Know Your Lore: An'she and the Holy Light, page 2

Tahu Sagewind can be found in the same tent as the Thunder Bluff scrolls with his friend Aponi Brightmane. The two NPCs, along with a quest associated with them were added in patch 3.2.0. The quest An Injured Colleague starts in Dalaran for Horde players. Players are asked to deliver a lost shield to Aponi, who was injured with an infected wound in her arm and sent to Thunder Bluff to recover. It's not really the quest that matters -- delivering the shield gains a thank you and a small sum of gold for level 80 players -- it's the conversation that follows between Tahu and Aponi that is the interesting part:
Tahu has the right idea -- the tauren revere nature and the balance of life, and yet for thousands of years they've been ignoring An'she, the other eye of the Earthmother, even though they acknowledge and appreciate Mu'sha and her contribution to the earth and the history and origins of the druids. For a race that supposedly holds the balance of nature and life so reverently, it is downright odd that they'd ignore the balance between Mu'sha and An'she, favoring one over the other. It's Tahu's suggestion that the tauren may want to look at this other side of the Earthmother that sparks Aponi and a host of others to form what is known in Cataclysm as the Sunwalkers -- the order of tauren paladins.Aponi Brightmane says: Talk to me, Tahu. Something. Anything! I'm going stir-crazy.
Tahu Sagewind laughs softly.
Tahu Sagewind says: All right, Aponi. I've enough on my mind to share. Have you ever spoken to the elves of Moonglade?
Aponi Brightmane says: Not much.
Tahu Sagewind says: The elves speak of a moon goddess, did you know? They put great stock in the light given by the moon.
Aponi Brightmane says: Like Mu'sha.
Tahu Sagewind says: Just like her. The parallels I've heard are interesting. And it's no secret all druids, Shu'halo and elf alike, can call upon Mu'sha's light.
Aponi Brightmane says: Where are you going with this?
Tahu Sagewind says: I wonder. Hamuul has guided us well, and I've learned so much from. The legends say that our people were druids when time began...
Aponi Brightmane says: I hear the "but" in your voice...
Tahu Sagewind says: ...but what Hamuul teaches is what the elves know. The night elves. They put such stock in their moon goddess, as creatures of the night.
Aponi Brightmane says: Do you think his teachings are wrong?
Tahu Sagewind says: No! No, nothing like that. He is an elder for good reason, sister. Mu'sha is one of the Earthmother's eyes, and she watches over us. That isn't sinister.
Tahu Sagewind says: But we're nothing if not people who strive for balance. Our warriors fight only when there is need. Our hunters take only what the tribes require to live, and use all they can when they do. The shaman stand as guide and mediator to the elemental spirits.
Tahu Sagewind says: And while we, as druids, are guardians of nature, I wonder if we've overlooked a key aspect of balance in all things.
Aponi Brightmane says: So are you going to bring this up to the elder?
Tahu Sagewind says: No, no. No need for him to trouble about a student's idle philosophizing while he entertains a friend.
Aponi Brightmane says: I suppose so. It's not silly, though, what you said.
Tahu Sagewind says: Well, it isn't exactly a new thought, sister.
Aponi Brightmane says: I see that thoughtful frown, Tahu.
Tahu Sagewind says: Sorry, sister. It's nothing to worry about.
Aponi Brightmane says: But something is on your mind, right?
Tahu Sagewind says: I'm thinking about the front to the north. The one you're so eager to return to.
Aponi Brightmane says: What about it?
Tahu Sagewind says: I know I'm counseling patience, Aponi, but I don't like remaining here any more than you do. Times are bleak, and failing to act only makes me worry that my idle hand may have been the one to turn the tide.
Tahu Sagewind says: Still... there is balance in all things, even death. I simply hate the concept that such destruction and darkness might be necessary.
Aponi Brightmane says: There's a phrase... "It's always darkest before the dawn." The dawn will come, though, Tahu. the sun will rise. The balance will shift back to where it should be.
