If not, priest cooldowns and a potion will get you through most encounters with just enough mana to spare. Bubbles do not crit, so crit is also useless, save for proccing teeny tiny Divine Aegis bubbles off the heal from Glyph of Power Word: Shield. Exciting, huh? (I'm not bitter.)
I did not mention what to gem for if you want more mana regeneration. Why? Because as you get past the point of needing those shiny 101 guides I have linked below, you will find you really do not need to gem for regen. Not at this point anyway; Cataclysm may be a whole different story. For now, this information should get you through the rest of Icecrown Citadel, Ruby Sanctum, and anything else Blizzard has in store for us before we see our experience bars again.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
jerdthewarlock Apr 18th 2010 8:21PM
(Gearscore) Haters United!
I hate gearscore alot...I read someone say in trade "LFM for less rabi 5500 gs minimum" and then after I read that I went and got a dungeon for H HoR and tanked it with 4400 gs and a healer of 4800 gs. I think I broke gearscore! :D
PS. I only have gear score because I constantly inspect peoples gear for fun when I'm in cities and it helps me pick out people with better gear so that I can see more shiny epix. :D
theRaptor Apr 18th 2010 9:42PM
People who want 5500 GS don't think it can't be done with less (it can, I mean we did those heroics in levelling blues a year ago) they just want to AoE pull the whole thing and finish 2 minutes earlier. Or are horrible horrible scrubs that need better geared players to carry them.
You only have to do one run with a 5k+ GS player who pulls just over 2k DPS (when my spriest is doing 4k+ with a 4600 GS) to know it isn't a great metric.
Hal Apr 18th 2010 10:12PM
Meh. Gearscore (while annoying) has never bothered me in dungeon/raid recruitment as much as asking for the achievement. It literally means that you have, like, a 2 week window when content is released to try out a raid, or else you'll never get in. No matter how much work you do to prepare yourself for that content, not having done it before means a lot of people will refuse to take you, especially if you're not DPS.
Goodk4t Apr 19th 2010 2:30AM
If you had every single piece of gear at ilvl 245, none higher, none lower, you'd have 5400 gear score. People asking for 5500+ GS for ie, ToC25, often don't stop to think that people with 5500 GS don't need ToC25 gear, or that back at patch 3.2 people used to successfully do ToC-25 with 4600 GS. I've even seen people asking for 5k+ GS for Naxxramas weekly.
glassmeli Apr 19th 2010 2:32AM
My only problem with this comment is the "link achievement" part. One...it can be false linked...two, everyone needs ONE time to go through. A LOT of people have done the bosses/achiev on other toons, therefore know the fight. I agree with wanting to make sure everyone knows what they are doing...but seriously...how hard is it to kick one person if they don't perform? Sorry...this is common sense to a person who has over 10 80s.
Snuzzle Apr 19th 2010 2:33AM
Less Rabi is a very tricksy achievement though, and yes you do need good gear to get it (especially with a PUG). The general strat is 4 dps and one tank, so the tank must be well-geared to not require healing (or more healing than a totem/spriest can provide). While I would possibly consider 5k a bit excessive, it's also not a very difficult number to obtain. My heally shaman has a GS of 4.8k (I just checked the website xD) and he still has some 200's.
Gothia Apr 19th 2010 2:48AM
People hate gear score because it is a measuring bar of "probable" performance. Unfortuantely, this addon has been misused and instead of it being a personal measuring stick for you to use to access your gear, it has become a watermark for access to content. Our guild has had problems with people that may have a high gear score, but are not gem'd or enchanted for optimal performance. When told this information we have had more than a few newer people take the information personnally and gquit.
There are many guides about raiding at various sites including this one and I appreciate the authors hard work. Actually, people that have high gear scores like Dawn's work very hard on properly enchanting, gemming, and spec rotations while evaluating their performance during and after raids. The 10 percenters that either don't care or don't know how to access information on their spec will perform at 2K dps, the majority will not. I hope even though you may be rejected for not having gear for raid content that it is still your personal goal to achieve these high standards.
