Gold Capped: Making money with enchanting scrolls

Want to get Gold Capped? This column shows you how. Join author Basil "Euripides" Berntsen, also of outdps.com, the Hunting Party podcast and the Call to Auction podcast.
Enchanting is like the auctioneer's sonic screwdriver. Having a maxed-out enchanter is a major boost to many other professions, as their ability to disenchant is just amazing. It will help you recuperate money when leveling your professions, as well as open up business opportunities that may not have been profitable otherwise.
So how else can you make money with enchanting?
The wrong way to make money with enchanting

Working for tips is something that can be worth it if you want people to help you level; however, it's a complete waste of time if you want to make serious money. The reality is that even if you're making 10g per job, considering all the hassle of getting to the person, trading mats and haggling over the tip, linking your book in trade brings in less money per hour than, say, doing a random dungeon. It brings in way less than someone who has access to the auction house and a little bit of entrepreneurial spirit can make!
If you have rare recipes or something, it might be worth your while; however, I never link my book in trade. I respond to people asking in trade, but more often than not, I'll just offer to sell them one of the scrolls I've made.
The best way to make money enchanting gear
Ever since Blizzard announced the ability for scribes to make armor and weapon vellum that will store an enchant to make a tradable scroll, selling enchant scrolls on the AH has been the best way to make gold from enchanting gear.The process is simple:
- Enchant vellum
- List scrolls on AH

Look down that list, and ensure that you only make scrolls that are going to sell for more than you could sell the mats for, whether you farmed or made them yourself or not. Otherwise you're spending gold enchanting other people's gear. Admirable though that may be, morally, I prefer to save freebies for friends and guildies.
You might want to look into finding some sort of profession addon that inter-operates with LilSparky's Workshop so you can sort. The one I use even lets me sort by profitability. Unfortunately, it barely works these days and is not seeing much love from the guy who kept it taped together when I started using it. If you feel like tinkering with a recalcitrant, always buggy and occasionally data-corrupting addon, download the Lilsparky's Skillet clone at your own risk here. There's light at the end of the tunnel, though; the author is apparently rewriting this from the ground up, which will be awesome.
"List scrolls on the AH"? Easy enough! These days, even the default UI lets you post stacks based on unit or stack price and list as many stacks as you want with one button click. Still, for this, I like to use Auctioneer's Appraiser tool to automatically undercut everyone. Click on my post about it to see how to configure it. You'll have to go over your whole inventory once to set all the scrolls you made up, and as you expand your production, you'll have to mark each scroll as auto-post once (click to embiggen).
Lastly, while I rarely advocate this if it's done with any level of dedication, if you wanted to mass cancel and re-undercut anything, these scrolls are probably the only thing where that's worth it. It's usually going to be less than 50 different types of scrolls, there's no deposit fee and there's often a butt-ton of margin on them. You don't want to give it away, but if you log in once in a while to cancel and relist, you're trading profits for volume.
If you do choose to cancel and relist, this macro will be handy:
/run local i=1;local n=1;while n ~= nil do n=GetAuctionItemInfo("owner",i);if n~=nil and strfind(n,"^Scroll of") then CancelAuction(i) end i=i+1 end It will cancel any enchanting scrolls auctions you have up, allowing you to relist them.
This market may or may not work out for you; sometimes there's too many aggressive undercutters or too many aggressive AH campers. If this is the case, your only option is either to find some other profitable niche or try to shock them out of the market. If you elect to shock them out, you're going to need another addon: Quickauctions. It's much more suitable for pricing wars, although it takes a long time to configure. More on that later!
Filed under: Economy, Gold Capped







Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Faith Trust Apr 28th 2010 5:34PM
in before the QQ fest
mark Apr 28th 2010 5:51PM
"This market may or may not work out for you; sometimes there's too many aggressive undercutters or too many aggressive AH campers."
well it bloody wont now you've posted this!
theres your QQ :)
uncaringbear Apr 28th 2010 7:33PM
Yeh, I've noticed a big increase in the number of people leveling up inscriptions, and subsequently flooding the market with cheap glyphs. Of those people, a few have become regular sellers, which further depresses the market.
This may or may not be attributed to the recent articles on gold-making with inscriptions. It could also be a cyclical thing, although I haven't seen a dip this large since I started playing the AH game. I'm curious if anyone else has observed a similar trend?
Basil Berntsen Apr 29th 2010 9:36AM
@Uncaringbear: what articles on selling glyphs? All I've done so far is advocate against it and not provide a guide. This is about enchanting scrolls :)
Hasselhoff Apr 29th 2010 9:41AM
@uncaringbear
YES! The last three weeks or so have been absolutely atrocious for the glyph market. It's gotten to the point where I just post once a day anymore because there's some saddies that just sit there and undercut you the minute you post. It's great for buyers, but the market's absolutely saturated for sellers these days.
But if you stop posting altogether, you're letting them win and prices will go back up. You've just got to hope that you can hold out longer than others in the face of the campers. One thing you can do if you're just wanting to make them mad is set your fallback + max price to the threshold price (lowest price you'll sell for) and look at it from the perspective of saving time trying to undercut constantly. You may find that the campers are okay with selling a few for less than, say 3g, but when everything's 3g (it costs me approx 1g/glyph to create), they may be less inclined to continue to camp as it becomes much less profitable. Do that for a week or so (just be prepared for lower profits and higher volume as the prices are depressed) and see if their behavior changes. If not, they're probably just peachy making that amount of money per glyph and there's not much else you can do except hope that they get tired of creating so many glyphs for such a low profit margin.
Good luck!
Evilry Apr 30th 2010 4:33AM
Glyphs selling for 3G won't get any purchase here. All glyphs here are selling at 1G-2G with more than 20 listed whenever you check AH. I don't even bother to create glpyhs anymore.
AltairAntares Apr 28th 2010 5:36PM
I stick my skill on trade when I'm just sitting in Dal for what ever reason- usually the people are in dal anyway so it's fast and a 20g tip is still a 20g tip that you wouldn't have gotten otherwise while just standing around.
One thing I would like to see if there are some good exotic enchants that sell well- mongoos and crusader are the primary ones- are there others that sell well?
Faith Trust Apr 28th 2010 5:39PM
weapon Spellpower or healing power (the MC ones)
weapon +15 agi +25 agi
+18 sta to shield
are some that come to mind ...usually used on heirlooms
and well the shield by tanks leveling by dungeons
elstor Apr 28th 2010 5:40PM
fiery is a great way to get some profit, wouldnt call it horribly exotic though. It takes about 5-10 quick BRD runs to get the drop (And I think its not even BoP)
Marzz Apr 28th 2010 5:42PM
I find the +30 spellpower enchant to be well worth the time I spent getting it. It's the strongest enchant that can go on a BoA caster weapon. There's an equivalent for DPS I know, but I can't remember it off the top of my head.
Tayla Apr 28th 2010 5:46PM
@elstor No, it's not BoP, and no, you don't even have to do 5-10 runs, it's dropped for me every single time i've run BRD, i think they changed the droprate. The pattern still sells for like, 100g on my server, though.
Faith Trust Apr 28th 2010 5:50PM
You might be thinking of cruzader or lifestealing
Vogie Apr 28th 2010 6:52PM
Best enchants to get
Heirloom Weapon:
+22 Intellect, Revered with Thorium Brotherhood
+29 & +30 Spellpower, Molten Core
+15 Agility, Honored with Timbermaw Hold
+25 Agility, 2 Hand, Friendly with Timbermaw hold
Crusader, Scarlets
Firey Weapon, BRD
Icy Chill, Highbourne in Winterspring
Unholy Weapon, Stratholme
Lifestealing, Scholomance
Rarer, but still useful:
Mongoose, SoulFrost & Sunfire, Karazhan
Executioner, Zul'Aman
Cat's Swiftness (Agility & Speed to boots), Kael'thas
Heirloom Chest:
+3 Stats, Trained
+4 Stats, Outlands drop
CaryEverett Apr 28th 2010 6:57PM
Part of what I like about selling in trade channel is when a new enchant comes out I can sell them for pretty insanely high.
For like the first 2-3 weeks after Ulduar came out, I was selling Blade Ward for 500-1500g each, WITH YOUR MATS.
Even for months afterwards, I was still generally able to sell it for about 150-250g each. I probably made at least 50,000g off of Blade Ward alone. And another 15,000g off of Blood Draining.
I may be underestimating Vellums, but I don't think I would have been able to make that much money selling them on the AH. The only place I put them on the AH was the neutral one. The enchant wasn't dropping on Alliance side, so I was able to sell them for like 5000-6000g on the neutral auction house to like 3 different Alliance raiders who asked for it on the realm forum.
xiani Apr 28th 2010 9:04PM
Vogie has it spot on correct. Lets hope no-one on my server read this, took me a while to collect 'em;)
The only hard ones to get from that list, if you don't mind a bit of rep grinding, are +30 SP (aaagh, MC runs...) and anything useful, BoP and *sellable* from BC drops, which is much just cats swiftness & +4 stats. Mongoose recipe is 100% drop from Moroes now, and you can 2-man him, or solo if right class.
Of course the real trick is getting hold of a regular supply of the required mats when no-one really does the necessary content any more...
vazhkatsi Apr 28th 2010 10:53PM
i got every exotic/old world enchant on my chanter and i sell a bunch every week, scrolls of 15 agi are easy to farm and sell for 100-250 gold depending if anyone else is selling
sugmeister Apr 28th 2010 5:50PM
whats happend to the "call to auction" podcast?
Basil Berntsen Apr 29th 2010 8:34AM
Have one recorded I need to edit, and recording one this weekend.
jstock23 Apr 29th 2010 1:38PM
YAY!
jfofla Apr 28th 2010 6:09PM
Anybody who knows anything about the AH will know you never, never, pay attention to undercutters on items that you can list for free. You DOUBLE what they are charging. Why? Because they will sell, and it costs you nothing to list them over and over again.
The other great market is poaching grossly underpriced scrolls and reposting them at 10 times what you bought them for.