Aponi Brightmane smiles and gestures to the north.
Aponi Brightmane says: Even on the glacier itself, the sun manages to peek through the gloom. I have hope, Tahu. I think we'll make it through this, no matter how dire it looks.
Aponi Brightmane says: But I'd rather still be there on the front lines helping it happen rather than trying to placate myself with belief. We can't just sit around and hope it happens.
Tahu Sagewind says: I know, sister. I know. We'll return to fighting one day. For now, though, maybe it's best to spread the word to others... give them the hope you have.
Aponi Brightmane says: And through that hope, strengthen our side in the fight?
Tahu Sagewind says: That's the idea.

This "Light" has no name or identifier; it is simply present -- like the eye of An'she, watching over Azeroth by day just as his companion Mu'sha watches over the night. This opens the origins of the Holy Light debate up all over again -- with the introduction of the naaru in Burning Crusade, it was shown without question where both draenei and blood elf paladins received (or in the case of the blood elves, took) their Light-given powers from. However for the paladins of Azeroth, this question remains unanswered. Where did the Light that the first human and dwarven paladins discover originate, exactly? Is there a naaru connection, or is it simply some undefined presence, much like the Earthmother herself?
At the current time, there are no answers to be found in Cataclysm. But the subject of religion and its existence on Azeroth is a hotly debated one -- religion as it exists on Azeroth is largely confusing, a strange mesh of pantheism and magic with no real definition attributed to it. While some are content to leave this as it is, others constantly try to uncover the source of the magic that is at its heart the basis of religion on Azeroth, with little success. I have my own theories on the subject regarding the naaru and their presentation in Burning Crusade, but again these are all speculations at best.
What we do know is that the tauren have a very valid, very solid root to their sudden undertaking of the Light, and all it took was a little nudging to an injured tauren to create the catalyst for an entirely new order of tauren warriors. Aponi apparently took Tahu's suggestion to heart, as she is currently one of the main paladin trainers located in Thunder Bluff come Cataclysm. As for Tahu and his incredibly perceptive line of reasoning ...

There are times, though, where it's not a matter of history undiscovered, but a matter of heritage -- of familial or racial connections long abandoned or dismissed in the name of strife. In the case of the Wildhammer, it's not a matter of being forgotten -- it's a matter of being sensible enough to keep your hands out of the fire, because you're well aware that fire will hurt. Next week, we'll take a look at Wildhammer dwarves, their history, the dwarven shaman, and why the last thing you want to do is make a Wildhammer angry.






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 6)
Chubz Aug 15th 2010 6:14PM
Wow, awesome article. My first toon was a Tauren Hunter and after all this time he's still my favorite all because he's a Tauren. Taurens rock and I can't wait to race change my pally into one!
Long live the Earthmother!
erknost Aug 16th 2010 2:49PM
Excellent article, but I have some comment regarding the Titan's origin of Azeroth and the part of the Earthmother. It is indeed a very extended beliefs that the Titans come to Azeroth more then one time. But I do not have it that clear. I have always read that the Titans are the "shapers" and "architects" and they "bring order into the chaos". I do not think the Titan create Azeroth. Also I do not think the Naaru are the Holy Light, the Naaru for me are just make of Holy Light. The Holy Light exist with or without the Naaru. The Naaru are just the most powerful Beacons of Holy Light.
I think, the Titan follow the "spirit", the "concept" of the Holy Light. The Pantheon is devoted to vanquish evil and bring peace and order. And example of this is when Iridi, a draenei priestess, told Korialstrasz aka Krasus that she can "feel" the power of the Naaru in him. Korialstrasz like all the modern dragonflights are the results of the Titan intervention and evolution over the ancient protodrakesflights. The red dragonflight is the one in charge to preserve life and take care of the lifeforms, pretty much like the general idea of the Holy Light.
