All the World's a Stage: Robot Devil tells you how to portray emotion

The Robot Devil is offended and screams, "Your lyrics lack subtlety! You can't just have your characters announce how they feel!" And then to provide an ironic counterpoint to his argument, the Robot Devil finishes up "That makes me feel angry!" However, when the Robot Devil finishes that exclamation, hopefully the audience is already quite aware of how the character is feeling. It's useless, it's just underlining the proof of "Show, don't tell."
It's considered ineffective at best or vulgar at worse to simply have your character announce how they feel, especially if that exclamation is the only method you use to tell the audience about the relevant emotion. As such, you should be on the look out for how to convey emotions like grief or love to other players. Let's review some tips for that.
Big emotion, big changes
I'm sure you've heard the phrase "you can talk the talk, can you walk the walk?" Or, similarly, "actions speak louder than words." This is the essence of roleplaying. The things that define your character aren't the things you spit out in /say or /yell while trying to be witty in Stormwind.
The things that define your character are the choices he makes in the face of difficult circumstance. The actions taken by your character will take him from being a cheap silhouette into being something three-dimensional and meaningful. It makes sense, therefore, that the best way to portray a deep change to your character's emotional landscape is by big changes to your character's actions.
For example, has your character become frustrated with the state of the realm? Think Varian's not doing such a great job leading the alliance? You can portray that kind of ennui without having to paint a protest sign and picketing the royal chambers. Your character could start being rude to officials of the kingdom. Casually spit in the direction of Stormwind from time to time. Roll your eyes when people shout "For the Alliance!" You have options here.
How to have a crush
Let's say your character has fallen in love. Even better, the object of his affection loves your character back. Great. Now you're in an in-character relationship. But trust me when I say no one wants to see this conversation:
"I love you, pookie."
"No, no, I love you, pookie. You're the cutest!"
"No, snugglebutt, you're the cutest! You're the cutest pookie to ever gag on velour!"
See? It's obnoxious. No one wants to see it. And while you might think you and your IC lover aren't quite that obnoxious, trust me when I say you're a sparkly chest away from Edward-level obnoxious crushes. You got to be more subtle. I sometimes feel like all of Azeroth is stuck at the Livejournal High School level of emotional relationships. Everything's heap big announcements and cups overflowing. No one's got subtlety.
Start with holding their hand in public. That's all. Hold their hand. If you're doing 5-man instances with your paramour, rez them first. (Let's avoid healing them first if they're not the tank; no need to go mucking about with group success for the sake of roleplay.) Wink at the character before pulls. Make a point of sitting next to your boyfriend or girlfriend.
These little clues will add up. Trust me, people will eventually get the point. And if someone doesn't get the point, and hits on your IC mancrush? Even better; bust out the sword and challenge them to an honor duel. Conflict enforces roleplay!
Vengeance can take a while
I plan on doing a full article on vengeance soon. Vengeance is fun to roleplay. It's awesome. It's the very essence of emotion; the aftereffect of someone who's been done wrong. But you don't need to drop to your knees and scream "Khaaaaan!"
Instead, take your time. Do little things. Is the object of your vengeance about to join a military excursion to Southshore? Join them. Make a big deal out how you've forgiven them. Be subtle. It makes your revenge that much more delicious.
I will caution that if you're roleplaying vengeance, however, that you need to make sure you're cool with the other player. Much like hatred or jealousy, vengeance is a fairly negative and destructive emotion. If you're taking part in it in-character, that's good story; letting it seep to the out-of-character is probably a bad idea.
Filed under: All the World's a Stage (Roleplaying)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Tigron Aug 29th 2010 8:36PM
But subtlety just doesn't work for some people, like young children or people with Asperger Syndrome. There really are some cases where you need to directly say what you're feeling.
Tigron Aug 29th 2010 8:47PM
Let me explain in further detail. I have Asperger Syndrome. I have trouble reading the subtle nonverbal cues that most people pick up on unconsciously. As a result, I usually don't even realize I've stepped on someone's toes until they start screaming at me. I realize that most people wouldn't agree, but I for one really do wish people would just up and say something before it comes to that point.
