Drama Mamas: Racism and setting social standards

We love updates! We've already heard back from the writer of last week's letter, Hacking a friend's account.
Hi, I recently sent in an email to the Drama Mamas; it was the "hacking a friend's account" one. Just sending this in to say thanks, he gave me a ring today, I manned up and answered it and probably wouldn't of done if not for you. We made up, both said sorry and I gave him his password back.
So all's well that ends well -- and sticking with a common theme, an end to situations that have no place in our game is what's on tap this week, too. The topic: racism and hate speech. (Before we begin: Standard warning for comments -- we'll be removing those that veer off the subject of handling racist hate speech in game, so please stay on topic and keep the language civil so we can have a productive conversation.)
Dear Drama Mamas, I have a fairly high tolerance for trade trolls and hecklers alike, but I just can't seem to handle it when people I've been placed into a random heroic dungeon with start spouting racist remarks. I was on my 80 rogue when I entered the Oculus as my daily random. So far things seem to be going great, we get to Mage-Lord Urom, and we get it done with no problem; then for no apparent reason, one of the other DPS spouts off in party chat, "omg nigger spic jew" "noob." There was more but you get the idea; in fact, he covered most races, actually, and ended it with noob for some reason. I waited a minute to be certain I had actually seen that, then responded with, "What is your issue?" "I'm Jewish." He responded with "noobe" (yes, he/she added an "e" to the end). I voted to kick him and the group backed me and he was kicked, and I reported it to Blizz.
So a day earlier, I was in a random on my level 40 hunter and in Scarlet Monastery cathedral. The tank pulled big right inside the cathedral and we wiped. He blamed my pet (which was attacking a mob he had already pulled but was running away). I defended myself and responded with it wasn't my pet, and even my husband (who was sitting right next to me) said you pulled too big. Okay, I shouldn't have brought my husband's opinion into it, but the next part was worse. He responded with, "Your husband is gay," to which I responded, "What are you, 12?" He then said, "Yes, and my mommy says you're black and we're gonna hang you later southern style." The healer replied with "I'm black," and dropped group, as did everyone else. I took a screenshot of the conversation and reported it to Blizz.
Then to top it all off, about 2 days ago, someone was yelling in trade chat "LF white healer for ICC-25." It seems lately there is racism everywhere in WoW. Is this normal or am I just unlucky? Do other people find racism in Azeroth too or is it just me? I can't sit by and say nothing while someone makes racist comments, so how can I handle this without causing drama but still managing to do something about it? And does Blizz do anything about racism or are we as players just subjected to whatever people want to say no matter what context it is, no matter how offensive? Please help, Intolerant of Intolerance
Is this normal, or am I just unlucky? Maybe both. Inexperienced people (I'd say "players," but this attitude is certainly not exclusive to WoW players or gamers in general) often believe that what happens on the internet is not "real." They don't understand how to conduct themselves in public on the internet, mistakenly believing that their online behavior is somehow exempt from the usual guidelines of socially acceptable and ethical behavior. These folks just don't get it yet. They also tend to believe that the internet is a great place to score some public attention, even of the negative variety. For these social newbies, it's all about rocking the boat and getting attention.
Do other people find racism in Azeroth too, or is it just me? Oh, it's not just you -- these types of players are everywhere. Judging by the similar approach of these incidents, it appears that your local varieties have noticed one another and are playing copycat, too.
How can I handle this without causing drama but still managing to do something about it? Report the incident immediately to Blizzard. Robin has a great checklist of how to respond to hatemongers and how to report hate speech; I'll let her detail the process more.
Does Blizz do anything about racism, or are we as players just subjected to whatever people want to say, no matter what context it is, no matter how offensive? Hate speech is against Blizzard's terms of service. After reporting an incident of hate speech, you'll receive a canned reply thanking you for your time, promising to look into the incident. That's all you'll hear, since privacy issues prevent Blizzard from divulging actions against player accounts. We do know that most hate speech perpetrators get hit with consequences ranging from temporary chat bans to permanent account bans.
Here's where your consistent, reasonable, mature reactions come into play. Your reactions and attitudes are every bit as influential to the tone of our online community as those of the hatemongers. Every time you respond to hate speech with restraint (don't give these people the negative feedback they crave) while taking steps to curb their ability to act out inappropriately, you help counteract the effect they have on others and spread an attitude of empowerment and respect among other players. Hate isn't the only speech that's contagious; your reactions can be equally powerful in creating the online world you want to live and play in.