For me:
Azeroth was created by natural means like the Big Bang Theory or by a alien being like the Earthmother. Azeroth was... a virgin and natural planet. With primitive species. Then the Old Gods, come from somewhere else, maybe the Twilight Nether, maybe another planet, maybe they birth from the prime chaos force in the Universe. They land in Azeroth and start to twist it and corrupt the existing wildlife. They use they own life essence to make they work and end eternally linked to the planet.
So Azeroth already exist, life already exist in the planet, and the Old Gods already start they duty of corruption, when the Titans found it. Then the Titan start doing what the Titans do. Bring Order into the Chaos. Fight the Evil beings. Vanquish them and "save" Azeroth from they malevolences influences. Then the Titans, fight, defeat and imprison the Old Gods, create the guardians and watchers, and put into work all the titan's origin infrastructure. Then after the creation of the Well of Eternity the Titan left.
With all this going on, all that chaos create by the Old Gods and all that order impose by the Titans, in some point of the history the Naaru approach Azeroth. After a while they start to be interested in the destiny of that amazing planet and follow closely what happen in there.
My theory of how the humans discover the Holy Light is that a Naaru, saw something good in the humans, but do not think reveal itself would be the best approach, maybe because of idea of a true God it is to primitive to the humans in Azeroth or maybe because it do not wanna to be worship. But it whisper someone and teach him how to contact the Holy Light directly. Maybe at first thought itself but in the end with out it help. That will be the one who found the Holy Order of Northshire Clerics of Northshire Abbey, and then the first Priest and user of the Holy Light in Azeroth.
For the draenei part, they where rescue from the Sargeras claw by the Naaru. They know, saw and feel the Holy Power that the Naaru emanate. All the first draenei where stuck in a dimensional ship with a couple of Naaru for many, many years. The Naaru, saw the good in the hearth of the draenei and teach them how to step closed to the blight aura of the Holy Light and how to use it make to the good and vanquish evil in the Universe. It was just natural and simple.
But going back to the main issue if this post. I think the Earthmother it is a different and independent being from the Pantheon, and if Mu'sha it is a Naaru it is just logical that An'she should be it also. All the Tauren has sometime see a Priest or a Paladin, maybe a human, maybe a draenei, maybe a belf. For me it is entirely possible that Tahu Sagewind, JUST by the power of his will "discover" the power of the Holy Light and them after that teach Aponi Brightmane how to call the Holy Light and Aponi "understand" the path of the Holy Light in a now and different way. Or the simple explanation it with that conviction in main Tahu Sagewind travel to Silvermoon and ask a Priest Trainer to train him.
So I wanna make it really clear... I think someone can make use of the Holy Light even without a Naaru in the way. The Holy Light is everywhere. And if should be theoretically accessible for all rational being who wanna do what they think its right and pure.
Wulfkin Aug 17th 2010 4:10AM
Thats a very good point Erknost. I think given the heavy emphasis this expansion has placed on the Titans, people seem to focus on them way too much. Its important to remember that the Titans did NOT create Azeroth, they just modified it. As such entities like the Earthmother may be Titan-related, but since the Tauren (alongside the Trolls and maybe Elves) appear to be a 'naturally' evolved race, perhaps the Earthmother they worship predates the Titan arrival as well. Maybe the Earthmother is in fact the original deity of Azeroth, from which life first sprang?
As to the the connection to the light, I also think people get far too hung up on the Naaru from TBC, and mistake them as the source of the light. Yes, the Draenei and the Blood Elves have found the Light through contact with the Naaru, but they are not the source of the Light themselves, they are more like conduits. Naaru can channel dark energies as well as light ones, they seem to be the energy conductors of the universe who have tapped into a good thing. The Light is not the Naaru, the Light is a great mystical force of goodness that seems to pervade the universe. That is how the Humans and Dwarves first came to worship it without anyone actually *telling* them about it.
