WoW Rookie: How to choose a new realm

Back in the day, I never would have believed that players would be so willing to up and transfer realms. It's not just the $25-per-character fee -- it's the loss of your alts and all their skills, as well as your friends and social circles. Yet here we are, with players hopping from one realm to the next at the drop of a hat. This apparent willingness to pay to move from realm to realm in search of an optimal play experience has forever altered the solidarity of the realm community experience. Today's players are much more likely to view a fresh start on another realm as merely one more way to chase down the precise playstyle they're after.
In the face of such a massive list of available realms, how on earth can you start whittling down the choices?
- Read our basic article explaining the different types of realms.
- Join us after the break for more specific tips for realm-hopping players.
What are you looking for in a realm?
Where do your friends play? Say you've got a neighbor, a couple of coworkers, some buddies and a family member or two scattered out across various WoW realms. All things being equal, as long as your playstyles and general game goals align, you may find it worthwhile to meet some or all of them on common ground. It really is more fun when you can play with real-life friends.
What's the faction ratio like? Life on a realm with a wildly imbalanced population (many more of Horde than Alliance, or vice versa) can be sheer hell -- or exactly the kind of antagonistic atmosphere you were looking for. Do you want an even shot, or do you relish the idea of being the underdog? While Blizzard doesn't make accurate player population census figures public, you can get a pretty good picture of population balance at sites like Warcraft Realms.
Is the realm population high or low? Low-population realms are usually very welcoming to new players. Realms marked "New" are most especially appropriate for rookies and perennially leveling players, since you're most likely to find other similarly leveled players working their way through the content. Wannabe raiders will enjoy a higher demand for recruits among low-pop realm raiding guilds, and guilds here are usually much more willing to mentor and gear up less experienced players. And of course, you'll never find yourself waiting in a login queue for a low-pop realm. On the other hand, fewer players overall means fewer players for you to group with, especially if you're still somewhere along the leveling curve. The lower population also means a much less robust player economy, meaning slimmer auction house pickings and higher prices for you.
High-population realms have a different set of benefits and challenges, most of them relatively discouraging to rookie WoW and MMO players. Players may find themselves staring at a login queue (from mere minutes to an hour or more) at the very times they want to log in and play the most. While the economy and dungeon finder/PUG population is robust on high-pop realms, the more anonymous atmosphere might mean more obnoxious, "it's-only-a-game-you-n00b" behavior. On some realms (and this isn't to say that low- and medium-pop realms are immune to these dangers), you might even find that bad behavior becomes the expected social norm. And if you're considering a "Full" realm? Don't. These communities most definitely will not welcome you with open arms; you're more likely to be met with outright hostility.
A medium-population realm, of course, offers the most balanced picture overall.
What's the word on the realm's official forums? Unfortunately, most official realm forums tend to be rather trollish affairs. If you keep that reservation in mind, it may be worth your while to skim them over for any exceptionally lumpish warts. Don't make any introductory or exploratory posts there while you're still looking, though; realm forums are notorious for mocking outsiders, and you're not likely to provoke any productive conversation.

What language do you speak (or want to speak)? If you hope to play anywhere but a predominantly U.S. realm, be sure to check what languages are most frequently spoken. Visit the official realm forums, and even run a new character to a big city to listen in on general chat for a while. Be sure to take the temperature of what languages and cultures may not be as welcome on a given realm.
What time of day do you play? Do you want to jump into the thick of the pack, or hide yourself away from the crowds? Choosing a realm based in a different time zone can help you make your way with or against the flow.
- If you work an odd schedule, you may be able to find a realm whose "normal" evening/night hours align with your usual gaming hours.
- If you enjoy instance groups or want to join in on endgame raiding, you'll want to align your schedule with a realm's "normal" play hours.
- If playing the auction house is your game, peak activity usually occurs during the late afternoon and evening hours.
- If you prefer solitary leveling or farming, you may prefer to avoid the crowds and play at a realm's off hours.
- You're less likely to be attacked on a PvP realm during traditionally quiet hours.
