Know Your Lore: Current Alliance politics -- the humans, part four

All right, you guys have read through almost everything there is to see with regards to the current political situation of the human race. The first three articles covered the history of the Alliance -- both old and new -- and the struggles of Varian Wrynn and his life as the "leader," so to speak, of the human race. The word leader is used in quotation marks because, to be perfectly honest, Varian wasn't much of a leader; he was brooding, depressed, not really willing to see anything that was going on around him, and the Council of Nobles was pretty much running the show.
The only "real" leader available to Alliance humans at the outset of World of Warcraft was Jaina Proudmoore, the leader of Theramore, who wasn't really much of a leader either. This was largely due to her somewhat unpopular beliefs that orcs were capable of peace and her attempts to work towards some sort of peaceful agreement between the orcs and humans of Kalimdor. So here we have the human race, largely left to its own devices -- but they seemed to be doing, if not amazingly well, at least OK for the most part. It's Varian's return and the events of Wrath that directly affect what's going on headed into Cataclysm.
King Varian Wrynn has a lot to catch up on, as we covered in the previous article -- improving relations with outlying kingdoms, getting in touch with the draenei and learning just what happened during the Burning Crusade, to name a few. He's been busy during Wrath of the Lich King, making amends where he could and working on continuing to send Alliance forces to Icecrown in the hopes of the Lich King's defeat. So where does that leave him once the Lich King is, in fact, dead?

In addition to this are his feelings surrounding the Horde, particularly the orcs. While Jaina has her own views about peace and understanding between the human and orc races, Varian definitely doesn't share them, which leaves a conflict between the two human leaders who should be working together towards the same goal. With Garrosh stepping up as Warchief, this only leads to more conflict and more chaos -- while Varian may have been able to work with Thrall in due time, Garrosh is one of those people that Varian absolutely despises.
So Varian needs to regain the trust of his people and either re-think his opinion of orcs in general or find a way to bring people over to his way of thinking. He's got two things standing in his way in regards to the latter. Jaina and her beliefs are a big obstacle at the moment. Not only is she working towards peace, but also she's got both the Kirin Tor and the Argent Crusade standing behind her at the present time -- both high-ranking organizations of extraordinarily powerful people who are completely sick of the infighting between the Horde and Alliance. But the bigger obstacle, and the one that just might bring Varian to his senses, comes in a smaller package: his son, Anduin Wrynn.

What we may have to watch for as players is the interaction between these three major characters. Varian has repeatedly been touted as the "anti-Thrall," a label that I don't necessarily agree with. However, his temper absolutely needs to be reined in; otherwise, the human race is facing all-out war with the Horde. Anduin is a voice of reason for Varian and has the power to change his father's mind at opportune moments -- but does Anduin have the courage to put his foot down and actually change his father's way of thinking for good? Or will Varian's attitudes towards the orcs and the Horde in general begin to rub off on the young prince? It'd be a shame to see the latter, especially since Anduin as presented in the comics has found his own, reasonable voice in things.
Then we have Jaina Proudmoore, no longer moping about Arthas and no longer having to deal with the oddities of an Old God's resurrection or the potential of a new Guardian. Obviously her time spent in Wrath of the Lich King was emotional, given the subject matter. She did, after all, love Arthas, and seeing the depths to which he'd fallen had to have an effect on her. The difference between her and Varian, however, lies in how they handle loss. With Varian, the loss of Tiffin sent him spiraling into depression. With Jaina, the loss of Arthas to the creature known as the Lich King hurt her terribly, more deeply than we've probably been shown, but she can put aside that grief in the name of doing what's right, for now.

So Jaina keeps trying again and again to bring Thrall and Varian together, to show Varian this other side of the Horde, but more often than not, it backfires in her face. And it isn't her fault. If we really want to point fingers, we should point them at Thrall, who can't seem to keep his people in line -- or more accurately, at Garrosh, who cannot even begin to fathom Thrall's way of thinking, and in Wrath has shown very little hope of ever doing so. With Thrall placing Garrosh in charge as Warchief, how will that affect Jaina and her way of thinking? She's spent years placing her trust in Thrall, only to have her efforts blow up in her face. Is she really going to look at Garrosh's rise to power as a good thing?

My guess is that these two will continue to interact in Cataclysm -- and from the looks of the event in Icecrown Citadel and how it played out, this is a really good thing. Varian is the sort of man who can help ease Jaina out of whatever sadness she feels at the loss of Arthas, and possibly be the one who can convince her that the fate of Arthas wasn't her fault. Jaina, on the other hand, is that calm voice of reason that Varian needs -- but unlike Anduin, she's not Varian's child. She's a woman who is capable of standing on her own two feet and also capable of calling Varian out on his behavior if he gets out of control. It seems as though the two of them are being set up for each other -- and given the backgrounds between the two of them, it makes perfect sense -- and it gives the humans a solid pair to look up to and follow.

