Know Your Lore: Current Alliance politics -- the humans, part four

All right, you guys have read through almost everything there is to see with regards to the current political situation of the human race. The first three articles covered the history of the Alliance -- both old and new -- and the struggles of Varian Wrynn and his life as the "leader," so to speak, of the human race. The word leader is used in quotation marks because, to be perfectly honest, Varian wasn't much of a leader; he was brooding, depressed, not really willing to see anything that was going on around him, and the Council of Nobles was pretty much running the show.
The only "real" leader available to Alliance humans at the outset of World of Warcraft was Jaina Proudmoore, the leader of Theramore, who wasn't really much of a leader either. This was largely due to her somewhat unpopular beliefs that orcs were capable of peace and her attempts to work towards some sort of peaceful agreement between the orcs and humans of Kalimdor. So here we have the human race, largely left to its own devices -- but they seemed to be doing, if not amazingly well, at least OK for the most part. It's Varian's return and the events of Wrath that directly affect what's going on headed into Cataclysm.
King Varian Wrynn has a lot to catch up on, as we covered in the previous article -- improving relations with outlying kingdoms, getting in touch with the draenei and learning just what happened during the Burning Crusade, to name a few. He's been busy during Wrath of the Lich King, making amends where he could and working on continuing to send Alliance forces to Icecrown in the hopes of the Lich King's defeat. So where does that leave him once the Lich King is, in fact, dead?

In addition to this are his feelings surrounding the Horde, particularly the orcs. While Jaina has her own views about peace and understanding between the human and orc races, Varian definitely doesn't share them, which leaves a conflict between the two human leaders who should be working together towards the same goal. With Garrosh stepping up as Warchief, this only leads to more conflict and more chaos -- while Varian may have been able to work with Thrall in due time, Garrosh is one of those people that Varian absolutely despises.
So Varian needs to regain the trust of his people and either re-think his opinion of orcs in general or find a way to bring people over to his way of thinking. He's got two things standing in his way in regards to the latter. Jaina and her beliefs are a big obstacle at the moment. Not only is she working towards peace, but also she's got both the Kirin Tor and the Argent Crusade standing behind her at the present time -- both high-ranking organizations of extraordinarily powerful people who are completely sick of the infighting between the Horde and Alliance. But the bigger obstacle, and the one that just might bring Varian to his senses, comes in a smaller package: his son, Anduin Wrynn.

What we may have to watch for as players is the interaction between these three major characters. Varian has repeatedly been touted as the "anti-Thrall," a label that I don't necessarily agree with. However, his temper absolutely needs to be reined in; otherwise, the human race is facing all-out war with the Horde. Anduin is a voice of reason for Varian and has the power to change his father's mind at opportune moments -- but does Anduin have the courage to put his foot down and actually change his father's way of thinking for good? Or will Varian's attitudes towards the orcs and the Horde in general begin to rub off on the young prince? It'd be a shame to see the latter, especially since Anduin as presented in the comics has found his own, reasonable voice in things.
Then we have Jaina Proudmoore, no longer moping about Arthas and no longer having to deal with the oddities of an Old God's resurrection or the potential of a new Guardian. Obviously her time spent in Wrath of the Lich King was emotional, given the subject matter. She did, after all, love Arthas, and seeing the depths to which he'd fallen had to have an effect on her. The difference between her and Varian, however, lies in how they handle loss. With Varian, the loss of Tiffin sent him spiraling into depression. With Jaina, the loss of Arthas to the creature known as the Lich King hurt her terribly, more deeply than we've probably been shown, but she can put aside that grief in the name of doing what's right, for now.

So Jaina keeps trying again and again to bring Thrall and Varian together, to show Varian this other side of the Horde, but more often than not, it backfires in her face. And it isn't her fault. If we really want to point fingers, we should point them at Thrall, who can't seem to keep his people in line -- or more accurately, at Garrosh, who cannot even begin to fathom Thrall's way of thinking, and in Wrath has shown very little hope of ever doing so. With Thrall placing Garrosh in charge as Warchief, how will that affect Jaina and her way of thinking? She's spent years placing her trust in Thrall, only to have her efforts blow up in her face. Is she really going to look at Garrosh's rise to power as a good thing?

My guess is that these two will continue to interact in Cataclysm -- and from the looks of the event in Icecrown Citadel and how it played out, this is a really good thing. Varian is the sort of man who can help ease Jaina out of whatever sadness she feels at the loss of Arthas, and possibly be the one who can convince her that the fate of Arthas wasn't her fault. Jaina, on the other hand, is that calm voice of reason that Varian needs -- but unlike Anduin, she's not Varian's child. She's a woman who is capable of standing on her own two feet and also capable of calling Varian out on his behavior if he gets out of control. It seems as though the two of them are being set up for each other -- and given the backgrounds between the two of them, it makes perfect sense -- and it gives the humans a solid pair to look up to and follow.