- Battlegrounds will run less frequently during non-peak hours.
Narrow down your search
If you're looking for PvE raiding:
- A realm's overall progression (how far its guilds have gotten into the current raiding content) can help you figure out which realms may be more likely to have the type of raiding guilds you're looking for. Look up progression on sites like GuildOx, or check the realm progression stickie found at the top of most realm forums.
- Low-progression realms offer more possibilities for casual raiders, since guilds here are still working their way through the current content. And since these players haven't farmed everything out already, gear requirements are likely to be less strict. If you want to take things as casually as possible, look for a low-population realm.
- High-progression guilds are more likely to have hardcore guilds tackling hard modes -- but competition for spots in those guilds is more likely to be competitive. Gear requirements will be much tighter. Many face-paced, hardcore guilds may go on hiatus toward the end of an expansion cycle, making it difficult to break in.
For arena PvPers in search of a more vigorous PvP pool:
- You're more likely to meet players who are interested in PvP on PvP (or RP-PvP) realms than on PvE realms.
- Arenajunkies.com's recruitment page can be a huge help in finding potential arena teams. You'll find that most class/specs are desirable by 1800+ to 2200+ teams.
- High-population realms are naturally home to more arena teams you can choose from. Certain realms have become known as high-rated PvP hubs and attract players from across all rating brackets; these realms include Kel'Thuzad, Mal'Ganis, Blackrock and Tichondrius.
If you're looking for world PvP:
- High-population realms generally have more active world PvP. Nosing around Arenajunkies.com will tip you off to realms that have become well known for their PvP activity; you'll also be able to send private messages to people on those realms.
If you're looking for roleplaying:
- Create an alt and stop by for an evening in one of the main cities. Alliance roleplayers usually make their way to Stormwind, while Horde players often head to Silvermoon. Avoid Goldshire entirely.
- Don't stop at a few questions in general or (heaven forbid) trade chat; wander the streets to see if you can find any roleplaying action.
- Install an addon like MyRoleplay that lets you look over other players' character descriptions.
- Google around to find out if the realm has an IRC channel, wiki, public RP voice channel, unofficial realm forum or special in-game IC or OOC chat channels.
- If you can't find any signs of life on a realm that's been recommended to you or has shown other indicators of possible RP activity, level up a little bit; time spent on a different day of the week may open up a treasure trove of activity.
One last review for the road
It never hurts to sample the goods. Make a level 1 alt and spend a week or so seeing what the action is like on different days of the week. If you're moving to join a new guild, see if they'll allow you to hang out in guild chat with your alt to see what the atmosphere is like (not likely for a tight raiding guild, but many social guilds won't have a problem with this).
How to initiate a realm transfer
Once you've researched and selected your new home, it's time to make the big leap. Blizzard explains the basics of transferring characters to another realm on this very complete reference page.
Filed under: PvP, Raiding, RP, WoW Rookie






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
(cutaia) Sep 16th 2010 6:04PM
My server is particularly hard on itself, so whenever a level 1 alt shows up in trade asking about the server, people just start acting like jerks and telling them how much our server sucks.
Talk about a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Spider Sep 16th 2010 6:12PM
You have an avatar now...
It's confusing me! D:
Eddy Sep 16th 2010 6:14PM
Urgh, mine is totally the same way. Every time someone asks about the roleplaying community, everyone in general starts saying how all the best roleplayers have quit or hopped server and how there's no community anymore, and that these new people should go reroll somewhere else.
With that attitude, its clear why the community has no good roleplay.
crschmidt Sep 16th 2010 6:17PM
Likely to be a common condition, since I've seen it on the multiple realms I've played on.
I generally answer in a whisper with the following:
Malygos is a mid-to-low level end-game progression server. We have a number of active guilds, and Alliance vastly outnumbers Horde; the population imbalance leads to a much more active Alliance community than Horde community, but the server-first guild is Horde-side.
Alliance Population varies from ~600 at low times to ~2000 at peak times; PUGing is typical, with 10 and 25 raids typically going about to Plagueworks, but no further, in ICC. (Heroic PUGs are rare.)
