Spiritual Guidance: Of lore, the forsaken and shadow priests

Regular readers of Spiritual Guidance know that over the last month, I've been putting together a leveling guide for aspiring shadow priests. In the last installment, I made a seemingly innocuous comment about shadow priests' being able to take the talent Shadowform at level 40:
I was literally describing the game mechanics; staying in Shadowform requires you to give up the spells in the holy tab. One of our commenters, aramis, used the line as a launching pad for an interesting comment that addressed a very basic question for us shadow priests: What the heck are shadow priests supposed to be, anyway?We're able to make that fateful decision to forsake the light in exchange for causing more destruction more effectively.
I won't reprint the entire comment here, but it's definitely worth reading. The gist of it can be understood by reading just the first few sentences:
Is aramis right? Follow me past the break as we explore a little bit of shadow priest lore, dip our toes into the cold waters of shadow priest roleplay, and try to solve an identity crisis that most of you probably don't even realize exists.Mr. V-A, we don't FORSAKE the light as Shadow Priests. On the contrary, we embrace it ... We accept the light as the balance of ourselves. Life is about balance: pleasure and pain; good and evil; life and death; light and shadow.
Religion in World of Warcraft
Wrath of the Lich King brought a standardization to the priest profession that, for better or worse, erased a lot of lore-rich distinction between the races. If you're a night elf priest, for example, you're likely going to be deriving your power from Elune, the moon goddess. Night elves used to have access to a special priest-only racial called Starshards, an Arcane-based ability that served as a special connection between your night elf character and Elune. Forsaken priests had Devouring Plague (though in a much different form than the one we have today). The racial spells the game developers liked stuck around and were given to all priests; the ones they didn't like got junked. Game mechanics triumphed over lore.
Dealing with topics of religion is certainly nothing new for the video game industry, but World of Warcraft has gotten increasingly skittish about it as the game has increased in subscribers worldwide. A lot of the religious aspects of the game are now glossed over, and some have even been retconned. Those seeking a lot of specific answers about the priesthood in Warcraft may be disappointed in what they find.
Still, some lore does exist. Perhaps the most familiar means of spirituality in World of Warcraft is the Holy Light. Embraced primarily by humans and draenei, the Holy Light is more a way of life than a deity (retcon!). Light is about love and beauty -- akin to a religion based around the amazing feeling cats get when they fall asleep in a sunbeam. Though one can eventually trace the light back to a supreme being, the magic behind the spells comes from the belief of the caster.
Built around the three virtues of respect, tenacity and compassion, the Light is good and holy. The domain of the righteous.
But we, dear friends -- we are the shadow. We are the antithesis of the light.
The forsaken and the Cult of the Shadow
Though the majesty of the shadow tree is available to all players, it is primarily the domain of the forsaken. In most respects, it was born from the forsaken.
As a mental exercise, consider this: You are a great priest of the Holy Light, fighting to defend Lordaeron. After decades of dedicating yourself to respect and compassion -- to the Light -- you find yourself falling to the scourge. Even after the bonds of the Lich King have gone, as a forsaken, the light is still physically painful to you. Hostile.
You are forced to accept a new reality: Your new form was born of a darkness from which you cannot escape. Through no fault of your own, you've been abandoned by the Holy Light. All that is left for you is the shadow. The Cult of Forgotten Shadows -- the premiere forsaken religion -- is based on that principle.
Deathknell, the forsaken starting area, is a stronghold of the Cult of the Forgotten Shadow. While there's no law that says undead priests have to be followers of the shadow, we should at least acknowledge the societal expectation. Just as you would expect a person born of Mecca to be a Muslim, so too should you expect a forsaken born of Deathknell to be a part of the Cult of the Forsaken Shadow.