Varian not only has to prove himself to his people, he has to prove himself to the Alliance at large. The majority of the other Alliance races simply doesn't know who Varian Wrynn is as a leader, and it's that lack of confidence that makes his relationship with the other Alliance races a little shaky at best. They may be wary of him, and it's understandable that they would be -- with humans like Tirion Fordring or even Rhonin to look at for example, regardless of what faction they happen to be allied with, why would they listen to a hotheaded king who's been largely absent for the majority of the new Alliance's existence?

This is what's needed from Varian: proof, simple proof that he can be an effective leader, that he can continue to strive for the best path for his people and for the Alliance as a whole, and that he can do so without living under the cloud of his past. Because Varian's past is tragic, undeniably tragic, much like Thrall's -- but he has yet to recover from it and move forward like Thrall has. He has an idea of what he wants: that ideal world where Anduin can grow up and be a strong king without having to go through the grief and sorrow that Varian experienced. He just hasn't got a clue how to get it. Peaceable talks? Varian's tried those with no success. Violence? He has many, many people telling him that isn't the way.
And that's more than likely what we're going to see in Cataclysm, on the human side of things. Either Varian is going to step up, take charge and show the Alliance that he can be the competent leader they can depend on, or he's going to continue to screw up. And if he keeps screwing up, there's always Anduin, who is a few years older and a few years wiser now and possibly capable of taking over where his father failed. As for Jaina, it's a matter of whether or not she's going to continue down the path of peace or take Thrall's appointment of Garrosh as Warchief as the final straw that shows her that maybe, just maybe, she was wrong about the orcs and the Horde. Either way, things are going to be interesting come Cataclysm.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 3 of 4)
Radioted Jul 3rd 2010 11:45PM
/co-sign
It seems like a match made by default more than anything else.
Diavola Jul 3rd 2010 11:51PM
Seriously.
CRtheMighty Jul 4th 2010 12:38AM
Sign me up, too. They have such disparate personalities that I could never see them working. Add in the fact that Jaina's still gonna be leery of dating anyone anytime soon due to her still getting over Arthas (and the fact that her boyfriends tend to go evil and die).
MrBlue Jul 4th 2010 2:38AM
I can already sense the eyes rolling. We want war, not love! raaaaarrrrrrrrrrr!!
Miz Jul 4th 2010 2:48AM
I just finished writing a mini-novel of about 1500 words about why Jaina and Varian shouldn't be together, but I realised nobody was going to read it, so I'll summarise it.
Dear Blizzard,
If you hook up one of my favorite characters (or if you make her cry again when Varian uses his rotten brain for the first time) with the Mr #3 Most Clicheed, Predictable and Boring Character of WoW (nobody beats #1 Med'an or #2 Rhonin), I'll get myself and all my friends in the first plane to Paris and we'll dance naked to Shakira's Waka Waka in front of your headquarters and tell the cops that you payed us to!
P.S. - Umm... French policemen don't like companies paying young adults to dance naked in front of their headquarters.... do they?
Kylenne Jul 4th 2010 8:46AM
I really didn't want to start a ship war in the comments but...yeah. I have always adored Jaina, because she's consistently been one of the very few humans to display any semblance of sense in the Warcraftverse, and thus one of the only ones I've ever had any respect for. Jaina was an incredibly strong leader in WC3. She's arguably the reason there's any humans still around today, considering that she was the ONLY one to listen to Medivh while the human kings were sitting around with their thumbs up their asses derping about the plague, Terenas included. There is no good reason to hook her up with Varian, unless you want to see one of the only strong female characters we have left in this setting that used to have so many active ones take a backseat.
Not that I'm some kind of deranged Thrall/Jaina shipper either--while I like the idea of that, I'm GLAD that she's not canonically involved with anyone. I hate this tendency of cliched fantasy writing (or writing period), that strong women always have to end up attached at the hip to some man (and inevitably their characterization suffers for it). I already fucking hate that Jaina's role in this game in Wrath of the Lich King was reduced to crying over Arthas and trying to talk sense into that dipshit Varian. It would get even worse if they hooked her up with Varian. The sad thing is, I've smelled the stink of this coming for a while now too.
I would much rather see her as an Elizabeth I type. Yeah, she's not actually "queen" of Theramore, but she's still royalty, and politically speaking it would probably be useful for her to remain unattached for the possibility of deepening alliances in the future.
Dreyja Jul 4th 2010 3:36PM
I too would like to add my name to this list. ;) If they end up putting Jaina and rage-boy together I'm going to be very cranky.