There is a typical number of trolls, but overall the community is relatively well-natured and congenial. For typical players, Malygos is a reasonable realm with no huge sticking points, but end-game progression targeted folks may prefer other more progressed homes.
Or something to that effect. I usually get a polite thank you while the trolls are still telling the person to never come to the realm.
Roy Sep 16th 2010 6:37PM
Heh. Malygos. I have characters there. My main server is Runetotem Alliance - with the Horde outnumbering the Alliance... and I rolled some alts on Malygos Horde to hang out with some people I know who moved away....
I suppose the funny thing is that I ended up with 10 toons of alliance on a horde dominated server, and 8 toons of horde on an alliance dominated server. Am I just a glutton for punishment?
Also, I tried the whole RP thing... or I wanted to anyhow... So I fired up a level 1 warlock named Malevon on Emerald Dream. However, I was pretty much told that all the RP was dead... I still kept a bank toon I had created for Malevon called "Servantofmal" (which ironically could also be read "servant of bad (or evil)".
Anywho...
Charles Sep 16th 2010 8:11PM
I played on Malygos Alliance since Wrath launched. I had 3 lvl 80 toons. The furthest I got in progression was TotC Normal 10. After that, I screwed my account up. due to losing my ipod, and the account owners name was my brothers. So I couldn't get it straightened out, and it remains in wow limbo I guess. And lost everything pretty much.
I was in 3 crappy raid guilds. 1 blew up 2 weeks after I joined, because the guild leader had a nervous break down, and dismantled the guild. The other was a semi-casual raid guild, who weren't willing to help anyone get geared for Ulduar at the time. The top members were very self-important, and felt if you weren't already through Naxx, you weren't worth the time to take a long for Ulduar, and to go and pug what you needed. Malygos pugs blew.
After that I took a break. Came back, formed a novelty guild called "Crusaders of Tacobell", which received threats from a previous guild party, who had it out for a few of my friends. I had one person contact a GM claiming the guild name was in violation of copyright infringement with Tacobell, which later was cleared with the same GM who said everything was alright, and not to worry.
After that, I dropped the guild because I realized I had no real intentions of doing anything with it. We didn't have enough people in it to do any serious raiding. And my friends had taken a break from WoW at that point.
A few months later, I came back, Ice Crown had hit Live. I was able to fill some gear slots with some of the drops out of IC5mans Heroic, and some T9s. And I joined yet another guild that has probably fallen apart by now. We started on Faction Rep grinds in ICC. That didn't last long, crap blew up. Guild was having major drama issues etc. And then I lost my wow account and haven't been back on Malygos since.
My experience with that server is, if you're looking for good raiding guilds, do your research thoroughly. There's a lot of so called "Casual Raiding Guilds" that fell apart fast before they started.
I'm not going to completely diss the entire the server here. I'm sure there are some really great guilds on there, with decent people. But I've had poor luck on there with guilds, as you can see.
Since then, I moved on to a pvp realm, mid sized, Horde. And I have done very well there. I basically went back to my roots, and I enjoy the game again. The end.
tl;dr: Played on Malygos for 2 years, had some terrible experiences with guilds, screwed my wow account up, doing better since then.
Bluelightning Sep 17th 2010 12:02PM
Hey, I play alliance side on emerald dream too. RP isn't dead on the server, you just have to look for it. Kingship of the east is a very large RP guild to look into. The people saying RP died are prolly the same ones QQing how alliance sucks at pvp bc we never win Wintergrasp. Having tenacity virtually every wintergrasp that isn't on Monday or Tuesday doesn't make you bad when you get overrun
Kurtis Sep 17th 2010 8:41AM
@Charles - How about "Tacobell's Cannon"?
Ysonia Sep 17th 2010 12:08PM
I don't think I would join a guild with "Tacobell" as part of the name and expect longevity and mature guildies. Just my opinion.