Deathknell's priest trainer, Dark Cleric Duesten, is a member of the cult. If you have any question about the adversarial nature of the shadow and the light, let him help put that to rest:
So, what's the main difference between the religion of the Light and the religion of the shadow? Primarily, two things:
Ascending into the shadows
Of course, as they are no longer "Mindless Ones," the forsaken do have a choice. Some merely turn their back on the light, just as they perceive the light has turned its back on them. The Cult of the Forgotten Shadow goes one step further -- instead of merely rejecting the light, they develop a loathing for it. Incredible power can be found by embracing the shadow, the essence of darkness that caused their new form.
To follow the shadow is to embrace a path into darkness. According to the Horde Player's Guide, that to which we aspire as shadow priests -- our ultimate reward -- is ascension:
Shadow priests outside the forsaken
While classes come with race limitations, specs do not. If they did, I suspect the shadow priest tree would be limited to the forsaken. As it stands now, however, the forsaken need not follow the shadow to the exclusion of the light. Similarly, a human or draenei need not follow the Light to the exclusion of the shadow.
That doesn't mean that following the light or shadow doesn't have it's consequences, however. The concept is illustrated beautifully by a recent comment made by blue poster Bornakk during one of Blizzard's recent "Ask a CDev" event:
Bornakk - Re: Ask CDev #1 Answers - Round 1
Without spoiling too much, we can tell you that wielding the Light is a matter of having willpower or faith in one's own ability to do it. That's why there are evil paladins (for example, the Scarlet Crusade and Arthas before he took up Frostmourne). For the undead (and Forsaken), this requires such a great deal of willpower that it is exceedingly rare, especially since it is self-destructive. When undead channel the Light, it feels (to them) as if their entire bodies are being consumed in righteous fire. Forsaken healed by the Light (whether the healer is Forsaken or not) are effectively cauterized by the effect: sure, the wound is healed, but the healing effect is cripplingly painful. Thus, Forsaken priests are beings of unwavering willpower; Forsaken (and death knight) tanks suffer nobly when they have priest and paladin healers in the group; and Sir Zeliek REALLY hates himself.
If the Light is wieldable (yet harmful) to the forsaken, then the shadow is just as wieldable (though probably just as harmful!) to the rest of us. Whether you're a troll witch doctor who consorts with spirits, a dwarven worshipper of the Holy Light, or a night elf priestess of Elune, it is your internal willpower and faith that allows you to conjure the shadow. We use our faith to mold our power. A follower of the Holy Light can utilize and embrace the shadow as a means of furthering their belief in the Light. Like in real life, what you believe and how you make these beliefs manifest in the world is entirely up to you.
But still, it is important to keep in mind the clear, inescapable link between the Cult of the Forgotten Shadow and the powers given to shadow priests. World of Warcraft doesn't say an awful lot when it comes to religion, but the game does put forward the general principle that all religions in the game are valid, based in fact and real. The Holy Light exists. So does Elune.
And, of course, so does the shadow. And we are its gods. Amen.
Are you more interested in watching health bars go down than watching them bounce back up? Think it's neat to dissolve into a ball of pure shadow every few minutes? Hunger for the tangy flesh of gnomes? The darker, shadowy side of Spiritual Guidance has you covered (occasionally through the use of puppets).
Wrath of the Lich King brought a standardization to the priest profession that, for better or worse, erased a lot of lore-rich distinction between the races. If you're a night elf priest, for example, you're likely going to be deriving your power from Elune, the moon goddess. Night elves used to have access to a special priest-only racial called Starshards, an Arcane-based ability that served as a special connection between your night elf character and Elune. Forsaken priests had Devouring Plague (though in a much different form than the one we have today). The racial spells the game developers liked stuck around and were given to all priests; the ones they didn't like got junked. Game mechanics triumphed over lore.
Dealing with topics of religion is certainly nothing new for the video game industry, but World of Warcraft has gotten increasingly skittish about it as the game has increased in subscribers worldwide. A lot of the religious aspects of the game are now glossed over, and some have even been retconned. Those seeking a lot of specific answers about the priesthood in Warcraft may be disappointed in what they find.