Varian not only has to prove himself to his people, he has to prove himself to the Alliance at large. The majority of the other Alliance races simply doesn't know who Varian Wrynn is as a leader, and it's that lack of confidence that makes his relationship with the other Alliance races a little shaky at best. They may be wary of him, and it's understandable that they would be -- with humans like Tirion Fordring or even Rhonin to look at for example, regardless of what faction they happen to be allied with, why would they listen to a hotheaded king who's been largely absent for the majority of the new Alliance's existence?

This is what's needed from Varian: proof, simple proof that he can be an effective leader, that he can continue to strive for the best path for his people and for the Alliance as a whole, and that he can do so without living under the cloud of his past. Because Varian's past is tragic, undeniably tragic, much like Thrall's -- but he has yet to recover from it and move forward like Thrall has. He has an idea of what he wants: that ideal world where Anduin can grow up and be a strong king without having to go through the grief and sorrow that Varian experienced. He just hasn't got a clue how to get it. Peaceable talks? Varian's tried those with no success. Violence? He has many, many people telling him that isn't the way.
And that's more than likely what we're going to see in Cataclysm, on the human side of things. Either Varian is going to step up, take charge and show the Alliance that he can be the competent leader they can depend on, or he's going to continue to screw up. And if he keeps screwing up, there's always Anduin, who is a few years older and a few years wiser now and possibly capable of taking over where his father failed. As for Jaina, it's a matter of whether or not she's going to continue down the path of peace or take Thrall's appointment of Garrosh as Warchief as the final straw that shows her that maybe, just maybe, she was wrong about the orcs and the Horde. Either way, things are going to be interesting come Cataclysm.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Clydtsdk-Rivendare Jul 3rd 2010 10:34PM
Regarding that last paragraph, specifically Jaina: We haven't seen the exact circumstances of Garrosh's rise to power AFAIK. It's entirely possible that Thrall appoints Saurfang to Warchief, then when he leaves for Hyjal Garrosh backstabs Saurfang (either literally, or figuratively) and seizes power. Or something like that. I know, I know, insert cleave joke here. But it's still a little hard to believe peace-loving Thrall just leaves the throne to Warmongerchief Garrosh.
I'd also like to see what any other commenters think about humans versus the whole Sylvanas thing (not gonna spoil it yet for those that haven't clicked the link).
Asgaroth Jul 3rd 2010 10:43PM
I think its interesting! I'm not going to comment about it much here to avoid spoilers. However, but it may definitely add to the stress and dysfunction between the horde and alliance!
Kaphik Jul 3rd 2010 11:23PM
I've got a good source who spoiled that for me...all I'll say is wait. It's VERY cool, in my opinion.
Possum Jul 4th 2010 3:56AM
Thrall seems to have a major blind-spot in Garrosh. He might leave it to him in the hope that he'll 'grow into it'.
Fletcher Jul 4th 2010 5:42AM
As Possum says, Thrall has a major blind spot where Garrosh is concerned; it's my belief that this is due to survivor guilt because of Grom's death in front of him. Thrall also had a major blind spot where Grom was concerned; it's my belief that *that* was because Grom was his blood-brother, and Thrall had (at that point, and still has) very little in the way of family figures, since Taretha got killed in front of him. Thrall is unable to function rationally where the Hellscreams are concerned - he acts as if his adopted family is beyond censure, when the rest of us are all waiting for Saurfang to beat some sense into Garrosh with his axe.
Eisengel Jul 4th 2010 6:07AM
This is entirely speculation, but, I think the answer is in the article. Thrall is a good, level-headed, calm, intelligent being... so he can come to reasonable conclusions and act carefully. This isn't the best way though to change the minds of Orcs. I think Thrall may recognize that he's done as much as he could do by carving out a new home, freedom and security for the Orcs. Now that the Orcs are established as a power and have decent relations with the rest of the races, they need a strong, charismatic leader that they can rally behind. Thrall isn't that Orc, however, like it or not, Garrosh could be. He certainly brooks no insubordination, has a very 'lively' personality and strongly outspoken opinions.
The greatest test of a leader is being able to step down when they are no longer effective, and I think Thrall may have realized that the Orcs need a different kind of leader now.
Ravasha Jul 4th 2010 7:34AM
As far as Garrosh's rise to power and the relationship with Jaina, it would most likely be ruined, thus explaining the balista's on the bridge of Theramore.
Drahken Jul 4th 2010 8:25AM