Jesse Felt Sep 17th 2010 6:01PM
My old server was like that, Fizzcrank. For the longest time I tried to defend it, but slowly the good players started migrating away and it jsut got worse and worse until finally our guild couldn't find enough players that were capable and reliable. The guild leaders decided to move to Stormrage and I moved with them. Probably was one fo the best things I ever did in this game, to be honest.
JaneLame Sep 19th 2010 12:33PM
True. Don't ask trade or LFRP or any public channel with 4chan mentallity. And don't ever set foot in a low population server, it'll be very frustrating when there are not enough people to complete a pug or when you cannot find goods you require on the AH.
polar Sep 16th 2010 6:10PM
For those wanting PvE progression, GuildOx has a realm ranking list showing the realms ranked by the sum of the progression of all guilds on that realm. It can be filtered by language and also shows the level 80 population.
http://www.guildox.com/go/g.asp?a=11
Aloix Sep 16th 2010 7:32PM
That's handy!
Although I couldn't figure out how to restrict it to US servers only (or I suppose any other broad region).
Aaron Sep 17th 2010 7:55AM
@Aloix
Under the very first tab it says:
GuildOx - World | US | EU | TW | KR | Realms | About | News | Search
Click US and it filters it. ;-P
Ciarnat Sep 16th 2010 6:16PM
For roleplayers looking for a new realm, stop by the official RP forum (World's End Tavern) on Blizzard's boards. There's a sticky post that goes in-depth on how to best avoid the trolls and find an active RP community.
One thing I've learned, though, is that no one RP server is right for everyone. You'll hear people rave about Moon Guard and Wyrmrest Accord, for example, but our whole guild left Moon Guard because of idiocy and drama, and none of us found WrA welcoming at all.
Most important, though, is to find a good guild. The server matters far, far less than finding a guild that can give you a good home.
Trinea Sep 17th 2010 1:59AM
Along that note, a common problem that tends to happen on roleplay servers is that people roll there without actually realizing what one is for, they come because they "have friends on the server", or they roll a character just to troll the population. Nothing speaks of idiocy more than calling roleplayers "nerds" or "dorks" when everyone in this game is, in fact, playing a Massively Multiplayer Online ROLEPLAYING Game. If it wasn't meant to be RPed on, then Blizzard wouldn't have made the servers. Don't get me wrong, though; if a person creates a character on a roleplay server for either of those first two reasons and they have a bit of respect for the community, no one's going to take issue.
As far as Moon Guard itself goes, half of our problem would be gone if the Blizzard GMs would actually get into Goldshire and take care of that mess they swore they were going to fix. The rest of it would be taken care of if the trolls left for servers they actually belonged on...like a PvP server.
When people ask about any server (and I'm on several RP servers), I usually reply with "your mileage may vary". For people like myself? Well, I can find the greatest roleplay guild on the entire server, but if the roleplay is so scarce that it's virtually in hiding, it feels like a waste of my time. I'm far less interested in closed guild storylines with little outside activity. I personally prefer a world that's more fully immersed in RP, and I can travel virtually anywhere, throw out an emote, and find someone willing to roleplay with me. But again, everyone's looking for something different in their roleplay, and for some, insular guild-only RP isn't their style. If you're looking for walk-up or random roleplay open in the world, I would actually -recommend- Moon Guard or Wyrmrest Accord, because those two servers seem to have the largest group of active roleplayers on the whole of the game.
So again, when looking for a RP server, YMMV. Like the article said, roll an alt and check the server out. /shrug
iceveiled Sep 16th 2010 6:18PM
moar twinkie the kid please!
Ashralien Sep 16th 2010 6:30PM
It's a little disheartening that you still recommend warcraftrealms. Too few players use the addon the data is based on making anything on there very unreliable.
(cutaia) Sep 16th 2010 6:58PM
Maybe that's why she keeps recommending it. ;)
Out of curiosity, is there any site like that with a bit more reliability?
Aloix Sep 16th 2010 7:37PM
Not that I know of.
I do try to contribute, have for a couple years. Basically once I realized 'oh this is a cool resource .. because and only because people like myself can contribute to it'. So I try to do my small part.