Still, some lore does exist. Perhaps the most familiar means of spirituality in World of Warcraft is the Holy Light. Embraced primarily by humans and draenei, the Holy Light is more a way of life than a deity (retcon!). Light is about love and beauty -- akin to a religion based around the amazing feeling cats get when they fall asleep in a sunbeam. Though one can eventually trace the light back to a supreme being, the magic behind the spells comes from the belief of the caster.
Built around the three virtues of respect, tenacity and compassion, the Light is good and holy. The domain of the righteous.
But we, dear friends -- we are the shadow. We are the antithesis of the light.
The forsaken and the Cult of the Shadow
Though the majesty of the shadow tree is available to all players, it is primarily the domain of the forsaken. In most respects, it was born from the forsaken.
As a mental exercise, consider this: You are a great priest of the Holy Light, fighting to defend Lordaeron. After decades of dedicating yourself to respect and compassion -- to the Light -- you find yourself falling to the scourge. Even after the bonds of the Lich King have gone, as a forsaken, the light is still physically painful to you. Hostile.
You are forced to accept a new reality: Your new form was born of a darkness from which you cannot escape. Through no fault of your own, you've been abandoned by the Holy Light. All that is left for you is the shadow. The Cult of Forgotten Shadows -- the premiere forsaken religion -- is based on that principle.
Deathknell, the forsaken starting area, is a stronghold of the Cult of the Forgotten Shadow. While there's no law that says undead priests have to be followers of the shadow, we should at least acknowledge the societal expectation. Just as you would expect a person born of Mecca to be a Muslim, so too should you expect a forsaken born of Deathknell to be a part of the Cult of the Forsaken Shadow.
Deathknell's priest trainer, Dark Cleric Duesten, is a member of the cult. If you have any question about the adversarial nature of the shadow and the light, let him help put that to rest:

Any priest, forsaken or not, can eventually become a shadow priest. In terms of named NPCs, however, virtually every shadow priest in the game is a forsaken. Further, virtually every shadow priest has an adversarial relationship with the Holy Light. If you need more proof, just head to your local library for a copy of Shadow Priest Allister's book, Holy Bologna: What the Light Won't Tell You.Ah, so between fire, plague, rioting, and much worse, one more of the "faithful" comes to my door. Well, let me bid you welcome, priest. And allow me a moment to explain a thing or two before you decide it's time for you to seek whatever drives you forward: the Holy Light no longer concerns you, the spirits of your forefathers are fairy tales, and creatures from the Nether don't want you. Do you understand me so far?
So, what's the main difference between the religion of the Light and the religion of the shadow? Primarily, two things:
- As part of the three principles, the Light values respect. The shadow values power.
- Followers of the Light absorb greatness from the universe and reflect that onto others. Followers of the shadow believe that power comes from within themselves. They use this power to shape the universe.
There are many lessons that the Forsaken have learned through experience -- things that some races can only begin to fathom. And although our path lies in darkness, you will find that a great many things rely on both the light and the dark. Your lessons shall teach you to use both... and with discretion. But heed my words: never forget we were forged in corruption and left to rot like so much carrion. The Darkness is our home.
Ascending into the shadows
Of course, as they are no longer "Mindless Ones," the forsaken do have a choice. Some merely turn their back on the light, just as they perceive the light has turned its back on them. The Cult of the Forgotten Shadow goes one step further -- instead of merely rejecting the light, they develop a loathing for it. Incredible power can be found by embracing the shadow, the essence of darkness that caused their new form.
To follow the shadow is to embrace a path into darkness. According to the Horde Player's Guide, that to which we aspire as shadow priests -- our ultimate reward -- is ascension:
Through embracing the concept of "Divine Humanism" -- that is, each individual has the power of a god, capable of shaping the world around him. Ascension is the apex of that power, the end point of the path from physical being to a god formed of naught but eternal shadow. For the player, this is more than just a theoretical concept; through training and investment in the shadow tree, ascension is a possibility. At least, that is, for a short time. After all, the same Horde Player's Guide explains ascension:The ultimate goal of practitioners of the Forgotten Shadow is to ascend. Ascension occurs once a person achieves complete control over herself and the power to transcend death. A Forsaken who ascends becomes invulnerable, invincible and eternal. In essence, she becomes a god.