That's the hard part, I know. Not reacting with a "What's your issue?" and "What are you, 12?" is difficult. It's natural to want to snipe back. But resist, please. Here are my revised steps for handling the hate:
- Stay calm.
- Write down the hater's name and server, being careful to include special characters and notice odd spellings.
- State in party chat that the hater's behavior is unacceptable and, if the hater doesn't recant, call for a votekick.
- Rightclick, ignore the hater or /ignore name-server. This will not only ignore him but make it impossible for him to be in your future random PUGs.
- If the votekick did not work, drop out of the group.
- Use the in-game help function to report the hater. Never skip this step, please. Click on the ? on your toolbar, choose Report Problem (no need to speak to a GM); and then give the name, server and incident.
Blizzard GMs are extremely busy, but they take these incidents very seriously. They will act on it as soon as they can -- and usually more swiftly than you expect. I recently had to report someone (we'll call him Spammynobrains) for harassment. Within about a half an hour, they had given Spammynobrains a two-hour ban. I know this because Spammynobrains logged on his other account to tell me. (Yeah, now you see where he got his nickname.) So when I reported him again (duh), the GM responded back with some interesting advice:

Drama buster of the week
One of the best ways to build a positive, enjoyable atmosphere is by using language that makes things feel more fun, not less. Gamespeak is silly and fun -- but come on, we all know how mocking and sarcastic some of these terms can be. Much of it ends up being a real drag on positivity: facerolling, facepulling, noob, huntard, toon, being carried ... Being aware of the inflections embedded in the terms you use in everyday chat goes a long way in making sure you're not putting off an unfriendly, arrogant, elitist or even downright hostile vibe.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Drama Mamas






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 11)
PKthe13thvah Jul 2nd 2010 2:09PM
I think a big part of this that people underestimate is trolling. The trade LFM that was mentioned strikes me especially as trollish.
That's not to say it excuses the racism or makes it any less bad, but it does provide a sort of explanation.
Wolftech Jul 2nd 2010 2:58PM
http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/
Mark Jul 2nd 2010 3:05PM
That's great, for randoms. What if it's your guild?
And before you say "Easy, /gquit" - it's a raiding guild, the only one I have managed to find that has raid times that actual working adults on the West coast (vs. college kids and younger, or people not on the West coast) can actually attend. So if I quit that guild, I may as well just stop playing.
Will Blizzard really start handing out two hour bans to my guild mates or will they just tell me to /ignore them?
Dane Bramage Jul 2nd 2010 3:46PM
depends on who it is, mark. if it's your GL, then put up with it or /gquit, if it's not, then speak to the GL or an officer. may may not be the only person in the guild that is offended
Sylver Jul 2nd 2010 3:58PM
@ Mark
As a Guild Mistress I take that kind of thing seriously. Blizz expects the GM and Officers of a guild to monitor in guild behavior. Talk to your GM about how what is going on in Guild chat offends you. You might be surprised to find out that you are not the only one being offended. I've kicked people out of my guild for lewd, crude, and socially unacceptable behavior. (and before you ask, yes I run a raiding guild on Alterac Mountains) Honestly your GM should take it seriously because someone who isn't comfortable around their raiding group is not going to be necessarily doing their best in the raid (or having fun
DragonFireKai Jul 2nd 2010 4:00PM
@Mark
Yes, blizz will ban your guildies. However, what do you itend to accomplish? People rarely change, and if they make you that uncomfortable before the ban, odds are, they'll be just as bad after they come back from the ban. You really are better off quiting and finding/founding a new guild. I highly doubt that your schedule is so oddball that there's only one guild that matches your raid times.
Stephen Jul 2nd 2010 4:14PM
@Mark:
The response Blizz has always give me when I tried to report guildies for this sort of thing was "We cannot intervene with guild matters, it is the job of the Guild Master to enforce things in this situation. Blizzard will only intervene if the incident happened in public channels or private whispers." So unfortunately, if your GM or officers won't handle it, you're on your own.
Mutak Jul 2nd 2010 4:22PM
Guild or not, people need to learn that this behavior is not acceptable.
I wouldn't sell out my principles for a few purples, but it's your call.