Zuljo Aug 29th 2010 8:50PM
And a good ol' whisper to the person involved along the lines of "My character is in love/angry/ with/at ."
It gets the point across and doesn't make you seem "obnoxious" to the wider, more general public :)
Lokanaya Aug 29th 2010 9:56PM
I know what you mean... I have Asperger's too, and I've had a hard time picking up on those clues. My solution was generally to have a pages document open (which I use to record what different clues mean) whenever I was roleplaying, and, if they did something I didn't recognize and wasn't in the document, I'd either whisper them (if they were a friend and not just some random person) or ask my guild Reaction X meant. Then, I'd take a couple seconds to record it and then continue RPing. Oh, and I always recorded it at the end, then, after the RPing was done, I'd sort it in a way I could understand. Always a good solution for me, though it did get my guildies occasionally irritated.
Hope this helps! :)
Sintraedrien Aug 29th 2010 8:50PM
/kneedrop
/yell KNAAAAAAAK!!!
Seriously, I really want vengeance upon him.
Sintra E'Drien of the Ebon Blade, né Sindorei (now Worgen-curious)
DeathPaladin Aug 29th 2010 9:39PM
I second your desire for vengeance.
Also, I must say that there is a very therapeutic quality to melodramatically screaming the name of the object of your vengeance while shaking your fist at the sky.
zdave Aug 29th 2010 9:13PM
The music is bad and you should feel bad!!
SaintStryfe Aug 29th 2010 9:18PM
That is my favorite single line from that entire series. just a hilariously blunt line.
Mattimus Aug 29th 2010 9:25PM
"I don't remember fighting Godzilla, but that is SO what I would have done."
DeathPaladin Aug 29th 2010 10:07PM
You may have to metaphorically make a deal with the devil. And by devil, I mean Robot Devil. And my metaphorically, I mean get your coat.
Qot Aug 29th 2010 10:18PM
Hello, Fry. Muahahahaha! Just dropped by to make sure you're as happy with our little deal as I am... oh, give me back my hands! These things are always touching me in... places.
pancakes Aug 30th 2010 6:36AM
Heheheh, yeah, they get around.
Faylla Aug 30th 2010 12:02PM
The use of words conveying something other than their literal intention. Now that, is, i-ron-y.
Faylla Aug 30th 2010 12:05PM
Leela: They're so cold!
Robot Devil: And yet Hell is so hot! Can I have my hands back?
Fry: No!
Robot Devil: You're not nice!
Akrazia Aug 29th 2010 9:28PM
Just in Fry, from Futurama's defense, it was the best musical ever written until he lost his hands and could not play the holophoner. When they cut to the robot selling papers the first time, it reads best musical ever written (at the intermission, when fry still had the devils hands) then after fry lost his hands the papers that the robot boy was selling read: Best Musical ever Sucked,
My point is, it was not Fry's imagination that failed, but his own hands, with the robot devils hands it showed that his imagination was not lacking.
Not to knock on the post though, it was great all in all
DeathPaladin Aug 29th 2010 9:36PM
Futurama references make me happy
Matt Aug 29th 2010 9:36PM
The subtlety quote is my favoritest line from the series. I am glad you mentioned it.
Soeroah_the_second Aug 29th 2010 9:43PM
"The Robot Devil is offended and screams, "Your lyrics lack subtlety! You can't just have your characters announce how they feel!" And then to provide an ironic counterpoint to his argument, the Robot Devil finishes up "That makes me feel angry!" However, when the Robot Devil finishes that exclamation, hopefully the audience is already quite aware of how the character is feeling."
Ooooh, NOW I get it!
Dr Invincible Aug 30th 2010 3:42AM
Can't uprate this enough. Way to ruin a joke for the benefit of the hard of understanding.
prenden2 Aug 29th 2010 10:05PM
"They're verrrrrry good hands."