My prediction for the Orc leadership scenario. The orcs were enslaved by the Legion, ensorcelled by a demon lord, and conditioned for decades to be merciless berserkers. They've only been free of that a relatively short time, so of course, alot of that warmonger attitude is still going to present itself. (and by the way, if we're pointing fingers, why blame Thrall who's trying his damnedest for peace DESPITE all of that, when Varian, who's people are quite impassive in comparison, is trying HIS damnedest to cause conflict? Declaring genocidal intent is no way to make friends, your highness.) Anyway, it's apparent that, yes, Thrall's diplomatic ways are lost on his people due to this nature. And it's been speculated in past KYLs that there may be growing discontent in Thrall among the orcs and they may want Garrosh and his warmongering ways to take over. But then they'll find out that what they THINK think maybe not be what they ACTUALLY want, and definitely not what they NEED. My personal prediction holds to this. Thrall is going off to be the next Guardian of Tirisfal and leaves Garrosh in charge. Much rejoicing among the more rowdy orcs. He quickly sets out to pick a fight with everything that moves, as we've seen so far from the beta. But this causes alot of problems. Despite what alot of them think of themselves, the orcs aren't the killing machines they were. Garrosh's brand of wholesale slaughter has no place in the Horde anymore. Plus the whole fact that he puts all of his resources into the military machine and then spreads it too thin. As we saw in the Soviet Union, when you forsake everything, such as infrastructure, in favor of military power, and try to take on too many fights, you're going to collapse. As the expansion progresses, he's going to get worse and worse until the end when something disastrous is going to happen. Maybe Orgrimmar falls under attack, and Garrosh abandons his post in the middle of the crisis to go fight Deathwing one on one. If he's lucky, he'd die right then. Ideally, WE'LL get to fight him and put him in his place. But more likely, he'll fail and be critically injured (and a group of 10 to 25 brave heroes will have to do the job). Then when he returns to the throne to resume leading, the people will be fed up. Thrall will show up to tell Garrosh what's what and smack his punk ass down. Then he'll leave someone else, more deserving, in charge. I'm looking at you, Saurfang. Think about it, he's perfect. A proven veteran of all three wars, plus the wars in Ahn'Qiraj and Northrend. And he's a prefect blend of the Thrall's patience and diplomacy and the glory and honor of the general orcish ways. And I hear his tears can cure cancer. Except he's never cried. (Oh, except when he collects his son's body. [We named him Dranosh.])
So that's my two cents. Just my personal predictions of hopes for what the expansion brings on that front. I meant to go into how I hoped a similar situation occurs on the Alliance side between Varian and Anduin, but I got kind of longwinded there.
Drahken Jul 4th 2010 8:31AM
Oh and on one last note: Have you seen Garrosh's new model? He looks like a friggin Frankenstein monster! PLEEEEASE say we get to beat him up!
Swapp Jul 4th 2010 10:31AM
@Drakhen I agree with the most part of what you said, except that I think varian is a good leader despite his extremeness and I think he's got the potential, especially if there is some romance going on with jaina and then It's going to be an awesome couple to lead the alliance, with young anduin at their side.
and also, I HIGHLGY doubt that thrall will be the next guardian because their is already a guardian: Med'an, Medivh and Garona's son, who looks like a reeeaaaally strong fella. however, jaina once offered thrall to be on the council of tirisfal, so it's likely that this is what he's going to do. just not be the guardian. either that or work with the earthen ring.
Saf Jul 4th 2010 12:25PM
"We haven't seen the exact circumstances of Garrosh's rise to power AFAIK."
Now that the NDA has been lifted, perhaps I can enlighten you... I will try to keep the spoilers to a minimum though, while still explaining what I can.
In the new Troll starting area, when you finish the quests and are about to be sent to Durotar proper, you are shown an image of Thrall, and he explains that the recent Cataclysm has forced him to leave his post as Warchief. The reason he left Garrosh in charge is because the Horde as a whole (though not neccesarily Horde players) WANT Garrosh to be in charge. They idolize him. So, Thrall is giving them what they want, for good or ill. And when his task is done, he will return to reclaim his title. By force if neccesary...
HeartOfTheSwarmBeta Jul 3rd 2010 10:34PM
"Jaina Proudmoore, the leader of Theramore, who wasn't really much of a leader either. This was largely due to her somewhat unpopular beliefs that orcs were capable of peace and her attempts to work towards some sort of peaceful agreement between the orcs and humans of Kalimdor."
So you aren't a real leader unless you want to fight a war instead of making peace? News to me...
Asgaroth Jul 3rd 2010 10:38PM
I believe Anne was describing Jaina's disposition as a leader by the perspective of the Humans in Azeroth. I don't believe that it was her personal opinion.
Eldoron Jul 3rd 2010 10:41PM
You can be an appointed leader but if you do and think things that your people do not agree with, you're not their leader in their hearts and minds.
Al Jul 3rd 2010 11:27PM
Jaina's been preaching her "The Horde only wanna be our fwiends!" to Theramore for 5 years or so, and with Forsaken and Taurens roaming the Marsh murdering and burning down settlements without hindrance, obviously the citizens would have some concerns by now.
Asgaroth Jul 3rd 2010 10:35PM
Very interesting themes and scenarios that were discussed. Although really enjoy Night Elf lore the most, the discussion about the human political climate is very interesting! No doubt.
sccorp.sc Jul 4th 2010 10:53AM
Just for that, I think I might cut down more of your trees.
-Sin
P.S. - I'm totally not an orc. Promise.
Eldoron Jul 3rd 2010 10:37PM
Well I don't agree with some things. But hey, it's not me writes for wow.com.
Eldoron Jul 3rd 2010 10:39PM
*not me who
Asgaroth Jul 3rd 2010 10:44PM
I don't think the writer was stating anything as fact! Very very speculative.