Ascendancy is ascribed to the domain of the forsaken. Still, it's hard to miss the clear references to shadow priest mechanics that are accessible to a priest of any race. A shadow priest experiences a major event in his ascendancy at level 40, when he enters Shadowform for the first time. Twenty levels later, ascendancy can be had with Dispersion -- if only for six seconds at a time. There is no question that the beliefs of the forsaken and the powers enjoyed by non-forsaken shadow priests are closely tied.At the culmination of this path, the ascendant's body fades, and they become a living shadow. While the Forsaken loses the strength of an undead body, they gain the perfection of undeath, an incorporeal and inhumanly powerful free soul. This form resembles their old form, but without facial features. Hair and body shape remains, formed of the stuff of shadows, and eyes remain as burning balls of unholy light. The Forsaken still has a body, however, and is not truly incorporeal as a ghost is. The ascendant's shadow body bears some substance, almost like an ephemeral, inky fluid, but it is so wispy that it almost doesn't exist.
Shadow priests outside the forsaken
While classes come with race limitations, specs do not. If they did, I suspect the shadow priest tree would be limited to the forsaken. As it stands now, however, the forsaken need not follow the shadow to the exclusion of the light. Similarly, a human or draenei need not follow the Light to the exclusion of the shadow.
That doesn't mean that following the light or shadow doesn't have it's consequences, however. The concept is illustrated beautifully by a recent comment made by blue poster Bornakk during one of Blizzard's recent "Ask a CDev" event:
Quote:
Can you please explain how "light" works? The lore states that undead are physically incapable of using the light, much like the Broken, but then we have Forsaken players casting healing spells, and Sir Zeliek in Naxxramas using pseudo-paladin abilities.
Can you please explain how "light" works? The lore states that undead are physically incapable of using the light, much like the Broken, but then we have Forsaken players casting healing spells, and Sir Zeliek in Naxxramas using pseudo-paladin abilities.
Without spoiling too much, we can tell you that wielding the Light is a matter of having willpower or faith in one's own ability to do it. That's why there are evil paladins (for example, the Scarlet Crusade and Arthas before he took up Frostmourne). For the undead (and Forsaken), this requires such a great deal of willpower that it is exceedingly rare, especially since it is self-destructive. When undead channel the Light, it feels (to them) as if their entire bodies are being consumed in righteous fire. Forsaken healed by the Light (whether the healer is Forsaken or not) are effectively cauterized by the effect: sure, the wound is healed, but the healing effect is cripplingly painful. Thus, Forsaken priests are beings of unwavering willpower; Forsaken (and death knight) tanks suffer nobly when they have priest and paladin healers in the group; and Sir Zeliek REALLY hates himself.
If the Light is wieldable (yet harmful) to the forsaken, then the shadow is just as wieldable (though probably just as harmful!) to the rest of us. Whether you're a troll witch doctor who consorts with spirits, a dwarven worshipper of the Holy Light, or a night elf priestess of Elune, it is your internal willpower and faith that allows you to conjure the shadow. We use our faith to mold our power. A follower of the Holy Light can utilize and embrace the shadow as a means of furthering their belief in the Light. Like in real life, what you believe and how you make these beliefs manifest in the world is entirely up to you.
But still, it is important to keep in mind the clear, inescapable link between the Cult of the Forgotten Shadow and the powers given to shadow priests. World of Warcraft doesn't say an awful lot when it comes to religion, but the game does put forward the general principle that all religions in the game are valid, based in fact and real. The Holy Light exists. So does Elune.
And, of course, so does the shadow. And we are its gods. Amen.
Filed under: Priest, (Priest) Spiritual Guidance






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
martin Jul 21st 2010 9:20PM
DK tanks healed by forsaken disc priest would be quite painful then
kazeko.fuuga Jul 21st 2010 10:00PM
The forsaken doing the healing would be in pain too. Since they have to channel the Light through their body.