Scooter Jul 2nd 2010 5:01PM
@Mark,
Personal principles aside, you need to consider the time your are spending. If you don't mind the slander then play to your hearts content so long as you don't contribute to it. If it bugs you then yes you need to do something about it.
If playing this game means regretting the time you've spent then don't friggin play it.
Endless Jul 3rd 2010 10:09AM
Insulting someone because of their race is stupid thing to do... people don't really get to pick their race themselves.
Honestly though, I think that "LF white healer" is kinda fun and it definitely fits the current "white men need not apply" state of the western society. Who cares whether it's racism, as long as it is fun? For all we know, that group asking for a white healer could've been full of blacks, simply striving to introduce some racial diversity. :-P
Also, consider this: If there was a "LF black healer" call in public channel, would anybody even *dare* to call it racism?
Zahira Jul 3rd 2010 3:53PM
Endless, yes, yes I would still call it racism if it was a LF black healer comment, racism is racism no matter who is being discriminated against
Sleutel Jul 6th 2010 9:34PM
@Mark:
People can and have been banned for breaking the terms of the TOS that apply to public chat channels for what they say in GChat. I know this because someone was banned in a friend's old guild when someone reported them for something particularly lame (I don't recall the details, but it was something like swearing, not racial slurs or anything like that).
vjax Jul 2nd 2010 2:15PM
Just a note: "White Healer" could easily be looking for a priest, as thier font color in the raid group interface is white.
N-train Jul 2nd 2010 2:20PM
I'm not sure why anyone in their right mind would put "white" when they could easily put "priest", unless they're really bad at spelling and don't want to embarrass themselves or can't find it in them to type a 6-letter word.
But seriously, I've never seen anyone ask for a priest like that as long as I've been raiding, I'm pretty sure the goal was to be offensive.
Wolftech Jul 2nd 2010 3:01PM
Not defending them,but they could be a refugee from Final Fantasy...
Mevima Jul 2nd 2010 3:04PM
That's what I thought as well, and maybe they thought they were being funny, but it still feels a bit... off.
edersons Jul 2nd 2010 3:15PM
yes, it could be a refugee from Final Fantasy I or II, but even then, common sense says thats a agressive term, specialy on the US.
Boz Jul 2nd 2010 3:29PM
FYI: I've seen it, and it comes from an old-school RPG gamer who was thinking in these terms:
Black Mage
Red Mage
White Mage
Remember too that you can get a lot of misunderstandings from players that do not speak English fluently. Gurubashi has a huge Brazilian population. Since its on my Battlegroup every now and then I'll get a player in a PUG that speaks zero English, or very broken English. One gamer used "gay" left and right and when I told him/her I was uncomfortable with the term, they just said that's how they thought we (Americans) talked. :sigh: Afterward, though, they stopped and the rest of the run went great. Sometimes you have to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Separately, I wanted to thank the Drama Mamas. I've been ignoring and reporting spam for blatant racism or hate speech, but never thought to use the help feature to report players. Thanks!
Scooter Jul 2nd 2010 3:59PM
I believe vjax was simply stating that we shouldn't so quick to be offended when someone uses a color as an adjective. Stating "I'm looking for a white healer" could mean a priest just as easily as a white skinned person. There simply isn't enough information in his sentence to tell exactly what he means.
N-train let me make it clear to you that your assumption puts you in the same category that you are placing upon the person writing the androgynous sentence and shame on anyone voting up your comment. Your entire argument is "I've never seen it done that way, so it MUST be bad!". This very argument rests on the same foundation as most racism..."It's different, so it's bad."
Never make assumptions about a person or their behavior. Make an educated decision by finding out as much information as you can. If this guy is indeed bad then report him put him on your ignore list and leave it at that.
N-train Jul 2nd 2010 6:27PM
@Scooter
Note the use of the words "pretty sure" in my last sentence.
I was simply pointing out that I believe this person was trying to be offensive. While yes, this could have been all the things people pointed out above (poor English, FF referance), it didn't look, to me, that it was considering I had never seen that usage before (and never implied it was somehow wrong...) and the connotations that using the word "white" in that context carries.
My argument was not that because it was different it must be wrong, it was: that along with the other strange things mentioned, the fact that it isn't commonplace to refer to a priest that way leads me to believe... yada yada.
Maybe that person didn't mean anything wrong, but I think we can all agree that if he had meant priest it certainly isn't very clear, I dunno how many priests would have caught that.