I know that some people feel that Jaina and Thrall together is just as contrived but I don't feel so AT ALL. Given her history with shimmering blond princes (both inherently selfish) I can't think of a better match for her spirit than Thrall. They share common values, hopes and have a friendship formed through years of strife and trust.
One of the greatest hopes I have for Thrall and For Jaina is that they will be able to work for the greater good of ALL Azeroth, together, openly. It's the one good thing I see coming out of Thrall leaving the leadership of the horde. I think that Anne is right, he's done his best but the majority of his people will never come around. Eventually, it would have killed him or destroyed his spirit.
Azeroth needs true heroes still.
Karasuu Jul 5th 2010 7:14AM
@Khylenne
Really, you like Jaina's approach to all of this? She may have been a strong leader in WC3, but all she has really done since has been to preach peace, when all the Horde has done is commit Acts of War against the Alliance. Jaina can be great, but she needs to get her thumb out of her ass, get over her infatuation with Thrall, and realize that he can't control his own people. Seeking peace is all well and good, but when the other side invades your land, you kick their asses out before you bring up peace again, unless of course your gonna surrender and give them the land they want.
You and every other person who leaves a comment about how bad Varian is really need to Actually Read the previous KYL articles about him. He has done A Lot to try and mend things with the Horde, more than he really can be expected to considering that the majority of the Horde show no desire for peace, and outside parties keep messing it up. All the Horde has ever shown him is the same old brutality and warmongering, other than their leader of course.... If only he could get the rest of his people to follow him.... As for you people saying that Varian needs to get over all the shit both the Old and New Horde has done to him personally or he can't be a good King, I say to you that He Has Tried, and they Just Keep Doing Shit. Lets say we throw out everything they ever did to him personally. Now lets say you are Varian. You have tried to make peace with the Horde twice. First time you get kidnapped, but you can forgive that because later you find out that it was Onyxia. You were still held as a slave and made to fight for your life. Oh Wait... we threw out the personal things... Ok, so you try again. This time you are almost assassinated by an Orc, the same Orc that killed your father for the Old Horde and you can't know that the Orc wasn't really working for Thrall. Oh Wait... personal stuff again. So you can't hold the Slave stuff against them, you can't hold the Assassin against them, thats all personal, and a "good" King can't allow personal things to influence his rule. Well how about this then. The whole time this has been going on, over the course of about 3-4 years, the Horde has been invading Ashenvale, Arathi and Alterac. While their leader has been preaching peace, his people have been wantonly commiting acts of war. Think people would mind if you held That against the Horde? I'm sure the Night Elves won't mind. Stromgarde, and I imagine all the other humans, won't mind. The Dwarves won't mind. I don't know though, all those commenters who think your dumb probably won't like it, how dare you try and hold the Horde accountable for their on going violence. You would be stupid to think the Horde is all but waging full war on you as we speak. You need to forget all this stuff and take care of your people by trying for peace instead of deciding that Enough is Enough and take the fight back to the Horde to show them your damn tired of the double standard.
Eh, went off on a rant there, sorry. But its all true. What else is Varian to do at this point?
Zaros Jul 4th 2010 6:02PM
A accurate an in-depth article about the life of Varian Wrynn.Thank you Anne for this amazing piece of work. I fear that Varian may be overthrown in cata.
Brasson Jul 3rd 2010 11:30PM
I'd recommend against shipping Varian and Jaina. Bad things happen to her boyfriends.
sardai Jul 4th 2010 12:11AM
note to self: hypnotize blizz into making jaina X varian, thrall will get jealous and kill him, or varian will become the champion of the most evil being on azeroth, whichever comes first
Coik Jul 3rd 2010 11:35PM
Well, depending on which version of ICC is canonical, in the Alliance version at least he did successfully take and hold the Lower Spire, ultimately allowing the destruction of the Upper Spire by the Argent Crusade and the subsequent death of the Lich King. So he's got at least one major, recent victory under his belt.
And I think it's a little bit early to be speculating that the Gilneans disrespect Varian and Stormwind, or the Alliance as a whole. (Some spoilers in the rest of the paragraph, fair be warned) We haven't really seen them interact with anyone but the Night Elves yet, and since the whole business with the Scythe ends up being a druidy thing, of course you're going to see a lot of the only druidy race that was in the Alliance at the time. (Incidentally, how weird is it that the xenophobic-as-all-get-out-in-WC3 Night Elves end up being the sponsors for both the Draenei and the Worgen?) We also find out in Hyjal that the Worgen greatly respect Goldrinn...and we all know what name he and Varian share. It's not an automatic respect transfer thing, but seeing how Stormrage beat us over the head with the Varian/Lo'gash comparison...