Jen Apr 19th 2010 2:53AM
My group did Less-Rabi in ilvl 232 gear, while we were between guilds and not really raiding (i.e. only badge gear). It took some well-timed interrupts and a few attempts, but it was by no means impossible.
Deathknighty Apr 19th 2010 6:55AM
I got Less-rabi without even trying on a random PuG on my dk. I just made sure to try to interrupt him. I have around 5.2-5.3 gs, and the group wasn't particularly amazing. Just hit http://www.wowhead.com/spell=47528 then http://www.wowhead.com/spell=47476 then http://www.wowhead.com/spell=47528 again, and then he was dead. :P
QQinsider Apr 19th 2010 7:57AM
I find that the people who love gearscore are the same ones that
- don't gem properly
- or enchant
- wear pvp gear for pve
- are useless
Gearscore is great for them because it takes absolutely no account of any of those things, it just measures average item level. And they get a bigger number than their dps.
Snuzzle Apr 19th 2010 3:10PM
The problem I find with trying to do Less-Rabi in pugs is people blow their CDs at the beginning, when his transforms are easy to interrupt, instead of near the end, when they become damn-near instantaneous. Since the transforms are linked to his health pool percentage and not a timer, doing it that way just doesn't work. I always hear "Aw man! Five more percent and he would have been dead!"
I have no clue about the scale of ilvl to GS, I am pretty sure that a full set of 232 is about 5k GS? Not at all sure since I don't use GS. But I do like Elitist Group for the sole purpose that not only does it show me average ilvl (far more useful than a GS number since I don't even know how it's calculated), whether they're properly gemmed and whether they're properly enchanted on a scale of 0-100%. 100% on enchants means they've got everything, even exalted Hodir shoulder.
I only really downloaded it though for my warrior so I know who to use Vigilance on, and so when I'm tanking I know at a glance if the healer can handle my chain pulling or if I might need to slow down for a fresh 80.
I have yet to see a 100% on gems or enchants in a pug.
Piisuke Apr 25th 2010 7:11PM
I use Elitist Group for that. Tells me much more than GS can ever do. Useless addon.
DrGerm Apr 18th 2010 8:28PM
You didn't mention which meta gems to use.
Dawn Moore Apr 18th 2010 8:45PM
Oh, how do I respond to this...
The short answer is: If you need mana, the Insightful Earthsiege Diamond. If you don't need mana, the Ember Skyflare Diamond if you want throughput, the Beaming Earthsiege Diamond if you want a different kind of throughput (throughput through crit), or the Revitalizing Skyflare Diamond if you want yet another kind of throughput. The Revitalizing would be most ideal for priests who have a lot of crit though.
Long answer: Someone should have some snarky response on this somewhere.
Faith-lb Apr 18th 2010 10:31PM
or , dawn , link to your previous meta gem posts !
Task Apr 18th 2010 8:28PM
I'm with Jerd as well, I only use GS to make comparisons on my Holy/Ret pally and mage.
As an aside, Dawn... that is crazy... your gearscore and your gear itself.
Kevin Apr 18th 2010 8:31PM
i like GearScore only because it lets you know, at a glance, how good the players gear is. I always remember though that they could still be retarded and not know what there doing.
Twaxie Apr 18th 2010 8:56PM
It does give you a decent at-a-glance at their potential, but it's also possible that the gear score is being gathered from gear that is absolutely terrible for their spec in some way or another. I think it's probably a better idea to look at the items and ask if there's anything uncertain about gear choices, personally.
glassmeli Apr 19th 2010 2:44AM
Gonna say again...I don't agree. I tried...TRIED to heal a person with a prot spec that was "gear score" 'd at over 5700 in H HoR and that person got hit like a paper frickin cup. A paly...with a lower gear score by 1k than what my husband who I have healed tons of times in there. So imo gs means nothing....after a few times of fail dps/tanks/healers/etc that didn't meet up to their "gearscore" I deleted the app. It's honestly not useful these days. I've seen 3800 gs'd peeps out dps 5300 gs'd peeps on a daily baisis.
glassmeli Apr 19th 2010 2:44AM
I meant 1k gear score less than my husband. He's rockin a 4800 gs and I have no problem whatsoever healing him in H HoR even when we aren't in the same room....