Noraa Jul 21st 2010 9:28PM
Now, if we could only not switch between the two like it's no big deal, it would be great.
Sean Riley Jul 21st 2010 9:30PM
Valuable extra reading: http://www.wow.com/2008/06/30/ask-a-lore-nerd-faith-and-religion/
MusedMoose Jul 21st 2010 9:35PM
An interesting read. I haven't played a priest much, but as a roleplayer at heart, I find the description of the Light - and now, the Shadow - in the lore to be fascinating, and worth knowing more about.
I also really like that following/worshiping the Light is based around "respect, tenacity, and compassion." I'd say more, but I don't want to derail this into a religious argument. Carry on!
Cameron Jul 21st 2010 9:39PM
"Though the majesty of the shadow tree is available to all players, it is primarily the domain of the forsaken. In most respects, it was born from the forsaken."
As someone who plays a troll shadow priest, I have to respectfully disagree with that statement. For him, embracing the darker side of existence is a natural extension of following the Loa (themselves often not exactly sweetness and light).
And the trolls and the Loa were here long before the Forsaken came into existence.
warriorpanda Jul 21st 2010 9:45PM
I was thinking the same thing about Night Elves. Elune, after all, has both a bright and a dark side, and Night Elves have always had a close relationship with the darkness and night ... if Tyrande's personality is usual for a Priestesses of the Moon, they're plenty militant and aggressive.
Possum Jul 21st 2010 10:34PM
While what you say about Night Elves certainly makes sense there isn't much in game to back it up. Trolls can turn to the dark loa (a good majority of them) for the shadow. There isn't much reference to the 'dark side' or Elune though you could certainly assume it was there.
If you're doing a follow up could you extrapolate on how the 'shadow' is seen in other cultures than the forsaken? Are human shadow priests okay or a bit taboo/seen in the same light as warlocks?
Anathemys Jul 21st 2010 10:42PM
@warriorpanda
Yes, but Elune's main feature (seems to me) to be the light IN the darkness. Elune, as the goddess of the moon, would represent not light in the abcense of dark, or dark in the absense of light, but the mixture of the two. Light and Dark, balancing each other in the cyclical dark/light phases of the moon, and as a light in the dark, revealing just enough to see, yet not shutting out the darkness.
Of course, I could probably argue all of these views 'till I (metaphorically, of course) go blue in the face and faint. Thing about lore is: it can be twisted and shaped to fit into whatever shape you want. That's what makes it so much fun!
Ambitus Jul 21st 2010 10:50PM
I disagree about the night elves, Elune is a Naru so I doubt they are any closer to the dark than the space goats are. They might have reason and ability to BE a shadow priest but I don't think they could claim to be a founder.
thadward Jul 21st 2010 11:09PM
The "Elune is a Naaru" bit is speculation. And until such time as Elune is proven not to exist (and like everything else the Draenei touch, turn-out to be yet another facet of the Light) she is a moon goddess and thus has New Moon, Waxing Crescent, Waxing Gibbous, Full Moon, Waning Gibbous, and Waning Crescent (with quarters thrown in there as well). Two full on aspects of light and dark and various in betweens. Though not spoken of, not a stretch. On the other hand, the Night Elven priesthood may be more focused on balance rather than extremes. It may not be so much about Light and Shadow (New Moon and Full Moon) but the phases in between, the balance between light and dark.
thain Jul 22nd 2010 9:40AM
I have to agree that the shadow certainly did NOT start with the forsaken, they might have recently expanded its following greatly, but the forsaken are a VERY VERY new addition to Warcraft.
The first Wars of Warcraft 1 and 2 had death knights and skeletons. And I think it is universally accepted that necromancy is part of the shadow. In addition to the troll ancient religion following darker paths, I think it is universally accepted that humans are very susceptible to corruption. And likely as soon as the religion gained prominence there were those who distorted it.