How does this relate to Tauren? Well its tricky not knowing the exact nature of the Earthmother. The Earthmother herself may be a 'force', rather than a deity with a specific form and personality (this makes sense to me as a primordial deity). As such she may be the force of natural life on Azeroth, and in doing so is in tune with the all-pervading force of 'The Light'. Alternatively, if she *is* a specific deity, she may simply be connected to whatever the Light is, and channel is through herself.
tl;dr - I think the Earthmother has little or nothing to do with the Titans, and has more basic natural relationship to the Light.
jaenicoll Aug 17th 2010 12:27PM
So, we have An'she the sun representing the Light (Priests and Paladins) Mu'sha or Elune representing Nature (Druids and Shamans). What about the smaller moon (The Blue Child) of Azeroth that disappeared during the events of the Burning Crusade?
As far as I know, there is no worship of it nor any ancient writings on it, which is strange considering the allegorical explanation of the Earthmother removing her eyes. Perhaps it hasn't always been there and arrived relatively recently in the history of Azeroth. Perhaps its disappearance isn't just a programming glitch but intentional. Could it be connected to some of the events we have seen over the last 2 expansions (maybe Malygos) or could it be a portent for some future event?
Anyone know if it can be seen in Cataclysm? If it were just a programming glitch I would imagine that would be the time of re-introduction.
razion Aug 15th 2010 6:15PM
"Next week, we'll take a look at Wildhammer dwarves, their history, the dwarven shaman, and why the last thing you want to do is make a Wildhammer angry."
Well, next week looks very promising as well! I certainly look forward to that article!
Tahu Sagewind was a very interesting character for me since I first listened to him in Thunderbluff. I do hope they do more with him than slap him in Thunderbluff being a simple priest trainer. For such a unique mind, I was hoping he would be doing more with himself--however, being humble as he was, maybe teaching was the one and only path he could have taken.
Why do I get this unshakable feeling that I won't be seeing many Tauren Priests but plenty of Tauren Paladins in the nearby future. . .?
ALF Aug 15th 2010 7:25PM
Stun, stun, stun... and more stuns. Stun Cows, Stunadins.
MusedMoose Aug 15th 2010 7:42PM
Ditto about looking forward to the next column. Dwarves are always one of my favorite fantasy races, and I'm really looking forward to playing a dwarf shaman when Cataclysm hits. Can't wait.
Also, since the dwarf shamans seem to be closely aligned with Clan Wildhammer, it'll be an excuse to run around with my cute little griffin pet all the time. ^_^
JKWood Aug 15th 2010 8:45PM
@ ALF:
One stun. ONE. Every 60 seconds.
Heilig Aug 15th 2010 9:24PM
I've never understood why people bitch and moan about our single long cooldown stun but don't really care that a mage can sheep them, drop a huge shatter combo, and immediately Deep Freeze and do it again.
Matthew Rossi Aug 15th 2010 9:38PM
Right now a tauren prot warrior can war stom, conq blow, charge and shockwave. That's four stuns. Why are you worried about paladins?
Maymer Aug 15th 2010 10:02PM
@Rossi
For a simple reason dear sir.
Ret bull gives them wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiings
thebitterfig Aug 16th 2010 12:09AM
Rossi, Rossi, Rossi... you forgot intercept. Six. :D
Eberron Aug 16th 2010 4:00AM
Because, Rossi, no one cares about warriors.
Go away you unwanted bastard children of the game!
... oh wait, sorry, I said warriors. I meant to say... nope, I was right.
Dirty filthy bastards.
.... okay, fine, so I'm leveling a Tauren warrior tank and I'm just straight up pissed off that out of all four tanking classes (including having played all three DK tank specs!) the warrior is by-far the most fun I've ever had tanking. ZOOM WARBRINGER SMASH LIGHTNING CLEAVE THUNK HAHA SHIELD BLOCK LOLDAMAGE ZOOM AGAIN MORE WARBRINGER SMASH MOAR LIGHTNING DAMAGE SHIELD THUNKTHUNKTHUNKROFLSTUNS.. so on, so forth.
You magnificent bastards.