Ultimately, I think Varian wants what's best for Anduin, his people, and the Alliance. The problem is that his life has been one of constant conflict. While he's certainly a good person to have as a leader during times of war (I'm reminded of Homer Simpson's "Men of cruelty" speech...), his real test will be if he'll be able to step aside and let people better suited to peace take the helm when the dust settles. Like the overprotective father he is, it may be difficult for Varian to let his "babies" go, even once they've outgrown him...
Murdertime Jul 4th 2010 3:39AM
Yeah. That is an issue.
I tend to personally take the view that all the big stuff in Vanilla and WotLK was done by the Alliance. Onyxia, Nefarian, Rags, both Naxxes, TotC and ICC. All Alliance gigs with the Alliance doing them.
Uld and AQ were both joint efforts involving an abstract band of adventurers of mixed faction that doesn't actually exist. The latter mostly because Saurfang played such a prominent role.
BC was all about the Belfs. The other Horde showed up as well, but it was a Belf story about Belfs coming to the promised land with their new Horde buddies, discovering it was not all it was promised and getting redeemed, for a given value of Redeemed. Draenei got to play bit parts but they were mostly there to look weird in the background.
I have absolutely nothing at all to support any of this.
Cata will, I think, mostly be a Horde expansion, about defining the Horde following the moral smacking around they got in WotLK.
Kylenne Jul 4th 2010 8:57AM
@Murdertime: I think you're seriously underestimating the impact that the Draenei had on the story of Burning Crusade. They were hardly there to just "look weird in the background" or play second fiddle to the Blood Elves. They were crucial to the success of the assault against Illidan in Shadowmoon Valley, and they made up one half of the Shattered Sun Offensive. Take the Draenei out of the equation, and not only would we never have gotten the Sunwell back, EVERYONE would probably be enslaved to the Legion right now, practicing our Heil Kil'jaedens.
And, lest we forget, the Draenei were intricately tied up in our salvation as a race. It was Velen's prophecy that foretold Kael's fall from grace, and it was Velen who was responsible for the Sunwell's restoration, being the one who recovered M'uru's spark.
sardai Jul 4th 2010 12:07AM
WTB assassin to kill varian, hell the blood elves'll do it, the humans hate us enough already. or we could just get a goblin NOT from kezan to do it, just promise them something shiny. ANDUIN FOR KING!
Killik Jul 4th 2010 9:34AM
You're an Anduin supporter but want to make him an orphan? Wow, with friends like you...
Pat Jul 4th 2010 2:10AM
Somtimes when I read these lore articles and the comments below.. I get the idea people want world peace on Azeroth?
I could'nt be more against peace in game, Sure I'd love to have the orc's move into Ironforge with the Dwarves and sprout a third Faction of just Warriors and Shaman, with the mission to kill every night and blood elf in game.
Nothing good could come of uniting the factions anyway and I always wished Jaina would just impale herself on Frostmourne for spewing that peace talk garbage.
That is just how I feel though.. I mean, I understand if you want to pick herbs in the Desolace (Post Cata) while your Tauren friend lets you ride around on his shoulders in the midday sun.
Got a little carried away, Great article! Very interesting.
Mau Jul 4th 2010 2:13AM
Excellent article that proves the point that I've been trying to get other people to see for years: why the !"#$% is Varian treated like the leader of the Alliance if he doesn't do anything on the name of it, why would the other racial leaders even hear him?
Sports72Xtrm Jul 4th 2010 2:19AM
I don't think this is an accurate representation of how the other leaders of the Alliance see Varian. You say that the Night Elves or Dwarves don't know Varian because of he wasn't at the Third War yet they know him when he was adventuring as Lo'gosh and afterwards when after he returned to normal after slaying Onyxia. He has interacted with many Alliance leaders and figures in the Warcraft comic and novels. And Lo'gosh has accomplished a lot of things worth noting. Helping the Silverwing Sentinels defend Ashenvale against the Warsong Outriders, being a Crimson Ring champion which has made him a world wide celebrity, helping the Night Elves recover the Idol Remulos, helping Malfurion defend against the Emerald Dream Nightmare by leading an army during the Nightmare invasion in the Stormrage novel, helping Magni reclaim Thandol Span, and slaying the Broodmother Onyxia. He's also the one who assembled the Valiance Expedition and lead the Alliance on the war against the Lich King. You write Varian in this article like he's some rookie who hasn't proven himself but Varian has earned his stripes and proven himself capable of leading the Alliance.
Dodec Jul 4th 2010 7:35AM
@SportsXtrm: The writer is pretty biased. Note how she says 'if Varian continues' to screw up', implying he's screwing up now. I personally think every single decision he's made has been spot on.
Then a gain the writer is someone who's claimed that the the Old Horde should not be blamed for two unprovoked attempts at genocide because 'someone told them to do it'.