It is likely however that due to their intertwined relationship with shadow, that they were able to learn and reveal more information about the shadow than previously generally known.
Angus Jul 22nd 2010 10:40AM
Even if Elune is a Naruu she's still got a connection to the darkness. Ask Ashbringer or M'uru for details or as a Horde member head to Nagrand.
Naruu have plenty of darkness in them.
jordie Jul 21st 2010 9:57PM
I've never played a priest or a Forsaken past 20 something (I prefer melee combat to distance and something about me loathes the undead) this lore insight makes me want to play a Forsaken Priest. Great article!
Hesen Jul 21st 2010 9:54PM
"Those who fear the darkness have never seen what the light can do."
- Selenia, Dark Angel, as recorded on the M:tG card "Lightning Blast"
You can't learn a thing without learning its opposite. You can't learn to cook safely without learning how to cause food poisoning. You can't understand anti-venom without understanding venom.
And you can't learn to channel all that is good and bright and noble and loving and restoring without learning that its not joyous and sparkly all the time. You can't light a candle without casting a shadow.
Shadowpriests aren't part of the darkness. They're the natural fulfillment of what light must be. Holy priests are physicians. Shadow priests are surgeons.
dannyflorida Jul 22nd 2010 6:54AM
No, I do not agree. People can and do learn a thing without learning its opposite. In fact, I'd say that is the norm.
Further, the opposite of physician is not surgeon. A more applicable antonym to physcian would be murderer. Holy priests have embraced goodness; shadow priests have embraced the opposite. I think many shadow priests have fallen so far into darkness that it is driving them to be delusional. How else to explain why some of these dark priests try to justify their beliefs by saying that they are indeed not evil?
Jack Miles Jul 22nd 2010 7:46AM
No, I do not agree. Though the oppisite of a physician IS a murderer, you still cannot learn to be a good physician without exploring it's opposite. At least that's what I told the Jury.
thain Jul 22nd 2010 9:54AM
Well I mean, the answer is yes, sort of, if you are a doctor. You need to know what afflictions do, so that you know how to treat them. You need to know the capacities (or failing points) of humans in various aspects so that you know what systems you can strain in order to relieve another one.
One technique in surgery is to literally stop a patients heart in order to be able to operate on it. That is by many definitions killing the patient. One technique in cancer is to bombard the patient with radiation, again you are killing part of a patient in order to let them survive. Even as far back as amputations.
Doctors learn that 30 CCs of X will kill any regular person by means of safety training and logical deduction.
Thus any regular priest learns about the shadow. You cannot learn to inspire others without manipulating them, and realizing that it would also be possibly to terrify them. The difference is that shadow priests have shifted their focus from learning these aspects as a byproduct of their faith, to being the focus of their faith.
Yeshe Jul 23rd 2010 2:55PM
Well said.
I have two priests, one Holy and one Shadow, both Disc offspec. They were trained by the same High Priestess and are mirror images of each other.
Holy priests use the Light to heal and damage. Shadow priests wield what most are afraid to see for both damage and healing. Discipline priests have learned to wield the mirror to similar effect. There is nothing of necromancy in a Shadow priest's training; it simply uses what is hidden to defeat enemies. (IMO)
Great discussion!
Asgaroth Jul 24th 2010 8:31AM
I think it is extremely important to look at the type of spells that shadow priests can do first. Their abilities are heavily focused on manipulating the psyche! To make a parallel to actual human culture, Shadow Priests are very similar to extremely fundamentalist religious organizations. Preachers/Priests from these types of organizations tend focus primarily on the consequences of sin of "hell, fire & brimstone." If you ever take t he time to listen, some of the things they say can actually incite fear and guilt. Especially if they have the tendency to discuss behaviors that you may have participated in. However, their words for those that believe in what the priest mentions can find the words to be inspirational and uplifting. Its quite the opposite for the nonbelievers. Abilities like Mind Melt or Mind Flay, can be quite symbolic to mean that the Shadow Priest belief is so strong that they can cause their foes to cower and lose all morale.