Byronius Aug 16th 2010 8:23PM
Believe me Heilig, I complain WAY more about mage CC than Paladins nowadays.
Nawaf Aug 23rd 2010 5:01PM
I remember back when this quest was released in the PTR, before Cataclysm was announced. There was an article about it. There was some speculation about a new type of druids: druids of the sun.
Kaz Aug 15th 2010 6:27PM
"Where did the Light that the first human and dwarven paladins discover originate, exactly? Is there a naaru connection, or is it simply some undefined presence, much like the Earthmother herself?"
Where Humans learned to use the Light is a mystery. They couldn't have learned it from the High Elves, highly unlikely from the dwarves or Gnomes, Tauren and Trolls didn't relate to it, and Orcs, Forsaken, and Draenai weren't even on Azeroth yet. Dragons didn't interfere with the mortal races. The Vyrkul weren't even a memory to even the early humans. The Titans were gallivanting around creating other worlds and hunting down their wayward sibling.
However, before the philosophy of the Holy Light was fully codified there were priests (primarily from Northshire Abby) that believed in "God" a deity of/within the Holy Light. This belief was unlikely to stem out of nowhere so it stands to reason that a human (or group there of) encountered some greater power that taught them how to use the Holy Light. Maybe it was an Epiphany of God, a reaching out of the Earthmother, or maybe a Naaru that was exploring Azeroth.
Hope Blizzard clarifies this one day.
Elovan Aug 15th 2010 6:52PM
My theory is that the lost Titan Watcher Tyr is the driving force behind the Light on Azeroth. Tyr features pretty heavily in Human lore and religion, even if they don't realize who Tyr actually is. Now whether Tyr is the ultimate source of the Light or merely the giver of the Light to Azeroth, much like the Naaru were the giver of the Light to the Draenei.
cartmensfoe Aug 15th 2010 7:06PM
Not to mention he is the main influence of the Knight of the Silver Hand. If Tyr is the main reason for the light it would make sense. He accepts sacrifice for a greater cause. He seems to be the only titan watcher that not only made it out of storm peaks alive and unharmed, but also the only one who the humans talked about.
I imagine that, since Vrykrul don't practice the art of the light, that maybe Tyr wasn't as influential as he could have been. In fact, you see that King Ymiron gets so upset with the titans and their curse on some children (later becoming the humans we see today) he leaves that belief behind to become of almost god-like (in his own mind) stature. So since the vrykrul didn't practice the light in any form, and the Storys of Tyr led to the belief in the Holy Light, you could easily connect Tyr to Human paladin's (Some of you may be thinking that there are priests in Vrykrul ranks, but they're all shadow, brought on by Arthas, or maybe Yogg-Saron).
shkss Aug 15th 2010 7:14PM
As the name The Holy Light seems to be a name given to the power by the humans, perhaps they have come to perceive the light as a sort of deity. The same way the Night Elves draw holy power from Elune, a figure from their ancient lore, maybe the humans have done the same, except being a comparatively young race they don't really have any ancient history or figures to resemble deities or demi-gods.
I.e. They have decided the power itself is a sort of sentient beyond-corporeal being that should be worshiped and gives blessings in return.
From common beliefs and speech among holy humans, it seems most likely that humans themselves encountered a Naaru, as this would appear to be nothing but pure light, light with immense power.
I think the humans, who would not have understood such an encounter, began trying to describe the being as simply made of light, and over the decades the encounter became intertwined with their new-found power and their power became the embodiment of the religion.
Or something. This is the fifth wall of text and seems to be the clearest I've managed to explain my theory. I am not good at explaining things.
shkss Aug 15th 2010 7:17PM
/sigh give edit button.
I took so long typing that I missed the two above posts which gave me a realization.
Tyr may also be a very likely origin of the light for humans. Tyr's Hand is the holy bastion for the scarlet crusade in eastern plaguelands and apparently named after a powerful warrior in human history.
Which may mean that the humans had at least some contact with the titan.