he mentioned the armor to gloves, but PvP shoulder Glyph? Really?
with resilience taking up a stat slot that could actually be useful in PvE content, which is what is being discussed? I think not.
~Tanking~

I've seen plenty of pve tanks using the pvp shoulder enchant. 30 stam is nothing to scoff at especially since it's not hard at all to get over the defense cap.

Resilience lowers the defense cap. It's far from useless.

Resilience does exactly what defense is so important for, lowering your chance to be critically hit. I would say yes resil is less useful, because it doesnt provide that small buff to dodge/parry etc... but still in a pinch or if perhaps its all you've got on you when you get an upgrade in ICC, go ahead and slap the pvp enchant on.

i use the pvp sholder enchant, and it allows me to stack EH gear without dodge on it and not have to gem or enchant unreasonably into def. 536 def and still capped. the 15 resil from the enchant is like having 5 def skill. now the pve shoulder enchant dosnt suck, but we're talking about blood dk's, we stack as much stam as possible for survival and mitigation combined. 300 life is big